The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Category: Templates & Printables

Free, ready-to-use classroom templates, logs, checklists, and printable packs for grades 6-12 teachers.

  • PBL Rubric Bundles for Middle and High School: Free and Paid Options

    PBL Rubric Bundles for Middle and High School: Free and Paid Options

    By Clay Shumate

    The best PBL rubric bundles for middle and high school start free. PBLWorks offers research-based 6–12 rubrics for collaboration, critical thinking, creativity, communication and self-direction with a free account, and Elevate the Norm publishes a free editable grades 6–12 PBL rubric. Paid bundles on Teachers Pay Teachers mostly save formatting time, not grading quality.

    Key Takeaways

    • PBLWorks’ five success skills rubrics were built with the National Center for the Improvement of Educational Assessment, come in a 6–12 version, and can be modified with attribution.
    • PBLWorks’ skills rubrics don’t assess subject content, so every PBL project still needs content rows the teacher writes.
    • Elevate the Norm offers a free grades 6–12 PBL rubric, presentation rubric and Socratic seminar rubric with no email gate.
    • A good secondary PBL rubric scores each student’s content knowledge separately from the group’s product.
    • Single-point rubrics work best for drafts and feedback during a project; analytic rubrics work best for the final grade.

    A PBL rubric bundle is a set of ready-made scoring guides for project-based learning, usually covering skills like collaboration and presenting, and sometimes content. Most teachers searching for one want one of two things: rubrics for the skills every project uses (collaboration, presenting, thinking) or a rubric for the content of a specific project. Free sources cover the first need very well. The second you’ll usually have to build or adapt. This page covers both, and ends with what separates a rubric that works in a secondary classroom from one that just looks thorough. For STEM-specific criteria, see our separate guide to PBL rubrics for high school STEM.

    Are there good free PBL rubrics for middle and high school?

    Good free PBL rubrics for middle and high school do exist, and PBLWorks’ research-based 6–12 success skills rubrics are the best-documented set. For the skills side of a project, they’re more than most teachers need.

    PBLWorks built five success skills rubrics with the National Center for the Improvement of Educational Assessment, based on a literature review for each skill: critical thinking, collaboration, self-directed learning, complex communication, and creativity. Each comes in K–2, 3–5, and 6–12 versions, and PBLWorks says you can modify them with attribution. The collaboration rubric page shows the 2023 versions sit behind a free login.

    PBLWorks also publishes a set of “4 Cs” rubrics. Its guide to using them explains that they draw on Common Core ELA literacy standards, cite those standards in the At Standard column, and leave the Above Standard column blank on purpose so you can describe exceptional work or write it with students. That same guide links presentation rubrics for upper elementary, middle school, and high school.

    Two more PBLWorks rubrics are aimed at teachers rather than students. The Project Design Rubric and Project Based Teaching Rubric help you judge your own project against the Gold Standard model, and a “Rubric for Rubrics” describes what makes a rubric well written.

    One honest limit: PBLWorks says these rubrics are for skills, not subject content. You’ll still need content rows for the actual history, science, or English in the project.

    What free PBL rubrics does Elevate the Norm offer?

    Elevate the Norm publishes three free secondary rubrics on the page itself, with no email or download wall: a full PBL rubric, a presentation rubric, and a Socratic seminar rubric.

    • Rubric for project-based learning: an editable grades 6–12 template with eight categories (content knowledge, inquiry, evidence, application, collaboration, revision, communication, reflection). It’s built so a student can’t disappear into a group grade, and it includes a student-friendly version plus adjustments for grades 6–7, 8–10, and 11–12.
    • Presentation rubric: scores the content and reasoning of a presentation rather than nerves or eye contact, with notes on grading group presentations and students who can’t present in front of the class.
    • Socratic seminar rubric: a grades 6–12 discussion rubric that scores preparation and reasoning instead of how many times a student talked.

    Disclosure: these come from Elevate the Norm, this site’s own framework, written by a practicing grades 6–12 teacher. They haven’t been independently evaluated. More free tools are in the resources library.

    Three free secondary rubrics from Elevate the Norm: project-based learning rubric, presentation rubric, and Socratic seminar rubric
    The three free grades 6–12 rubrics published on this site, with no email gate.

    How do free and paid PBL rubric sources compare?

    Free PBL rubric sources win on skills rubrics, while paid sources mostly save formatting time. The table compares five sources by cost, grade band, coverage, and whether you can edit them.

    SourceCostGrade bandsWhat it coversEditable?
    PBLWorks success skills rubricsFree accountK–2, 3–5, 6–12Critical thinking, collaboration, self-direction, communication, creativityYes, with attribution
    PBLWorks presentation rubricsLinked from PBLWorks; check access termsUpper elementary, middle, high schoolFinal presentationsAdaptable
    Elevate the Norm PBL rubricFree, no email6–12, with 3 grade-band adjustmentsContent plus skills, individual vs. groupYes
    Teachers Pay TeachersFree to paidVaries by sellerAnything; quality variesOften
    Teacher Emergency Toolkit Grading & Assessment bundlePaid ($25.50 list; often on sale)6–12Single-point rubrics, retakes, makeup workRubrics editable
    Table comparing five PBL rubric sources by cost and grade band: PBLWorks skills rubrics, PBLWorks presentation rubrics, Elevate the Norm, TPT, and the TEK bundle
    Cost and grade bands for the five PBL rubric sources covered in this guide.

    Teachers Pay Teachers is the main marketplace for paid PBL rubric bundles. Filter by grade band and preview an actual rubric page before buying.

    TPT’s browse sidebar lets you filter by grade (middle school 6th–8th, high school 9th–12th), subject, format, and price, including a Free option. A search on project-based learning with Common Core alone returns more than 35,000 results, so filters matter. Look at the preview for an actual rubric page, check whether the file is editable (Google or Microsoft formats usually are; flat PDFs usually aren’t), and read reviews for comments from teachers who used it in class. If your gradebook uses a 4-point scale, the 1-4 grading scale chart shows how those levels convert.

    Paid option from this site’s author: the Grading & Assessment Growing Bundle in the Teacher Emergency Toolkit store is owned by the same teacher who writes this site, so weigh this mention accordingly. It’s five printable resources for grades 6–12: editable single-point rubrics with 30 feedback codes, a test corrections and retake system, a makeup work system, test-taking lessons, and an end-of-quarter reflection. Its list price is $25.50, and TPT often shows it on sale for less. As a growing bundle, the price rises as resources are added, so confirm the current price on TPT. It’s a general grading toolkit, not a PBL-specific set, and the single-point rubrics are the part most useful for projects. The full store is linked from our store page.

    What makes a PBL rubric good for secondary students?

    A good secondary PBL rubric grades each student’s learning separately from the group’s product, uses language students can act on, and has few enough rows that you’ll actually use it.

    Use this checklist when you look at any free or paid rubric:

    1. Individual content knowledge is its own row. A group can make a polished product with the wrong answer. Content understanding should always be scored per student.
    2. Skills and content are separated. PBLWorks recommends adding content rows or a separate content rubric to its skills rubrics. Mixing them hides what a student actually knows.
    3. Descriptors name observable work. “Cites two credible sources and explains how they support the claim” beats “uses good research.”
    4. Students see it on day one. PBLWorks advises giving students the rubric early and having them self-assess at checkpoints.
    5. It fits the grade band. Sixth graders need fewer rows and plainer words than seniors. A rubric with 12 rows and four levels is 48 descriptors no 12-year-old will read.
    6. It has a student version. If the only version is teacher-facing, students can’t use it to revise.
    7. It doesn’t grade the wrong things. Neatness, color, and “effort” rows reward supplies and confidence, not learning.
    Six numbered checks for a secondary PBL rubric: individual content row, skills separated from content, observable descriptors, shared day one, student version, no wrong rows
    Six of the seven checks above, in one graphic, to run on any free or paid PBL rubric before using it with secondary students.

    Should I use single-point or analytic rubrics for projects?

    Use an analytic rubric for a project’s final grade and a single-point rubric for drafts and feedback along the way.

    An analytic rubric describes every level for every row, which helps when grades need to hold up to a parent or administrator. A single-point rubric describes only the target and leaves space for “needs work” and “beyond” comments, which makes it faster to use during critique and revision. Many secondary teachers use both in one project: single-point during the build, analytic at the end. If your school uses standards-based grading, our standards-based grading rubrics show a four-level version.

    Clay’s take: As a grades 6–12 teacher, I’d start with the free PBLWorks skills rubrics and spend the time you saved writing two or three content rows for your own project. That’s the part no bundle can write for you.

    Does Elevate the Norm sell a PBL rubric bundle?

    Elevate the Norm doesn’t sell a PBL-specific rubric bundle. Its free rubrics cover grades 6–12 project, presentation, and discussion assessment instead.

    Disclosure again: Elevate the Norm is this site’s own framework and hasn’t been independently evaluated. The free rubrics above pair with the project-based learning guide and PBL tools roundup. If you need units to go with your rubric, see where to find Common Core-aligned PBL units. For classroom systems more broadly, the classroom culture frameworks Q&A answers 63 common questions.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Are PBLWorks rubrics free?

    Yes. PBLWorks offers its research-based success skills rubrics free through My.PBLWorks.org, which asks you to create a free account before downloading. The rubrics cover critical thinking, collaboration, self-directed learning, complex communication and creativity, come in K-2, 3-5 and 6-12 versions, and may be modified with attribution.

    What should a middle school PBL rubric include?

    A middle school PBL rubric should include an individual content knowledge row, a few skills rows such as collaboration and communication, plain student-friendly language, and a short student version. Keep it to a handful of rows. A rubric with 12 rows and four levels is 48 descriptors, which is more than most sixth and seventh graders will read.

    Do I need to buy a PBL rubric bundle?

    Most teachers don’t need to buy a PBL rubric bundle for skills like collaboration, presentation and critical thinking, because PBLWorks and Elevate the Norm offer free versions. A paid bundle can save formatting time, but no bundle knows your project, so you’ll still need to write the content rows yourself.

    What is a single-point rubric?

    A single-point rubric describes only the target performance for each criterion and leaves open space on either side for comments on what needs work and what goes beyond. It’s faster to use than an analytic rubric during critique and revision, so it works well for drafts and feedback while a project is still being built.

    How do I grade individuals in a group project?

    Score content knowledge and communication for each student individually, and use collaboration rows that measure each student’s own contribution rather than how well the group got along. A polished group product can hide a student who doesn’t understand the content. The free Elevate the Norm PBL rubric is built around this individual-versus-group split.

    Will a PBL rubric grade hold up if a parent questions it?

    An analytic PBL rubric holds up best when a parent or administrator questions a grade, because it describes every level for every row. Share the rubric with students on day one, keep a student version they can read, and score content per student so the grade reflects what that student actually showed.

    Can teachers change the PBLWorks rubrics?

    Teachers can modify the PBLWorks success skills rubrics as long as they give PBLWorks attribution. PBLWorks suggests reviewing and pilot testing the rubrics and adapting them to your local context. It also recommends adding content rows or a separate content rubric, because its skills rubrics don’t assess subject knowledge.

    Should students help write a PBL rubric?

    Students can help write part of a PBL rubric. PBLWorks leaves the Above Standard column of its 4 Cs rubrics blank on purpose so teachers can describe exceptional work or write it with students, for example by studying strong past work. Either way, students should see the rubric on day one and self-assess at checkpoints.

    Sources

    How is this page kept accurate?

    Every product fact and price on this page is checked against its source and linked inline. Prices change, so confirm on each site before buying. Products owned by this site’s author are labeled. See our editorial standards and corrections policy to report an error.


    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Would You Rather Questions for Students: 105 Classroom-Safe Prompts for Grades 6–12

    Would You Rather Questions for Students: 105 Classroom-Safe Prompts for Grades 6–12

    By Clay Shumate

    Would you rather questions for students are two-choice prompts that make every student pick a side and give a reason. In grades 6–12 they work as five-minute bell ringers, discussion warm-ups and brain breaks. Use clean, classroom-safe questions, have students write before they talk, and grade the reason, never the choice.

    Would you rather questions are two-choice prompts that force a decision and a reason. This page has 105 clean, school-appropriate would you rather questions for students, sorted into six sets, plus a five-minute routine that keeps the fun from turning into chaos.

    The questions are the easy part. The routine is what makes a would you rather game worth the class time: students commit in writing, pick a side, and defend it with a reason. That is the same skill a Socratic seminar asks for, practiced in five low-stakes minutes.

    Key Takeaways

    • 105 would you rather questions for students, in six sets: icebreakers, history and social studies, academic and thinking, funny, middle school, and high school.
    • Classroom-safe questions stay off private ground. None asks about appearance, family money, religion, partisan politics or anything a student couldn’t answer in front of the whole room.
    • Thirty seconds of silent writing comes first. Writing before talking turns a would you rather game into a thinking routine, because quiet students commit before they hear the loudest opinion.
    • Grade the reason, never the choice. A would you rather pick can’t be wrong; the reason behind it is what students practice.
    • Free printable cards. All 105 questions come as cut-apart PDF cards, eight per page, with no email required.

    Why should teachers use would you rather questions in class?

    Would you rather questions get every student into the conversation in the first minute of class, instead of the same five hands, because nobody needs background knowledge and no answer is wrong. There’s no right answer to fear. That makes these questions especially useful in the first weeks of school, with new students, and with classes that are slow to talk.

    They also teach something real. To answer well, a student has to make a choice, give a reason, and listen to someone who chose the other side. Those are the core moves of argument writing and discussion in every subject. A would you rather question is a low-stakes place to practice them before the stakes go up. When students are ready for a graded discussion, use the Socratic seminar rubric for high school.

    Finally, they are a classroom management tool. A short, predictable opener gives students something to do the moment they walk in, which is the same idea behind good bell ringer ideas and classroom routines. When the routine is the same every day, the start of class runs itself.

    Four steps of a five-minute would you rather classroom routine: write first, move, defend, pivot
    Same four steps every time, so students know the drill.

    How do you use would you rather questions as bell ringers?

    A would you rather bell ringer runs the same four steps every time: write, move, defend, pivot. The whole routine takes about five minutes once students know it.

    1. Write first. Post the question as students walk in. They write their pick and one reason in a notebook or on a sticky note. Thirty seconds of silence. This step keeps quieter students from just copying the loudest opinion.
    2. Move. One side of the room for option A, the other for option B. No middle. Movement wakes up a sleepy first period and makes the vote visible.
    3. Defend. Call on two students from each side for one reason each. If you use cold calling, the written answer from step one means nobody is caught empty-handed.
    4. Pivot. Ask, “Did anyone hear a reason that almost changed your mind?” Then connect it to the lesson and move on.

    Clay’s take: Stop at five minutes. A bell ringer that eats fifteen minutes stops being a bell ringer, and students learn they can stretch it.

    When you would rather have the question written for you, our daily bell ringers page posts a fresh set for grades 6–8 and 9–12 every school day, with teacher notes hidden until you want them.

    StepWhat students doWhy it matters
    1. WriteWrite their pick and one reason during 30 seconds of silenceQuiet students commit before hearing the loudest opinion
    2. MoveGo to the option A or option B side of the room, no middleWakes up the room and makes the vote visible
    3. DefendTwo students from each side give one reason eachPractices claim and reason; nobody is caught empty-handed
    4. PivotAnswer: did anyone hear a reason that almost changed your mind?Connects the warm-up to the lesson
    The five-minute would you rather routine. Stop at five minutes.

    How do you use would you rather questions for class discussion?

    For a longer would you rather discussion, pick a question from the history or thinking sets and ask students to argue the side they didn’t choose. Arguing the other side is harder than it sounds, and it is one of the best quick exercises for argument writing. Other variations that work well in grades 6–12:

    • Reason ranking. Collect five reasons on the board. Students rank them from strongest to weakest and explain the top one.
    • Evidence round. For a history question, students must use one fact from the unit to support their choice.
    • Write-around. Each student writes a reason, passes the paper, and the next student responds to it in writing.
    • Exit ticket version. Use a question that connects to the day’s lesson as the last thing students answer before they leave.

    How do you keep would you rather questions from getting out of hand?

    Would you rather discussions get noisy because of unclear rules, not because of the questions. Set these four norms once and post them:

    Graphic titled Four norms that keep it under control, listing pick one, give a reason you could say to a judge, disagree with the reason never the person, and one pass per week.
    The four norms to post before the first round.
    • Pick one. “Both” and “neither” are not answers. The point is to commit.
    • Give a reason you could say to a judge. “Because it’s cool” is a start, not an answer.
    • Disagree with the reason, never the person. This is where a fun activity can turn into a lesson in respect in the classroom.
    • One pass per week. Students may pass once. It lowers anxiety without letting anyone opt out every day.

    Use a consistent signal to end the movement and bring the room back. If you need one, our post on classroom attention getters has several that work with teenagers. And keep the questions fair: skip any prompt that would make a student reveal something about their family, money, body or beliefs. Every question on this list was written with that rule in mind.

    Free download: 105 would you rather question cards

    Fifteen pages. Page 1 is the five-minute routine and classroom norms. The rest are 105 cut-apart cards, eight per page, labeled by set and numbered to match this article. Print on card stock and keep a stack by the door.

    Free. No email address required. Built for grades 6–12.

    The questions below are numbered straight through, 1 to 105, so the cards and this page match.

    What are good icebreaker would you rather questions for students?

    Good icebreaker would you rather questions are low-stakes choices every student can answer without knowing anything, like flying versus being invisible. Use them in the first weeks, after a long break, or any time a new student joins.

    1. Would you rather be able to talk to animals or speak every human language?
    2. Would you rather have a rewind button or a pause button for your life?
    3. Would you rather live in a big city or in the middle of the countryside?
    4. Would you rather be the best player on a losing team or a bench player on a championship team?
    5. Would you rather read the book or watch the movie first?
    6. Would you rather have summer all year or winter all year?
    7. Would you rather be famous for something you made or for something you did?
    8. Would you rather explore the deep ocean or outer space?
    9. Would you rather always know the answer or always ask the best question?
    10. Would you rather have a personal chef or a personal driver?
    11. Would you rather wake up at sunrise every day or stay up until 2 a.m. every night?
    12. Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible?
    13. Would you rather know how to play every instrument or speak every language?
    14. Would you rather have one best friend or ten good friends?
    15. Would you rather be really good at one thing or pretty good at everything?
    16. Would you rather never have homework again or never have a test again?
    17. Would you rather live without music or without movies?
    18. Would you rather plan every detail of a trip or show up and figure it out?
    19. Would you rather be the oldest sibling or the youngest?
    20. Would you rather have a free week off school now or an extra week of summer later?

    What are good would you rather questions for history and social studies?

    History would you rather questions put students inside a period, such as ancient Rome or the Constitutional Convention, and make them defend a choice. They do double duty as a hook: the reasons students give tell you what they already think about the period before you teach it. See our history project ideas for unit ideas they lead into.

    1. Would you rather meet a famous person from the past or a famous person from 100 years in the future?
    2. Would you rather live in ancient Rome or ancient Egypt?
    3. Would you rather sail with Magellan or ride with the Pony Express?
    4. Would you rather sign the Declaration of Independence or help write the Constitution?
    5. Would you rather be a medieval knight or a medieval merchant?
    6. Would you rather travel the Silk Road or cross the Atlantic on the Mayflower?
    7. Would you rather witness the first Moon landing or the fall of the Berlin Wall?
    8. Would you rather be a scribe in ancient Egypt or a printer right after Gutenberg?
    9. Would you rather live through the Renaissance or the Industrial Revolution?
    10. Would you rather be president for one year or a Supreme Court justice for twenty?
    11. Would you rather be an explorer who finds a new land or a scientist who finds a new cure?
    12. Would you rather live without electricity or without running water?
    13. Would you rather visit the Library of Alexandria or the Great Wall while it was being built?
    14. Would you rather be a newspaper reporter during the American Revolution or the Civil Rights Movement?
    15. Would you rather have dinner with Benjamin Franklin or with Harriet Tubman?
    16. Would you rather lead an army or lead a debate in Congress?
    17. Would you rather live in a monarchy with a fair king or a democracy with an unpopular leader?
    18. Would you rather be a pioneer on the Oregon Trail or a worker building the transcontinental railroad?
    19. Would you rather be the first person to fly with the Wright brothers or the first to ride a car with Henry Ford?
    20. Would you rather know the full history of your town or the full history of your family?
    21. Would you rather have a vote on every law or elect someone you trust to vote for you?
    22. Would you rather be an inventor in the 1800s or an astronaut in the 1960s?
    23. Would you rather live in a castle with no heat or a log cabin with a fireplace?
    24. Would you rather read a diary from a teenager in 1776 or a letter from a soldier in 1944?
    25. Would you rather be remembered in history books or remembered by everyone in your town?

    What are good academic would you rather questions for students?

    Academic would you rather questions are about learning itself: reading versus doing, effort versus results, one final exam versus ten quizzes. They make good openers before a test, a project launch or a feedback conversation, because students end up talking about how they work best.

    1. Would you rather solve a hard problem alone or an easy problem in a group?
    2. Would you rather write a five-page essay or give a five-minute speech?
    3. Would you rather learn by reading or learn by doing?
    4. Would you rather know a little about everything or everything about one subject?
    5. Would you rather be graded on effort or graded on results?
    6. Would you rather take one big final exam or ten small quizzes?
    7. Would you rather have a teacher who is strict and fair or relaxed and unpredictable?
    8. Would you rather discover a new planet or a new species of animal?
    9. Would you rather be able to remember everything you read or understand everything you hear?
    10. Would you rather argue the side you agree with or the side you disagree with?
    11. Would you rather build a robot or write a novel?
    12. Would you rather have unlimited books or unlimited internet?
    13. Would you rather fix a problem fast or fix it perfectly?
    14. Would you rather be the person with the idea or the person who makes it happen?
    15. Would you rather get honest feedback that stings or kind feedback that is vague?
    16. Would you rather study with music or in total silence?
    17. Would you rather have a class with no grades or a class with no deadlines?
    18. Would you rather be able to predict the weather perfectly or predict the stock market perfectly?
    19. Would you rather lose your phone for a week or lose your voice for a week?
    20. Would you rather make a mistake in front of the class or never try at all?

    What are funny would you rather questions that are still classroom-safe?

    Funny classroom-safe would you rather questions are silly on purpose but clean enough to read aloud with an administrator in the room. Save them for Fridays, the day before a break, or the class that needs a reset.

    1. Would you rather have spaghetti for hair or sweat maple syrup?
    2. Would you rather talk like a pirate for a day or sing everything you say?
    3. Would you rather have a pet dinosaur the size of a cat or a cat the size of a dinosaur?
    4. Would you rather only be able to whisper or only be able to shout?
    5. Would you rather have hands for feet or feet for hands?
    6. Would you rather wear socks that are always wet or shoes that are always one size too small?
    7. Would you rather sneeze glitter or hiccup bubbles?
    8. Would you rather have a rewind button for embarrassing moments or a mute button for annoying people?
    9. Would you rather ride a giant chicken to school or a tiny horse?
    10. Would you rather eat only pizza for a year or never eat pizza again?
    11. Would you rather have a nose that glows when you lie or ears that wiggle when you are nervous?
    12. Would you rather be a superhero with a useless power or a villain with an amazing one?
    13. Would you rather have a theme song play every time you walk in or a laugh track play after every joke you make?
    14. Would you rather live in a house made of candy or a house made of LEGO?
    15. Would you rather have a talking backpack or a talking locker?
    16. Would you rather fight one horse-sized duck or one hundred duck-sized horses?
    17. Would you rather have to hop everywhere or crab-walk everywhere?
    18. Would you rather lose all your eyebrows or have one giant eyebrow?
    19. Would you rather swap lives with your pet for a day or with your teacher for a day?
    20. Would you rather have a cloud that follows you and rains or a sun that follows you and makes you sweat?

    What are good would you rather questions for middle school students?

    Good would you rather questions for middle school stay close to a middle schooler’s world: lunch, seats, field trips and friends. Middle schoolers want to talk about that world, and these ten keep the question there.

    1. Would you rather have recess back or have a longer lunch?
    2. Would you rather be the class president or the yearbook photographer?
    3. Would you rather go on a field trip to a museum or to a science center?
    4. Would you rather sit wherever you want or have the teacher pick the perfect seat for you?
    5. Would you rather have a pet hamster in class or a fish tank?
    6. Would you rather be on the school play crew or in the school play?
    7. Would you rather have gym every day or art every day?
    8. Would you rather write with a pencil forever or a pen forever?
    9. Would you rather be able to skip one class a week or leave school an hour early on Fridays?
    10. Would you rather do a group project with your best friend or with the smartest person in class?

    What are good would you rather questions for high school students?

    Good would you rather questions for high school take students’ real decisions about work, school and money seriously without asking anyone to share anything private. High schoolers are starting to make those decisions, so these ten put them on the table.

    1. Would you rather go to college right after graduation or take a gap year to work and travel?
    2. Would you rather have a job you love that pays okay or a job you tolerate that pays a lot?
    3. Would you rather learn a trade or earn a four-year degree?
    4. Would you rather have your first car be brand new and boring or old and awesome?
    5. Would you rather live close to home after high school or move across the country?
    6. Would you rather start your own business or work your way up at a big company?
    7. Would you rather have a great reputation or a great bank account?
    8. Would you rather know your future career now or figure it out as you go?
    9. Would you rather run for city council at 18 or vote in your first presidential election?
    10. Would you rather be the team captain or the player who scores the most?

    How do you write your own would you rather questions?

    A good classroom would you rather question has two choices that are close enough to split the room. If 28 out of 30 students pick the same side, there is nothing to discuss. A few tests before you use a new one:

    Graphic titled Four tests before you use a new question, listing is it a real tradeoff, can every student answer it, could you read it with the principal in the room, and does it connect to something.
    Four tests to run on a prompt before it reaches the class.
    • Is it a real tradeoff? Both choices should have a good side and a cost.
    • Can every student answer it? No question should depend on having money, a certain family, or a certain experience.
    • Could you read it aloud with the principal in the room? If not, cut it.
    • Does it connect to something? The best ones lead into the lesson. “Would you rather live in a monarchy with a fair king or a democracy with an unpopular leader?” is a two-week civics unit in one sentence.

    Students can write them too. Having a class write would you rather questions about a unit is a quick review activity that shows you what they think the big tradeoffs were. It pairs well with classroom review games at the end of a unit.

    A set like this runs out eventually, which is why I put a fresh bell ringer idea in every issue of Bell to Bell, my free weekly newsletter for grades 6–12 teachers. A new issue goes out each Wednesday, and every other one includes a printable classroom resource.

    Sources

    This page makes no outside research claims. The questions, the five-minute routine and the four norms are Elevate the Norm’s own, and they match the free would you rather question cards PDF: 15 pages, the routine and norms on page 1, and 105 numbered cards in the same six sets.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are good would you rather questions for students?

    Good would you rather questions for students offer two choices close enough to split the class, can be answered by every student, and are clean enough to read aloud in any classroom. Examples include: Would you rather be able to talk to animals or speak every human language? Would you rather live in ancient Rome or ancient Egypt? Would you rather learn by reading or learn by doing?

    How do you play the would you rather game in a classroom?

    To play the would you rather game in class, post the question and give students thirty seconds to write their choice and one reason. Have them move to one side of the room for each option, then call on two students per side to share a reason. End by asking if anyone heard a reason that almost changed their mind. The routine takes about five minutes.

    How long should a would you rather bell ringer take?

    A would you rather bell ringer should take about five minutes. Students write a pick and one reason in 30 seconds of silence, move to a side of the room, hear two reasons from each side, then answer one pivot question that connects to the lesson. A bell ringer that runs fifteen minutes stops being a bell ringer, and students learn they can stretch it.

    How do you keep would you rather discussions from getting out of hand?

    Keep would you rather discussions under control by posting four norms: pick one side, give a reason you could say to a judge, disagree with the reason and never the person, and allow one pass per week. Use the same signal every time to end movement and bring the room back. Most of the noise comes from unclear rules, not from the questions.

    Can would you rather questions be used in history class?

    Would you rather questions work well in history class as hooks, such as asking whether students would rather sign the Declaration of Independence or help write the Constitution. The reasons students give show what they already believe about a period, and you can require them to support their choice with one fact from the unit to turn the warm-up into an evidence round.

    Should would you rather answers be graded?

    Judge a would you rather answer on the reason, never on the choice. A pick can’t be wrong, so a student who takes the less popular side should never pay for it. The point of the routine is practice making a claim and backing it with a reason, and every student may pass once a week, which keeps the stakes low without letting anyone opt out every day.

    Are these would you rather questions appropriate for middle school?

    All 105 would you rather questions on this page are clean and school-appropriate for middle school. None asks students to share anything about their appearance, family, money, religion or partisan politics. The list also includes a ten-question set written for middle school students and another ten for high school, so a sixth-grade class and a senior class can each start with questions built for them.

    Is there a printable version of these would you rather questions?

    A free printable version of all 105 would you rather questions is available as a 15-page PDF. Page 1 holds the five-minute routine and the classroom norms, and the other pages hold cut-apart cards, eight per page, labeled by set and numbered to match this article. The PDF downloads directly with no email address or sign-up required.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Fun History Facts for Students: 55 Sourced Bell Ringers for Grades 6–12

    Fun History Facts for Students: 55 Sourced Bell Ringers for Grades 6–12

    By Clay Shumate

    Fun history facts for students work best as short, surprising openers: one fact, one question, four minutes. Below are 55 fun facts for students in grades 6–12, grouped by era from the ancient world to the space station. Every fact links to the source it was checked against, and 9 of them bust a myth students probably already believe.

    If you searched for “facts of fun” or “fun facts for students,” this is the history version, built for teachers. Each fact comes with an opinion question, so it works as a bell ringer, a discussion starter or a quick brain break. There is a free printable card set below, with no email required.

    Key Takeaways

    • 55 facts across six eras, mixing world and U.S. history.
    • Every fact has a named source. The source is linked here and printed on each card, so students can check it themselves.
    • 9 myth-busting facts correct stories students think they know, like horned Viking helmets and George Washington’s wooden teeth.
    • Each fact has a discussion question that asks for an opinion and a reason, not a definition.
    • Four minutes, four steps: read the fact, ask the question, take two answers, check the source.

    How to use fun history facts as bell ringers

    The fact gets attention, and the question does the teaching. A surprising fact on the board gives students a reason to look up when they walk in. The opinion question that follows asks them to explain, compare or predict, which is the thinking a history class runs on. Here is the four-minute routine:

    1. Read the fact. Project it or read it as students sit down. Each student writes one sentence that starts with “I think this because…”
    2. Ask the question. Students answer in writing first, then talk with a partner for one minute.
    3. Take two answers. Call on two students. Push for a reason, not a guess.
    4. Check the source. At least once a week, point to the source and ask, “How would we check this?”

    That last step is the one that pays off all year. A class that gets used to asking where a fact came from is a class that is ready for primary sources, research projects and the history projects that ask students to build an argument from evidence. For more warm-up formats, see our full list of bell ringer ideas. For one already written for tomorrow, a new social studies prompt is posted every school day beside four other subjects. When the class needs to talk rather than write, 105 classroom-safe would-you-rather prompts, sorted into icebreaker, history, thinking and funny sets run on the same kind of five-minute routine.

    Four steps of a history fact bell ringer: read the fact, ask the question, take two answers, check the source
    The same four steps every day keep the warm-up to four minutes.

    Why the myth-busting facts matter most

    The myth-busting facts teach the most important habit in a history class: a story everyone repeats is not the same as a story someone checked. Students arrive believing that Vikings wore horned helmets, that medieval people thought the Earth was flat, and that Paul Revere shouted “The British are coming!” Each of those has a clear, citable correction, and each correction leads to a better question: why did the myth spread in the first place?

    Graphic titled Three myths with a citable correction, listing horned Viking helmets, the flat Earth belief in the Middle Ages, and Paul Revere shouting The British are coming, each with the correction beneath it.
    Three myths students arrive with, and the correction for each.

    Use one in the first week of school and then come back to the idea all year. When a student later repeats something from a video or social media, “Is this a horned-helmet fact?” becomes a quick shared shorthand for checking it.

    Free download: 55 fun history fact bell ringer cards

    Fifteen pages. Page 1 is the four-minute routine. The rest are 55 cards, four per page, each with the fact, an opinion question and the source it was checked against. Numbered to match this article.

    Free. No email address required. Built for grades 6–12.

    Fun history facts: Ancient World (to 500 CE)

    Pyramids, pirates and a Greek machine with gears. These work well in the first unit of a world history course, or any time students think ancient people were simple.

    1. For about 3,800 years, the Great Pyramid of Giza was the tallest human-made structure on Earth. Discuss: Why do you think people in ancient Egypt put so much time and effort into building something so huge? (Britannica – How long did the Great Pyramid of Giza hold the record as the tallest man-made structure in the world?)
    2. Evidence suggests the Egyptian pyramids were built by paid laborers, not by slaves as many people believe. Discuss: Why do you think the myth that slaves built the pyramids has lasted so long? (History.com – 11 Things You May Not Know About Ancient Egypt)
    3. Cleopatra came from a family of Greek Macedonians, but she was the first ruler in her family line to learn the Egyptian language. Ancient writers said she may have known as many as a dozen languages. Discuss: How do you think speaking many languages helped Cleopatra as a ruler? (History.com – 10 Little-Known Facts About Cleopatra)
    4. When pirates captured a young Julius Caesar and demanded a ransom of 20 talents, Caesar laughed at them and said he was worth at least 50. Discuss: Was Caesar being brave or just showing off? Explain your thinking. (Britannica – The Time Julius Caesar Was Captured by Pirates)
    5. The month of July was first called Quintilis, Latin for 'fifth month.' It was renamed to honor Julius Caesar in 44 BCE. Discuss: If you could rename a month after someone from history, who would you choose and why? (Britannica – July)
    6. Some ancient Roman concrete can heal its own cracks: reactive chunks of lime in the mix help seal tiny cracks before they spread. Rome's Pantheon, dedicated in 128 CE, still has the world's largest unreinforced concrete dome. Discuss: Why do you think modern builders are now studying ancient Roman concrete? (MIT News – Riddle solved: Why was Roman concrete so durable?)
    7. The Rosetta Stone, found in 1799, has the same decree carved in three scripts: Egyptian hieroglyphs, demotic, and ancient Greek. It helped scholars finally learn to read hieroglyphs. Discuss: Why do you think having the same message in three scripts made the Rosetta Stone so valuable? (Britannica – Rosetta Stone)
    8. Divers pulled the Antikythera mechanism, sometimes called an 'ancient Greek computer,' from a shipwreck in 1900–1901. Its gears could track the Sun, Moon, and planets, predict eclipses, and show when the Olympic Games would happen. Discuss: Why do you think nothing this advanced appeared again for more than a thousand years? (Smithsonian Magazine – What Is the Antikythera Mechanism, the World's First Computer?)
    9. In 1974, farmers digging a well in China found China's Terracotta Army. Archaeologists have since found about 8,000 life-size clay soldiers, and each one appears to have its own unique face. Discuss: Why do you think an emperor wanted an army of clay soldiers buried near his tomb? (History.com – 5 Things You May Not Know About the Terracotta Army)

    Fun history facts: Medieval World (500–1450)

    This set is heavy on myths students already believe, which makes it a strong set for teaching how to question a story everyone repeats.

    1. Myth busted: Vikings almost certainly did not wear horned helmets. The horned look became popular in the 1870s, when a costume designer created horned helmets for an opera by Richard Wagner. Discuss: Why do you think movies and costumes keep the horned-helmet myth alive? (History.com – Did Vikings really wear horned helmets?)
    2. Scientists proved Vikings were cutting down trees in Newfoundland, Canada, in the year 1021, using a solar storm signal locked inside tree rings. That is more than 470 years before Columbus sailed in 1492. Discuss: Why do you think Columbus is remembered more than the Vikings who reached North America first? (Smithsonian Magazine – New Dating Method Shows Vikings Occupied Newfoundland in 1021 C.E.)
    3. In 1324, Mansa Musa, king of Mali, traveled to Mecca with a huge caravan carrying hundreds of pounds of gold. He spent and gave away so much gold in Egypt that its value dropped, and the economy took 12 years to recover. Discuss: Can being too generous ever cause problems? Explain using Mansa Musa as an example. (History.com – This 14th-Century African Emperor Remains the Richest Person in History)
    4. Myth busted: Educated people in the Middle Ages knew the Earth was round. The idea that they believed in a flat Earth was largely made up in 1828 in a popular biography of Columbus by Washington Irving. Discuss: Why do you think a made-up story can become 'common knowledge'? (History.com – Christopher Columbus Never Set Out to Prove the Earth Was Round)
    5. Myth busted: The image of medieval people as dirty and unwashed is false. Bathing and handwashing were common and were treated as important routines. Discuss: Why do you think people today often imagine the past as dirtier or less advanced than it really was? (National Geographic – What life in medieval Europe was really like)
    6. The computer word 'algorithm' comes from the name of al-Khwarizmi, a Muslim scholar who lived in the 800s, through a Latin translation of his math book. Discuss: Why do you think so many science and math words come from other languages and cultures? (Britannica – Algorithm)
    7. At its peak in the late 1200s, the Mongol Empire covered about 9 million square miles, making it the largest connected land empire in history. Discuss: What challenges do you think came with ruling such a huge empire? (History.com – What Were the Biggest Empires in History?)
    8. Explorer Marco Polo was one of the first Europeans to see an Asian rhinoceros, and he thought the horned animals were unicorns. Discuss: Why do you think Marco Polo compared the rhino to something he already knew about from stories? (History.com – 11 Things You May Not Know About Marco Polo)
    9. The famous Bayeux Tapestry is not actually a woven tapestry. It is a strip of linen about 230 feet (70 meters) long with scenes embroidered on it. Discuss: Why do you think people told history through pictures like this instead of only in writing? (Britannica (Compton's) – The Bayeux tapestry is not a woven tapestry)
    10. Only four original copies of the 1215 Magna Carta still exist today. It was sealed by King John at Runnymede, England. Discuss: Why do you think a document from 1215 still matters to people today? (Library of Congress – Lincoln Magna Carta (Magna Carta: Muse and Mentor exhibit))

    Fun history facts: Early Modern / Age of Exploration & Revolutions (1450–1800)

    Explorers, revolutions and the founders, including several things American students are usually taught wrong.

    1. Ferdinand Magellan's 1519 voyage set out with about 240 men on five ships, but only 18 men made it back to Spain in 1522. Magellan himself died in the Philippines before the trip was finished. Discuss: Why do you think explorers were willing to take such huge risks? (National Geographic – 240 men started Magellan's voyage around the world. Only 18 finished it.)
    2. Tomatoes were first grown in Mexico and came to Europe in the 1500s. For a long time, many Europeans thought tomatoes were poisonous, and tomato sauce did not become a regular part of Italian cooking until the late 1700s. Discuss: Why do you think people are sometimes afraid to try new foods? (Smithsonian Magazine – A Passion for Tomatoes)
    3. In January 1610, Galileo used a homemade telescope to discover four moons circling Jupiter. Astronomers still call them the Galilean moons. Discuss: Why do you think Galileo's discovery upset people who believed everything circled the Earth? (NASA – 415 Years Ago: Astronomer Galileo Discovers Jupiter's Moons)
    4. During the Dutch 'tulip mania' of the 1630s, one rare tulip bulb sold for more than the cost of a mansion in Amsterdam. Historians now say the famous 'crash' was overblown and few people were ruined. Discuss: Why do you think people pay huge amounts for things that are popular or rare? (Smithsonian Magazine – There Never Was a Real Tulip Fever)
    5. Isaac Newton served in Parliament, but he reportedly spoke only once—to ask an usher to close a window because it was chilly. Discuss: Can someone be a genius in one area and quiet or unsure in another? Explain. (History.com – 9 Things You May Not Know About Isaac Newton)
    6. Congress voted for independence on July 2, 1776. The Declaration of Independence is dated July 4, but it was not actually signed until August 2. Discuss: Why do you think Americans celebrate July 4 instead of July 2? (National Archives – Did You Know… Independence Day Should Actually Be July 2?)
    7. Myth busted: Paul Revere almost certainly did not shout 'The British are coming!' on his 1775 ride. Most colonists still thought of themselves as British, and he most likely warned that 'the regulars are coming out.' Discuss: Why do you think the more dramatic version of the story became so popular? (Paul Revere House – Revisit the Ride: What Did Paul Revere Actually Say?)
    8. Myth busted: Benjamin Franklin never officially proposed the turkey as America's national bird. He did write a letter to his daughter calling the bald eagle a bird of 'bad moral character' and the turkey 'a much more respectable bird.' Discuss: Which animal do you think best represents the United States, and why? (The Franklin Institute – Did Benjamin Franklin Want the National Bird To Be A Turkey?)
    9. Myth busted: George Washington's false teeth were never made of wood. His dentures used materials like tin, gold, lead, and human teeth; staining over time made them look like wood grain. Discuss: Why do you think people like to tell surprising (but false) stories about famous leaders? (George Washington's Mount Vernon – Wooden Teeth Myth)

    Fun history facts: 19th Century (1800–1900)

    Inventions, purchases and one very loud volcano. Good openers for U.S. history units on expansion and industry.

    1. Former presidents John Adams and Thomas Jefferson died within hours of each other on July 4, 1826—exactly 50 years after the Declaration of Independence. Discuss: Is this just a coincidence, or does it feel like something more? Explain your opinion. (Thomas Jefferson's Monticello – John Adams)
    2. The oldest surviving photograph from a camera was made in 1827 by Joseph Nicéphore Niépce. It showed the view from his window and took several days of sunlight to capture. Discuss: How would life be different if taking a photo still took days? (Harry Ransom Center, University of Texas at Austin – The Niépce Heliograph)
    3. Ketchup most likely began centuries ago as a fermented fish sauce, similar to sauces found in Southeast Asia. The first published recipe for tomato ketchup did not appear until 1812. Discuss: What other everyday foods do you think might have surprising origins? (Smithsonian Magazine – A Brief (But Global) History of Ketchup)
    4. Abraham Lincoln is the only U.S. president to hold a patent. In 1849 he patented a device that used inflatable air chambers to lift riverboats over sandbars. Discuss: Why do you think problem-solving skills are useful for a president? (Smithsonian Magazine – Abraham Lincoln Is the Only President Ever to Have a Patent)
    5. Myth busted: Napoleon was not unusually short. He was probably about 5 feet 6 or 7 inches—average or taller for a Frenchman of his time—but British cartoonists drew him as tiny. Discuss: How can cartoons and media shape the way people see a leader? (Britannica – Was Napoleon Short?)
    6. The Pony Express mail service started in April 1860 but lasted only about 18 months. The new transcontinental telegraph made it outdated in October 1861. Discuss: What modern technology do you think will become outdated as fast as the Pony Express did? (Smithsonian National Postal Museum – Pony Express)
    7. In 1867, the United States bought Alaska from Russia for $7.2 million. Critics mocked the deal as 'Seward's Folly,' but a later gold discovery proved it was a smart buy. Discuss: Have you ever made a choice others doubted that turned out well? How is that like the Alaska purchase? (U.S. Department of State, Office of the Historian – Purchase of Alaska, 1867)
    8. The 1883 eruption of the Krakatoa volcano in Indonesia is considered the loudest sound in modern history. People heard it as far as 3,000 miles away. Discuss: How do you think people 3,000 miles away explained a sound they could not see the cause of? (Britannica – What's the Loudest Sound in History?)
    9. The Statue of Liberty was not always green. Its copper skin, only about as thick as two pennies, slowly reacted with the air and formed a green layer called a patina that protects the metal. Discuss: Do you think the statue looks better green or would it look better copper-colored? Why? (National Park Service – Frequently Asked Questions About the Statue of Liberty)

    Fun history facts: 20th Century (1900–1945)

    World wars, famous landmarks and a stolen painting. Several of these lead straight into a lesson on how ordinary people shaped big events.

    1. The teddy bear is named after President Theodore Roosevelt. In 1902 he refused to shoot a bear that had been tied to a tree on a hunting trip, and a toy maker soon sold a stuffed 'Teddy's Bear.' Discuss: Why do you think this story made Roosevelt more popular with Americans? (National Park Service – The Story of the Teddy Bear (Theodore Roosevelt Birthplace))
    2. The Wright brothers' first powered flight on December 17, 1903, lasted just 12 seconds and went 120 feet. Pieces of their airplane later traveled to the Moon with Neil Armstrong and to Mars on NASA's Ingenuity helicopter. Discuss: Why do you think astronauts and NASA chose to carry pieces of the Wright Flyer into space? (NASA – 120 Years Ago: The First Powered Flight at Kitty Hawk)
    3. In 1911, the Mona Lisa was stolen from the Louvre by Vincenzo Peruggia, a former handyman there, who hid it in his Paris apartment for about two years. The theft actually made the painting far more famous. Discuss: Why do you think a crime made the Mona Lisa more famous instead of less? (History.com – The Heist that Made the Mona Lisa Famous)
    4. On Christmas Day 1914, during World War I, some British and German soldiers met in 'No Man's Land' between the trenches, exchanged gifts, and played informal games of football (soccer). Discuss: What does the Christmas Truce tell us about the soldiers on both sides? (Imperial War Museums – The Real Story of the Christmas Truce of 1914)
    5. Jeannette Rankin of Montana became the first woman elected to Congress in 1916—nearly four years before the 19th Amendment gave women across the U.S. the right to vote. Discuss: How do you think Rankin felt serving in Congress when most American women still could not vote? (Library of Congress (Picture This blog) – Jeannette Rankin: First Woman Elected to Congress)
    6. Almost 400 men and women worked on carving Mount Rushmore from 1927 to 1941, and despite the dangerous conditions, no one died during the carving. Discuss: What do you think made it possible for such a dangerous project to have no deaths? (National Park Service – The Workers (Mount Rushmore National Memorial))
    7. The top of the Empire State Building was built as a docking port for dirigibles (giant airships), but strong winds at the top made docking nearly impossible. Discuss: Why do you think people in the 1930s imagined airships would be the future of travel? (History.com – 10 Surprising Facts About the Empire State Building)
    8. During World War II, the U.S. 'Ghost Army,' a unit full of artists and designers, fooled the enemy with 93-pound inflatable tanks and loudspeakers playing recorded troop sounds. Its records stayed secret until 1996. Discuss: Do you think creativity can be as important as strength in a conflict? Why? (Smithsonian Magazine – The Ghost Army of World War II Used Art to Deceive the Nazis)
    9. The code created by Navajo Code Talkers in World War II was never broken. Because Navajo had no word for 'submarine,' they used 'besh-lo,' meaning 'iron fish.' Discuss: Why do you think a code based on a spoken language was so hard for the enemy to crack? (The National WWII Museum – American Indian Code Talkers)

    Fun history facts: Cold War & Modern (1945–present)

    Satellites, space and the end of the Cold War, through the invention of the web. Students tend to find this era closest to their own lives.

    1. Sputnik 1, the world's first artificial satellite, was launched by the Soviet Union on October 4, 1957. It was about the size of a beach ball and circled Earth about every 98 minutes. Discuss: Why do you think a satellite the size of a beach ball worried so many Americans? (NASA – Sputnik and The Dawn of the Space Age)
    2. In 1960, six-year-old Ruby Bridges helped integrate New Orleans schools, walking to school with federal marshals. Her teacher, Barbara Henry, taught her as her only student for an entire year. Discuss: What do you think gave a six-year-old the courage to keep going to school every day? (History.com – Who Is Ruby Bridges?)
    3. Myth busted: The Cold War 'hotline' between Washington and Moscow, set up in 1963 after the Cuban Missile Crisis, was never a red telephone. It used teletype machines that sent typed messages. Discuss: Why do you think written messages might have been safer than phone calls in a crisis? (Smithsonian Magazine – There Never Was Such a Thing as a Red Phone in the White House)
    4. Myth busted: NASA did not invent Velcro or Tang. Velcro is a Swiss invention from the 1940s, and Tang was made by General Foods in 1957; astronauts just made them famous. Discuss: Why do you think people give NASA credit for inventions it did not create? (NASA – Tang, Teflon, Velcro)
    5. The Voyager Golden Record, sent into space aboard NASA's Voyager probes, carries greetings in 55 languages along with pictures, music, and sounds from Earth. Discuss: If you could add one sound or song to represent Earth, what would it be and why? (NASA Science – Golden Record Greetings)
    6. In 1980, the World Health Organization declared smallpox eradicated. It is still the only human disease that has been completely wiped out. Discuss: Why do you think it has been so hard to eradicate other diseases the way smallpox was? (World Health Organization – History of smallpox vaccination)
    7. Tim Berners-Lee invented the World Wide Web in 1989 while working at CERN in Switzerland. The world's first website was at the address info.cern.ch. Discuss: How would your daily life be different without the World Wide Web? (CERN – A short history of the Web)
    8. The Berlin Wall opened on November 9, 1989, partly because of a mistake: East German official Günter Schabowski announced new travel rules would start 'immediately,' though they were meant to begin the next day. Crowds rushed to the border. Discuss: Can one mistake change history? What other examples can you think of? (History.com – 10 Things You May Not Know About the Berlin Wall)
    9. People have lived on the International Space Station without a break since November 2000. The station circles Earth 16 times a day, so its crew sees 16 sunrises and sunsets every 24 hours. Discuss: Would you want to live on the space station for six months? Why or why not? (NASA – International Space Station Facts and Figures)

    Turning a fun fact into a full lesson

    Some of these facts are big enough to carry a whole class period. A few that grow well:

    Graphic titled Four facts that grow into a full lesson, listing the August 2 signing of the Declaration, the Berlin Wall opening partly by mistake, Mansa Musa devaluing gold, and the Ghost Army inflatable tanks, each with the classroom activity it supports.
    Four facts big enough to carry a whole class period.
    • The Declaration was signed August 2, not July 4. Students compare the dates and decide which day Americans should really celebrate, using evidence. It pairs with our civics project ideas.
    • The Berlin Wall opened partly because of a mistake. Students list other turning points that hinged on one decision, then rank how much each one changed.
    • Mansa Musa spent so much gold that its value dropped. A fast, memorable entry point to supply and demand in a world history or economics class.
    • The Ghost Army fooled the enemy with inflatable tanks. Students argue whether creativity or strength matters more, using two or three examples from the unit.

    To review a whole era at the end of a unit, mix a few of these facts into one of the classroom review games that actually review, or use them as true-or-false rounds where students must name the source to earn the point.

    How these facts were checked

    Every fact on this page was checked against the page it links to, and the wording was adjusted when a source did not fully support it. The sources include Britannica, CERN, George Washington’s Mount Vernon, Harry Ransom Center, University of Texas at Austin, History.com, Imperial War Museums, Library of Congress, MIT News, NASA, NASA Science, National Archives, National Geographic, National Park Service, Paul Revere House, Smithsonian Magazine, Smithsonian National Postal Museum, The Franklin Institute, The National WWII Museum, Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello, U.S. Department of State, Office of the Historian, and World Health Organization. Several popular “fun facts” were left out because no reliable source supported them. If you find an error, the site’s corrections policy explains how to report it.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are some fun history facts for students?

    A few favorites: the Great Pyramid of Giza was the tallest human-made structure on Earth for about 3,800 years; the Declaration of Independence was not signed until August 2, 1776; Abraham Lincoln is the only U.S. president to hold a patent; and Vikings almost certainly did not wear horned helmets. Each fact on this page links to the source it was checked against.

    What does “facts of fun” mean?

    People who search for “facts of fun” are usually looking for fun facts: short, surprising true statements. This page collects fun facts about history for students in grades 6 to 12, each with a discussion question and a source.

    How do you use fun facts as bell ringers?

    Show one fact as students arrive, have them write one sentence about it, ask an opinion question, take two answers out loud, and once a week ask how the class could check the source. The whole routine takes about four minutes.

    Are these history facts true?

    Each fact was checked against the reputable source it links to, such as the Smithsonian, the National Archives, the Library of Congress, NASA, the National Park Service or Britannica. Popular facts that could not be verified were left out.

    What grade level are these fun facts for?

    They are written for grades 6 to 12, at roughly a middle school reading level, so they work in middle school social studies and in high school world history and U.S. history.

    What are some history myths students believe?

    Common ones include that Vikings wore horned helmets, that medieval people believed the Earth was flat, that George Washington had wooden teeth, that Napoleon was unusually short, and that Paul Revere shouted “The British are coming!” This page includes the correction and the source for each.

    Is there a printable version?

    Yes. All of the facts come as free printable bell ringer cards in a PDF, with the discussion question and source on each card. It downloads directly with no email or sign-up.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Free Teacher Printables for Grades 6-12: What Is Worth Printing, and How to Tell

    Free Teacher Printables for Grades 6-12: What Is Worth Printing, and How to Tell

    By Clay Shumate

    Free teacher printables are classroom-ready documents — primary source sets, data tables, reading guides, rubrics, trackers — that you can download and print without paying. For grades 6–12 the best ones come from federal agencies, museums, archives, universities and public media rather than worksheet mills. The hard part is not finding them. The hard part is telling which ones are worth the paper.

    Most search traffic for free printables lands in elementary territory: coloring pages, letter tracing, bulletin board sets. This article stays in middle and high school, where the useful material looks completely different. A good secondary printable is usually a document, a data set, a structured protocol or a rubric — not a fill-in-the-blank page. Below are the quality criteria first, then the places that actually have the goods, with links I opened in October 2026.

    Key Takeaways

    • Judge the task, not the design. A clean-looking page that asks students to copy definitions is worse than an ugly page that asks them to explain something.
    • Federal material is usually public domain. U.S. copyright law states that copyright protection is not available for any work of the U.S. Government, which is why National Archives and Library of Congress material is so adaptable.
    • Free is not the same as unrestricted. Marketplace downloads typically carry single-classroom licenses and explicit bans on reposting, even when the file cost nothing.
    • Worksheets have one strong, narrow use. Retrieval practice and spaced review are the two study techniques rated high utility in the major cognitive-psychology review. Most other worksheet uses are not supported.
    • Check the reading level before you print thirty copies. A primary source at a grade 14 reading level is an accessibility decision, not a rigor decision.
    • Everything on this site is free and ungated. All 53 printables in our library download directly, with no email, account or sign-up.

    What are free teacher printables, really?

    They are any document you can print and put in front of students without paying for it, which covers an enormous range of quality. That range is the whole problem. The phrase lumps together a declassified cable from the National Archives and a crossword of vocabulary words, and search engines cannot tell them apart.

    For grades 6–12, useful printables tend to fall into five types. Primary and secondary source documents. Data sets, tables and charts students have to interpret. Structured protocols — discussion formats, peer review sheets, lab procedures, project planners. Rubrics and checklists. And practice sets, where the point is repeated retrieval rather than discovery.

    Notice what is missing from that list: anything whose main function is to occupy time. That is not a moral judgment about busywork, it is a practical one. Paper that occupies time without producing evidence of thinking gives you nothing to grade honestly and gives students nothing to be proud of.

    What is a worksheet actually good for?

    A worksheet has one strong use: structured, repeated retrieval of things students need fast and automatic. Vocabulary, formulas, dates, conjugations, equation forms, map features. That use is well supported and worth defending.

    The large review by Dunlosky, Rawson, Marsh, Nathan and Willingham rated ten common learning techniques for utility. Only two earned a high rating: practice testing and distributed practice. They write that these “received high utility assessments because they benefit learners of different ages and abilities.” Rereading and highlighting were both rated low utility — highlighting, which students lean on heavily, “does not consistently boost students’ performance.” Summarization and keyword mnemonics also came in low, and elaborative interrogation and self-explanation came in moderate, partly because they “have not been adequately evaluated in educational contexts” (Dunlosky et al., Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58, 2013).

    That review covers a wide age range and a lot of laboratory work, not only secondary classrooms, so take it as a guide to which direction the evidence points rather than a prescription. But the direction is clear. A printable that functions as a short retrieval quiz, returned to a week later, is doing something the research supports. A printable that asks students to find and highlight the definitions is doing something the research rates poorly.

    So: use worksheets for retrieval and spacing. Do not use them to introduce concepts, to substitute for reading, or to fill a Friday. That is the narrow good use, stated plainly.

    Five of the seven screening questions for evaluating a free classroom printable before copying it
    Two minutes of screening rejects most of what a search turns up.

    Seven questions to ask before you print

    Run any candidate printable through these seven questions. It takes about two minutes and will reject most of what you find.

    1. Does it match what I am actually teaching? Not the topic — the specific skill or standard in this unit. Topical overlap is not alignment.
    2. Does it ask students to think, or to transcribe? Read the directions on the student page. If the verb is “list,” “match,” or “copy,” ask what the thinking is.
    3. What is the reading level, and who gets left out? Paste a paragraph into a readability tool. Then decide whether you are scaffolding the text or just hoping.
    4. Is the source credible and named? An anonymous PDF with no author, date or institution is a guess. Historical and scientific content from an unnamed source is a particular risk.
    5. Is it accurate? Spot-check two factual claims. Free content is not peer reviewed, and errors in dates, units and attributions are common.
    6. What does the license allow? Can you adapt it, copy it for all your sections, share it with a colleague, post it to your LMS? These are four different permissions.
    7. Does it produce something I can look at? If finished student work would not tell you anything you did not already know, skip it.

    Question three deserves one more sentence. A document written for adults in 1863 is not automatically rigorous for a ninth grader; it is simply hard. Either you excerpt it, gloss it, chunk it, and build a scaffold, or you are handing out an obstacle. Checking whether the text landed matters more than the text’s prestige.

    What may I legally adapt, copy and share?

    Three separate things govern a free file: copyright, the license, and your district’s policy. Free to download tells you nothing about any of them.

    The most permissive category is federal government work. Section 105 of U.S. copyright law states that “Copyright protection under this title is not available for any work of the United States Government,” while noting the government may hold copyrights transferred to it (17 U.S.C. § 105). In practice that is why you can crop, excerpt, retype and remix a National Archives document or a federal data table freely. Two cautions: material a federal site hosts may still be owned by someone else, and some agency logos and seals carry separate restrictions.

    Openly licensed material is the next tier. OER Commons, which has been curating open materials since 2007, labels resources so you can tell adaptation rights at a glance — the site states that “each resource has one of four conditions of use labels” that “help you quickly distinguish whether a resource can be changed or shared without further permission required” (OER Commons). Read the label. Share-alike and non-commercial conditions are real conditions.

    Then there are free files with restrictive licenses, which is most of a teacher marketplace. A free download from Teachers Pay Teachers typically comes with a single-classroom license and explicit instructions not to repost. Browsing the free section, you will find terms like “PLEASE DO NOT POST THIS PRODUCT ANYWHERE. Not on your classroom website, not online for your friends, nowhere” and resources marked “for personal use only” (TPT free resources). Those terms are not unreasonable, but they mean a free file can still be one you may not put in a shared department drive.

    Federal sources, and why they are the best starting point

    Start with the National Archives and the Library of Congress. These are the two highest-value free sources for secondary social studies, English and anything document-based, and both are built by people who understand classrooms.

    DocsTeach, run with support from the National Archives Foundation, offers “thousands of primary sources — letters, photographs, speeches, posters, maps, videos, and other document types — spanning the course of American history.” When I checked in October 2026 the site listed 13,639 primary source documents and 294 activities available without registering, and states plainly: “It’s completely free!” A free account adds more teacher-built activities and lets you build and save your own (DocsTeach).

    The Library of Congress publishes classroom materials “Created by teachers for teachers” — primary source sets organized by topic, many with teacher’s guides, covering the Civil War, the American Revolution, the civil rights movement and dozens more (Library of Congress classroom materials).

    For economics and personal finance, the Federal Reserve’s education site describes itself as “A FREE platform with economics and personal finance resources for classrooms and communities,” with middle school, high school and college levels, and lessons, readings, modules and infographic posters. Browsing is open; saving resources and getting answer keys requires a free teacher account (Federal Reserve Education).

    Museums, libraries and archives

    The Smithsonian Learning Lab is the strongest single museum source for grades 6–12. It describes itself as “Free to discover,” holding “millions of Smithsonian digital images, recordings, texts, and videos in history, art and culture, and the sciences” plus “thousands of examples of resources organized and structured for teaching and learning,” with collections filterable by grade band (Smithsonian Learning Lab). Browsing is open; saving and assigning requires an account.

    Your state archive and your state historical society are underused. Nearly every state has digitized local newspapers, maps, census records and photographs, and local documents are frequently more interesting to teenagers than national ones. Your county or city public library system often has free database access with a library card, which is a genuinely free resource most teachers never mention to students.

    Four categories of free classroom material sources for middle and high school teachers
    Institutions beat worksheet mills, especially above grade six.

    Public media, associations and universities

    Public media is reliable but usually gated behind a free account. PBS LearningMedia offers videos, interactives and lesson plans and is free, stating plainly “Register Now It’s free!” — which does mean an account (PBS LearningMedia). That is a reasonable trade, but it is a gate and I am not going to pretend otherwise.

    Subject-matter professional associations are the most reliable source of standards-aligned secondary material, because they write the standards. The national councils and associations for English, mathematics, science, social studies and world languages all publish free classroom material alongside their member-only content. Check what is open before paying for membership for that reason alone.

    University centers publish free curriculum too, and the quality is usually high because it is tied to research programs. These sources often require a free account, and the material is frequently narrow — one skill, done thoroughly. That is a feature.

    A warning about link rot from this same category. When I verified sources for this article in October 2026, the deep links for the National Endowment for the Humanities’ EDSITEment lesson plans — recommended in teacher materials for over two decades — redirected to a single NEH project page rather than the lesson library. Any list of free resources older than about a year will contain dead ends. Open the link before you plan around it.

    Teacher marketplaces and their free tiers

    Marketplaces have enormous free sections and wildly variable quality, and the filter has to be yours. Teachers Pay Teachers lists hundreds of thousands of free resources across all grades and subjects, and an account is required to download them.

    Two honest cautions. First, marketplace material is not reviewed for accuracy or alignment by anyone except the buyer, so questions four and five in the checklist above matter most here. Second, the volume skews heavily elementary, so grade 6–12 searching takes patience and tight filters. When it works, it works well for exactly one thing: a structure someone else already built that you would otherwise spend an evening making.

    Our own free teacher printables, and what we charge for

    Every printable on this site is free and downloads directly — no email, no account, no sign-up. As of October 2026 the resource library holds 53 free printable PDFs, organized into classroom management, assessment and grading, instruction and discussion, families and conferences, integrity and responsibility, and teacher wellbeing and reflection.

    Concretely, that includes seating chart planners, transition cues, formative assessment checks, standards-based grading templates, Socratic seminar protocols, project planners, bell ringers, parent communication logs, student-led conference templates, academic integrity materials and reflection journals. All grades 6–12. All ungated.

    We also sell some packaged versions of this material on Teachers Pay Teachers. Those are paid. Stating that plainly is the point: nothing that is free here will ever move behind a purchase, and if you only ever use the free files, that is the intended outcome, not a loss.

    Five common ways free printables fail with middle and high school students
    Secondary students will do hard work with a visible purpose and resist easy work without one.

    Where free printables go wrong in middle and high school

    The failure mode is almost always age mismatch dressed up as differentiation. A few patterns to watch for.

    • Elementary material relabeled. Clip art, large fonts, one-word answers. Teenagers read this instantly as being talked down to, and they are right.
    • Volume substituted for difficulty. Forty problems at the same level is not more rigorous than eight at increasing levels. It is longer.
    • The reading level nobody checked. An unexcerpted primary source handed out cold, with no glossary and no chunking.
    • Answers in the directions. Graphic organizers so prescriptive that filling them in requires no decisions.
    • No visible purpose. If a student asks why they are doing this and the honest answer is “to have something to turn in,” do not print it.

    That last one is the test I would apply above all others. Secondary students will do difficult work if the purpose is legible to them, and they will resist easy work whose purpose is not. Treating them as developing young adults means the paper has to be able to justify itself, which is also the argument for giving them real choices inside an assignment rather than more pages of it.

    A quick comparison of source types

    Source typeTypical qualityAccount needed?Adaptation rightsBest for
    Federal agencies and archivesHigh; curated by educatorsUsually no for browsingBroadest — federal works are not copyrightable under § 105Primary sources, data sets, document-based tasks
    Museums and librariesHighBrowsing open; saving usually requires oneVaries by item; check eachImages, objects, curated collections by grade band
    Public mediaHighUsually yes, freeClassroom use; redistribution restrictedVideo-anchored lessons, interactives
    Professional associationsHigh, standards-alignedMixed; some member-onlyVaries; frequently classroom-use onlyStandards alignment, assessment design
    Open education collectionsVariable but labeledUsually noExplicitly labeled; often adaptableFull units, textbooks, remixable material
    Teacher marketplacesVery variableYes, to downloadUsually single classroom, no repostingReady-made structures and templates

    Free teacher printables: a short plan for this week

    Pick the one unit coming up where you are least happy with your materials, and spend forty minutes on free teacher printables for that unit only. General browsing produces a folder you never open. A specific hunt produces something you use on Thursday.

    Start at the National Archives or the Library of Congress if the unit is document-based, the Federal Reserve if it is economics, the Smithsonian if it is object- or image-based. Run every candidate through the seven questions, especially reading level and what the task asks students to do. Check the license before you put anything in a shared drive. And if what you need is a protocol, a tracker or a rubric rather than content, start with our free printable library, which downloads directly with no email required.

    One more thing worth saying. Hunting for materials is legitimate professional work, and it counts. If you are building a growth goal you will actually revisit or logging hours toward your state’s license renewal requirement, improving your materials is a real place to point that effort — as long as the test stays the same: does this paper produce thinking I can look at?

    Sources

    1. John Dunlosky, Katherine A. Rawson, Elizabeth J. Marsh, Mitchell J. Nathan and Daniel T. Willingham, “Improving Students’ Learning With Effective Learning Techniques,” Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58, 2013. Supports the high utility ratings for practice testing and distributed practice and the low ratings for rereading, highlighting and summarization. Caveat: the review spans a wide age range and relies substantially on laboratory studies rather than secondary classrooms; the authors note some techniques are rated moderate precisely because they “have not been adequately evaluated in educational contexts.” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1529100612453266
    2. U.S. Copyright Law, Title 17, Section 105, “Subject matter of copyright: United States Government works,” U.S. Copyright Office. Supports the statement that copyright protection is not available for works of the U.S. Government. Caveat: this covers works authored by the federal government, not everything hosted on a federal website, and agency seals and logos may carry separate restrictions. https://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html
    3. DocsTeach, National Archives, accessed October 2026. Supports the document and activity counts, the “completely free” statement, and the distinction between browsing without an account and the additional activities a free account adds. https://www.docsteach.org/
    4. Library of Congress, “Classroom Materials,” accessed October 2026. Supports the description of teacher-built primary source sets with teacher’s guides organized by historical topic. Caveat: the landing page does not itself state grade bands, so check each set. https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/
    5. Smithsonian Learning Lab, accessed October 2026, and Federal Reserve Education, accessed October 2026. Support the quoted descriptions of holdings, the grade-band filtering, the “FREE platform” description, and the statement that a free teacher account is needed to save resources and access answer keys. https://learninglab.si.edu/
    6. OER Commons, accessed October 2026. Supports the four conditions-of-use labeling system and the 2007 founding date used to describe the collection. https://www.oercommons.org/
    7. Teachers Pay Teachers, free resources browse page, accessed October 2026. Supports the existence of a large free tier, the requirement to log in to download, and the quoted single-classroom and no-reposting terms that individual sellers attach. Caveat: licensing terms are set per resource by sellers, so read the terms on the specific file rather than assuming. https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Browse/Price-Range/Free

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Are worksheets bad for middle and high school students?

    No, but they have one narrow good use: structured, repeated retrieval of things students need fast and automatic, revisited after a gap. That use lines up with the only two techniques rated high utility in the major review of learning strategies — practice testing and distributed practice. What is not supported is using a worksheet to introduce a concept, to replace reading, or to fill a period. The question to ask is not whether a page is a worksheet, but whether finished student work on it would tell you something you did not already know.

    If a printable is free, can I change it and share it with my department?

    Not automatically, and these are separate permissions. Works authored by the U.S. federal government are not protected by copyright, which is why National Archives and Library of Congress material can be cropped, excerpted and remixed freely. Openly licensed material carries explicit labels you should read, including share-alike and non-commercial conditions. Free marketplace downloads usually carry single-classroom licenses and explicit bans on reposting, even though the file cost nothing. Before anything goes into a shared drive or an LMS, read the terms attached to that specific file.

    How do I check whether a document is too hard for my students?

    Paste a representative paragraph into a readability tool and look at the grade estimate, then make a deliberate decision rather than hoping. A document written for adults in 1863 is not automatically rigorous for a ninth grader; it is simply hard. If you keep it, excerpt it, chunk it, gloss the vocabulary and build a scaffold. If you cannot do that work before Thursday, pick a different text. Handing out an unmodified hard source and calling it rigor mostly produces students who learn that reading is futile.

    Why do so many free printable sites skew elementary?

    Because that is where the demand volume is, and because elementary material is faster to produce. The practical consequence for secondary teachers is that general searches waste time and you should go to specific institutions instead. Federal archives, museums, the Federal Reserve, professional subject associations and university centers all produce genuinely secondary-level material. On marketplaces, use tight grade and subject filters from the start. And be suspicious of anything with clip art and one-word answer lines, which is usually elementary material relabeled.

    Do I have to create an account to get free materials?

    It depends on the source, and it is worth knowing before you plan a lesson around something. Browsing the National Archives, Library of Congress, OER Commons and the Smithsonian Learning Lab works without an account, though saving and assigning on the Smithsonian site requires one. PBS LearningMedia and the Federal Reserve both ask you to register for free. Teachers Pay Teachers requires an account even for free downloads. Everything in this site’s own library downloads directly with no email, account or sign-up, which is a deliberate choice.

    Is paid material from a marketplace better than free material?

    Not reliably. Price is a signal about packaging and the seller’s time, not about accuracy or alignment. Marketplace material of either kind is not reviewed by anyone except the buyer, so a paid file and a free file from the same marketplace deserve the same scrutiny. Where paying can genuinely be worth it is for a complete, coherent structure you would otherwise spend several evenings building. Where it is rarely worth it is for single pages, which free institutional sources usually provide at equal or better quality.

    How often do free resource links break?

    Often enough that you should open every link before planning around it. While checking sources for this article in October 2026, I found that the deep links for a federal humanities agency’s long-recommended lesson plan library now redirect to a single project page rather than the lessons themselves. That resource had been recommended in teacher materials for over two decades. If a federal site can move out from under its own URLs, any roundup list older than a year will contain dead ends. Download the files you rely on rather than bookmarking them.

    How should I decide what to look for in the first place?

    Start from a unit, never from a browse. Pick the one upcoming unit where you are least happy with your materials, name the specific gap — a text, a data set, a protocol, a rubric — and spend forty focused minutes on that gap only. General browsing produces a folder of downloads you never open again. A targeted hunt produces something in students’ hands on Thursday. Then run each candidate through the alignment, task, reading level, credibility, accuracy, license and evidence questions before it goes near a copier.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Sub Plans for Middle and High School: What to Leave So the Day Actually Runs

    Sub Plans for Middle and High School: What to Leave So the Day Actually Runs

    Sub plans are the instructions you leave so someone else can run your class for a day. Good ones do three jobs: they keep students safe, they keep students doing real work, and they tell a stranger what normal looks like in a room they have never seen. Most sub plans only try to do the second job, and that is why most sub days go sideways.

    This guide covers what to put in sub plans for grades 6–12, how to write the day so a substitute can actually follow it, the difference between emergency sub plans and the ones you write for a planned absence, and what to do about the days no substitute shows up at all. If you want the other side of the door — what the person walking in can and cannot control — that is in the guide to running a room that isn’t yours.

    Key Takeaways

    • Sub plans are written for a stranger, not for you. Anything that only makes sense if you know the room has to be spelled out.
    • Write the day in minutes. Start and stop times for each task turn a vague plan into one a substitute can enforce.
    • Emergency sub plans are a different document. They stand alone, they are built at the start of the year, and anyone in the building can run them.
    • Report the absence early. In one large district’s data, substitute coverage rose sharply for every hour a job was posted ahead of time through the first day.
    • Plan for no sub at all. When an absence goes uncovered, students are often split into other rooms or a colleague gives up a planning period. The plan has to work for them too.
    • Make the work count. Students can tell a holding pattern from a real assignment, and they act accordingly.

    What Should Sub Plans Include?

    Sub plans should include the schedule written in minutes, a seating chart and roster, how the room normally runs, the exact location of every copy, answer keys, the names of people to call, the health and safety information your school requires you to share, and a sheet for the substitute to write back on. That is the binder. The lesson is only one part of it.

    Checklist of eight items for a sub plans binder: the day in minutes, seating chart and roster, how the room runs, where the work is, answer keys, who to call, health and safety notes, and a note-back sheet
    The lesson is one part of the binder. The other seven are what a stranger needs at 7:40 a.m.

    Think about what a substitute actually needs at 7:40 in the morning. Not your philosophy of teaching. They need to know where the copies are, what happens when the bell rings, and who to send for when something goes wrong. A plan that says “students will continue their reading” tells them nothing about any of that.

    The day, in minutes

    Each period gets a start time and a stop time for every task. “8:05–8:15: bell work on the board. 8:15–8:40: reading and questions 1–6. 8:40–8:50: turn in to the tray by the door.” Times give the substitute something to point at. A posted time is easier to hold students to than an adult’s opinion about when they should be done.

    Seating chart and roster

    A substitute who can use names is in a different room than one who can’t. Keep the seating chart current and mark two or three students per class who can answer a question about where things are. Pick them for reliability, not for being your favorites. A seating chart built for the room you actually have does double duty here.

    How the room runs

    Entry, materials, phones, restroom passes, dismissal. Write down how these work in your room, not how they work in the handbook. If students pick up their own folders at the door, say so. If phones go in a pocket chart, say where it is. Most of what a substitute reads as students “getting away with something” is students following a routine nobody told the sub about. Your routines and procedures are the thing being handed over.

    Where the work is, and the keys

    Copies made, labeled by period, in one place, named in the plan. Answer keys in the same folder. Keys let the substitute check work and let students who finish early check their own, which keeps the last fifteen minutes from turning into the loudest fifteen minutes of the day.

    Who to call, and the private information

    Name the teacher next door and the number for the office. Say plainly that if something is unsafe, the substitute does not need anyone’s permission to call for help. Health plans and emergency procedures belong in the binder only in the form your school requires. Do not leave copies of individual student plans loose on a desk; follow your building’s procedure for what a substitute is given and where it is kept.

    Write Sub Plans to the Minute

    My own rule for running a room is short: “Taking control of a classroom is done by organization to the minute and then you pause. Be confident.” The posted times are the setup. The pause is the enforcement. You lay out the plan, stop talking, and let the silence do its job.

    A substitute cannot borrow your confidence, and they do not have your history with the class. What they can borrow is your organization. If the plan is written to the minute, the substitute does not have to invent authority. They read the time, point at the board, and wait. The plan carries the weight a stranger’s voice cannot.

    That is also why vague plans fail even with a strong substitute. “Work on the project” leaves the adult in the room arguing about what counts as working. “Draft paragraph two, due in the tray at 9:20” does not. If you have never written the room down this way, a written classroom management plan is the document to start from.

    Emergency Sub Plans vs. Planned-Absence Sub Plans

    Emergency sub plans are the ones you build before you need them. They stand alone, they do not depend on yesterday’s lesson, and anyone in the building can run them cold. Planned-absence sub plans are written the week you know you’ll be out and continue the unit students are already in.

    Two-column comparison: emergency sub plans are written in advance, stand alone, can be run by anyone and are filed where the office can find them; planned-absence sub plans are written the week before, continue the current unit, and are replaced each time
    Emergency sub plans are the ones you can’t write when you need them.

    The emergency folder is the one that matters most, because it is the one you can’t write when you need it. You wake up sick at 5:30. Your kid has a fever. There is a family emergency two hours away. Nobody is writing a lesson plan in those moments, and nobody should have to.

    Three rules make emergency sub plans work:

    • Standalone. No reference to “where we left off.” The work makes sense on any day of the year.
    • Keyed and copied. A full class set for each day, with an answer key, already in the folder.
    • Findable. The office knows where the folder is. So does the teacher next door. Tell them both.

    Three days is the right number for most secondary teachers. One day runs out the first time you’re out twice in a month, and five days is a lot to build before the year has started.

    If building three standalone days from scratch is the part that keeps getting pushed back, start with the lesson library at SubstitutePlans.com. It holds 500 free ready-to-print sub plans for grades 6–12 across 12 subjects, each with a teacher plan, a student worksheet and an answer key, and there is no account to create.

    Stocking the folder costs little. The list of cheap classroom supplies covers the pencils, half sheets, sleeves and clips worth keeping in it.

    I write these for my own room and put them on TPT. The Any-Day Emergency Sub Plan Card is free: one page any adult can run, in any subject. If you teach social studies, Emergency Sub Plans World History is five strange-but-true readings with questions and answer keys, written so a substitute can hand them out without knowing the content. The same format covers Civics Sub Plans Vol. 1 for government classes and Renaissance Sub Plans. For a full ancient-to-medieval sequence, the Ancient & Medieval Sub Plans Bundle covers Egypt, Greece, Rome, and the Middle Ages in one folder.

    Out the week of Halloween? Halloween Sub Plans are five spooky history readings a substitute can run cold, so the sub day isn’t a word search.

    Subject-Neutral Sub Plans That Still Count

    Not every emergency day can be a content day. Sometimes the substitute is covering three different preps, or the class is being split into other rooms. That is when subject-neutral work earns its place. The test is simple: would a reasonable student see it as real work, and would you actually look at it when you got back?

    Work that passes that test:

    What fails the test: a movie with no task, a word search, or a packet nobody collects. Students read those as a day off, and the substitute pays for it.

    Behavior and Logistics: What the Substitute Needs to Know

    Tell the substitute what normal looks like, so they can tell when something isn’t. If partner talk is how your room works, say so, or a quiet-room substitute will spend the day fighting your design. If one class needs a seating change after lunch, write it down. If a student has a plan for stepping out when they need to, put it in the binder the way your school requires.

    Then give them something to say when a student pushes back. Most substitutes have a few phrases they lean on; it helps to leave a few that match how your room already talks. The free 5 De-escalation Scripts You Can Use Today fit on one page in the binder. If you want the full set for yourself, De-escalation Strategies for Teachers has 100 scripts for middle and high school.

    Finally, leave clear limits. Name the two or three things a substitute should write down and leave for you, rather than handle on the spot. That protects students from a stranger making a big call on a single day, and it protects the substitute from having to.

    When to Write Sub Plans, and When to Report the Absence

    Five-step timeline for sub plans: build the emergency folder in the first two weeks, report the absence right away, write the day in minutes before you leave, let the plan do the work, and grade the work when you return
    Report the absence early. Coverage drops for jobs posted at the last minute.

    Build the emergency folder in the first two weeks of school, while you still have the energy and before you need it. Look at it again at the start of each grading period and swap anything that has gone stale.

    When you know you’ll be out, report it right away. In a study of a large West Coast district, Brookings researcher Jing Liu and colleagues found that how early a substitute job was posted was one of the strongest predictors of whether it got filled. Coverage climbed quickly for each hour of notice through the first 24 hours, and jobs posted at the last minute were the least likely to be covered. A plan that never gets a substitute to read it is a plan for whoever ends up in your room instead.

    Plan for the Day No Substitute Comes

    Uncovered absences are not rare. In the same district data, teachers were out about 11.8 days a year, and roughly one of those days went without a substitute. When that happened, students were split into other classrooms about 37 percent of the time, a teacher gave up a planning period about 35 percent of the time, and an administrator covered about 12 percent of the time.

    The same study found that schools serving more disadvantaged students had systematically lower substitute coverage, and that substitutes often cited student behavior when they named the schools they avoided. Reporting from 2024 citing federal survey data put the share of public schools that had difficulty finding substitutes at 35 percent in 2023–24. Read honestly, that is not a reason to blame anyone. It is a reason to write plans that a colleague can run in another room, with your students sitting in the back of a class that isn’t theirs.

    That means one more rule for emergency sub plans: they have to work for 25 minutes in someone else’s room. A one-page reading with questions does. A lab, a discussion, or anything that needs your projector does not.

    What Students Should Be Doing, and Why It Matters

    Students behave differently on a sub day for reasons that make sense. The adult is new, the routine is off, and the day looks like it might not count. Responding to that isn’t a character flaw. It’s a reasonable read of what they’ve been handed.

    The fix is on our end. Leave work that is clearly real, collect it, and tell them in the plan that you will read it. Then do. If the work is graded, grade it the way you would on any other day. Don’t punish a whole class for what the substitute’s note says a few students did; deal with those students individually, the way you would if you had been there.

    Families notice this too. If a sub day turns into a grade, a student should be able to explain to a parent what the assignment was and why it counted. If you get questions, clear parent-teacher communication is easier when the work was clearly worth doing.

    Review Sub Plans Like the Person Reading Them

    Before you file it, read the plan as a stranger would. Could someone who has never been in your building find the copies? Could they start class without asking anyone? Could a colleague run the same pages in their room? Could a student tell what they are being graded on? If any answer is no, that is the line to fix.

    Build Sub Plans Once

    The point of all this is that the hard thinking happens once. A good emergency folder is built in August and keeps paying for itself every time life gets in the way. A good binder template means the planned-absence day takes twenty minutes to write instead of an evening.

    If you would rather start with everything already built, The Teacher Emergency Kit Ultimate Bundle puts 64 resources for grades 6–12 in one download. If you’re buying during a sitewide sale, the TPT sale guide explains how the discounts stack. Free printables for the rest of the classroom are in the free resource library.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What should be included in sub plans?

    A minute-by-minute schedule for each period, a seating chart and roster, how routines like entry, phones, and dismissal work, where the copies and answer keys are, who to call for help, the health and safety information your school requires, and a sheet for the substitute to leave notes on. The lesson itself is only one part.

    What are emergency sub plans?

    Emergency sub plans are standalone lessons you prepare before you need them, usually at the start of the year. They don’t depend on where the class left off, they come copied with answer keys, and they are kept where the office and a neighboring teacher can find them. Three days is a practical number for most secondary teachers.

    How detailed should sub plans be?

    Detailed enough that someone who has never been in your building could run the day without asking anyone. Use start and stop times for each task, name exactly where materials are, and spell out routines that students already know but a substitute doesn’t.

    Should sub plan work be graded?

    If you want students to take it seriously, yes. Collect it, read it, and grade it the way you would on any other day. Work that is never collected teaches students that sub days don’t count.

    What if no substitute is available?

    Plan for it. When an absence goes uncovered, students are often split into other classrooms or a colleague covers on a planning period. Emergency sub plans should work in 25 minutes in someone else’s room, which means short readings with questions rather than labs or discussions.

    Can a substitute show a movie?

    Only with a task attached and only if your school allows it. A video with a set of questions that gets collected is work. A movie with nothing attached tells students the day doesn’t count, and the substitute usually pays for that.

    How early should I report an absence?

    As early as you can. In one large district’s data, coverage rose sharply with each hour of notice through the first 24 hours, and last-minute postings were the least likely to be filled.

    Sources

    • Liu, J. (2020). America faces a substitute teacher shortage—and disadvantaged schools are hit hardest. Brookings Institution, Brown Center Chalkboard. Read the analysis — source for the 11.8 days of average absence, the share of uncovered absences and how they were covered, the effect of posting time on coverage, and the lower coverage rates in disadvantaged schools. Data from one large urban district on the West Coast, 2011–12 to 2017–18; it describes associations in that district, not a national rate.
    • DiFurio, D. (2024). Substitute teachers keep schools running. Here are the best ways schools can attract more amid the shortage. Stacker, with HeyTutor. Read the article — source for the 35% of public schools reporting difficulty finding substitutes in 2023–24 (attributed there to NCES School Pulse Panel data) and for the finding that substitutes rank solid lesson plans highest when choosing an assignment (from Red Rover’s 2023 survey of about 4,000 substitutes). This is a secondary summary; the NCES and Red Rover figures are cited as reported there.

    About Clay Shumate

    By Clay Shumate — Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.