The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Tag: positive reinforcement

  • What Makes Elevate the Norm Different From Other Frameworks

    What Makes Elevate the Norm Different From Other Frameworks

    By Clay Shumate

    What makes Elevate the Norm different from other frameworks is seven design choices. It’s built only for grades 6–12, it’s free with no email gate, it rewards consistency over perfection, it pairs praise with strict follow-through, it uses class-vs-class 3-2-1-Done for transitions, it runs respect both ways, and it fits project-based learning. It hasn’t been independently evaluated.

    Key Takeaways

    • Elevate the Norm is a free classroom culture framework built only for grades 6–12, while the biggest PBIS and Responsive Classroom trials ran in elementary schools.
    • Elevate the Norm announces recognition criteria in advance and rewards consistency, because a study of 15,329 students in grades 6–12 found surprise perfect-attendance awards were followed by about 8.3% more absences.
    • In a BYU study of 28 middle school classrooms, class-wide on-task behavior rose 60–70% when teachers praised at least as often as they reprimanded.
    • A brief exercise that encouraged teachers to keep relationships positive during discipline cut suspension rates in five middle schools from 9.6% to 4.8%, the research behind Elevate the Norm’s “respect both ways” rule.
    • Elevate the Norm has not been independently evaluated; the research cited here supports its individual design choices, not the framework itself.

    Elevate the Norm is this site’s own classroom culture framework, built by one secondary teacher for grades 6–12. This page explains why each piece of it is built the way it is and what research it draws on. It isn’t a product comparison. For a side-by-side table against PBIS, Responsive Classroom, CHAMPS and others, see Elevate the Norm vs other classroom culture frameworks. For the full set of framework questions, start at the classroom culture frameworks hub.

    What are Elevate the Norm’s design choices, in one table?

    Elevate the Norm’s design choices each answer a specific problem secondary teachers run into, and most connect to a published finding. The table gives praise and follow-through separate rows because they draw on different research.

    Design choiceProblem it addressesResearch it lines up with
    Secondary-first (grades 6–12)Most frameworks were built and tested in elementary schoolsMajor trials of PBIS and Responsive Classroom ran in elementary grades
    Free, no email gateCost and sign-up walls stop individual teachersDesign value, not a research claim
    Recognition for consistency, criteria announcedSurprise awards for perfection can backfireRobinson et al., 2019
    Specific praise in front of correctionTeachers tend to reprimand far more than they praisePraise-to-reprimand ratio studies, 2020
    Class-vs-class 3-2-1-DoneSlow quieting and transitionsTeam-based group contingencies (Good Behavior Game)
    Follow-through and remediationPositive systems that never enforce lose credibilityClassroom PBIS: predictable, consistent responses
    Respect both waysPunitive spirals with older studentsOkonofua, Paunesku & Walton, 2016
    Built for PBL and student leadershipBehavior systems designed for rows, not group workKnowledge in Action AP trial

    Why build a framework only for grades 6–12?

    Elevate the Norm is built only for grades 6–12 because most well-known classroom culture frameworks started in elementary schools, and secondary classrooms work differently. The biggest PBIS trial ran in 37 elementary schools (Bradshaw et al., 2012). Responsive Classroom’s main trial covered grades 2–5 (Rimm-Kaufman et al., 2014). Conscious Discipline is written for PreK–5 (Conscious Discipline).

    A secondary teacher may see five or six groups a day, has no single homeroom to build community in, and teaches students who expect a say. The Center on PBIS makes the same point about high schools: students expect input on decisions that affect them, so systems need student voice built in (High School PBIS). Elevate the Norm’s recognition and point systems are designed to run across several class periods without a homeroom.

    Numbered graphic of Elevate the Norm's seven design choices: built only for grades 6–12, free with no email gate, consistency over perfection, praise backed by strict follow-through, class-vs-class 3-2-1-Done, respect both ways, and built for project-based learning.
    The seven design choices that make Elevate the Norm different from other classroom culture frameworks.

    Why is everything free with no email gate?

    Elevate the Norm is free with no email gate because the teacher most likely to need a classroom system is often the one with no budget and no schoolwide support. Every classroom resource is on the free resource library, with no sign-up. Prizes run well under a hundred dollars a year for one teacher, paid out of pocket.

    To be transparent: the same teacher sells a separate paid product, the Teacher Emergency Toolkit on TPT, listed on the store page. It covers things like de-escalation scripts and behavior documentation. The framework doesn’t require it.

    Why recognize consistency instead of perfection?

    Elevate the Norm recognizes consistency instead of perfection because awards for rare perfection can signal that the behavior isn’t the norm, and in one large study that backfired. In a field experiment with 15,329 students in grades 6–12, students who got a surprise award for past perfect attendance were absent about 8.3% more the next month. The researchers think the award told students that perfect attendance wasn’t expected of everyone, and that they’d already outperformed their peers (Robinson, Gallus, Lee & Rogers, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2019).

    Elevate the Norm’s three tiers, immediate recognition, Student of the Week and Student of the Month, work the other way around:

    • Criteria are announced in advance, so nothing is a surprise.
    • Students are judged on consistency and self-improvement, not a perfect record.
    • Recognition is framed as something most students in the room can reach, not a prize for a rare few.

    The study looked at attendance awards, not classroom recognition, so this is a design that’s consistent with the finding, not proof that the tiers work.

    Graphic summarizing a study of 15,329 students in grades 6–12 where surprise perfect-attendance awards were followed by about 8.3% more absences, and how Elevate the Norm announces criteria in advance and rewards consistency instead.
    Why Elevate the Norm rewards consistency instead of perfection, and the limit of the evidence behind it.

    How much praise does Elevate the Norm call for?

    Elevate the Norm calls for more specific praise than correction, because classroom studies show students stay on task more as the praise-to-reprimand ratio rises. In 151 K–6 classrooms, researchers found no single ideal praise-to-reprimand ratio but a steady linear relationship: the higher the ratio, the more students were on task (Caldarella et al., Educational Psychology, 2020, via Education Week).

    It holds for older students. In 28 middle school classrooms, teachers began by reprimanding four to nine times as often as they praised. When they praised at least as often as they reprimanded, class-wide on-task behavior rose 60–70%, and high-risk students gained a full letter grade (BYU, Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions). That’s why immediate recognition is the first tier, not an extra.

    Why use class-vs-class competition for transitions?

    Elevate the Norm uses class-vs-class competition for transitions because team-based contingencies turn quieting down into a shared goal instead of a teacher-versus-student standoff. In 3-2-1-Done, each class period starts the week at zero. If the class is quiet on 3, 2, 1 or “done,” it earns 3, 2, 1 or 1 point, and it loses a point for each second past “done.” The weekly winner gets a small snack or drink and 15–20 minutes of its own time at a low murmur. The full method is in classroom attention getters.

    The closest researched cousin is the Good Behavior Game, where teams win small prizes for keeping rule-breaking under a set limit. Blueprints rates it “Promising,” with long-term benefits concentrated among highly aggressive first-grade boys and mixed results in independent evaluations (Blueprints for Healthy Youth Development). That’s elementary evidence, and 3-2-1-Done pits whole classes against each other instead of teams within one room, so treat the link as a family resemblance.

    One honest note: in its most recent year, students took about six weeks to buy in, double the usual three.

    Is Elevate the Norm just rewards?

    Elevate the Norm is not just rewards. Positive reinforcement only works if the teacher does exactly what they say, including taking earned privileges away after repeated warnings. Elevate the Norm calls that “remediation.” Serious discipline goes to administration, not the classroom point system. The Center on PBIS describes effective classrooms as “predictable” and consistent for the same reason (Classroom PBIS). More detail in positive discipline for teens and classroom consequences.

    What does “respect both ways” mean in Elevate the Norm?

    In Elevate the Norm, “respect both ways” means teachers model the respect they expect, and students’ urge to talk is channeled into structured roles instead of shut down. The research case here is strong. In a randomized field experiment in five middle schools, a brief online exercise that encouraged teachers to value students’ perspectives and keep relationships positive during discipline cut year-long suspension rates in half, from 9.6% to 4.8% (Okonofua, Paunesku & Walton, PNAS, 2016). That’s what the framework means by respect running both directions. See respect in the classroom.

    Why design it around project-based learning?

    Elevate the Norm is designed around project-based learning because group projects need students who can lead and manage themselves, and many behavior systems assume rows and silence. In a randomized trial across 68 schools, AP U.S. Government and AP Environmental Science students taught with the Knowledge in Action project-based approach were about 8 percentage points more likely to score a 3 or higher (College Board research brief). Elevate the Norm’s recognition criteria reward the habits projects depend on, like follow-through and leading a group. See the project-based learning guide and student leadership activities.

    What are Elevate the Norm’s limitations?

    Elevate the Norm’s main limitations are that it hasn’t been independently tested, it’s one teacher’s classroom system rather than a schoolwide one, and it uses tangible rewards that some research cautions against.

    • No independent evaluation. Every finding above supports a design choice; none tests Elevate the Norm itself.
    • One teacher’s system. It doesn’t give a school data teams, tiered interventions or fidelity tools. PBIS does. See classroom culture frameworks vs PBIS.
    • Rewards carry risk. A meta-analysis of 128 experiments found expected tangible rewards tend to lower intrinsic motivation, while positive verbal feedback tends to raise it (Deci, Koestner & Ryan, Review of Educational Research, 2001). Keeping prizes small and leading with words is how the framework tries to manage that, but it’s a real tension.
    • Not for elementary. It wasn’t written for PreK–5.
    • Buy-in takes weeks. 3-2-1-Done has taken three to six weeks to catch on.
    Graphic listing five limitations of Elevate the Norm: no independent evaluation, one teacher's system, rewards carry risk, not for elementary, and buy-in takes weeks.
    Elevate the Norm’s honest limitations, as listed on this page.

    Clay’s take, as a grades 6–12 classroom teacher: lead with specific words, keep the prizes small, and do exactly what you said you’d do. The research behind each piece is real; the framework as a whole still hasn’t been tested, and this page won’t pretend otherwise.

    The principles behind all of this are on the what we believe page.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What makes Elevate the Norm different from PBIS?

    PBIS is a schoolwide, three-tier system run by a team that uses data to plan supports. Elevate the Norm is a classroom culture framework one teacher can run alone in grades 6 to 12. The two can work together: a teacher in a PBIS school can use Elevate the Norm as the classroom acknowledgment system while the school keeps its tiers and data teams.

    Has Elevate the Norm been studied?

    No. Elevate the Norm hasn’t been independently evaluated, and no claim on this site says it has. Its design choices line up with published research on praise-to-reprimand ratios, the timing of awards and empathic discipline, and each study is linked on this page. That research supports individual design choices, not the framework as a whole.

    Why does Elevate the Norm reward consistency instead of perfection?

    A field experiment with 15,329 students in grades 6 to 12 found that surprise awards for past perfect attendance were followed by about 8.3% more absences the next month. The researchers think the award signaled that perfect attendance wasn’t expected. Elevate the Norm announces criteria in advance and rewards consistency to avoid that effect, though the study looked at attendance, not classroom recognition.

    What is 3-2-1-Done?

    3-2-1-Done is Elevate the Norm’s class-vs-class point system for quieting down. Each class period starts the week at zero, earns 3, 2 or 1 point for being quiet by that count or 1 point on done, and loses a point for each second past done. The weekly winner gets a small snack or drink and 15 to 20 minutes of its own time at a low murmur.

    Does Elevate the Norm cost anything?

    No. Every Elevate the Norm classroom resource is free on this site’s resource library, with no email gate or sign-up. Prizes cost one teacher well under a hundred dollars a year, paid out of pocket. The same teacher sells a separate paid Teacher Emergency Toolkit on TPT, but the framework doesn’t require it.

    Can Elevate the Norm be used in elementary school?

    Elevate the Norm wasn’t written for PreK to 5 and isn’t recommended there. Its recognition tiers, point systems and student roles assume secondary students who rotate through several class periods and expect a say in decisions. Elementary teachers have frameworks built for their grades, including Responsive Classroom, whose main trial covered grades 2 to 5, and Conscious Discipline, written for PreK to 5.

    How long does it take students to buy into Elevate the Norm?

    Buy-in to 3-2-1-Done has taken three to six weeks. Three weeks is typical, and in its most recent year students took about six. Teachers starting Elevate the Norm should plan for a slow first month and keep following through on points and privileges the whole time, because positive systems that never enforce lose credibility with students.

    Do classroom rewards hurt student motivation?

    Expected tangible rewards can lower intrinsic motivation, according to a meta-analysis of 128 experiments by Deci, Koestner and Ryan, while positive verbal feedback tends to raise it. Elevate the Norm tries to manage that tension by leading with specific praise and keeping prizes small, but the tension is real and the framework hasn’t been tested on it.

    Sources

    How is this page kept accurate?

    Study figures come from the original papers or official summaries linked inline. Elevate the Norm is labeled as this site’s own framework wherever it appears, and no claim here says it has been tested. Corrections follow the editorial standards and corrections policy.


    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Classroom Attention Getters: The 3-2-1-Done Method That Took Six Weeks to Work

    Classroom Attention Getters: The 3-2-1-Done Method That Took Six Weeks to Work

    By Clay Shumate

    Classroom attention getters are the signals a teacher uses to move a room from talking to listening: a countdown, a call-and-response, a raised hand, a chime. The one I use with grades 6–12 is 3-2-1-Done — the countdown every kid learned in kindergarten, with a weekly class-versus-class competition attached. The countdown is simple. Getting teenagers to believe in it is not. This year, that took six weeks.

    Key Takeaways

    • The signal is not the problem. Secondary students ignore attention getters that cost them nothing to ignore. The fix is giving the class a stake in answering, not finding a cleverer chant.
    • 3-2-1-Done is scored. Quiet on three earns 3 points, two earns 2, one earns 1, and done earns 1. Every second past done costs a point. Every class starts the week at zero.
    • It is an old, well-studied idea. Class-wide team scoring is the core of the Good Behavior Game, studied since 1969. The evidence is solid, and smaller in randomized trials than in the headline numbers.
    • The reward has to be consistent before it has to be good. A bag of chips every single week beats a pizza party that might happen.
    • Buy-in can take twice as long as you expect. Students who have learned not to trust school will test whether you mean it. Keep going.

    Free Download · PDF

    3-2-1-Done Weekly Scoreboard

    A one-page printable scoreboard with the point values, a row for every class period, a bonus column, and a line for the weekly winner. Print it, post it, fill it in daily. No email required.

    Download the free PDF

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Browse every printable in Your Free Library.

    Why Most Classroom Attention Getters Stop Working After Elementary School

    In second grade, “class, class” gets “yes, yes” because the adult asked. By ninth grade, that is no longer reason enough. A fourteen-year-old weighing whether to finish a sentence to a friend or go quiet for a teacher is doing a small cost-benefit calculation, and most attention getters put nothing on the scale. When attention drops, I pull a card from my Brain Breaks for Middle and High School on TPT: 60 resets that need no prep and no supplies.

    So the signal escalates. The chant gets louder, then the teacher does, and the room learns that the real signal is the third, angriest repetition. That is the pattern behind why yelling manufactures order instead of restoring it: it works for a moment, and it teaches students to wait for it.

    The fix is not a better chant. It is giving the whole class a reason to answer the first one.

    The 3-2-1-Done Method, Step by Step

    Everybody already knows the countdown: three fingers up, three, two, one, done. What changes is that every count is worth something, and every class is keeping score against every other class.

    Scoring chart for the 3-2-1-Done attention getter: plus 3 for quiet on three, plus 2 on two, plus 1 on one, plus 1 on done, and minus 1 for every second past done
    The whole scoring system fits on one poster.
    1. Every class starts the week at zero. Monday is a clean slate for every period, no matter how last week went.
    2. Count down out loud with fingers up. Three, two, one, done.
    3. Award points for when the room goes quiet. Quiet on “three” is 3 points. On “two,” 2 points. On “one,” 1 point. On “done,” also 1 point.
    4. Past done, count the seconds out loud. One Mississippi, two Mississippi, three Mississippi. Every second is a point off.
    5. Post the board. Every class sees every other class’s running total. That visibility is where the competition comes from.
    6. Name a winner every week. Highest total on Friday gets the reward. No skipped weeks.

    Yes, “one” and “done” are both worth a point. That is on purpose: the class gets two chances to earn something before anything is taken away. I would rather drive a room with points it can still earn than with points it is losing. Plenty of teachers skip that and just keep counting — four, five, six — with no second chance at “done.” That works too. Pick one version and hold it all year.

    Other ways to earn and lose points

    The countdown does not have to be the only thing on the board. A class can earn points when every student turns in the day’s work, and lose them for tardies. Add what fits your room, and add it at the start of a week, never in the middle of one.

    Lean on positives or on negatives?

    Both work. I keep negatives as low as I can and give out positives sparingly, so a point means something. I have also seen it run almost entirely on negatives, where the class closest to zero at the end of the week wins. The version matters less than two rules: the scoring never changes midweek, and you are honest about every point. If you shave a point off one class because you are annoyed with them, every class will know by lunch.

    Why It Works: An Old Idea in a New Coat

    Nothing here is new. Scoring a whole class as a team, so that students have a reason to manage each other’s noise rather than just their own, is the core of the Good Behavior Game. Barrish, Saunders and Wolf first described it in 1969, and researchers call the mechanism an interdependent group contingency: the group earns or loses together.

    The research base is large. Bowman-Perrott and colleagues (2016) pooled 21 single-case studies covering 1,580 students from pre-kindergarten through grade 12 and found a large effect: a Tau-U of 0.82, meaning problem behavior dropped substantially and prosocial behavior rose.

    The honest caveat: single-case studies follow a small number of classrooms very closely, and they tend to produce big numbers. When Smith and colleagues (2021) pooled seven randomized controlled trials covering about 4,700 children, the effects were real but modest — Hedges’ g between 0.09 and 0.32, depending on the outcome. Most of that research is also in elementary classrooms, not high schools.

    So the defensible claim is this: class-wide team scoring is one of the better-supported classroom management tools out there, and it will not transform a room overnight. 3-2-1-Done aims it at one behavior — getting quiet on a signal — that happens many times a day. That is exactly the kind of small, repeated moment a modest effect is useful for.

    The Part Nobody Warns You About: Buy-In Took Six Weeks

    A lot of the students I have this year came up through classrooms that were mostly bookwork — worksheets in, worksheets out, next period. They know what that feels like from the student side.

    “Students know when you’re doing that, just like when you’re overstaying your welcome at somebody’s house. They feel it.”

    “Why in the heck would we want a student to feel like they are not wanted or needed somewhere? In a school.”

    So when I told them there would be a Student of the Week every week, and a winning class from 3-2-1-Done every week, they did not believe me. Nobody had ever told them that and then followed through. The first winner did not convince them. Neither did the second.

    Timeline of weeks one through six showing a winning class named every week and students finally buying in during week six
    A winner every single week. Belief showed up in week six.

    “They didn’t believe it. Even after it happened once. And twice. And three, four, five, six times. And then guess what? They bought in.”

    Six weeks is about twice as long as buy-in usually takes me with a new class. But it came, and it came all the way: every student wants the win now, and kids who walked in expecting another year of worksheets enjoy coming to social studies. Who would have thought history wasn’t boring.

    “Sometimes the three weeks is six weeks. Sometimes it’s nine weeks. Sometimes it’s 12, sometimes it’s never.”

    If you are in week three and nothing has moved, that is not evidence the method failed. It may be evidence of how many times these students have been promised something before.

    The Reward: Consistent Beats Big

    My weekly reward is a can of Pringles, a water, and fifteen to twenty minutes of the class’s own time — as long as they stay seated and keep the room at what I call a low murmur. Some teachers give a few minutes of free time. Some do something else entirely. There are plenty of ways to run it.

    Four-part graphic listing what makes a weekly class reward work: consistent, scarce, small, and conditional on staying seated at a low murmur
    The size of the reward matters less than whether it shows up every week.

    What you are after is a consistent reward. A modest reward that arrives every single Friday does more than a big one that might happen. When the class can count on it, they start to believe you — and that belief is the thing you are actually building. The weekly reward is just the proof.

    Two practical checks before you buy snacks. Ask about food allergies and have a non-food swap ready, like extra free time or choosing the seating for a day. And check whether your school has a policy on food rewards or free time; some do, and it is easier to ask first.

    Honesty Is the Whole System

    For a minute, stop calling them students.

    “You can be a student at any age.”

    When I taught at a community college, some of my students were 65 and 70 years old. Nobody would talk to them the way some adults talk to a room of 14- to 17-year-olds, because we assume their maturity is higher. Maybe it is. Maybe it is not. The same is true in a ninth-grade classroom: a 15-year-old might walk in with the maturity of a 10-year-old or of a 19-year-old, and you do not know what either one has had to live through to get there.

    “Children are like rubber bands. They can snap back. But eventually they’re going to break if you snap them too much.”

    That is why the honesty matters more than the scoring. Every point you award or take has to be real. Every winner has to be earned. Every reward has to show up. The countdown is just the part students can see.

    “Once you can gain trust, you better sure as heck not lose it.”

    Keep that trust and you can get a class to buy into more and more of what you need from them. That is how a countdown turns into a classroom management plan that actually runs.

    Common Mistakes With 3-2-1-Done

    • Skipping a week. One missed Friday tells students the promise was never real, and you start the buy-in clock over.
    • Changing the rules midweek. New point sources start on Monday, announced ahead of time.
    • Counting in your head. Say the seconds out loud. If students cannot hear the count, the score feels arbitrary.
    • Turning the countdown into a threat. Keep your voice level. The points carry the weight so your tone does not have to.
    • A reward they can get anyway. If free time is available every day, it is not a reward on Friday.
    • Quitting at week three. Some groups need twice as long. See the section above.

    If you want a second signal for moments when you cannot use your voice, pair the countdown with visual cues students can actually see. And for classes that respond to competition, the same team energy powers classroom review games.

    What It Looks Like When It Works

    Keep a positive attitude through the weeks when nothing seems to move. Keep elevating them. Show them the norm is not bookwork and negative thoughts — it is positive, soft-skill-driven, standards-driven work.

    “They are learning about life as they are learning about history.”

    Or whatever your subject is. That is a win. It is also the whole idea behind positive reinforcement classroom management: the countdown gets the room quiet, and the consistency gets the room to trust you.

    Before you go: grab the free 3-2-1-Done Weekly Scoreboard (PDF) — ElevateTheNorm.com branded, printable, no email required.

    Need the pause itself, not just the signal? Our guide to brain breaks for high schoolers has six formats that survive an older classroom, an honest read of the thin adolescent evidence, and the five mistakes that end the practice in one lesson.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are the best classroom attention getters for high school?

    The ones students have a reason to answer. High schoolers will ignore a chant, a chime, or a raised hand if ignoring it costs nothing. A plain countdown attached to a class score, like 3-2-1-Done, works because the whole class has a stake in going quiet fast. The specific signal matters much less than consistency and a visible payoff.

    Isn’t a 3-2-1 countdown too babyish for teenagers?

    On its own, maybe. With points, a public scoreboard, and a weekly winner, it stops being a kindergarten routine and becomes a competition. Teenagers who would roll their eyes at a chant will go quiet on three when their class is two points behind the period after them.

    Why are ‘one’ and ‘done’ both worth one point?

    It gives the class two chances to earn something before anything is taken away, which keeps the system driven by what students can gain rather than what they are losing. Some teachers skip that and simply keep counting past one. Either version works as long as you choose one and never change it midyear.

    How long does it take for students to buy in?

    Usually about three weeks with a new class, in my experience. This year it took six, because many students did not believe a teacher would actually follow through every week. Some classes take longer. Keep naming a winner every single week; consistency is what eventually convinces them.

    What should the weekly reward be?

    Something small, scarce, and completely consistent. Mine is a snack, a water, and 15 to 20 minutes of the class’s own time as long as they stay seated at a low murmur. Check for food allergies and any school policy on food rewards first, and have a non-food option ready.

    Does class-wide team scoring actually have research behind it?

    Yes. It is the core of the Good Behavior Game, studied since 1969. A 2016 meta-analysis of 21 single-case studies found large reductions in problem behavior, while a 2021 meta-analysis of randomized trials found smaller but real effects. Most of that research is in elementary classrooms, so treat it as a well-supported tool rather than a guaranteed fix for older students.

    Is this a good strategy for new teachers?

    It is one of the easiest systems a first-year teacher can run. It needs no technology, no budget beyond a weekly snack, and one poster. The hard part is not the mechanics; it is holding the line every single week, including the weeks when nothing seems to be working yet.

    Sources

    1. Barrish, Harriet H., Muriel Saunders, and Montrose M. Wolf. “Good Behavior Game: Effects of Individual Contingencies for Group Consequences on Disruptive Behavior in a Classroom.” Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, vol. 2, no. 2, 1969, pp. 119–124. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.1969.2-119
    2. Bowman-Perrott, Lisa, Mack D. Burke, Samar Zaini, Nan Zhang, and Kimberly Vannest. “Promoting Positive Behavior Using the Good Behavior Game: A Meta-Analysis of Single-Case Research.” Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, vol. 18, no. 3, 2016, pp. 180–190. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1104009
    3. Smith, Stephanie, Kimberly Barajas, Brandi Ellis, Christina Moore, Spencer McCauley, and Brian Reichow. “A Meta-Analytic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials of the Good Behavior Game.” Behavior Modification, vol. 45, no. 4, 2021, pp. 641–666. https://doi.org/10.1177/0145445519878670

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.