By Clay Shumate
A 10 point grading scale gives each letter grade a ten-point band: 90–100 is an A, 80–89 a B, 70–79 a C, 60–69 a D, and anything under 60 is an F. It replaced the older seven-point scale, where an A started at 93. Same work, wider bands, sometimes a different letter on the transcript.
Free Download · Printable PDF
10 Point Grading Scale Chart
One page: the letter-grade cutoffs, unweighted and weighted quality points, the 7 point scale side by side, and the five averages where the two scales give a different letter. Print it for your syllabus, your wall or your parent night.
Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Using standards-based grading instead? See what a 1–4 score converts to.
That’s the whole mechanical answer, and it’s the part people come looking for. The part worth staying for is what the switch actually did, because it was never sold as a teaching improvement and it never was one. It moved lines on a page. Whether that helps a student depends entirely on what you do inside the bands.
Key Takeaways
- One letter per ten points. A 90–100, B 80–89, C 70–79, D 60–69, F below 60. North Carolina’s state policy writes the bottom band as “below 59,” which leaves 59 unassigned — a small drafting gap that has been sitting in an adopted statewide policy for years.
- The seven-point scale that the 10 point grading scale replaced started an A at 93 and a B at 85. A student with an 86 average was a B on both scales. A student with a 91 was an A on one and a B on the other.
- States switched to the 10 point grading scale for transcript comparability, not learning. North Carolina’s board voted on 2 October 2014; South Carolina’s approved unanimously on 13 April 2016. Both rationales were about transcripts, college admissions, scholarships and families transferring in.
- No study shows that widening a grading band teaches anybody anything. What a wider band changes is which side of a line a student lands on, and how many students sit near a line at all.
- The research on scale length is not kind to percentages. Simulation work puts the useful number of categories at four to seven. A percentage scale has 101. In one replication, the 73 trained English teachers who graded the same paper on a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96.
What Is a 10 Point Grading Scale?
A 10 point grading scale is a percentage grading scale where every letter covers exactly ten points, so the cutoffs land on round numbers: 90, 80, 70 and 60. Here’s the chart, with the 4.0 quality points most transcripts attach to each letter. If you are starting from a raw score like 3/4 or 14/25, the fraction to letter grade chart converts it to a percent first.
| Letter | Percent | Standard quality points | What it is usually called |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 90–100 | 4.0 | Exceeds or fully meets |
| B | 80–89 | 3.0 | Meets |
| C | 70–79 | 2.0 | Partially meets |
| D | 60–69 | 1.0 | Credit, barely |
| F | below 60 | 0.0 | No credit |
Weighting sits on top of that and is where a lot of transcript confusion actually lives. Under North Carolina’s grading policy, honors courses add 0.5 quality points and AP, IB, Cambridge and eligible dual-enrollment courses add 1.0 — so an A in an AP course is a 5.0, and a student can finish with a weighted GPA above 4.0 while every single grade was earned on the same ten-point bands. Students get both an unweighted and a weighted GPA, and official class rank comes off the weighted one.
One more thing the chart hides: the scale is a reporting rule, not a grading method. It tells you what band a number falls in. It says nothing about how the number was produced, which is the only part you control.
How Is a 10 Point Grading Scale Different From a 7 Point Scale?
The seven-point scale North Carolina used before 2015 set an A at 93–100 and a B at 85–92, and anything below 70 was an F. A 10 point grading scale moves those lines down to 90, 80 and 60. Every cutoff on the seven-point scale is higher, and its F band is much bigger.
| Average | 10 point scale | 7 point scale | What changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 95 | A | A | Nothing |
| 91 | A | B | A full letter and a quality point |
| 86 | B | B | Nothing |
| 69 | D | F | Course credit versus repeating the course |
| 55 | F | F | Nothing |

Run a few numbers through both and the pattern shows up fast. A 91 is an A on the ten-point scale and a B on the seven-point. An 86 is a B either way. A 69 is a D on the ten-point scale and an F on the seven-point — that’s the real one, because it is the difference between credit and a repeated course.
When North Carolina made the change, a local report put the problem in one sentence: a student with a 91 in every class had a 4.0 in Atlanta and a 3.0 at home. That is not a rigor argument. It is a paperwork argument, and it was a fair one.
Notice what the comparison does not show. It does not show that students on one scale learn more. Both scales are percentage scales. Both carry every problem a percentage scale has. One of them just puts the walls in different places.
Why Did States Switch to a 10 Point Grading Scale?
States switched to a 10 point grading scale because transcripts weren’t comparable across state lines, so students graded on a seven-point scale competed for college admission and scholarships at a disadvantage.
North Carolina’s State Board of Education approved the ten-point range on 2 October 2014, beginning with freshmen in 2015–16. Elementary and middle schools kept the right to use a locally approved system, though the state recommends the same 90–100 scale, and any high school course taken in middle school has to use the high school scale.
South Carolina’s State Board approved a uniform ten-point scale unanimously on 13 April 2016, effective 2016–17. The reasons the department gave were specific: the change would help military and other families transferring into the state, give South Carolina students an equal chance against neighboring states for college admission and scholarships, and end the confusion for students in dual-credit courses. Its conversion chart puts 59 and below at F, so South Carolina doesn’t have the gap North Carolina’s policy text leaves at 59. The department also said it would re-examine its Hope, Life and Palmetto Fellows scholarship requirements “to ensure fairness and rigor” afterward — which is the quiet admission that moving cutoffs moves who qualifies for money.
That is the honest case for the switch, and it is strong. It is also narrow. Nobody in either state claimed a wider B band would improve a single lesson, and nobody should quote them as if they had.
If you are the one who has to implement a change like that, the hard part is not the new chart. South Carolina’s department named the real work in its own announcement: deciding the timing, merging grade calculations for students already enrolled, and preparing for the knock-on effect on lottery-funded scholarships. For a year or two you have students in the same building whose transcripts were built on two different rules, and every one of those families deserves a plain-language explanation before they ask for one.
Does a 10 Point Grading Scale Make Grades Easier?
A 10 point grading scale lowers four cutoffs, so on identical work more students clear each line. That isn’t the same thing as grade inflation, and the two get confused constantly.
Grade inflation is real and it’s measurable. An ACT study of one southern state’s ACT-tested graduates found mean self-reported high school GPA rose from 3.17 in the 2017 class to 3.38 in 2022, and its model adjusted for students’ and schools’ ACT scores when estimating how much of that was inflation. It also found inflation weakened what a GPA predicts: for two students with a 2.5, the one from a school with 0.5 of inflation was predicted to finish first-year college 0.37 GPA points lower.
Read that carefully before you use it. That study is one state, a sample that was majority White and slightly majority female, and a five-year window that included the pandemic. It does not attribute any of the rise to scale changes, and it does not test scale changes at all. Anyone telling you the ten-point scale caused grade inflation is borrowing a real number to support a claim nobody has tested.
One finding in it does deserve attention from anyone thinking about equity: the inflation the study estimated was concentrated more among schools whose average GPAs were lower to begin with — a correlation, not a cause. If a GPA means less coming out of the schools whose students can least afford a discounted signal, that is a problem worth naming — and it is a problem about grading practice, not about where the A cutoff sits.
What the scale change genuinely does is a one-time shift in the distribution. Every student near a cutoff moves up a letter once, and then the system settles. If grades keep climbing after that, the cause is somewhere else — in retake policies, in how late work gets scored, in extra credit, in what gets averaged into the gradebook at all.
How Many Levels Should a Grading Scale Have?
A grading scale works best with far fewer than a hundred levels. Simulation research lands on four to seven categories, and a percentage scale has 101.

Lozano, García-Cueto and Muñiz simulated thirty-item scales across sample sizes from 50 to 500 and response options from two to nine. Reliability and validity improved as options increased, but the gains flattened out: their conclusion was that the optimum sits between four and seven, that fewer than four costs you real precision, and that past seven the improvement is small. That is a psychometric simulation, not a classroom study, and it is about rating scales generally rather than report cards — but 101 is not within shouting distance of seven.
Thomas Guskey has made the applied version of this argument for years. His case against percentage grades is that the precision is imaginary: a standard error of two items on a twenty-item test becomes a twenty-point range on a percentage scale, often spanning two letter grades. More cutoffs mean more students misclassified at boundaries, not fewer. And with a pass mark near 60, roughly two-thirds of the scale is devoted to describing gradations of failure that nobody needs.
The reliability evidence underneath that is older than most grading debates. In 1912 and 1913, Starch and Elliott had 147 high school English teachers grade two identical papers — scores ran 64 to 98 on one and 50 to 97 on the other — and 128 mathematics teachers grade geometry papers, where one paper drew scores from 28 to 95. A century later Hunter Brimi ran the replication with teachers in a single district who’d been trained in a writing-assessment framework. Ninety teachers graded one paper; the 73 who used a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96.
Here is the part that cuts against the easy conclusion. If fewer levels are better, then the ten-point scale is an improvement on the seven-point one, because its bands are wider and its boundaries are fewer in the range where students actually cluster. But it is still a percentage scale with 101 levels underneath the letters, and Guskey’s own recommendation is not a wider percentage band at all — it is a 0–4 integer scale. If you want that argument in full, including why the conversion back to a letter is the hard part, it is in the 1–4 scale and its conversion problem, and the system it belongs to is laid out in what standards-based grading actually fixes.
What Changes for a Student at 69 Instead of 70?
A student at 69 earns a D and course credit on a 10 point grading scale, but an F and a repeated course on a seven-point scale. Same work, same kid, different year.
That is the strongest practical argument for the wider bands, and it deserves to be stated plainly rather than buried in a policy rationale. It is also the argument that should make you look hard at your own gradebook, because the scale is not what put the student at 69. Something else did, and a wider band does not fix it. It just stops that particular thing from costing a credit.
There is a cost on the other side, and it is worth saying before someone else does. A ten-point scale hands out credit at 60 that a seven-point scale withheld until 70. Some of those students walk into the next course without the ground under them, and the transcript says they are fine. The letter is not the problem there — the problem is a student moving up without the skill, and nothing about the band width tells you which students those are. That is what the boundary review in the next section is for.
The zero is where this gets ugly. On a 100-point scale a single zero is not one bad grade, it is a hole — moving a student from a zero to passing takes six or seven times the gain that moving a B to an A takes. Guskey, Fisher and Frey call minimum-grade policies a Band-Aid for exactly this reason: a 50 percent floor is an attempt to fix the arithmetic of the scale without changing the scale, and teachers using one still have to tell apart 51 distinct levels of performance. Several districts have put floors in and then pulled them back out; Texas legislated against them.
None of that is an argument for giving a student a number they did not earn. It is an argument for not building a system where one missed assignment is mathematically unrecoverable. If a student can screw up that badly in your class, look at the planning before you look at the student — and give them a real route back, whether that is test corrections that actually teach or a reassessment with the same standard and a new attempt.
How Do You Run a 10 Point Scale Without Lying to Students?
Run a 10 point grading scale honestly by treating it as the reporting rule it is and putting your effort into what produces the number. Five things, in order.

- Publish the cutoffs in September, in writing. A rule given in advance is a policy. The same rule produced in May is an argument you will lose. Include the weighting if your school weights, because that is where families get blindsided.
- Grade against criteria, not against the class. A ten-point band is only meaningful if 85 means something describable. If it means “a bit above the middle of this particular group,” the band is decoration. A written description of what each level looks like does more for accuracy than any cutoff you pick, and the quickest way in is to write the description of a 90 and the description of a 70 first. Once the top and the pass line are on paper in plain words, the middle writes itself.
- Keep behavior out of the number. Compliance, neatness and attendance are real and worth tracking, and they are not what the letter is supposed to report. Starch and Elliott found math teachers factoring neatness, form and spelling into geometry grades in 1913. That has not gone away on its own.
- Build the route back before anyone needs it. Decide in advance what a student does about a zero, a missed assessment, or a standard they have not reached yet — and write it down with the cutoffs. Deciding case by case is how you end up being generous to the students who ask and strict with the ones who do not.
- Read the cutoff cases by hand before grades post. Pull everyone within two points of a line and look at the evidence instead of the average. In most sections that is a handful of students, and it is a few minutes of reading rather than a re-grade. The arithmetic put them there; your judgment is what the cutoff was always standing in for. If you cannot defend the letter to the student, do not post it — and if the student thinks you have it wrong, let them bring the evidence and make the case. A sixteen-year-old arguing from their own work is the best outcome on this entire list.
Then say it out loud to the room. Students handle a hard line fine when it was announced in advance and applied the same way to everybody. What they do not forgive is a cutoff that moved. Doing exactly what you said you would do is the entire mechanism, and it works the same way with families as it does with a seventeen-year-old staring at an 89.
What Should Teachers and Schools Do About a 10 Point Grading Scale?
Teachers on a 10 point grading scale should put their effort into what happens inside the bands. Schools choosing a scale should know the switch buys comparable transcripts and nothing instructional.
If you’re a teacher on a ten-point scale, you don’t get to choose it, so spend your effort on the steps above that are yours: published cutoffs, criteria instead of a curve, behavior out of the number, a route back, and a hand-read of the boundary cases. The band is somebody else’s decision. The number inside it is yours.
If you are the one choosing the system, the honest brief is short. Moving from seven points to ten buys you comparable transcripts, fewer students failing on a technicality, and fewer boundaries to misclassify at — and it buys you nothing instructional. If you want the scale itself to carry meaning, the evidence points past percentages altogether, toward four to seven levels with written descriptors. Start with how the gradebook has to be set up, because that is the part that decides whether a new scale survives its second year.
Clay’s take: whatever scale you’re on, write your rule down before you need it. That single habit prevents more grading arguments than any scale ever has.
Frequently Asked Questions
Whatever scale your district uses, the semester exam is where the cutoffs bite hardest, so the test itself should be sound. Mid-Terms.org has 200 free printable midterms with answer keys for grades 6–12 in Social Studies, ELA, Math and Science, with a Form A and Form B for every course.
What are the letter grades on a 10 point grading scale?
Each letter covers a ten-point band: 90 to 100 is an A, 80 to 89 is a B, 70 to 79 is a C, 60 to 69 is a D, and anything below 60 is an F. On the older seven-point scale it replaced, an A started at 93, so the same work could earn a different letter on the transcript.
What letter grade is an 85 on a 10 point scale?
An 85 is a B on a 10 point grading scale, because the B band runs from 80 to 89. A 95 is an A, a 75 a C, a 65 a D, and anything under 60 an F. An 85 is a B on the older seven-point scale too, but a 91 isn’t: it’s an A on the ten-point scale and a B on the seven-point.
Is a 10 point grading scale easier?
On identical work, a 10 point grading scale lets more students clear each line, because four cutoffs moved down. That’s arithmetic, not generosity, and it happens once when the scale changes rather than year after year. It isn’t the same thing as grade inflation, and no study has tested whether switching scales causes inflation. If grades keep climbing after the transition year, look at retake rules, late-work scoring and extra credit.
Why did states switch to a 10 point grading scale?
States switched to a 10 point grading scale for transcript comparability, not for learning. North Carolina’s State Board approved it on 2 October 2014, starting with 2015–16 freshmen, after reports that a student with a 91 average could hold a 4.0 in one state and a 3.0 in another. South Carolina’s board approved it unanimously on 13 April 2016, citing families transferring in, college admissions, scholarships and dual-credit confusion.
Should a teacher round an 89 up to an A?
Whether to round an 89 up to an A should be decided before September and applied to everyone; that’s the only fair version. A published rule is a policy. The same decision made in May for one student is a favor, and the class will hear about it. The defensible practice is reviewing every student within a point or two of a line against the actual evidence, and letting a student who disagrees bring their work.
Is a D a passing grade on a 10 point grading scale?
A D (60–69) normally earns course credit and one quality point, so it passes. Whether it counts toward a specific requirement is a separate question — many graduation pathways, athletic eligibility rules, NCAA core-course lists and college prerequisites set a higher floor than a D. It is also the band most worth a second look, because a student can clear 60 and still walk into the next course without the ground under them.
Does a 10 point grading scale hurt college admissions?
A 10 point grading scale generally helps in college admissions, which is why states adopted it. A student graded on a seven-point scale could arrive with a lower GPA than an identically performing student from a ten-point state, and the switch removes that penalty. It doesn’t change course rigor, test scores or weighting, where honors courses usually add 0.5 quality points and AP, IB or dual-enrollment courses add 1.0.
How many levels should a grading scale have?
A grading scale needs far fewer than a hundred levels, according to the research. A simulation study by Lozano, García-Cueto and Muñiz found reliability and validity improving up to about four to seven response categories, with little gain past seven. A percentage scale has 101. In one replication study, the 73 trained English teachers who graded the same paper on a 100-point scale gave it scores from 50 to 96.
Sources
- North Carolina State Board of Education. GRAD-009: High School Grading and Transcript Standards. Adopted 1 June 2017, last revised 7 November 2024. States the required high school scale (A 90–100, B 80–89, C 70–79, D 60–69, F below 59), the 4.0 quality-point values, honors +0.5 and AP/IB/CIE/college +1.0 weighting in force since 2015–16, dual unweighted and weighted GPAs, and the local option for elementary and middle schools. The policy text reads “< 59 = F,” which leaves a score of exactly 59 unassigned; that is reported here as written. GRAD-009 (PDF)
- South Carolina Department of Education. 10-Point Uniform Grading Scale Approved by State Board of Education. News release, 13 April 2016. Unanimous approval effective 2016–17; rationale covers military and other families transferring in, an equal chance against neighboring states for college admission and scholarships, and confusion in dual-credit courses; notes the implementation work of merging calculations for enrolled students and reviewing the Hope, Life and Palmetto Fellows scholarships. ed.sc.gov
- South Carolina Department of Education. 10-Point Grading Scale Conversion Chart. Linked from the release above. Whole-number conversion: 90 and up A, 80 B, 70 C, 60 D, 59 and below F, with honors and AP/IB/dual-credit weightings. ed.sc.gov (PDF)
- WRAL. NC changes high school grading scale. 2 October 2014. Reports the State Board vote, the prior seven-point ranges (A 93–100, B 85–92, failing below 70), the 2015–16 freshman start, and the 91-average example yielding a 4.0 in Atlanta against a 3.0 in North Carolina. News reporting, cited for the vote date and the comparison it states rather than as research. wral.com
- Guskey, T. R. (2013). The Case Against Percentage Grades. Educational Leadership, 71(1), 68–72. Argues that a 100-level scale creates false precision (a two-item standard error on a twenty-item test becomes a twenty-point range), that more cutoffs mean more boundary misclassification, that roughly two-thirds of the scale describes failure once the pass mark sits near 60, and that a single zero takes six or seven times the gain of a B-to-A move to recover from. Recommends a 0–4 integer scale instead. Read in the author’s own posted copy; this is an argument article, not an empirical study, and his recommendation is not a wider percentage band. tguskey.com (PDF)
- Guskey, T. R., Fisher, D., & Frey, N. (2024). The Unwinnable Battle Over Minimum Grades. Educational Leadership, 82(2). Treats 50 percent floors as a “Band-Aid approach” to the arithmetic of the percentage scale, notes that a teacher using one must still discern 51 distinct levels of performance, and records districts amending or rescinding such policies and Texas legislating against them. Cites the four-to-seven-level reliability research. ascd.org
- Brimi, H. M. (2011). Reliability of Grading High School Work in English. Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation, 16(17). Ninety high school English teachers in a single district, trained in NWREL’s 6+1 Traits of Writing, graded one identical student paper; the 73 who used a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96. Cited from the ERIC record, which was read; the journal’s full text was not. One paper, one district. eric.ed.gov
- Lozano, L. M., García-Cueto, E., & Muñiz, J. (2008). Effect of the Number of Response Categories on the Reliability and Validity of Rating Scales. Methodology, 4(2), 73–79. Monte Carlo simulation of thirty-item scales, inter-item correlations .2–.9, samples of 50–500, two to nine response options; reliability and validity rise with more categories but the optimum sits between four and seven, with small gains past seven. A psychometric simulation of rating scales in general, not a study of report-card grades, and cited from the published abstract. doi.org/10.1027/1614-2241.4.2.73
- Sanchez, E. I. (2025). The Implications of Grade Inflation: Evaluating the Prediction of First-Year College GPA Using High School GPA and ACT Scores. ACT Research Report R2432. Mean self-reported HSGPA rose from 3.17 (2017 class) to 3.38 (2022) in one southern state with a statewide ACT contract; cohorts of 22,717 and 16,199 students; inflation appeared concentrated among lower-GPA schools; for two students at a 2.5 HSGPA, 0.5 of school inflation predicted a first-year college GPA 0.37 points lower. One state, a majority-White, slightly majority-female sample, and a window that includes the pandemic. The study does not test grading-scale changes and attributes none of the rise to them. act.org (PDF)
- Starch, D., & Elliott, E. C. (1912). Reliability of the Grading of High-School Work in English. The School Review, 20(7), 442–457; and the 1913 mathematics companion study. Cited as reported by Guskey (2013) — 147 English teachers scoring two identical papers 64–98 and 50–97, and 128 mathematics teachers scoring one geometry paper 28–95. The 1912 article’s bibliographic record was confirmed, but the full text was not read in this session, so the figures are attributed to Guskey’s account of them. archive.org


