The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Tag: secondary teaching

  • Sub Plans for Middle and High School: What to Leave So the Day Actually Runs

    Sub Plans for Middle and High School: What to Leave So the Day Actually Runs

    Sub plans are the instructions you leave so someone else can run your class for a day. Good ones do three jobs: they keep students safe, they keep students doing real work, and they tell a stranger what normal looks like in a room they have never seen. Most sub plans only try to do the second job, and that is why most sub days go sideways.

    This guide covers what to put in sub plans for grades 6–12, how to write the day so a substitute can actually follow it, the difference between emergency sub plans and the ones you write for a planned absence, and what to do about the days no substitute shows up at all. If you want the other side of the door — what the person walking in can and cannot control — that is in the guide to running a room that isn’t yours.

    Key Takeaways

    • Sub plans are written for a stranger, not for you. Anything that only makes sense if you know the room has to be spelled out.
    • Write the day in minutes. Start and stop times for each task turn a vague plan into one a substitute can enforce.
    • Emergency sub plans are a different document. They stand alone, they are built at the start of the year, and anyone in the building can run them.
    • Report the absence early. In one large district’s data, substitute coverage rose sharply for every hour a job was posted ahead of time through the first day.
    • Plan for no sub at all. When an absence goes uncovered, students are often split into other rooms or a colleague gives up a planning period. The plan has to work for them too.
    • Make the work count. Students can tell a holding pattern from a real assignment, and they act accordingly.

    What Should Sub Plans Include?

    Sub plans should include the schedule written in minutes, a seating chart and roster, how the room normally runs, the exact location of every copy, answer keys, the names of people to call, the health and safety information your school requires you to share, and a sheet for the substitute to write back on. That is the binder. The lesson is only one part of it.

    Checklist of eight items for a sub plans binder: the day in minutes, seating chart and roster, how the room runs, where the work is, answer keys, who to call, health and safety notes, and a note-back sheet
    The lesson is one part of the binder. The other seven are what a stranger needs at 7:40 a.m.

    Think about what a substitute actually needs at 7:40 in the morning. Not your philosophy of teaching. They need to know where the copies are, what happens when the bell rings, and who to send for when something goes wrong. A plan that says “students will continue their reading” tells them nothing about any of that.

    The day, in minutes

    Each period gets a start time and a stop time for every task. “8:05–8:15: bell work on the board. 8:15–8:40: reading and questions 1–6. 8:40–8:50: turn in to the tray by the door.” Times give the substitute something to point at. A posted time is easier to hold students to than an adult’s opinion about when they should be done.

    Seating chart and roster

    A substitute who can use names is in a different room than one who can’t. Keep the seating chart current and mark two or three students per class who can answer a question about where things are. Pick them for reliability, not for being your favorites. A seating chart built for the room you actually have does double duty here.

    How the room runs

    Entry, materials, phones, restroom passes, dismissal. Write down how these work in your room, not how they work in the handbook. If students pick up their own folders at the door, say so. If phones go in a pocket chart, say where it is. Most of what a substitute reads as students “getting away with something” is students following a routine nobody told the sub about. Your routines and procedures are the thing being handed over.

    Where the work is, and the keys

    Copies made, labeled by period, in one place, named in the plan. Answer keys in the same folder. Keys let the substitute check work and let students who finish early check their own, which keeps the last fifteen minutes from turning into the loudest fifteen minutes of the day.

    Who to call, and the private information

    Name the teacher next door and the number for the office. Say plainly that if something is unsafe, the substitute does not need anyone’s permission to call for help. Health plans and emergency procedures belong in the binder only in the form your school requires. Do not leave copies of individual student plans loose on a desk; follow your building’s procedure for what a substitute is given and where it is kept.

    Write Sub Plans to the Minute

    My own rule for running a room is short: “Taking control of a classroom is done by organization to the minute and then you pause. Be confident.” The posted times are the setup. The pause is the enforcement. You lay out the plan, stop talking, and let the silence do its job.

    A substitute cannot borrow your confidence, and they do not have your history with the class. What they can borrow is your organization. If the plan is written to the minute, the substitute does not have to invent authority. They read the time, point at the board, and wait. The plan carries the weight a stranger’s voice cannot.

    That is also why vague plans fail even with a strong substitute. “Work on the project” leaves the adult in the room arguing about what counts as working. “Draft paragraph two, due in the tray at 9:20” does not. If you have never written the room down this way, a written classroom management plan is the document to start from.

    Emergency Sub Plans vs. Planned-Absence Sub Plans

    Emergency sub plans are the ones you build before you need them. They stand alone, they do not depend on yesterday’s lesson, and anyone in the building can run them cold. Planned-absence sub plans are written the week you know you’ll be out and continue the unit students are already in.

    Two-column comparison: emergency sub plans are written in advance, stand alone, can be run by anyone and are filed where the office can find them; planned-absence sub plans are written the week before, continue the current unit, and are replaced each time
    Emergency sub plans are the ones you can’t write when you need them.

    The emergency folder is the one that matters most, because it is the one you can’t write when you need it. You wake up sick at 5:30. Your kid has a fever. There is a family emergency two hours away. Nobody is writing a lesson plan in those moments, and nobody should have to.

    Three rules make emergency sub plans work:

    • Standalone. No reference to “where we left off.” The work makes sense on any day of the year.
    • Keyed and copied. A full class set for each day, with an answer key, already in the folder.
    • Findable. The office knows where the folder is. So does the teacher next door. Tell them both.

    Three days is the right number for most secondary teachers. One day runs out the first time you’re out twice in a month, and five days is a lot to build before the year has started.

    If building three standalone days from scratch is the part that keeps getting pushed back, start with the lesson library at SubstitutePlans.com. It holds 500 free ready-to-print sub plans for grades 6–12 across 12 subjects, each with a teacher plan, a student worksheet and an answer key, and there is no account to create.

    Stocking the folder costs little. The list of cheap classroom supplies covers the pencils, half sheets, sleeves and clips worth keeping in it.

    I write these for my own room and put them on TPT. The Any-Day Emergency Sub Plan Card is free: one page any adult can run, in any subject. If you teach social studies, Emergency Sub Plans World History is five strange-but-true readings with questions and answer keys, written so a substitute can hand them out without knowing the content. The same format covers Civics Sub Plans Vol. 1 for government classes and Renaissance Sub Plans. For a full ancient-to-medieval sequence, the Ancient & Medieval Sub Plans Bundle covers Egypt, Greece, Rome, and the Middle Ages in one folder.

    Out the week of Halloween? Halloween Sub Plans are five spooky history readings a substitute can run cold, so the sub day isn’t a word search.

    Subject-Neutral Sub Plans That Still Count

    Not every emergency day can be a content day. Sometimes the substitute is covering three different preps, or the class is being split into other rooms. That is when subject-neutral work earns its place. The test is simple: would a reasonable student see it as real work, and would you actually look at it when you got back?

    Work that passes that test:

    What fails the test: a movie with no task, a word search, or a packet nobody collects. Students read those as a day off, and the substitute pays for it.

    Behavior and Logistics: What the Substitute Needs to Know

    Tell the substitute what normal looks like, so they can tell when something isn’t. If partner talk is how your room works, say so, or a quiet-room substitute will spend the day fighting your design. If one class needs a seating change after lunch, write it down. If a student has a plan for stepping out when they need to, put it in the binder the way your school requires.

    Then give them something to say when a student pushes back. Most substitutes have a few phrases they lean on; it helps to leave a few that match how your room already talks. The free 5 De-escalation Scripts You Can Use Today fit on one page in the binder. If you want the full set for yourself, De-escalation Strategies for Teachers has 100 scripts for middle and high school.

    Finally, leave clear limits. Name the two or three things a substitute should write down and leave for you, rather than handle on the spot. That protects students from a stranger making a big call on a single day, and it protects the substitute from having to.

    When to Write Sub Plans, and When to Report the Absence

    Five-step timeline for sub plans: build the emergency folder in the first two weeks, report the absence right away, write the day in minutes before you leave, let the plan do the work, and grade the work when you return
    Report the absence early. Coverage drops for jobs posted at the last minute.

    Build the emergency folder in the first two weeks of school, while you still have the energy and before you need it. Look at it again at the start of each grading period and swap anything that has gone stale.

    When you know you’ll be out, report it right away. In a study of a large West Coast district, Brookings researcher Jing Liu and colleagues found that how early a substitute job was posted was one of the strongest predictors of whether it got filled. Coverage climbed quickly for each hour of notice through the first 24 hours, and jobs posted at the last minute were the least likely to be covered. A plan that never gets a substitute to read it is a plan for whoever ends up in your room instead.

    Plan for the Day No Substitute Comes

    Uncovered absences are not rare. In the same district data, teachers were out about 11.8 days a year, and roughly one of those days went without a substitute. When that happened, students were split into other classrooms about 37 percent of the time, a teacher gave up a planning period about 35 percent of the time, and an administrator covered about 12 percent of the time.

    The same study found that schools serving more disadvantaged students had systematically lower substitute coverage, and that substitutes often cited student behavior when they named the schools they avoided. Reporting from 2024 citing federal survey data put the share of public schools that had difficulty finding substitutes at 35 percent in 2023–24. Read honestly, that is not a reason to blame anyone. It is a reason to write plans that a colleague can run in another room, with your students sitting in the back of a class that isn’t theirs.

    That means one more rule for emergency sub plans: they have to work for 25 minutes in someone else’s room. A one-page reading with questions does. A lab, a discussion, or anything that needs your projector does not.

    What Students Should Be Doing, and Why It Matters

    Students behave differently on a sub day for reasons that make sense. The adult is new, the routine is off, and the day looks like it might not count. Responding to that isn’t a character flaw. It’s a reasonable read of what they’ve been handed.

    The fix is on our end. Leave work that is clearly real, collect it, and tell them in the plan that you will read it. Then do. If the work is graded, grade it the way you would on any other day. Don’t punish a whole class for what the substitute’s note says a few students did; deal with those students individually, the way you would if you had been there.

    Families notice this too. If a sub day turns into a grade, a student should be able to explain to a parent what the assignment was and why it counted. If you get questions, clear parent-teacher communication is easier when the work was clearly worth doing.

    Review Sub Plans Like the Person Reading Them

    Before you file it, read the plan as a stranger would. Could someone who has never been in your building find the copies? Could they start class without asking anyone? Could a colleague run the same pages in their room? Could a student tell what they are being graded on? If any answer is no, that is the line to fix.

    Build Sub Plans Once

    The point of all this is that the hard thinking happens once. A good emergency folder is built in August and keeps paying for itself every time life gets in the way. A good binder template means the planned-absence day takes twenty minutes to write instead of an evening.

    If you would rather start with everything already built, The Teacher Emergency Kit Ultimate Bundle puts 64 resources for grades 6–12 in one download. If you’re buying during a sitewide sale, the TPT sale guide explains how the discounts stack. Free printables for the rest of the classroom are in the free resource library.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What should be included in sub plans?

    A minute-by-minute schedule for each period, a seating chart and roster, how routines like entry, phones, and dismissal work, where the copies and answer keys are, who to call for help, the health and safety information your school requires, and a sheet for the substitute to leave notes on. The lesson itself is only one part.

    What are emergency sub plans?

    Emergency sub plans are standalone lessons you prepare before you need them, usually at the start of the year. They don’t depend on where the class left off, they come copied with answer keys, and they are kept where the office and a neighboring teacher can find them. Three days is a practical number for most secondary teachers.

    How detailed should sub plans be?

    Detailed enough that someone who has never been in your building could run the day without asking anyone. Use start and stop times for each task, name exactly where materials are, and spell out routines that students already know but a substitute doesn’t.

    Should sub plan work be graded?

    If you want students to take it seriously, yes. Collect it, read it, and grade it the way you would on any other day. Work that is never collected teaches students that sub days don’t count.

    What if no substitute is available?

    Plan for it. When an absence goes uncovered, students are often split into other classrooms or a colleague covers on a planning period. Emergency sub plans should work in 25 minutes in someone else’s room, which means short readings with questions rather than labs or discussions.

    Can a substitute show a movie?

    Only with a task attached and only if your school allows it. A video with a set of questions that gets collected is work. A movie with nothing attached tells students the day doesn’t count, and the substitute usually pays for that.

    How early should I report an absence?

    As early as you can. In one large district’s data, coverage rose sharply with each hour of notice through the first 24 hours, and last-minute postings were the least likely to be filled.

    Sources

    • Liu, J. (2020). America faces a substitute teacher shortage—and disadvantaged schools are hit hardest. Brookings Institution, Brown Center Chalkboard. Read the analysis — source for the 11.8 days of average absence, the share of uncovered absences and how they were covered, the effect of posting time on coverage, and the lower coverage rates in disadvantaged schools. Data from one large urban district on the West Coast, 2011–12 to 2017–18; it describes associations in that district, not a national rate.
    • DiFurio, D. (2024). Substitute teachers keep schools running. Here are the best ways schools can attract more amid the shortage. Stacker, with HeyTutor. Read the article — source for the 35% of public schools reporting difficulty finding substitutes in 2023–24 (attributed there to NCES School Pulse Panel data) and for the finding that substitutes rank solid lesson plans highest when choosing an assignment (from Red Rover’s 2023 survey of about 4,000 substitutes). This is a secondary summary; the NCES and Red Rover figures are cited as reported there.

    About Clay Shumate

    By Clay Shumate — Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full.

  • Student Goal Setting: What Works in Grades 6–12, and What the Evidence Won’t Carry

    Student Goal Setting: What Works in Grades 6–12, and What the Evidence Won’t Carry

    By Clay Shumate

    Student goal setting is the practice of having students name a specific, near-term target for their own learning, plan how they will hit it, and check whether they did. It is cheap, it is popular, and the federal evidence review rates it “promising” rather than strong — which is a more useful place to start than the version you got in a faculty meeting.

    What follows is what the research supports, the large trial that found nothing, and the part that actually moves the needle: the plan, not the goal.

    Key Takeaways

    • The official rating is Tier III, “promising evidence.” That is the third-highest tier, below strong and moderate. Anyone selling this as settled is overselling it.
    • The best secondary study is correlational. 1,273 high school students over five years showed a significant relationship between goal writing and proficiency — with no control group, so causation is not established.
    • A large randomised trial found nothing. About 1,400 first-year college students, precisely estimated null on grades, credits and persistence — and it was a failed replication of a pilot that had reported more than half a standard deviation.
    • The plan beats the goal. Across 94 studies, forming a specific “if X, then I will Y” plan had a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment (d = .65). Wanting it more is not the mechanism.
    • Goal setting alone is not an intervention. The federal review says so outright: it “cannot be assumed to produce positive outcomes for students” on its own.

    Free Download · PDF

    The Student Goal and If-Then Plan Sheet

    Student-facing: five tests for a goal worth setting, the if-then plan frame, four worked examples by subject, and a two-week check-back log.

    Download the free PDF

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Browse every printable in Your Free Library.

    What Is Student Goal Setting?

    Student goal setting is a short cycle, not a form. The student names a specific target for their own learning, decides what they will actually do to reach it, does it, gathers some evidence, and judges honestly whether they got there. Then the cycle runs again.

    The word doing the work in that definition is own. A target a teacher assigns and a student copies onto a sheet is not goal setting; it is an objective with a student’s handwriting on it. The federal practice guide is specific that letting students set their own goals is one of the components associated with better outcomes, alongside goals that are proximal (near-term rather than end-of-year), specific rather than general, and optimally challenging — hard enough to require something, not so hard the student has already lost.

    It is also the forward-facing half of a pair. Student self-assessment asks a teenager to judge work they have already done. Goal setting asks the same student to aim at work they have not done yet. Neither one works well without the other — a goal set by a student with no accurate read on where they currently stand is a guess.

    Does Student Goal Setting Actually Work?

    The honest answer is “promising, conditional, and less certain than the training implies.” Three pieces of evidence, and they do not all point the same way.

    The official rating. The Regional Educational Laboratory Midwest reviewed student goal setting for the Institute of Education Sciences and rated it Tier III, “promising evidence” under the federal evidence standards. Tier III is the third-highest of four. It means there is correlational research with statistical controls behind the practice — not that it has been shown to cause anything in a well-controlled trial.

    The best secondary-school study. Moeller, Theiler and Wu followed 1,273 high school students across five years, 21 teachers and 23 Nebraska schools, using a portfolio system built on self-assessment, goal writing and evidence collection. Goal writing and action-plan writing both showed statistically significant relationships with language proficiency scores, independent of teacher effects. It is a large, long, genuinely secondary study, and the authors say plainly that there was no control group and causation cannot be established. Goals like these also fit naturally into a student led conference template.

    The trial that found nothing. Dobronyi, Oreopoulos and Petronijevic randomly assigned about 1,400 first-year university students to a structured goal-setting exercise, with or without follow-up reminders, against a control group. They found “no evidence of an effect of treatment” on grades, credits taken, credits failed, or second-year persistence — and their sample was large enough to have detected a 7 percent standardised effect. Their study was an attempt to replicate an earlier pilot that had reported a treatment effect on GPA of more than half a standard deviation. It did not replicate.

    Those students were undergraduates, not teenagers, and a one-off written exercise is not a classroom routine. Both of those are real reasons the null might not transfer. But it is exactly the kind of result that quietly disappears from professional development, and it is the reason the federal review ends up at “promising” instead of “strong.”

    What the review actually concludes is the sentence to keep: goal setting “in isolation cannot be assumed to produce positive outcomes for students.” It works when it is attached to planning, self-evaluation, regular feedback and reflection. Handed out as a September worksheet, it is a September worksheet.

    Why Do Most Classroom Goal-Setting Systems Die by October?

    Because the goal gets set and nothing after it is scheduled. Every failure I have watched has the same shape: a strong launch, a folder, and then nothing on the calendar that forces anyone to look at the folder again.

    Four specific failure modes, and each one has a cheap fix.

    1. The goal is too far away. “Raise my grade this semester” gives a student nothing to do on Tuesday. Proximal beats distal in the research and in the room. Two weeks is a good default.
    2. The goal is a wish, not a behavior. “Try harder in this class” cannot be checked by anybody, including the student. If you cannot tell from the outside whether it happened, it is not a goal.
    3. Nobody scheduled the review. This is the big one. If the goal review is not a thing that happens on a specific day, it does not happen. Put it in the plan the same way you would put in a quiz.
    4. The teacher owns it. The moment students believe the goal sheet is for you — for a binder check, for a walkthrough, for the folder an administrator might ask about — they write what looks good. You will get twenty-eight reasonable-sounding goals and zero information.

    There is a version of the fourth failure that no teacher can fix alone. If a district requires the goal sheet as a walkthrough artifact or a PLC deliverable, it has made the sheet an adult document by design, and students will read that correctly within a week. Goal setting is cheap enough to mandate and fragile enough that mandating it is usually how it dies. If it has to be collected, collect the evidence that the review happened — a date, a count — and leave the goals themselves with the student.

    The fourth one is the one worth guarding hardest, and it connects to something this site keeps coming back to: a choice that is really a compliance task in disguise teaches students to produce the appearance of the thing instead of the thing.

    What Makes a Goal Worth Setting?

    Five tests, and a goal that fails any of them will not survive two weeks. Run a student’s draft against these before it goes in the folder.

    Numbered list of five tests for a student goal: the student wrote it, it names a behavior rather than a wish, it is optimally challenging for that student, it is close enough to act on, and it has an if-then plan under it
    Run a student’s draft against these before it goes in the folder.

    The hardest of the five is the third. “Optimally challenging” sounds like jargon, and in practice it means a goal a student has maybe a sixty percent chance of hitting — which means some goals are supposed to be missed. Say that to the students in those words, on day one: you are supposed to miss some of these, and missing one is not a problem you will be in trouble for. If you do not say it, they will write goals they are certain of, and the whole system drifts toward targets everybody hits and nobody learns anything from. Say it to whoever reads the folder too, for the same reason.

    And “optimally challenging” is calibrated to the student, not to the class. A goal that is a genuine stretch for one student is a formality for the one beside them, which means the whole point breaks the moment you set a common goal and call it differentiated. It also means a student who has spent years being told they are behind may aim absurdly low the first time. That is information, not defiance, and the move is to negotiate one notch up rather than to reject the goal. The same argument sits underneath holding a standard high while making the path to it real: a target nobody misses was never a target.

    Are SMART Goals the Right Format?

    They are a reasonable checklist and a weak intervention, and it is worth knowing which one you are using. Specific and measurable are supported by the research on goal specificity. What SMART does not contain is the part that most predicts whether a goal gets reached.

    Look at what a SMART goal actually produces: a well-formed description of a destination. “I will score at least 80 percent on the next two vocabulary quizzes.” Specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound — and it contains no information about what the student will do differently on Wednesday. A student who could already answer that question did not need the acronym.

    I am not telling anyone to throw the format out. If your school uses it, use it. Just do not stop there, because the next section is where the evidence is.

    The If-Then Plan That Does the Work

    Adding a specific “if X happens, then I will do Y” plan to a goal had a medium-to-large effect on whether the goal got reached — d = .65 across 94 studies. Psychologists call these implementation intentions. Students can call them if-then plans and use them in about ninety seconds.

    Table comparing a wish, a SMART goal and an if-then plan, showing what each sounds like and why the if-then plan names the moment, the action and the thing it replaces
    SMART describes a destination. The if-then plan names the moment you act.

    Gollwitzer and Sheeran’s meta-analysis describes them as “if-then plans that link situational cues… with responses that are effective in attaining goals.” The effect split two ways that map exactly onto what teenagers struggle with: d = .61 for getting started and d = .77 for getting derailed. The larger of the two is the one about staying on track after something goes wrong, which is the failure mode for most students, most of the time.

    Two honest limits from the same paper. If there are few real barriers to a goal, the if-then plan is superfluous — a student who was going to do it anyway does not need one. And the strong effects showed up “predominantly when the underlying goal intention was strong.” An if-then plan attached to a goal the student does not care about does nothing. That is not a flaw in the technique; it is the reason the student has to write the goal.

    Here is the frame students actually use, and it is worth writing on the board: “If it is [a specific time or trigger], then I will [a specific action].” The test is whether a stranger could tell from the outside that it happened. Watch a real one get fixed: “I will review my notes more” is not a plan. “If it is Tuesday and I have finished eating, then I will redo the two problems I got wrong before I open my phone” is one, because it names the moment, the action and the thing it replaces. Most student first drafts are missing the moment. That is the only edit you usually have to make.

    Worth saying about the population too: this meta-analysis spans health, behavior change and academic contexts across a wide age range, not a set of secondary classrooms. The mechanism is general. The classroom result is a reasonable inference, not a measured one.

    Student Goal Setting Examples for Grades 6–12

    A usable goal names a behavior, a number and a date, and is followed by a plan that names a moment. Here is the difference in practice, by subject.

    Table of four student goal setting examples in math, social studies, science and English, each paired with the if-then plan that sits under it
    Four subjects, four goals, and the plan that makes each one survive two weeks.

    Notice what every one of the good versions has that the bad version does not: a specific when. Not “I will study more” but “when I sit down Tuesday after practice.” The when is the whole mechanism. Without it the student has written a wish with a deadline attached.

    One more thing about the examples above: none of them is about a grade. Grade goals are the ones students reach for first, and they are the least useful, because a grade is an outcome the student only partly controls and it gives no instruction about behavior. “Get a B” tells you nothing to do Tuesday. If a student insists on a grade goal, ask the follow-up: what would have to be different in your week for that to happen? The answer is the actual goal.

    What Teachers Should Not Do With Student Goals

    Three things, and all three are common.

    Do not grade the goal. A graded goal is a goal a student sets low, which destroys the only thing a goal is for. Grade the work; the goal is instrumentation. If you need a grade out of the process, grade whether the reflection is honest and specific — a student who writes “I did not do this and here is why” has done the assignment correctly.

    Do not post them. Goal walls, goal charts and public trackers look like accountability and function as ranking. A student setting a goal is disclosing what they are not good at yet, in front of everyone they eat lunch with. Some students can carry that and some cannot, and you will not know which is which until it goes wrong. Keep goals in a folder, a document, or a conversation.

    Do not let a classroom goal collide with an IEP goal. If a student has goals written into an IEP or a 504 plan, those are legal documents with their own review cycle and their own people attached. A classroom goal that restates them turns your folder into a parallel record of a student’s disability, and one that pulls against them creates a conflict the student has to resolve. Ask the case manager first. Usually the answer is simple — keep the classroom goal about something the IEP does not cover — but it should be a decision rather than an accident.

    And tell families what this is before they hear about it secondhand. One sentence in a syllabus or an email does it: students set a short-term learning goal every two weeks, the goals are not graded and are not a judgment about the student, and a missed goal is a normal part of how the routine works. Parents who learn about a goal folder from a worried fourteen-year-old will assume it is an evaluation, and they will be reasonable to assume it.

    Do not let a goal become a record. If a student’s goal sheet contains anything about their home life, their diagnosis, their family or their mental health — and if you ask an open enough question, eventually one will — then you are holding a document you did not plan to hold. Keep the prompts academic and behavioral, say clearly what you do and do not do with the sheets, and know your school’s policy before you build a system that collects them. A goal-setting routine is a data-collection routine whether you designed it as one or not.

    How Often Should Students Revisit a Goal?

    Every two weeks, on a date that is already on the calendar, and in writing. Anything longer and the goal stops being operative; anything shorter and you are spending class time on the system instead of the work.

    The review is three questions and it takes six minutes. Did you do the thing you said you would do? What is the evidence? What is the goal for the next two weeks — the same one, or a different one? A student who missed and says why has not failed the routine. A student who quietly rewrites history has, and the way you prevent that is by making it clearly safe to have missed.

    The version I trust most is not a form at all. I pull students over one at a time and ask them to defend their own decisions out loud — why this goal, why that plan, what the evidence is. It takes longer than collecting sheets and it is harder to fake. A student who has to say it to your face either has a reason or discovers on the spot that they do not, and both of those outcomes are more useful than a folder.

    The arithmetic does not work at scale, and pretending otherwise is how this advice gets ignored. Six minutes times a hundred and forty students is not a thing anyone is doing every two weeks. So rotate: five or six conversations per cycle, everybody else writes, and every student gets a real check-in roughly once a quarter. Choose the five deliberately rather than by who volunteers — the students who most need to say it out loud are rarely the ones raising a hand.

    One thing to watch for across cycles: a student who misses every goal is not a student who is failing at goal setting. It is a miscalibration, and the calibration is the adult’s job. Sit down, cut the goal in half, and let them hit one. A student who has never once hit a target they set has learned only that setting targets is pointless, which is worse than not having asked. When these check-ins feed a conversation with families, they are also most of the preparation for a conference the student actually leads.

    What to Do Next

    Pick one class. Have every student write one two-week goal that names a behavior and a number, and then — this is the part that matters — have them write one sentence underneath it in the form “If [specific moment], then I will [specific action].” Put the review date in your plans before the students leave the room.

    Then run it twice before you judge it. The first cycle teaches them the format. The second one is the first real data you will get, and it will tell you more about your class than the goals themselves do.

    And set your expectations where the evidence sets them. This is a promising practice that works as part of something — planning, feedback, honest self-assessment, a conversation — and does very little on its own. A worksheet in September is not a goal-setting system. A date on the calendar is.

    Before you go: grab the free The Student Goal and If-Then Plan Sheet (PDF) — ElevateTheNorm.com branded, printable, no email required.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is student goal setting?

    It is a short repeating cycle in which a student names a specific, near-term target for their own learning, plans what they will actually do to reach it, gathers evidence, and judges honestly whether they got there. The key word is “own” — a target the teacher assigns and the student copies onto a sheet is an objective in the student’s handwriting, not a goal.

    Does student goal setting improve achievement?

    The federal evidence review rates it Tier III, “promising evidence” — the third-highest of four tiers. A five-year study of 1,273 high school students found a significant relationship between goal writing and proficiency, but it had no control group. A randomised trial of about 1,400 first-year college students found no effect at all on grades, credits or persistence. The honest summary is that it helps when it is attached to planning and feedback and does little by itself.

    Are SMART goals good for students?

    They are a reasonable checklist for describing a destination and a weak intervention on their own. Specific and measurable are genuinely supported by the research on goal specificity. What SMART does not include is any statement of what the student will do differently, and that is the part that predicts whether the goal gets reached. Use it if your school uses it, then add an if-then plan underneath.

    What is an if-then plan and why does it matter more than the goal?

    It is a sentence in the form “if [specific situation], then I will [specific action]” — researchers call it an implementation intention. Across 94 studies it had a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment, d = .65, with d = .61 for getting started and d = .77 for getting back on track after getting derailed. A goal describes where you want to end up. The if-then plan names the moment you will act.

    How often should students revisit their goals?

    About every two weeks, on a date that is already in your plans. Longer than that and the goal stops being operative; shorter and you spend class time on the system instead of the work. The review is three questions and takes six minutes: did you do it, what is the evidence, and what is the goal for the next two weeks.

    Should student goals be graded?

    No. A graded goal is a goal the student sets low, which removes the only thing a goal is useful for. If you need a grade from the process, grade whether the reflection is honest and specific. A student who writes “I did not do this, and here is why” has done the assignment correctly.

    Should I post student goals on the wall?

    No. A public goal chart looks like accountability and functions as a ranking, because a student setting a goal is disclosing what they are not good at yet in front of everyone they eat lunch with. Keep goals in a folder, a document or a conversation. Visibility is not the mechanism; the plan and the review date are.

    Why do goal-setting systems stop working after a few weeks?

    Almost always because nothing after the goal was scheduled. The four usual causes are a goal that is too far away, a goal that describes a wish rather than a behavior, a review that never got a date, and a system students correctly perceive as being for the teacher’s binder. Only the last one is about motivation, and it is fixed by keeping the goals out of anything that gets inspected.

    Sources

    1. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, Regional Educational Laboratory Midwest. Student Goal Setting: An Evidence-Based Practice. 2018. ERIC ED589978. Rates student goal setting Tier III, “promising evidence,” under federal evidence standards; identifies optimally challenging, proximal, specific, self-set and mastery-oriented goals as the supported components; and states that goal setting “in isolation cannot be assumed to produce positive outcomes for students.” https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED589978.pdf
    2. Moeller, Aleidine J., Janine M. Theiler, and Chaorong Wu. “Goal Setting and Student Achievement: A Longitudinal Study.” The Modern Language Journal, vol. 96, no. 2, 2012, pp. 153–169. Five-year quasi-experimental study, 1,273 high school students, 21 teachers, 23 Nebraska schools; goal writing and action-plan writing significantly related to proficiency scores independent of teacher effects. No control group; the authors state causation cannot be established. https://www.ncssfl.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/MLJ.2012.GoalSettingandStudentAchievementLongitudinalStudy.pdf
    3. Dobronyi, Christopher R., Philip Oreopoulos, and Uros Petronijevic. “Goal Setting, Academic Reminders, and College Success: A Large-Scale Field Experiment.” Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, vol. 12, no. 1, 2019, pp. 38–66. Randomised trial, approximately 1,400 first-year university students; “no evidence of an effect of treatment” on grades, credits or persistence, precise enough to detect a 7 percent standardised effect. A failed replication of a pilot reporting more than half a standard deviation on GPA. Population: undergraduates, not secondary students. https://oreopoulos.faculty.economics.utoronto.ca/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/dobronyi-et-al-goal-setting-academic-reminders-and-college-success-jree-2019.pdf
    4. Gollwitzer, Peter M., and Paschal Sheeran. “Implementation Intentions and Goal Achievement: A Meta-Analysis of Effects and Processes.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, vol. 38, 2006, pp. 69–119. 94 studies; overall d = .65, with d = .61 for getting started and d = .77 for getting derailed. Notes that effects are reduced when few barriers exist and that strong effects appeared “predominantly when the underlying goal intention was strong and activated.” Spans health and behaviour-change contexts across a wide age range, not secondary classrooms specifically. https://cancercontrol.cancer.gov/sites/default/files/2020-06/goal_intent_attain.pdf

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Questions for Socratic Seminar: 40 That Work in Grades 6–12

    Questions for Socratic Seminar: 40 That Work in Grades 6–12

    By Clay Shumate

    Good questions for a Socratic seminar have no answer you could look up, no answer the teacher is holding, and at least two defensible readings in the text itself. That is the whole test. A question that a prepared student can settle in one sentence is a comprehension check — useful, but it will not carry thirty minutes of discussion.

    Below are forty questions you can use tomorrow, sorted by what they are for, plus the way to write your own out of whatever text you are already teaching.

    Key Takeaways

    • Three kinds of question run a seminar: one opening question, several core questions you may never need, and closing questions that ask what changed.
    • The research on “higher-order questions” is weaker than the training says. One meta-analysis of 20 studies found a significant positive effect; a second, of 14 studies, found the effect small. Both are true and both are old.
    • What does hold up is the authentic question — one the teacher does not already have an answer to. In a study of more than 1,100 eighth and ninth graders, that predicted higher literature achievement.
    • Wait longer than feels reasonable. Teachers average about one second. Three is the floor for a recall question, and for a genuinely open one there appears to be no ceiling.
    • Students should be writing questions too. A seminar where only the teacher asks is a recitation with the chairs moved.

    Free Download · PDF

    40 Socratic Seminar Questions

    All forty questions in five groups, the six stems to post for students, and the ten-minute method for turning a text of your own into seminar questions.

    Download the free PDF

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Browse every printable in Your Free Library.

    What Makes a Good Socratic Seminar Question?

    Four things, and you can test all four in about a minute. Write your question down, then run it against this list before you take it anywhere near a class.

    1. You cannot answer it in one sentence. Try. If you finish in a line, you have written a comprehension check. Keep it — just do not open with it, and file it with your other ways of checking what landed.
    2. You do not already know the answer. This is the hard one, because teachers are trained to ask questions we can assess. A seminar question is one where you would genuinely take notes on the replies.
    3. The text can support more than one answer. Not “what do you think” — opinions with no evidence anchor produce a conversation nobody can lose or learn from. The disagreement has to be arguable from the page.
    4. It cannot be Googled. If a phone settles it in twenty seconds, it will get settled in twenty seconds.

    The fourth one has quietly become the most important. A question like “what were the causes of the conflict” is a research task. “Which of the causes the author lists is doing the most work, and which one is there to make the argument look balanced?” is a seminar, because the answer is not written down anywhere.

    The Three Kinds of Question a Seminar Needs

    An opening question, a stack of core questions, and a closing question — and you should expect to use the opening one and maybe two others. The stack is insurance, not a script.

    Numbered list of four question types for a Socratic seminar: the opening question, core questions, closing questions, and the follow-up built on what a student just said
    Three kinds you write down, and the one you cannot.

    The opening question is the only one you are guaranteed to ask. It should be answerable from a first reading, hard enough to divide the room, and broad enough that four different students can enter it from four different places. It usually points at the whole text rather than a line.

    Core questions go down into the text. These are the ones that name a paragraph, a word choice, a contradiction between two claims. Write six and plan to use two — and if you have five preps and six is not happening, write three. Three real ones beat six you assembled at 10pm. The worst thing you can do with a good stack is work through it, because then you are running the agenda and the students are answering it.

    Closing questions leave the text. What does this mean for something the students actually deal with? What changed in your thinking, and whose comment did it? That second one belongs in the post-seminar writing, and it is the single best assessment item this format produces. One guard on it: ask students to name a classmate for credit, never for criticism. “What did this conversation get wrong?” is a question about the conversation, and it is worth saying so out loud before they write.

    There is a fourth kind that never gets written down, and it is the one that matters most in the room: the follow-up. Building the next question out of what a student just said — researchers call it uptake — is what separates a discussion from a round of answers.

    Does Asking Harder Questions Actually Improve Achievement?

    Less clearly than the training slides claim, and it is worth knowing why before you rebuild your question bank around Bloom’s taxonomy. Two meta-analyses looked at the same question and did not agree.

    Kathleen Cotton’s synthesis for the Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory lays both out. Redfield and Rousseau’s 1981 meta-analysis of 20 studies “concludes that asking higher cognitive questions has a significant and positive effect on student performance.” Samson and colleagues ran a second meta-analysis in 1987 across 14 studies and found that students exposed to higher cognitive questions did outperform others, “but that the effect size is small.”

    A later critical review by Mikyeong Yang went further, concluding that this body of work “reported incoherent results” and that the evidence cannot support the expectation that higher-cognitive questions are more effective than fact questions. So: a real effect, a small effect, and a serious argument that the whole line of research is not measuring what it thinks it is.

    Here is what survives all three, and it is not about difficulty at all. Nystrand and Gamoran studied eighth- and ninth-grade English classes across sixteen middle schools feeding nine high schools, testing more than 1,100 students in fall and spring. Students whose teachers asked a higher proportion of authentic questions — ones the teacher did not already have an answer to — and who practiced uptake scored significantly higher on literature achievement.

    Authentic is not the same as hard. “Analyze the author’s use of irony” is high on Bloom’s and completely inauthentic if you have a rubric in your hand describing the right answer. “Is the last line a joke?” is simple, open, and genuinely contested. Write for authentic, not for the taxonomy. It is the same trade as anywhere else on this site: real questions hand students something to do, which is what giving students a genuine decision rather than a cosmetic one actually looks like inside one class period.

    One more number worth carrying, from the same Cotton synthesis: in ordinary classroom recitation, about 60 percent of teacher questions are lower cognitive, 20 percent higher cognitive, and 20 percent procedural. A seminar is one of the few structures that changes that ratio on purpose.

    40 Questions for Socratic Seminar

    Eight questions in each of five categories, written to be subject-general so you can drop your own text into them. Every one of these is a shell — swap in your author, your document, your data set.

    Two things before you use them. They are subject-general on purpose, which means the question is only as safe as the text you put under it; choosing a text on a contested public issue is a decision that belongs to you and your school’s policy, not to a question bank on the internet. And the fourth group — the ones that surface disagreement — is asked to the room, never to a named student. “Who read that line differently?” is an invitation. “Marcus, you disagree, right?” is an ambush, and the student you do it to will remember it longer than the text.

    Opening questions (use one)

    1. What is the most important sentence in this text, and what does the rest of it do?
    2. What is this author afraid of?
    3. If you had to remove one paragraph without losing the argument, which one goes?
    4. Who is this written for? How can you tell?
    5. What does this text refuse to say?
    6. Is the author describing the world or arguing about it?
    7. What would have to be true for this to be right?
    8. What question is this text an answer to?

    Core questions: evidence and claims

    1. Which claim here has the least support behind it?
    2. Where does the author stop explaining and start assuming?
    3. Are the two claims in the second and fourth paragraphs compatible?
    4. What counts as evidence in this text, and who decided that?
    5. Is the strongest objection to this argument in the text, or did the author leave it out?
    6. Which detail would change your reading if it turned out to be wrong?
    7. Does the author distinguish what they know from what they think?
    8. If this were written by someone on the other side, which sentence would survive?

    Core questions: language and choice

    1. Why that word and not the obvious one?
    2. What work is the title doing?
    3. Where does the tone shift, and what happens right before it?
    4. Who is given a name in this text, and who is not?
    5. What is the effect of the thing the author repeats?
    6. Is the ending earned by what came before it?
    7. What would be lost if this were written plainly?
    8. Which sentence do you think the author rewrote the most times?

    Questions that surface disagreement

    1. Who in this room read that line differently than you did?
    2. What is the strongest version of the argument you disagree with?
    3. Is this a disagreement about the text or about something outside it?
    4. What would change your mind?
    5. Can both readings be true at once?
    6. What are we assuming that the text never says?
    7. Which of us is using a word to mean two different things?
    8. Is the disagreement about what happened or about whether it was right?

    Closing and reflection questions

    1. What did you come in believing that you are less sure of now?
    2. Whose comment changed or sharpened your thinking, and what did they say?
    3. What question do we still not have an answer to?
    4. What would you need to read next to settle this?
    5. Where does this argument show up outside of school?
    6. If you had to explain this text to someone in one sentence, what would you leave out?
    7. What did this conversation get wrong?
    8. What is the question you wanted to ask and did not?

    Question Stems Students Can Use

    The fastest upgrade to a seminar is teaching students to ask each other questions instead of taking turns making statements. Most students arrive with one move — say your opinion and stop — and a short posted list fixes it faster than any amount of coaching.

    Six question stems students can use in a Socratic seminar, including what in the text makes you say that, can you say more, I read that line differently because, are you saying X or Y, what would change your mind, and we have not heard from
    Post six. Nobody reads twenty.

    Post six stems and refer to them by name. Do not post twenty; nobody reads twenty.

    The other half of this is teaching students to write a question, since you are requiring one at the door. Give them one frame and it stops being mysterious: point at a specific place in the text, say what confused or bothered you about it, and end with a question you cannot answer yourself. “On page two the author says X, but earlier they said Y — which one are they actually arguing?” is a better seminar question than most of mine, and a fourteen-year-old can produce it on the second try.

    For a student who found the text hard, say plainly that the question can be about the part they did understand. A question from paragraph one is a real contribution. Nobody has to have finished the text to have something worth asking about it.

    Two of these deserve a note. “What in the text makes you say that?” does most of the work of a facilitator and it is the one stem I would teach first — it is polite, it is not a challenge, and it forces the conversation back to the page every time it drifts. And “Can you say more?” is how a quiet student participates without having to produce a position of their own, which matters more than it sounds like.

    How Long Should You Wait After Asking?

    Three seconds minimum, and for a genuinely open question, longer than you think you can stand. This is the oldest finding in the questioning literature and it is still the one teachers violate most.

    Table of wait-time research findings: teachers wait about one second, comment within nine-tenths of a second, three seconds is the recall-question threshold, no threshold was found for open questions, and answers lengthen at three to five seconds
    Teachers average about one second. Eight costs you nothing.

    Mary Budd Rowe measured it in the early 1970s. Teachers allowed an average of about one second for a student to respond, and followed a student’s answer with a comment within roughly nine-tenths of a second. When those two waits were stretched to three to five seconds, student responses got longer, more students answered without being called on, speculative thinking went up, students began comparing their evidence to each other’s rather than to the teacher, and fewer questions went unanswered. Worth naming honestly: Rowe’s classrooms were elementary science. The effect has held up widely, but that is the population she measured.

    One cheap adjustment that goes with the wait: put the opening question in writing as well as saying it. On the board, on the handout, anywhere it stays. A student who processes slowly, who missed the first three words, or who is rereading the text while you talk should not lose the question because it only existed as sound. It costs nothing and it changes who is able to answer.

    Cotton’s synthesis adds the part that matters for seminars specifically: three seconds is the threshold for lower cognitive questions, and for higher cognitive questions there appears to be no threshold at all — students “seem to become more and more engaged and perform better and better the longer the teacher is willing to wait.”

    I have tested the ceiling on this and I would not recommend the experiment. I once waited more than five minutes. It was one of the most awkward moments of my life, that section finished nine minutes behind my other classes, and it is the only time I have ever assigned homework. I am not telling that story as a technique. I am telling it because the price of waiting is real and it is worth knowing what it costs before you decide the silence is unbearable at eight seconds. Eight seconds costs you nothing.

    How to Turn Your Own Text Into Questions in Ten Minutes

    Read for the seams, not for the content. You are not looking for what the text says. You are looking for the places where it strains.

    1. Mark every hedge. “Arguably,” “some have suggested,” “it is possible that.” Each one is a place the author was not sure, and each one is a question.
    2. Find two sentences that do not quite fit together. Not a contradiction — a tension. “Are these both true?” is a seminar question that writes itself.
    3. Note what is missing. Who is not quoted. Which objection is not answered. What the author had to leave out to make the piece work.
    4. Write your opening question from the whole text, and three core questions from the marks you made.
    5. Answer your own opening question in one sentence. If you can, go back to step two.

    That is the whole process, and it gets faster. The fourth time you do it you will find yourself marking hedges while you read for other reasons, which is a better outcome than any question bank.

    Questions That Wreck a Seminar

    Four shapes, and all four are easy to write by accident.

    • The question you already answered in class. Students will give you your own words back, correctly, and nothing will happen.
    • The yes-or-no question with an obvious side. “Was the narrator wrong to lie?” gets twenty-eight yeses. Ask instead what the lie cost, and who paid.
    • The question that requires a personal disclosure. “Have you ever been treated this way?” will get an honest answer from a fifteen-year-old in front of twenty-seven peers, and that is exactly the problem. Keep the question on the text and let students bring themselves to it if they choose. If a text is likely to pull the room in that direction, that is a conversation to have with an administrator before it is a seminar question.
    • The question with a correct answer you will eventually supply. Students can smell this within four minutes, and once they have, the seminar becomes a guessing game about you.

    The third one is the one worth being most careful with, because it usually comes from a good instinct. Relevance is not the same as exposure. A question can matter to a student’s life without requiring them to narrate it to the class.

    What to Do Next

    Take the text you are teaching this week and spend ten minutes on the five steps above. Write one opening question, three core questions, and one closing question. Then pull four questions from the bank here that fit the same text, so you have something in reserve you did not have to invent.

    Ask your opening question once, and count to eight in your head before you do anything else. That is the whole practice. If you want the rest of the format — the norms, the seating, what to do about the students who will not talk — it is in the full guide to running a Socratic seminar. And if the questions you write keep coming out as comprehension checks, that is not a failure; it means you have a set of quick checks for understanding and a seminar question still to write. To score the discussion itself, use the Socratic seminar rubric.

    Before you go: grab the free 40 Socratic Seminar Questions (PDF) — ElevateTheNorm.com branded, printable, no email required.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What makes a good Socratic seminar question?

    One you cannot answer in a sentence, that you do not already have an answer to, that the text can support more than one answer to, and that a phone cannot settle in twenty seconds. The first two are the ones teachers miss. We are trained to ask questions we can assess, and a question you can assess is usually a question you already answered.

    How many questions should I prepare for a seminar?

    One opening question, about six core questions, and two closing questions — and expect to use three of them. The stack is insurance against a dead room, not an agenda. Working through all nine is how a seminar turns back into a recitation with the chairs moved.

    What is the difference between an authentic question and a higher-order question?

    An authentic question is one the teacher does not have an answer to. A higher-order question is one high on Bloom’s taxonomy. They are not the same thing, and the research suggests the first matters more. “Analyze the author’s use of irony” is higher-order and completely inauthentic if you are holding a rubric describing the right answer.

    How long should I wait after asking a seminar question?

    Three seconds is the research floor, and for open questions there appears to be no ceiling — students engage more and perform better the longer the teacher is willing to wait. Teachers average about one second, which is why this feels so unnatural. Eight seconds costs you nothing and changes who answers.

    Should students write their own seminar questions?

    Yes, and it is the change that most reliably fixes a flat seminar. Require one written question from every student, collected on the way in. Make it an expectation rather than a bar — a student who arrives without one writes it in the first two minutes. A seminar where only the teacher asks questions is not a seminar.

    Can I use the same questions for any text?

    Most of them, yes. The forty here are deliberately subject-general: “what does this text refuse to say?” works on a court opinion, a poem, a lab report and a political speech. What does not transfer is the core questions, because those name a specific paragraph or word choice. Write those yourself from the text in front of you.

    What questions should I avoid in a Socratic seminar?

    Anything you already answered in class, yes-or-no questions with an obvious side, questions with a correct answer you plan to supply eventually, and questions that require a student to disclose something personal in front of the class. That last one usually comes from a good instinct — relevance — but relevance is not the same as exposure.

    Do harder questions actually raise achievement?

    The evidence is genuinely split. A 1981 meta-analysis of 20 studies found asking higher cognitive questions had a significant positive effect on performance; a 1987 meta-analysis of 14 studies found the effect small; and a later critical review argued the whole line of research reported incoherent results. What holds up better is the authentic question and the follow-up built on what a student just said.

    Sources

    1. Cotton, Kathleen. Classroom Questioning. School Improvement Research Series, Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory, May 1988. Reports Redfield and Rousseau (1981), 20 studies, “significant and positive effect” for higher cognitive questions, against Samson et al. (1987), 14 studies, effect “small”; a three-second wait-time threshold for lower cognitive questions and no apparent threshold for higher cognitive ones; and a 60 / 20 / 20 split of lower cognitive, higher cognitive and procedural questions in ordinary recitation. https://educationnorthwest.org/sites/default/files/ClassroomQuestioning.pdf
    2. Rowe, Mary Budd. Wait-Time and Rewards as Instructional Variables: Their Influence on Language, Logic, and Fate Control. 1972. ERIC ED061103. Teachers allowed an average of about one second for a response and commented within about nine-tenths of a second; extending both to three to five seconds produced longer responses, more unsolicited appropriate answers, more speculative thinking, more student-to-student evidence comparison and fewer unanswered questions. Population: elementary science classrooms. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED061103
    3. Nystrand, Martin, and Adam Gamoran. Student Engagement: When Recitation Becomes Conversation. National Center on Effective Secondary Schools, 1990. ERIC ED323581. Eighth- and ninth-grade English classes in sixteen middle schools feeding nine high schools across eight Midwestern communities; over 1,100 students tested fall and spring. Higher proportions of authentic questions and uptake predicted significantly higher literature achievement. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED323581.pdf
    4. Yang, Mikyeong. “A Critical Review of Research on Questioning in Education: Limitations of Its Positivistic Basis.” Asia Pacific Education Review, vol. 7, no. 2, 2006, pp. 195–204. Argues that the teacher-questioning meta-analyses “reported incoherent results” and that the evidence cannot support the expectation that higher-cognitive questions outperform fact questions. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ752340.pdf
    5. Applebee, Arthur N., Judith A. Langer, Martin Nystrand, and Adam Gamoran. “Discussion-Based Approaches to Developing Understanding: Classroom Instruction and Student Performance in Middle and High School English.” American Educational Research Journal, vol. 40, no. 3, 2003, pp. 685–730. 64 middle and high school English classrooms, grades 7, 8, 10, 11 and 12. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ782328
    6. National Paideia Center. “Paideia Seminar.” The seminar defined as a collaborative intellectual dialogue facilitated with open-ended questions about a text, run as a pre-seminar / seminar / post-seminar cycle. https://paideia.org/blogs/npc/paideia-socratic-seminar

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Socratic Seminar: How to Run One That Grades 6–12 Take Seriously

    Socratic Seminar: How to Run One That Grades 6–12 Take Seriously

    By Clay Shumate

    A Socratic seminar is a structured, whole-group discussion in which students question a shared text and each other while the teacher stays mostly silent. There is no winner and no correct answer to arrive at. The point is that students do the reasoning out loud, in front of each other, using evidence from something they all read.

    That is the definition. What follows is the part most guides skip: what the research actually supports, what it does not, and how to run one in a real secondary class without the same five kids carrying it.

    Key Takeaways

    • A seminar is not a debate. Nobody is assigned a side, nobody is trying to win, and the question has to be one you cannot settle by looking something up.
    • The strongest evidence is about discussion generally, not this format specifically. A study of 64 middle and high school English classrooms found discussion-based teaching predicted higher spring literacy performance — for low-achieving students as well as high-achieving ones.
    • The most honest finding is a mixed one. A meta-analysis found discussion produced big jumps in student talk and real gains in text comprehension, but few approaches moved critical thinking and reasoning.
    • Preparation is the whole game. A seminar with an unread text is twenty minutes of opinions.
    • Silence is not failure. The most common way a teacher wrecks a seminar is by answering the question they just asked.

    Free Download · PDF

    The Socratic Seminar Prep Sheet

    A text-selection check, the opening-question test, the six moves in order, six norms worth posting, a turn-count tally for you, and the four-way autopsy for a seminar that died.

    Download the free PDF

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Browse every printable in Your Free Library.

    What Is a Socratic Seminar?

    A Socratic seminar is a formal, text-based dialogue where students ask and answer open-ended questions with each other, and the teacher facilitates instead of teaching. The National Paideia Center — which has trained schools in this format for decades — defines it as “a collaborative intellectual dialogue facilitated with open-ended questions about a text.” That definition is doing more work than it looks like.

    Every word in it rules something out. Collaborative rules out debate. Open-ended rules out questions with answers. About a text rules out a free-floating conversation on a topic. Take away any one and you have something else — possibly useful, but not a seminar. Here is the distinction that matters most in a secondary room, because teenagers assume it is a debate unless you tell them otherwise. When a debate is what you actually want, run it on purpose with a format rather than letting a seminar slide into one.

    Comparison table of a Socratic seminar, a class discussion and a debate across goal, positions, teacher role, what the talk is anchored in, and whether changing your mind counts as success
    A seminar is not a debate. Nobody is assigned a side and nobody wins.

    Does the Research Actually Support Discussion-Based Teaching?

    Yes for discussion in general — and more cautiously than most professional development admits when it comes to thinking. Two studies point in slightly different directions, and both are worth knowing before you build a unit around this.

    The strong one is squarely in our grade band. Applebee, Langer, Nystrand and Gamoran studied 64 middle and high school English classrooms across grades 7, 8, 10, 11 and 12. Controlling for fall performance and background, discussion-based approaches were significantly related to spring literacy performance. Their own summary of why: students in discussion-heavy rooms “internalize the knowledge and skills necessary to engage in challenging literacy tasks on their own.” And the finding held “for low-achieving as well as high-achieving students” — which is the opposite of what people assume about discussion, and the single best argument for not reserving it for honors sections.

    An earlier study from the same research group found the mechanism. Across sixteen middle schools feeding nine high schools in eight Midwestern communities, more than 1,100 eighth and ninth graders were tested in fall and spring. Students whose teachers asked a higher proportion of authentic questions — questions the teacher did not already have an answer to — and who practiced uptake, building the next question out of what a student just said, scored significantly higher on literature achievement. Not more questions. Different questions.

    There is an equity finding buried in the first study that deserves more attention than it gets. Applebee and colleagues note that their interpretation is “complicated because instruction is unequally distributed across tracks.” Translated: the discussion-based teaching that helps low-achieving students the most was not what low-achieving students were mostly getting. If a school is going to act on this research at all, the action is not “add seminars” — it is checking which sections currently get them.

    Now the cautious one, and it is the reason this section exists. Murphy and colleagues ran a meta-analysis of classroom discussion approaches in the Journal of Educational Psychology. They found “strong increases in the amount of student talk and concomitant reductions in teacher talk, as well as substantial improvements in text comprehension.” Then they found this: “Few approaches to discussion were effective at increasing students’ literal or inferential comprehension and critical thinking and reasoning.”

    Read that twice. The talk goes up reliably. Comprehension of the text goes up. Whether students get better at thinking is not established by the pooled evidence, and the majority of the studies in that analysis were conducted in fourth through sixth grade, not with teenagers. If someone tells you seminars teach critical thinking, that is a hope, not a result.

    The same gap shows up in a study built specifically around Socratic dialogue. Mahoney and colleagues ran an eight-week Socratic dialogue series in Dutch vocational secondary education with 85 students and five teachers. Teachers found it deliverable but cognitively demanding, and all five asked for more facilitation training. The study’s own limitations section says there was “no measurement of actual critical thinking skill development.” A paper with “learning to think critically” in the title did not measure whether anyone did. The researchers said so themselves; it is a warning about how this format gets sold, not about them.

    One more, because the number gets quoted at teachers without its age attached. England’s Education Endowment Foundation ran a randomised controlled trial of Dialogic Teaching across 76 schools and roughly 5,000 pupils and found two additional months’ progress in English and science, with larger gains for pupils on free school meals. Those pupils were nine and ten years old. The practices probably transfer to a secondary room. The effect size does not automatically come with them.

    The defensible version: structured, text-anchored discussion with authentic questions is one of the better-evidenced things you can do with a secondary class, and the evidence for it is about comprehension and engagement rather than about producing better reasoners in eight weeks. If you want a structure where changing your mind is visible rather than merely permitted, philosophical chairs builds that move into the furniture: students cross the room the moment an argument persuades them.

    One implication for anyone above the classroom level: this is not a practice you mandate in August and audit in October. Every teacher in the Dutch study asked for more training in facilitation specifically, and facilitation is the whole skill. A department that runs four seminars and talks about them afterward will get further than a district that requires one per unit.

    What Do You Need Before the First Seminar?

    Three things: a text worth arguing about, a question with no answer, and students who have actually read it. Skip any one and the seminar fails in a predictable way.

    The text. Short beats long. One or two pages that every student can hold and mark up beats a chapter half of them skimmed. It needs genuine ambiguity — a primary source with a point of view, a court opinion, a poem, a paragraph from a science paper where the authors hedge. If the text has one obvious reading, there is nothing to discuss and students will know it within four minutes.

    Two constraints on that choice, both easy to miss when you are excited about a text. Every student has to be able to read it. A twelfth-grade primary source in a mixed ninth-grade class produces a conversation among the strongest readers while everyone else decodes. If the text is hard, read it aloud together or gloss the four words that will stop people — but do not let reading level decide who participates. And check the text against your own building’s ground. Ambiguity is the point; a text likely to pull a student into disclosing something personal in front of twenty-eight peers is a different situation, and it is worth a conversation with an administrator before it is worth a seminar.

    The opening question. Write it down before the seminar and test it against one standard: could a well-prepared student answer this in one sentence and be finished? If yes, it is a comprehension check, not a seminar question. “What does the author claim?” is a warm-up. “Is the author being honest about what they do not know?” is a seminar. If writing them is the part you get stuck on, there are forty subject-general seminar questions and a ten-minute way to write your own.

    The reading. This is what quietly kills most first attempts. The Paideia model puts multiple close readings in a pre-seminar phase before any discussion and writing in a post-seminar phase afterward. That three-part shape is the format, not an optional extra. Read the text once ten minutes before the circle forms and you get opinions instead of evidence — then conclude your class cannot handle seminars. Your class is fine. The prep was missing.

    A note on when they read it. The obvious move is to send the text home the night before, and I would push back on that — not on principle, but because it decides in advance that the students who read at home get to participate and the ones who do not, do not. Read it in class. Ten minutes of everyone reading the same page in the same room is not lost time; it is the thing that makes the next twenty minutes possible.

    One practical note about the room. The tables in my room are trapezoids pushed together in groups rather than desks in rows, which is closer to a discussion shape than a lecture hall — but it still is not a circle, and the furniture has to move. Build that into the clock. A seminar that starts with four minutes of scraping chairs starts four minutes late, every time, and you will feel it at the end.

    How Do You Actually Run One?

    Six moves, in order, and the hardest is the fifth. You can run this sequence in a single period and repeat it until it stops feeling like an event.

    Numbered list of six moves for running a Socratic seminar: read the text together in class, everyone writes one question, move the furniture into a circle, restate two norms by name, ask the question once then stop, and write afterward naming whose comment changed your position
    Six moves you can run in a single period. The fifth is the hard one.

    The sequence is deliberately boring in the middle. Step five is the interesting one, and the one I get wrong most often.

    In my own room I have landed on roughly a fifteen-count before I respond to something that is off track — and I mean roughly. It is an average, not a rule, because real classes change day to day and a number you enforce mechanically stops being judgment. A seminar asks for that same discipline in a different situation. You ask the opening question, nobody talks, and everything in you wants to rephrase it. Rephrasing is how you teach a room that if they wait long enough, you will do the work. Ask it once. Then sit there.

    The related move is refusing to evaluate. The instant you say “good point,” you have told twenty-eight teenagers that the goal is to produce points you approve of, and the conversation reorients toward you. Write the comment down instead. Nod. Look at somebody else. The Applebee study’s mechanism — authentic questions and uptake — only works if students believe you do not already have the answer, and praise is the fastest way to convince them you do.

    What Are the Rules, and Who Enforces Them?

    Keep the list short enough that students can hold it, and hand enforcement to them by the third seminar. Long norm lists get read aloud once and ignored. Five or six behaviors, posted, referred to by name, is enough.

    Six Socratic seminar norms: cite the page, disagree with the claim not the person, invite before you add, silence is allowed, ask rather than announce, and you may change your mind out loud
    Short enough that students can hold them, and short enough to enforce by name.

    The norms that matter protect the conversation from its two failure modes: nobody talking, and three people talking. Everything else is manners.

    There is one behavior worth planning for: the student who is performing for the room rather than talking to it. Do not handle that inside the circle. Naming it publicly makes it a bigger performance, and the seminar stops. Let it pass, keep the conversation moving to someone else, and take it up with the student afterward at normal volume. A seminar is a bad place to win an argument with a teenager.

    Worth saying clearly, because it is where teenagers get this wrong: disagreeing with an idea is the job. A seminar where everyone agrees has not happened yet. What is off-limits is going after the person instead of the claim, and the fix is a sentence frame, not a lecture — “I read that line differently, because…” does the whole job. The broader argument for why this works in a secondary room is the same one behind holding students to an adult standard of disagreement rather than a polite one.

    What About the Fishbowl Format?

    A fishbowl Socratic seminar puts one group in an inner circle discussing while an outer circle observes, then swaps them. It exists to solve two real problems: a class of thirty is too big for one conversation, and students who never get observed never get feedback on how they discuss.

    It works, with one condition. The outer circle needs a job. An outer ring with nothing to do is a ring of spectators with phones. Give each outer student one inner-circle partner to track, and one thing to record — how many times their partner cited the text, or the one question their partner asked that moved the conversation. Keep the record behavioral: what the partner did, not how well they did it. “You went back to the text three times” is feedback. “You seemed nervous” is not, and a fifteen-year-old should not be handed that by a classmate. Hand the note to the partner rather than reading it to the room. That feedback is usually more useful than anything I would have said, because it comes from a peer who was watching only them — but it belongs to the person it is about.

    Do not make it your first seminar of the year, though. Students end up learning two unfamiliar procedures at once and the period goes to logistics.

    How Do You Handle the Students Who Won’t Talk?

    Stop treating silence as a single problem, because it is at least three problems with different fixes. Some students have nothing prepared. Some have something prepared and cannot find an opening. Some are genuinely afraid of the sound of their own voice in a quiet room, and no amount of encouragement touches that.

    A study of quiet students by Medaille and Usinger is instructive here, with a caveat stated up front: the participants were ten undergraduates, not teenagers, so treat it as a description of an experience rather than a finding about your seventh period. Nine of the ten struggled with instructor expectations for verbal participation. Six reported physical reactions — trembling, blushing, stuttering — when speaking aloud. And one of them described the thing I now believe is the actual mechanism: “When I speak [in class] I plan out what I want to say.”

    That is not shyness. That is a student who needs a draft, and the fix is not calling on them warmly — it is giving the whole room ninety seconds to write before the circle opens, so the students who need a draft have one and nobody is singled out for needing it.

    Three more moves that cost nothing:

    • Give the quiet student a job that is not an opinion. Tracking which page the group keeps returning to, or reporting the one question nobody answered, is a real contribution that does not require volunteering a view.
    • Use written entry. A sticky note with one question on it, collected at the door and read aloud anonymously, gets a reticent student’s thinking into the room without their voice attached to it. Read them yourself before you read any of them out. Anonymous is not the same as safe — a question can identify the student who wrote it, or disclose something that should not be discussed in a circle, and the two seconds it takes to scan the stack is the whole safeguard.
    • Do not grade volume. More on that next, because it is the single change that most reliably changes who talks.

    I would not promise that a seminar fixes this. Some students will speak twice all year and write the best post-seminar reflection in the class. That is a real outcome, and the format should be built to catch it.

    Should You Grade a Socratic Seminar?

    Grade the preparation and the reflection. Do not grade how many times a student spoke. The moment participation counts, you have created an incentive to talk rather than to think, and the students who most need the practice are the ones the incentive punishes.

    Count what you can defend. Did they annotate the text? Did they bring a written question? Does the post-seminar writing show they changed or sharpened a position — and can they name whose comment did it? That last one is the best assessment item this format produces, because only a student who was listening can answer it. Three comments in a circle are easy to fake. “I came in thinking X, and the point about the second paragraph is why I do not think that anymore” is not.

    This is also the answer when a parent asks why their quiet child is not being penalized, or why their talkative one is not being rewarded: the grade is on the thinking you can see on paper, and it is the same standard for everyone in the room. If your school requires a participation grade, take it from the written pre- and post-work and say out loud, to the students, that the talking is not scored. There is a four-criterion rubric that scores it this way, free and printed on the page. Then hold to it. The first seminar after they believe you is a different conversation. This is the same logic behind treating ungraded checks as information rather than points — the second you attach a score, you stop learning what students actually think.

    Four Ways a Seminar Goes Wrong

    Every one of these is a design problem, not a student problem. If a seminar dies, the autopsy is almost always in the prep.

    1. The question had an answer. Students find the answer in six minutes and then sit there. Fix: write the question the night before and try to answer it yourself in one sentence. If you can, it is not the question.
    2. The teacher kept talking. You clarified, you rephrased, you summarized, and the conversation routed through you every time. Fix: count your own turns. More than four in a thirty-minute seminar and you are running a recitation with the chairs moved.
    3. Three students ran it. Not because they are hogging it — because they are the only ones who prepared. Fix: require a written question from everyone, collected as they come in. Make it an expectation, not a bar — a student who arrives without one writes it in the first two minutes while the furniture moves. Nobody gets locked out of the conversation for being unprepared; they get two minutes and then they are in it.
    4. It happened once. A seminar in October and a seminar in March are two events. Students never get past the awkwardness of the format itself. Fix: shorter and more often. Fifteen minutes on a half-page every other week will outperform two forty-minute showpieces.

    The fourth is the one I would push hardest. Frequency turns this from a special activity into the way the class talks, and the same logic runs through any structure that hands students the thinking: the first run is about the structure, and only the fourth or fifth is about the content.

    What to Do Next

    Pick a one-page text you already teach — something with a hedge or a contradiction in it — and write one question you cannot answer in a sentence. Give students ten minutes in class to read it, mark two places they disagree, and write one question. Move the furniture. Ask your question once, and then do not talk for as long as you can stand.

    Then do it again in two weeks. The first one will be rough, and that is not information about your students. Run four before you decide whether this works in your room.

    If you want the underlying argument for why handing teenagers this much of the conversation is worth the mess, it is the same one behind giving students real decisions rather than cosmetic ones. A seminar is just the version of that argument you can run on a Tuesday.

    Before you go: grab the free The Socratic Seminar Prep Sheet (PDF) — ElevateTheNorm.com branded, printable, no email required.

    Want the everyday version, without the protocol? Our guide to student discourse in grades 6–12 covers the five moves that get students answering each other, and the research finding that explains why a brilliant discussion between four students changes nothing.

    A seminar on a story runs aground fastest when nobody can say what the story is arguing. Theme is the claim under the discussion, and most students arrive with a one-word topic instead of a claim. How to teach theme so a discussion has something to stand on covers the definition, the difference between topic and theme, and how students test a proposed theme against the whole text rather than one scene.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is a Socratic seminar in simple terms?

    It is a structured discussion where students question a shared text and each other while the teacher mostly stays quiet. There is no assigned side, no winner, and no single correct answer to land on. The National Paideia Center calls it a collaborative intellectual dialogue facilitated with open-ended questions about a text. If the question has an answer, or if the teacher is doing most of the talking, it is a class discussion rather than a seminar.

    How long should a Socratic seminar last?

    Fifteen to thirty minutes of actual discussion is plenty for grades 6–12, and shorter is better when you are starting. A full class period sounds ambitious and usually produces twenty good minutes followed by fifteen of people repeating themselves. Frequency beats length. A fifteen-minute seminar every other week on a half-page text will build the skill faster than two long ones a year.

    What is the difference between a Socratic seminar and a debate?

    A debate assigns positions and produces a winner. A seminar assigns nothing and produces a better-understood question. That difference changes student behavior immediately: in a debate, changing your mind is losing, and in a seminar, changing your mind is the evidence that it worked. Tell students this explicitly before the first one, because teenagers default to debate unless you rule it out.

    Do Socratic seminars actually improve student learning?

    The evidence is genuinely mixed and worth knowing honestly. A study of 64 middle and high school English classrooms found discussion-based approaches significantly predicted spring literacy performance, including for low-achieving students. But a meta-analysis in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that while discussion produced strong increases in student talk and substantial gains in text comprehension, few approaches improved critical thinking and reasoning — and most of those studies were in grades 4 through 6. Discussion is well supported. The claim that it teaches thinking is not settled.

    How do you get quiet students to participate in a Socratic seminar?

    Give the whole class ninety seconds of writing time before the circle opens, so students who need to plan what they say have a draft and nobody is singled out for needing one. Beyond that, offer jobs that are not opinions — tracking which passage the group keeps returning to, or reporting the question nobody answered. And do not grade how often a student speaks. That single change does more than any amount of encouragement, because it removes the reason a struggling student is performing rather than thinking.

    Should I grade a Socratic seminar?

    Grade the preparation and the reflection, not the talking. Annotated text, a written question brought to the circle, and a post-seminar piece of writing are all defensible and all reward thinking. Counting comments rewards volume and penalizes the students who most need the practice. If a participation grade is required, pull it from the written work and tell students plainly that speaking is not scored.

    What makes a good Socratic seminar question?

    One you cannot answer in a sentence and cannot settle by looking something up. Test your question by trying to answer it yourself before the seminar; if you finish in one line, it is a comprehension check. Questions that work usually ask about a tension inside the text — whether the author is being honest about what they do not know, whether two of their claims can both be true, or what the text refuses to say.

    How many students should be in a Socratic seminar?

    Twelve to fifteen is the practical ceiling for one circle. Above that, the students at the edges stop being participants. That is what the fishbowl format is for: put half the class in an inner circle discussing and half in an outer circle observing a specific partner, then swap. Do not run a fishbowl as your first seminar though — students end up learning two unfamiliar procedures at once and the period goes to logistics.

    Sources

    1. Applebee, Arthur N., Judith A. Langer, Martin Nystrand, and Adam Gamoran. “Discussion-Based Approaches to Developing Understanding: Classroom Instruction and Student Performance in Middle and High School English.” American Educational Research Journal, vol. 40, no. 3, 2003, pp. 685–730. 64 middle and high school English classrooms, grades 7, 8, 10, 11 and 12; discussion-based approaches significantly related to spring performance controlling for fall performance, and effective for low-achieving as well as high-achieving students. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ782328
    2. Murphy, P. Karen, Ian A. G. Wilkinson, Anna O. Soter, Maeghan N. Hennessey, and John F. Alexander. “Examining the Effects of Classroom Discussion on Students’ Comprehension of Text: A Meta-Analysis.” Journal of Educational Psychology, vol. 101, no. 3, Aug. 2009, pp. 740–764. Strong increases in student talk and substantial improvements in text comprehension; “few approaches to discussion were effective at increasing students’ literal or inferential comprehension and critical thinking and reasoning.” Majority of included studies were conducted in grades 4–6. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ861185
    3. Nystrand, Martin, and Adam Gamoran. Student Engagement: When Recitation Becomes Conversation. National Center on Effective Secondary Schools, 1990. ERIC ED323581. Eighth- and ninth-grade English classes in sixteen middle schools feeding nine high schools across eight Midwestern communities; over 1,100 students tested fall and spring, 1987–88 and 1988–89. Higher proportions of authentic questions and uptake predicted significantly higher literature achievement. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED323581.pdf
    4. Jay, Tim, et al. Dialogic Teaching: Evaluation Report and Executive Summary. Education Endowment Foundation, July 2017. ERIC ED581114. Three-level clustered randomised controlled trial, 38 intervention schools (2,492 pupils) and 38 control schools (2,466 pupils); +2 months English, +2 months science, +1 month maths; three-padlock security rating. Pupils were in Year 5, aged nine and ten — this is not a secondary-school result. Evaluators note 21% of pupils excluded from analysis. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED581114.pdf
    5. Mahoney, Bethany, Ron Oostdam, Hessel Nieuwelink, and Jaap Schuitema. “Learning to Think Critically Through Socratic Dialogue: Evaluating a Series of Lessons Designed for Secondary Vocational Education.” Thinking Skills and Creativity, vol. 50, 2023, article 101422. 85 students and 5 teachers, Netherlands, eight weekly lessons; teachers found the format deliverable but demanding and all five requested more facilitation training. The study states as a limitation that there was no measurement of actual critical thinking skill development. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1871187123001906
    6. Medaille, Ann, and Janet Usinger. “Quiet Students’ Experiences with the Physical, Pedagogical, and Psychosocial Aspects of the Classroom Environment.” Educational Research: Theory and Practice, vol. 31, no. 2, 2020, pp. 41–55. Qualitative study of ten upper-division undergraduates — not secondary students; nine of ten struggled with verbal participation expectations and six reported physical symptoms when speaking aloud. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1274336.pdf
    7. National Paideia Center. “Paideia Seminar.” Definition of the seminar as a collaborative intellectual dialogue facilitated with open-ended questions about a text, and the pre-seminar / seminar / post-seminar cycle. https://paideia.org/blogs/npc/paideia-socratic-seminar

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Formative Assessment Strategies for Writing: Checks That Fit a Real Week

    Formative Assessment Strategies for Writing: Checks That Fit a Real Week

    By Clay Shumate

    Formative assessment strategies for writing are the checks a teacher runs while a piece is still being written, so the information can still change the draft. Exit tickets and comprehension checks do not transfer here. Writing has its own set, because the thing being assessed takes days, gets revised, and is too long to read thirty times a week. The equivalents for reading work on a different clock and are collected separately.

    That last constraint is the real problem. Almost every writing-feedback system that gets abandoned was abandoned because it required reading every draft. What follows is what the research supports, the number that should worry you, and a set of checks that fit an ordinary secondary schedule.

    Key Takeaways

    • Feedback works, and the size depends on who gives it. A meta-analysis found adult feedback at an effect size of 0.87, self-evaluation at 0.62 and peer feedback at 0.58 — but that study covered grades 1–8.
    • Two popular practices showed no meaningful effect in the same analysis. Teacher progress monitoring and the 6+1 Trait Writing model did not improve writing quality.
    • The federal practice guide rates the assessment recommendation as its weakest. Of three recommendations for teaching secondary writing, “use assessments to inform instruction and feedback” carries minimal evidence. That is worth knowing before anyone sells you a system.
    • Assess one thing at a time. A draft marked for everything gets revised for nothing. Pick the criterion the lesson taught and check only that.
    • Never put a grade on a draft you want revised. Self-assessment that counts toward a mark stops being honest, and the same logic applies to a draft.

    Free Download · PDF

    Formative Assessment Quick-Use Pack

    A strategy decision matrix, an evidence tracker, four exit-ticket formats, and a next-day response planner — four pages built around changing the next instructional move.

    Download the free PDF

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Browse every printable in Your Free Library.

    What Makes a Writing Check Formative?

    Timing and use. A check is formative if it happens while the piece can still change and if somebody acts on it. Both conditions. A rubric applied to a final draft, however detailed, is a grade with extra steps.

    That rules out more of the standard toolkit than teachers expect. Marking a finished essay is summative no matter how much you write in the margin. A reading quiz is not a writing check. A participation grade for peer editing measures compliance with a procedure, not the quality of anything. The general versions of these checks are covered in the general version, twenty techniques sorted by lesson phase; this page is about the ones built for a text that takes a week.

    What is distinctive about writing is that the product has stages. A thesis exists before the paragraph does, an outline before the draft, a draft before the revision. Each stage is a place to check something cheaply, while it is still cheap to fix. The whole art is checking the earliest stage at which the problem is visible — because a thesis fixed on Monday saves five paragraphs that never had to be written.

    What Does the Research Actually Show?

    That feedback on writing works, that two popular practices do not, and that the evidence for the whole assessment-driven approach is weaker than its popularity suggests. All three are worth having straight.

    The central study is Graham, Hebert and Harris’s 2015 meta-analysis in the Elementary School Journal, which pooled experimental studies of formative writing assessment and reported effect sizes by who does the assessing:

    PracticeEffect on writing quality
    Adult feedback0.87
    Students evaluating their own writing0.62
    Peer feedback0.58
    Computer feedback0.38
    Teachers monitoring student progressno meaningful improvement
    The 6+1 Trait Writing modelno meaningful improvement

    Three things to notice. First, the grade band is 1 through 8. Only the top three grades of that range are secondary, and none of it is high school. The practices are reasonable to carry upward; the numbers do not travel with them.

    Second, the two null results are the most useful rows in the table. Progress monitoring — tracking writing scores over time to inform instruction — showed no meaningful improvement, and neither did 6+1 Trait, which is a widely adopted framework. That does not make either worthless, but it does mean a department should not treat adopting them as having addressed writing feedback.

    Third, student self-evaluation at 0.62 nearly matched adult feedback and beat peer feedback. For a teacher with 120 students, that is the most consequential number in the table, because it is the only one that does not scale with your reading time.

    Now the part most articles omit. The What Works Clearinghouse practice guide on teaching secondary students to write effectively, written by a panel including Steve Graham, Jill Fitzgerald, Linda Friedrich, Katie Greene, James Kim and Carol Booth Olson, makes three recommendations and rates the evidence behind each. Explicitly teaching writing strategies through a model–practice–reflect cycle is rated strong. Integrating writing and reading using exemplar texts is rated moderate. Using assessments to inform instruction and feedback is rated minimal.

    Minimal is the lowest rating in that system, and it is attached to the recommendation this article is about. Read it as a statement about proportion rather than a reason to stop. If you have a fixed amount of energy for improving writing in your classroom, the guide says to spend it first on explicitly teaching strategies and modeling them — and the assessment practices below are what you run inside that, not instead of it.

    Table of effect sizes on writing quality from a formative assessment meta-analysis: adult feedback 0.87, student self-evaluation 0.62, peer feedback 0.58, computer feedback 0.38, and no meaningful effect for teacher progress monitoring or the 6+1 Trait Writing model
    Graham, Hebert and Harris (2015), grades 1-8. The two null rows are the most useful in the table.

    Which Checks Fit a Secondary Schedule?

    The ones that read a sentence rather than a draft. Every strategy below is designed around the fact that you cannot read 120 full drafts and still have a weekend.

    • The thesis-only check. Collect one sentence. Read all of them in ten minutes, sort into three piles — arguable, too broad, not a claim — and hand them back with the pile name. Fixing this on day one prevents most of what you would otherwise write in margins on day six.
    • The one-criterion read. Announce that today’s read is only about evidence, or only about topic sentences. Mark only that. A draft marked for everything gets revised for nothing, because a student facing thirty marks does not know where to start and usually starts with the commas.
    • The highlight-and-justify. Students highlight the sentence in their own draft that meets a specific criterion, and write one line explaining why. If they cannot find it, that is the check — and they have found it themselves, which is the part that matters.
    • The first-paragraph conference. Two minutes per student, on the opening paragraph only, while the rest write. Twelve students a period, everybody covered across a week.
    • The anonymous exemplar. Put two short pieces of writing on the board with names removed — one that does the thing, one that nearly does it — and have the class say which and why. This is the model–practice–reflect cycle the WWC rates as strong evidence, run as a five-minute check. Ask before you use a student’s work, even anonymized, because the writer always recognizes their own sentences and so do the people sitting next to them. Asking takes ten seconds, almost nobody says no, and the ones who do have a reason. Writing your own two versions, or using last year’s with permission, works just as well.
    • The revision log. One line per revision: what changed, and why. It takes a student thirty seconds and tells you whether feedback was used, which is the only question a progress tracker was ever trying to answer.

    Notice what is missing: reading every draft, writing extended comments, and any system requiring a spreadsheet. Those are the things that get abandoned in October, and abandonment is the real failure mode — not choosing the second-best check. If you would rather start from something printed, the free formative assessment quick-use pack has a general version to adapt.

    Graphic listing six formative writing checks: the thesis-only check, the one-criterion read, the highlight-and-justify, the first-paragraph conference, the anonymous exemplar, and the revision log
    Every one of these reads a sentence rather than a draft. That is what makes them survive past October.

    How Do You Make Self-Evaluation Work?

    Give the criteria first, keep it out of the gradebook, and ask for evidence rather than a rating. At 0.62 this is the best return per minute of teacher time in the whole table, and all three conditions matter.

    Heidi Andrade’s 2019 critical review in Frontiers in Education supplies the design rules. Criterion-referenced self-assessment showed main effects on every criterion assessed, and concrete task-specific criteria outperformed vague competence-based ones — a result she attributes to Fastré and colleagues. In writing terms, “every claim is followed by a quotation and an explanation of it” is checkable. “Uses evidence effectively” is not.

    The decisive rule is about grading. Andrade cites Tejeiro and colleagues, where self-assessment counted toward the final grade: overestimation rose dramatically and no correlation remained between the instructor’s assessment and the student’s. Run formatively, agreement improved substantially, and all twenty studies in her review that used self-assessment formatively showed a positive association with learning.

    Andrade makes one more point worth carrying. There is little evidence that inaccurate self-assessment produces worse learning, and students act on their predictions regardless of accuracy. You are not trying to make a student’s judgment match yours. You are trying to make them read their own draft as a reader. The broader version of the practice is in the student self assessment guide; writing only changes what sits in the criteria.

    Is Peer Feedback Worth the Class Time?

    Yes at 0.58, and only if you narrow what you ask for. Unstructured peer review produces “I liked it, maybe add more detail,” which is the outcome most teachers have seen and correctly concluded is a waste of twenty minutes.

    There is a useful finding from an adjacent literature. Falchikov and Goldfinch’s meta-analysis of 48 higher-education studies comparing peer marks with teacher marks found that agreement was closest when students made a global judgment against well-understood criteria, and worse when asked to break the judgment into many separate dimensions and score each. Those were undergraduates marking work, not teenagers giving revision advice, so treat it as a design hint rather than a transferred result — but the hint points somewhere useful: the twelve-box peer editing checklist is probably the worst available format.

    What works better is narrower and more concrete:

    • Ask for a location, not a judgment. “Underline the sentence where the argument actually starts.” A reader can do that honestly; “rate the organization” they cannot.
    • Ask what the reader could not follow. This is the one thing a peer knows that you do not, because they read it without already knowing what the writer meant.
    • Ask for one question, not one suggestion. Suggestions are advice from a novice. A genuine question — “is this the same person as in paragraph two?” — is information the writer can act on without deferring to anyone.

    Two cautions. Peer feedback has a social cost that teacher feedback does not. A fifteen-year-old asked to critique a classmate’s writing is managing a relationship as well as a text, and most will resolve that tension by being vague. Asking for locations and questions rather than evaluations removes the tension rather than asking students to override it. And decide who reads what before you start. Writing is personal in a way a math worksheet is not; a student writing about something that matters to them should know in advance whether a classmate will see it, and should have a way out.

    A One-Week Routine That Does Not Require Reading Every Draft

    Four checks across a week, none of which takes you more than fifteen minutes.

    1. Day one — collect the thesis only. One sentence per student. Sort into three piles, hand back with the pile name, and give the “not a claim” pile five minutes to try again.
    2. Day two — the anonymous exemplar. Two openings on the board, names off, one working and one nearly working. The class names the difference. This is the modeling step, and it is the one with the strongest evidence behind it.
    3. Day three — highlight and justify. Students find the sentence in their own draft that meets today’s single criterion and write one line saying why. Walk the room and read over shoulders; collect nothing.
    4. Day four — peer question round. Swap drafts. Each reader underlines where the argument starts and writes one genuine question. Ten minutes, no checklist.

    Then the revision log on day five: one line per change, what and why. That log is the whole assessment record, and unlike a score tracker it answers the question that actually matters, which is whether any of this changed the draft.

    Two adjustments. First, differentiate the container rather than the criterion — a student who cannot produce the written justification quickly can say it to you in the last minute of class, and a student working in a second language can highlight and point. The judgment against criteria is what has to survive. Second, if a student’s draft has a problem that is not today’s criterion, note it for yourself and leave it. You will get to organization on the week you are checking organization, and a student who receives one correctable thing at a time actually corrects it. For the general version of this discipline, see what actually counts as evidence that a class understood something.

    Four Ways Writing Feedback Fails

    All four are common, and all four are about the system rather than the student.

    Everything gets marked. A draft returned with thirty corrections communicates that the piece is bad, not what to do next. Students respond by fixing the easiest marks, which are almost always the mechanical ones. One criterion per read is not a compromise — it is what makes revision possible.

    A grade goes on the draft. Once a number is attached, the piece is finished in the student’s mind, and the comments underneath it become an explanation of the number rather than instructions for a revision. If you need the draft in the gradebook, grade completion rather than quality, and say which you are doing.

    The one-criterion rule is also the thing families most often ask about, usually in the form of why the teacher did not correct all the errors. It deserves a straight answer rather than a defensive one: every error was noticed, and marking all of them is what produces a draft a student fixes the commas in and hands back otherwise unchanged. The errors get their turn, one at a time, on the assignment where that is the thing being taught. Said in advance, in a sentence on the assignment sheet, that lands as a deliberate method. Said after a parent email, it sounds like an excuse.

    There is no time to act on it. Feedback returned the day the final is due is a post-mortem. If the schedule does not contain a revision block after the feedback, the feedback is decorative, and it is more honest to admit that than to keep writing comments into a void.

    Graphic listing four ways writing feedback fails: everything gets marked, a grade goes on the draft, there is no time to act on it, and a framework is adopted and called done
    All four are about the system rather than the student.

    The department adopts a framework and calls it done. This is where the two null results earn their keep. Adopting 6+1 Trait or installing a progress-monitoring spreadsheet is a visible action that showed no meaningful effect on writing quality in the meta-analysis. The things that did work — someone reads a piece of writing and responds to it, or a student reads their own against criteria — are less visible on a plan, and are the ones worth protecting time for.

    What to Try on the Next Assignment

    Take the next piece of writing you have already assigned. Collect the thesis on its own, before anything else exists, and sort the sentences into three piles. That single move costs you ten minutes and changes more drafts than any set of margin comments you will write later.

    Then pick one criterion for the whole assignment and check only that — in the exemplar, in the self-evaluation, in the peer round, in your own read. Put a revision block on the calendar before you give any feedback, and keep a number off the draft.

    None of this is a system, and that is deliberate. The evidence for assessment-driven writing instruction is rated minimal by the people best placed to judge it, while explicit strategy instruction and modeling are rated strong. The checks here are worth running because they are cheap and they surface problems early. They are not a substitute for teaching students how to write, and any resource presenting them as one has the proportions backwards.

    Before you go: grab the free Formative Assessment Quick-Use Pack (PDF) — ElevateTheNorm.com branded, printable, no email required.

    A writing check you run in one period and a writing measure you can plot across ten weeks are not the same instrument. State guidance for high-school monitoring suggests five-minute writing samples scored by correct minus incorrect word sequences, which is a deliberately narrow number that can sit next to twelve other numbers. How that kind of repeated measure works, and where it runs out at secondary level covers the frequency standards, the reliability problem with the measures that fit a full class, and why the graph tells you when to change something without telling you what.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Do these effect sizes apply to high school students?

    Not directly, and it matters. The meta-analysis behind the headline numbers — adult feedback 0.87, self-evaluation 0.62, peer feedback 0.58 — covered grades 1 through 8, so only its top three grades are secondary at all and none is high school. The practices are reasonable to carry upward because the mechanisms are not age-specific, but the numbers should not be quoted as a high school result. The federal practice guide that does cover secondary writing rates the assessment recommendation as having minimal evidence.

    Should I put a grade on a draft?

    Not if you want it revised. Once a number is attached, most students treat the piece as finished and read the comments as justification for the mark rather than instructions for a revision. The self-assessment research points the same way: when self-evaluation counted toward a grade, overestimation rose sharply and agreement with the instructor disappeared. If a draft has to appear in the gradebook, grade completion rather than quality and tell students that is what you are doing.

    Is 6+1 Trait Writing a waste of time?

    That is stronger than the evidence supports. What the meta-analysis found is that 6+1 Trait showed no meaningful improvement in writing quality, and the same was true of teachers monitoring student progress over time. That is a real finding and a department should not treat adopting the framework as having addressed writing feedback. It is not a finding that a shared vocabulary for talking about writing is harmful — it is a finding that the vocabulary alone does not move the writing.

    How do I give feedback to 120 students without losing every weekend?

    Stop reading whole drafts. Collect one sentence rather than one essay; mark one criterion rather than everything; run two-minute conferences on opening paragraphs while the rest write; and lean on self-evaluation, which came in at 0.62 and is the only practice in the table that does not scale with your reading time. A teacher who reads every draft thoroughly in September and nothing at all by November has given less useful feedback than one who reads one paragraph from everybody every week.

    Does peer feedback actually help, or is it busywork?

    It helped at an effect size of 0.58, which is real — but what most classrooms run is not what was studied. Unstructured peer review produces “I liked it, add more detail.” Narrow the ask instead: have readers underline where the argument starts, say what they could not follow, and write one genuine question rather than one suggestion. Those ask for information a peer actually has. Also settle who reads what before you begin, because writing is more personal than a worksheet and a student should know in advance.

    What if a student’s draft has problems that are not this week’s criterion?

    Note them for yourself and leave them alone. A student who receives one correctable thing at a time usually corrects it; a student who receives thirty fixes the commas. Keep your own running list and let it decide what the criterion is for the next assignment — that list is more useful as a planning document than as margin notes, and it means the pattern across the class shapes what you teach next rather than disappearing into thirty separate drafts.

    How is this different from just marking essays carefully?

    Timing and use. Marking a finished essay is summative however detailed it is, because nothing about that piece can change afterwards. A formative check happens while the writing is still in progress and is followed by time to act on it. The practical test is simple: if there is no revision block on the calendar after the feedback goes back, what you did was grading, and calling it formative assessment does not make it function like one.

    Where should I spend my energy if I can only change one thing?

    Not here, according to the people who reviewed the evidence. The What Works Clearinghouse panel rates explicitly teaching writing strategies through a model–practice–reflect cycle as strong evidence, integrating reading and writing with exemplar texts as moderate, and using assessments to inform instruction and feedback as minimal. If you have one change in you this year, make it the modeling. The checks on this page are cheap enough to run inside that work, and they are not a replacement for it.

    Sources

    1. Graham, Steve, Michael Hebert, and Karen R. Harris. “Formative Assessment and Writing: A Meta-Analysis.” Elementary School Journal, vol. 115, no. 4, 2015, pp. 523–547. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1068976
    2. Graham, Steve, Jill Fitzgerald, Linda D. Friedrich, Katie Greene, James S. Kim, and Carol Booth Olson. “Teaching Secondary Students to Write Effectively” (practice guide summary). What Works Clearinghouse, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/Docs/PracticeGuide/wwc_secwrit_summary_053117.pdf
    3. Andrade, Heidi L. “A Critical Review of Research on Student Self-Assessment.” Frontiers in Education, vol. 4, art. 87, 2019. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2019.00087/full (The Tejeiro et al. 2012 and Fastré et al. 2010 findings are reported in this review; the primary papers were not read directly.)
    4. Falchikov, Nancy, and Judy Goldfinch. “Student Peer Assessment in Higher Education: A Meta-Analysis Comparing Peer and Teacher Marks.” Review of Educational Research, vol. 70, no. 3, 2000, pp. 287–322. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ630369

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.