The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Author: Clay Shumate

  • Email to Parents About Student Behavior: What to Write and What to Leave Out

    Email to Parents About Student Behavior: What to Write and What to Leave Out

    By Clay Shumate

    An email to parents about student behavior should name one specific behavior, say when it happened, state what you have already tried, ask one question, and propose a next step. Keep it under 200 words, leave every other student’s name out of it, and send it before the pattern hardens.

    Key Takeaways

    • In a randomized field experiment, weekly teacher-to-parent messages raised the share of high school students earning credit by 6.5 percentage points — what the authors describe as a 41 percent reduction in students failing to earn credit — at an estimated cost of about $13 per student-course.
    • Messages about what a student needed to improve outperformed positive-only messages, 8.8 percentage points against 4.5. The authors say they lacked the statistical power to call that difference significant, so treat it as a lean, not a law.
    • About 84 percent of improvement messages in that study were actionable. About 8.5 percent of positive messages were. That gap is the most useful finding in the research for a teacher writing an email tonight.
    • FERPA generally prohibits nonconsensual disclosure of information derived from education records, which is the clearest reason never to name another student in a behavior email. What you personally witnessed is treated differently from what a record says.
    • The same research reports a cost: students in the treated groups rated their own effort lower, and teachers rated their relationships with those students lower. Contact works. It is not free.

    Most behavior emails fail in the first two sentences. They open with a paragraph of throat-clearing, bury the actual incident in the middle, end with “please speak with your child at home,” and arrive after the fourth occurrence instead of the first.

    The fix is not warmer language. It is a shorter email with a specific ask in it. Below is the structure, three samples you can copy and adapt for free, the list of things that should never appear in one, and the honest research on whether any of it works — including the part that says it costs you something with the student.

    What should an email to parents about student behavior actually say?

    Five things, in this order: the specific behavior, when it happened, what you already tried, one question for the parent, and one next step. Everything else is padding. A parent reading on a phone between shifts needs the behavior and the ask in the first three lines.

    1. Name one behavior, not a character. “Marcus has not turned in the last three assignments” is a behavior. “Marcus has a bad attitude” is a verdict, and it is the sentence that makes a parent defensive before they reach the second line.
    2. Say when. Dates or class periods. A parent who can anchor the behavior in time can ask their kid about it; a parent who gets “lately” cannot.
    3. Say what you already did. Moved his seat, talked to him after class, gave an extra day. This is the sentence that tells a parent you are not outsourcing the problem, and it is the one teachers skip most often.
    4. Ask one real question. Not “please address this at home.” Something you actually want the answer to: is anything going on I should know about, does this happen in other classes, what works at home when he shuts down.
    5. Propose one next step with a date on it. “I’ll check in with him Thursday and email you Friday either way.” A next step with a date is the difference between a complaint and a plan.

    Under 200 words. If it runs longer than that, the thing you actually need is a phone call or a meeting, and the email should be two lines asking to schedule one.

    Numbered graphic of the five parts of an email to parents about student behavior: name one behavior, say when, say what you tried, ask one question, propose a next step with a date.
    Five parts. Everything else is padding.

    Tell the student before you send it

    This is the step that gets skipped and it is the one that matters most for grades 6–12. A 15-year-old who finds out at dinner that you emailed home has learned that you go around them. A 15-year-old you told at the end of class — “I’m emailing your mom tonight about the missing work, here’s what I’m going to say” — has been treated like somebody with standing in their own life.

    It costs about twenty seconds and it changes what the email is. It also tends to improve the email, because saying the sentence out loud to the person it is about is a good test of whether it is fair.

    Two practical notes on load and access. You cannot do this for 120 students, so triage: contact home for the students where an early, small email prevents a large problem later, and accept that the rest gets handled in the room. And check how the family actually receives information before assuming email is it — some households do not read email, some need the message in a language other than English, and most districts have a translation route or a phone option through the student information system. An email nobody opens is not communication, it is documentation.

    Does emailing parents about behavior actually change anything?

    Yes, measurably, and by more than most teachers expect. The best evidence comes from a randomized field experiment in a five-week summer credit recovery program, where teachers wrote brief weekly messages home about high school students.

    Kraft and Rogers randomized 435 consenting students into three groups — positive messages, improvement messages, or no messages — and sent parents four weekly messages. The pooled treatment raised the share of students earning credit by 6.5 percentage points against a control pass rate of 84.2 percent, which the authors describe as a 41 percent reduction in students failing to earn credit.

    Almost all of that came from students not dropping out rather than from students passing who would have failed. Treatment cut the dropout rate by 6.1 percentage points. Absence fell from 12 percent to 9.5 percent. The estimated cost was about $13 per treated student-course, which the authors put at under a tenth of the district’s usual cost per credit.

    Now the caveats, because this is the kind of result that gets quoted without them. The setting was summer credit recovery, where the students are already in trouble and the stakes are visible — that is a long way from a regular October Tuesday. Only 435 of 1,417 enrolled students consented, so the sample is not the whole program. And the study found two costs worth knowing about: students in the treated groups rated their own effort and engagement lower than control students did, and teachers rated their relationships with treated students lower.

    That last part is not a reason to stop emailing. It is a reason to be deliberate about which students get contacted and how often, because the contact is doing something to the relationship as well as to the credit.

    One caveat that applies to both of the randomized studies cited in this article: they ran in summer programs, four and five weeks long, with teachers who had been asked to write home as a condition of the research. Neither tested what happens when a teacher with a full roster does this across a nine-month year. The direction of the evidence is encouraging and the dose is not the one you will be working at.

    Should the email be positive or focused on what needs to improve?

    Improvement-focused, if you have to pick one. In the same experiment the improvement arm gained 8.8 percentage points on credit earned while the positive arm gained 4.5, though the authors are explicit that they could not statistically separate the two estimates.

    The mechanism is clearer than the headline number, and it is the part worth acting on.

    Five rows comparing positive and improvement-focused messages home, including an 8.8 versus 4.5 percentage point gain in credit earned and 84 percent versus 8.5 percent actionable content.
    The actionable-content gap is the finding worth acting on.
     Positive messagesImprovement messages
    What the message saidWhat the student was doing wellWhat the student needed to work on
    Gain in credit earned+4.5 points (p = .236)+8.8 points (p = .016)
    Share of messages that were actionableAbout 8.5 percentAbout 84 percent
    Effect on absenceSmaller−3.2 percentage points
    Parent–child conversations about improvingNo measured differenceMore frequent (odds ratio 1.63)

    Look at the actionable row. Eight and a half percent against eighty-four. That is the real finding. A positive message usually has nothing in it a parent can do anything with — “she had a great week” is pleasant and inert. An improvement message almost always contains a thing: a missing assignment, a study habit, a deadline.

    Which means the useful rewrite of a positive email is not to make it negative. It is to make it actionable. “She had a great week” becomes “she rewrote her thesis after the first round of feedback, and if she does that on the next two drafts she is in good shape for the unit grade.” Same tone, now a parent has something to reinforce.

    Worth adding one piece of contrary context before anyone concludes that more parent contact is always better. A 2014 meta-synthesis of nine meta-analyses summarizing Hill and Tyson’s middle school work reports that academic socialization had the most significant impact on achievement, while homework assistance did not — and in some instances was negatively correlated with achievement. Not all parent involvement is the same thing, and asking a parent to sit on their fourteen-year-old through homework is the kind that research supports least.

    What should never go in an email about student behavior?

    Another student’s name is the first one, and it is the one with legal weight behind it. The U.S. Department of Education states that FERPA generally prohibits the nonconsensual disclosure of information derived from education records, and a behavior email that names who else was involved can put you on the wrong side of that line.

    The Department also notes that FERPA does not prohibit a school official from releasing information about a student that came from the official’s personal knowledge rather than from education records. That distinction is narrower than it sounds and it varies by district policy, so the practical rule stands: describe what the student you are writing about did, and refer to everyone else as “another student.”

    • Other students’ names, initials, or descriptions that identify them. “The boy who sits behind him” identifies a child to any parent who has seen the seating chart.
    • Anything that reads as a diagnosis. You can describe behavior. You cannot suggest a cause that belongs to a clinician, and an email is a written record that will outlive your memory of writing it.
    • A consequence you have not confirmed with an administrator. Never promise or threaten a referral, a suspension, or a removal from an activity that is not yours to give.
    • Sarcasm, or anything written while you are still angry. Tone does not survive email. Write it, save it, send it in the morning.
    • A list of every incident this semester. A wall of grievances reads as a case being built against a child. One behavior, one email.
    • “Please address this at home.” It hands the problem to someone who was not in the room and gives them nothing to work with.

    One more that is procedural rather than legal: send it from your school account, not a personal one, log the contact wherever your school logs it, and assume every word could be forwarded to your principal, because sometimes it is. That is not a reason to be bland. It is a reason to be accurate.

    Six rows listing what never belongs in a behavior email, from another student’s name and FERPA through sarcasm and the phrase please address this at home.
    Six things that should never appear in a behavior email.

    And the necessary disclaimer, because this section touches law: none of the above is legal advice. FERPA interpretation is fact-specific, districts layer their own policy on top of it, and some states add student-privacy statutes of their own. If a situation is serious enough that you are weighing what you are allowed to write, that is the moment to ask an administrator rather than an article.

    Sample emails to parents about student behavior

    Three templates, free to copy and adapt. Each follows the five-part structure above and each stays under 200 words. Replace the bracketed parts and delete anything that is not true of your situation.

    1. First contact, low-level pattern

    Subject: Quick note about [student] in [course]

    Hi [name] — nothing serious, but I wanted you to hear this from me early rather than at report cards.

    Over the past two weeks [student] has been talking during independent work often enough that he is not finishing it in class. It happened Monday, Wednesday and today. I moved his seat last Thursday and talked with him after class on Friday, and both helped for about a day.

    Is there anything going on I should know about? And is this showing up in his other classes, or just mine?

    Here is what I will do: I will check in with him Thursday about the independent work specifically, and I will email you Friday either way — good news or not.

    Thanks, [your name]

    2. A pattern that has not responded to what you tried

    Subject: [student] — asking for your help with a plan

    Hi [name] — I emailed two weeks ago about [student] leaving the room during class without asking. It has happened four more times since, most recently today.

    What I have tried: a private conversation, a signal we agreed on so she could step out without asking, and a check-in at the start of class. The signal worked for about a week.

    I would rather build something with you than keep writing these. What works at home when she needs a break?

    Can we talk for ten minutes this week? I am free [two specific times]. If neither works, send me a time and I will make it work.

    Thanks, [your name]

    3. A single serious incident already reported to an administrator

    Subject: [student] — incident in [course] today, [date]

    Hi [name] — I am writing so you hear this from me today rather than secondhand.

    During fourth period, [student] and another student had a verbal argument that I had to stop. Nobody was hurt. I have reported it to [administrator], who will contact you about anything that follows on the school’s side, and I am not the person who decides consequences.

    What I want you to know from me is that [student] is welcome back in my room tomorrow and I am not holding this over him. We will deal with the work he missed.

    If you want to talk about what I saw, I am available [time].

    Thanks, [your name]

    Notice what the third one does not contain: the other student’s name, a description of what the other student did, or any statement about what will happen to anyone. That is deliberate, and it is the template most likely to get a teacher in trouble if it is written in the ten minutes after the incident.

    Before sending anything like template 3, check whether your school wants to make first contact. Many do, particularly when an incident involves more than one student or may lead to a consequence, and a teacher email that lands before the administrator’s call can cut across a process and put the family’s first impression in the wrong hands. Ask, then send — or ask the administrator to tell you when they are done.

    Is a phone call better than an email?

    A call is better for anything complicated and worse for anything you need a record of. Calls also frequently fail to connect. In one randomized study of daily home contact, only 54.9 percent of prescribed calls actually reached a parent or guardian.

    That study — Kraft and Dougherty’s four-week experiment with 140 incoming 6th and 9th graders — combined daily calls with daily texts or written notes. Its one result significant at the conventional threshold was class participation, up 15 percent (p = .03). Homework completion rose about 40 percent in odds and redirections fell about 25 percent, but both of those sat at p < .10, which the authors themselves label suggestive rather than established.

    It also found something that cuts against the “call home more” advice: broken out by grade, the participation effect was strongly positive for 6th graders and slightly negative for 9th graders. The authors flag that subgroup result as underpowered and exploratory, so it is not a finding so much as a caution. Still, a 14-year-old and an 11-year-old do not experience a call home the same way, and the research is not reassuring that what works for one works for the other.

    The honest answer for a secondary teacher with 120 students: email for the record and the routine contact, call when the email has not worked twice or when the subject is serious enough that tone matters more than documentation. If you want a system rather than a reflex, the one-page communication plan is built for exactly this load, and what actually works in grades 6–12 covers the wider ground.

    Clay’s take: send it earlier and make it smaller

    The failure mode I see most often is not a badly written email. It is a correctly written email sent three weeks late, after the behavior has become the student’s reputation in your head and your frustration is doing the typing.

    An email after the second incident is a small, boring, fixable thing. The same email after the tenth is a confrontation, and the parent can hear in it that you have already decided who their kid is. Teenagers can hear it too, because parents forward these.

    The other thing I would push back on is the staffroom belief that positive emails are the kind that build relationships and improvement emails are the kind that damage them. The research does not support that cleanly, and the actionable-message gap suggests the opposite: a parent who gets a specific, useful note about something their kid can fix has been treated as a partner. A parent who gets “great week!” has been managed.

    And one line I would keep in every behavior email, somewhere near the end: that the student is welcome back tomorrow. Grades 6–12 students carry these conversations into the next class period. Saying plainly that the room is not closed to them costs nothing and changes what they walk in expecting.

    What to do next

    Pick the one student whose behavior has been bothering you longest and write the first template tonight. Keep it under 200 words, make sure there is one real question and one dated next step in it, and reread it once for any name that is not the student’s.

    Then decide what you want the rest of the year to look like, because a reflex is not a system. If the behavior is a repeating pattern rather than an incident, a behavior contract written with the student is the next step up from an email. If the question underneath is what happens after the email, consequences that teach instead of humiliate is the piece to read. And if the next contact is a conference rather than a message, these are the questions worth asking in it. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How do you write an email to a parent about student behavior?

    Name one specific behavior, say when it happened, state what you already tried, ask one real question, and propose one next step with a date on it. Keep the whole thing under 200 words. If it runs longer, what you actually need is a phone call, and the email should be two lines asking to schedule one.

    Should a behavior email be positive or focused on problems?

    Focused on something the parent can act on. In a randomized experiment, improvement-focused messages gained 8.8 percentage points on credit earned against 4.5 for positive messages, though the authors could not separate the two statistically. The clearer finding was that 84 percent of improvement messages were actionable versus 8.5 percent of positive ones.

    Can you name another student in an email to a parent?

    No. The U.S. Department of Education states that FERPA generally prohibits nonconsensual disclosure of information derived from education records, and naming another child in a behavior email risks exactly that. Describe only the student you are writing about and refer to anyone else as another student, including in follow-up replies.

    How long should an email to parents about student behavior be?

    Under 200 words. Parents frequently read these on a phone, so the behavior and the ask both need to appear in the first three lines. A longer email usually means the situation has outgrown email, in which case the message should simply request ten minutes on the phone and offer two specific times.

    When should a teacher email home about behavior?

    After the second occurrence, not the tenth. An early email is small and fixable; the same email sent three weeks later reads as a case being built, and the parent can hear that the teacher has already decided who their child is. Early contact also keeps your own frustration out of the writing.

    Does contacting parents about behavior actually improve anything?

    The evidence says yes, with caveats. Weekly messages home raised credit earning by 6.5 percentage points in a summer credit recovery experiment, mostly by reducing dropout, at about $13 per student-course. The same study found treated students rated their own effort lower and teachers rated relationships with them lower, so the contact is not costless.

    Is a phone call better than an email about student behavior?

    A call is better when tone matters and worse when you need a record. In one randomized study of daily home contact, only 54.9 percent of prescribed calls actually reached a parent or guardian. For a secondary teacher with 120 students, email handles routine contact and a call is the escalation when two emails have not worked.

    What should you do if a parent replies angrily to a behavior email?

    Answer the factual parts, decline the argument, and move to a call. Keep the reply short, correct anything you got wrong, and avoid defending a characterization you should not have written in the first place. If the exchange is escalating or a consequence is involved, loop in an administrator before you reply again.

    Sources

    • Kraft, M. A., & Rogers, T. (2015). The underutilized potential of teacher-to-parent communication: Evidence from a field experiment. Economics of Education Review, 47, 49–63. Five-week summer credit recovery program, large urban Northeastern district; 435 of 1,417 enrolled students consented and were randomized into positive (n = 146), improvement (n = 136) and control (n = 153) groups. The authors state they lacked power to distinguish the positive and improvement estimates from each other.
    • Kraft, M. A., & Dougherty, S. M. (2013). The effect of teacher-family communication on student engagement: Evidence from a randomized field experiment. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness. Four-week mandatory summer academy, 140 incoming 6th and 9th graders in 14 class groups, cluster-randomized. Only the class-participation effect reached p < .05; homework completion and redirections sat at p < .10 and the authors label them suggestive.
    • U.S. Department of Education, Student Privacy Policy Office. FERPA Frequently Asked Questions. The quoted language on nonconsensual disclosure and on personal knowledge comes from this page. FERPA interpretation is fact-specific and districts add their own policy on top of it; this article is not legal advice.
    • Wilder, S. (2014). Effects of parental involvement on academic achievement: A meta-synthesis. Educational Review. A synthesis of nine meta-analyses. The Hill & Tyson (2009) findings on academic socialization and homework assistance are cited here as Wilder reports them, because Wilder is the document that was read for this article rather than the original meta-analysis.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Managing Classroom Procedures: What the Rubric Wants and What Actually Works

    Managing Classroom Procedures: What the Rubric Wants and What Actually Works

    By Clay Shumate

    Managing classroom procedures is component 2c of Charlotte Danielson’s 2013 Framework for Teaching. It scores how little instructional time a room loses to instructional groups, transitions, materials and routines. The top level is not a quieter teacher. It is students running the routines themselves with minimal prompting from the adult.

    Key Takeaways

    • “Managing classroom procedures” is the name of component 2c in the 2013 edition of Danielson’s Framework for Teaching, and it is scored on four levels from “much instructional time is lost” up to “instructional time is maximized.”
    • The 2022 edition of the Framework renamed 2c to “Maintaining Purposeful Environments.” Many districts are still evaluating on the 2013 wording, so a teacher can be observed under either name depending on which instrument the district bought.
    • Level 4 on this component cannot be reached by a teacher who runs everything personally. The rubric requires that students take initiative in transitions, materials and instructional groups, and that routines “may be initiated by students.”
    • A single observation by a single observer produced reliability between .27 and .45 in the Measures of Effective Teaching study, which used this exact instrument. One score on 2c is a weak estimate of what a room normally does.
    • Seven districts and charter networks spent $597 million from 2009 to 2016 building evaluation systems around rubrics like this one. RAND’s final report concluded the initiative “did not achieve its goal of increased student achievement and graduation.”

    Most teachers meet the phrase “managing classroom procedures” in one of two ways. Either a pre-observation form asks them to write about it, or a post-observation conference hands them a 2 on it and a sentence about transitions.

    Neither of those tells you what the phrase means. So here is the whole thing: where it comes from, what each score level actually says, which procedures carry the most weight in a secondary room, and what the research says about how much one of these scores is worth. Some of that research is not flattering to the rubric, and it is in here anyway.

    What does “managing classroom procedures” mean?

    Managing classroom procedures means running the non-teaching machinery of a classroom so it costs as little learning time as possible. In the Danielson rubric it covers four things: instructional groups, transitions, materials and supplies, and everyday classroom routines.

    That is a narrower idea than “classroom management,” and the distinction matters when you are being scored. Classroom management in ordinary staff-room usage covers behavior, relationships, consequences, tone, everything. Component 2c is not about behavior. Behavior lives in a different component. 2c is about logistics: whether the room knows how to start, move, get supplies, work in groups and finish without an adult narrating every step.

    If you want the practice side rather than the rubric side, the companion piece on classroom routines and procedures for grades 6–12 is the one that walks through which routines to teach and how to teach them. This article is about the instrument.

    Where does the phrase come from, and is it still in the rubric?

    “Managing Classroom Procedures” is component 2c of Domain 2 in the 2013 edition of the Framework for Teaching. The 2022 edition of the Framework renamed that slot to “Maintaining Purposeful Environments,” which the Danielson Group publishes as its current 2c rubric.

    That rename is worth knowing before a pre-conference, because the two editions are in use at the same time. A district that adopted the Framework a decade ago and never repurchased is still scoring teachers on the 2013 language. A district that updated is using the 2022 language. The phrase on your evaluation form tells you which one you are on.

    EditionComponent 2c is calledWhat it emphasizesWho is likely using it
    2013 Framework for TeachingManaging Classroom ProceduresInstructional groups, transitions, materials, routines, and minimizing lost instructional timeDistricts still on the instrument they adopted during the evaluation-reform era
    2022 Framework for TeachingMaintaining Purposeful EnvironmentsThe same ground, framed as a purposeful environment rather than a set of managed proceduresDistricts that have repurchased or retrained since 2022

    Both versions are asking the same practical question. The older wording is blunter about it, and because the keyword people actually search is the older wording, that is the version the rest of this article quotes.

    What does an observer look for at each level?

    An observer is looking for lost instructional time and who prevents it. The 2013 rubric sorts rooms by how much time the procedures cost and by how much prompting students need, and the jump from Proficient to Distinguished is entirely about students doing the work instead of the teacher.

    Here is the actual ladder, in the rubric’s own terms.

    LevelInstructional timeStudent prompting requiredWhat an observer writes down
    1 — Unsatisfactory“Much instructional time is lost due to inefficient classroom routines and procedures”“Little evidence that students know or follow established routines”Disorganized transitions, no visible procedure for handing out or collecting anything, students not working with the teacher are off task
    2 — Basic“Some instructional time is lost due to partially effective classroom routines and procedures”Students follow routines “with regular guidance and prompting”Procedures appear to exist but do not run smoothly; students are confused about carrying them out; independent work is only partially engaged
    3 — Proficient“There is little loss of instructional time due to effective classroom routines and procedures”Students follow routines “with minimal guidance and prompting”Smooth transitions between large and small group, efficient distribution and collection of materials, productive small-group and independent work
    4 — Distinguished“Instructional time is maximized due to efficient and seamless classroom routines and procedures”Routines “are well understood and may be initiated by students”Students take initiative in transitions, in distributing and collecting materials, and in managing instructional groups; they ensure their own time is used productively

    Read the top row again, because it is the part that gets missed. You cannot earn a 4 on this component by being an excellent manager of a room. The rubric explicitly requires that students take initiative, and that routines can start without you. A teacher who runs a beautifully tight ship personally, calling every move, is describing a 3.

    Four stacked rows showing the Unsatisfactory, Basic, Proficient and Distinguished level descriptors for component 2c, managing classroom procedures.
    The four levels, in the 2013 rubric’s own words.

    Which means the move from 3 to 4 is a handoff, not an improvement. Take one of the four procedures the rubric names — materials is usually the easiest — and give it to students to start and run. Three guardrails on that, because the handoff goes wrong in predictable ways. Do not turn it into peer policing, where students enforce the routine on each other; the rubric asks students to run procedures, not to discipline classmates. Do not let the same three reliable kids absorb every job, which is how a management win becomes unpaid labor for the students who were already compliant. And check it against accommodations first, because a routine that requires every student to get up and collect their own materials is not neutral for a student whose IEP or 504 plan says otherwise.

    That is a demand this site happens to agree with, for reasons that have nothing to do with evaluation scores. If a 15-year-old cannot be trusted to hand back papers or start a group task without an adult counting down, somebody decided that in advance.

    Which procedures carry the most weight in grades 6–12?

    The four the rubric names carry the weight, because those are the four an observer is scoring. Everything else in a secondary classroom is downstream of entry, transitions, materials and group work.

    Numbered list of five classroom procedures that carry the most weight in grades 6 to 12, from entry routines through closing and cleanup.
    Entry and transitions cost the most time in most secondary rooms.
    1. Entry and the first four minutes. Whether the room starts working before you speak. This is the procedure an observer sees first and the one that colors the rest of the period.
    2. Transitions between activities. The rubric’s Proficient language is specifically “transitions between large- and small-group activities are smooth.” If you only tighten one thing before an observation, tighten this.
    3. Distribution and collection of materials. Named in all four levels. At level 4, students are doing it. Chromebook carts, paper, lab equipment, novels, calculators — whatever your room hands out, there is a visible procedure for it or there is not.
    4. Instructional groups and independent work. The rubric asks whether students not working directly with the teacher are productively engaged. In a secondary room this is usually the weakest of the four, because it is the one you cannot personally supervise.
    5. Closing and cleanup. Not separately named in the rubric, but it is the visible end of “instructional time is maximized.” A period that dissolves four minutes early is losing time no matter how good the middle was.

    Transitions are the usual culprit, and they have their own article: how to stop losing six minutes a lesson, plus a shorter piece on cues students can actually see for rooms where verbal direction is already competing with thirty conversations.

    How do you show this to an observer who is only in the room for 15 minutes?

    Pick a segment that contains a transition and some independent work. A short observation that lands entirely inside a lecture gives an observer nothing to score on 2c, so they score what they can infer, which is worse for you than showing them the real thing.

    Short observations are now common, and the MET study found they are not worthless: a single 15-minute observation produced about 60 percent of the reliability of a full-lesson observation while taking under a third of the time. That is a reasonable trade for an observer with forty teachers to see. It also means the 15 minutes they pick carries a lot of weight, which is an argument for making sure those minutes are representative rather than exceptional.

    Plenty of districts do unannounced walkthroughs with no pre-conference at all, and in that case none of the framing above is available to you. The only defense there is that the procedures run the same whether an adult with a clipboard is standing in the door or not — which is the actual point of the component, and the reason gaming it is a waste of a week.

    • Name the component in the pre-conference. Say which procedures they will see and when. An observer who knows the materials routine happens at minute six will look for it.
    • Make one student-run routine visible. Level 4 language requires student initiative. If a student starts the routine, say so in the post-conference reflection, because an observer who missed the first thirty seconds cannot score what they did not see.
    • Have the written procedure somewhere. Posted, in the syllabus, in the slide deck — it does not matter where. It matters that “procedures seem to have been established” (level 2) can be upgraded to “established” with something you can point at.
    • Do not stage a procedure the room does not have. The rubric’s level 2 descriptor is literally the look of a staged routine: procedures that “seem to have been established, but their operation is not smooth,” with students confused about carrying them out. Observers recognize it.
    • Ask which edition you are scored on. 2013 or 2022. It changes the vocabulary of the entire conference.

    If your procedures are not where you want them yet, the honest move is to say so in the pre-conference and name what you are working on. A teacher who can diagnose their own level 2 is easier to coach than one who is surprised by it, and in most districts the conversation is the part that actually changes anything.

    Does a good score on this component mean you are a better teacher?

    Not reliably, and the research on that is clear enough that it should change how much weight anybody puts on one number. The instrument is a decent description of good practice. The scoring of it is noisy, and the systems built on top of it did not produce the results they were built to produce.

    The Measures of Effective Teaching project tested exactly this instrument — ten items from Domains 2 and 3 of the Framework for Teaching, scored on the four-point scale, in Hillsborough County, Florida. Its finding on single observations is the number every teacher being evaluated should know: reliability for one observation by one observer ranged from .27 to .45.

    It gets more specific. Broken out by who is doing the observing, one rating by one observer produced reliability of .510 for a same-school administrator, .433 for an administrator from another school, .287 for a peer with the same certification, and .240 for a peer with a different certification. The study’s blunt conclusion was that “having more than one observer really does matter” — adding a second set of eyes bought more than twice the reliability gain of adding a second lesson with the same observer. The smallest combination the study tested that reached a .65 threshold was four full-lesson observations by two observers.

    Almost no district does that. Which means most 2c scores in America are a single reading with somewhere between .27 and .51 reliability attached to it.

    Five rows of classroom observation reliability figures by observer type, from .510 for a same-school administrator down to .240 for a peer with different certification.
    One observer, one lesson, on the same instrument being scored.

    One honest limit on those figures: they come from a single district, Hillsborough County, Florida, with observers trained for that study. A different district with different training could do better or worse. The direction of the finding — one observer, one lesson, weak estimate — has held up well enough to be worth acting on, but the specific decimals are not a national constant.

    The bigger finding is about the systems rather than the scores. RAND’s final evaluation of the Intensive Partnerships for Effective Teaching followed seven sites — three districts and four charter management organizations — from 2009 through 2016 as they built evaluation systems combining rubric-based observation with student achievement growth. The initiative cost $597 million, of which $237 million came from Gates Foundation grants.

    RAND’s conclusion was that “the initiative did not achieve its goal of increased student achievement and graduation.” There were exceptions in both directions — high school English improved in the charter networks and in Pittsburgh, grades 3–8 math declined in the charter networks — but no widespread gain, no graduation improvement in most sites and grade ranges, and no improvement in low-income minority students’ access to effective teaching, which had been one of the stated goals. By the end, almost all teachers were rated effective, with only 1 to 2 percent rated ineffective at most sites.

    Two caveats before anyone quotes that as a verdict. The seven sites covered elementary through high school, so the achievement results are not specific to grades 6–12. And the initiative changed far more than observation rubrics — it touched pay, tenure, staffing and professional development — so the null result belongs to the whole package, not to component 2c.

    Report that honestly and it cuts both ways. It is not evidence that procedures do not matter. Lost instructional time is real and the rubric describes it accurately. It is evidence that scoring teachers on it, at the scale and frequency districts can afford, did not move student outcomes. Districts are still legally required to evaluate teachers, so the useful question is not whether to do it but what to take from it — and the specific, concrete feedback has always been the valuable half.

    Clay’s take: the rubric is better than the score

    The 2c language is one of the few places in a teacher evaluation instrument that says something genuinely useful about teenagers. Read level 4 without the evaluation context and it is a description of a classroom where students are trusted with the running of their own room.

    That is worth chasing on its own terms. Not because a 4 looks good on a summative, but because the alternative is a room where a near-adult cannot distribute a stack of papers without supervision. The rubric is right that those are different rooms, and it is right about which one loses less time.

    Where I would not spend much energy is the number itself. A measurement with .27 to .45 reliability from one observer is not a verdict on a semester of work, and a half-billion-dollar initiative built on these instruments did not raise achievement or graduation rates. Take the feedback, which is usually specific and often correct. Hold the score loosely.

    And if the feedback says your transitions cost time, that is probably true regardless of what the reliability coefficient says. Transitions are the one thing on this component that nearly every teacher can see for themselves with a stopwatch.

    What to do next

    Find out which edition your district evaluates on, then read your own 2c language rather than a summary of it. Pick the one procedure that costs you the most time — for most secondary teachers that is transitions or materials — and build it into something a student can start.

    Then put it in writing somewhere an observer can see. If you want the longer version of the underlying work, start with which routines are worth teaching in grades 6–12, keep a management plan that actually runs on one page, and if the room is still loud through every handoff, the prevention side is the better place to spend a week than the rubric is. The expectations framework covers what the procedures are supposed to be serving.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is component 2c Managing Classroom Procedures?

    Component 2c is a slot in Domain 2 of the 2013 edition of Charlotte Danielson’s Framework for Teaching. It scores how much instructional time a classroom loses to instructional groups, transitions, materials and supplies, and everyday routines, and how much teacher prompting students need to follow them. It is scored on four levels, from much time lost up to instructional time maximized.

    Is managing classroom procedures the same as classroom management?

    No. Classroom management in everyday staff-room usage covers behavior, relationships, consequences and tone. Component 2c is narrower and deliberately excludes behavior, which is scored elsewhere in the framework. 2c is logistics: whether the room can start, move between activities, handle materials and work in groups without an adult narrating every step.

    What does a Distinguished rating on 2c actually require?

    Student initiative, not teacher efficiency. The 2013 rubric’s level 4 says routines are well understood and may be initiated by students, and that students take initiative in transitions, in distributing and collecting materials, and in managing instructional groups. A teacher who personally directs every smooth move is describing level 3, not level 4.

    Was component 2c renamed in the 2022 Framework for Teaching?

    Yes. The 2022 edition renamed 2c from Managing Classroom Procedures to Maintaining Purposeful Environments, and the Danielson Group publishes that as the current 2c rubric. Both editions are in active use, because districts adopt the instrument they purchased. Ask which edition your evaluation form uses before a pre-observation conference.

    How reliable is one observation score on classroom procedures?

    Not very. The Measures of Effective Teaching study, which scored this exact instrument, found reliability of .27 to .45 for a single observation by a single observer. Broken out by observer, one rating ran .510 for a same-school administrator down to .240 for a peer with different certification. More observers helped more than more lessons.

    Which classroom procedures should a secondary teacher fix first?

    Transitions, in most rooms. The rubric names transitions in all four levels and the Proficient descriptor specifically calls for smooth movement between large- and small-group activities. Transitions are also the easiest procedure to measure yourself with a stopwatch, which makes them the cheapest place to find real lost time before anybody observes you.

    Do evaluation systems built on these rubrics improve student outcomes?

    The largest test of that says no. RAND’s final evaluation of the Intensive Partnerships for Effective Teaching followed seven sites from 2009 to 2016 at a cost of $597 million and concluded the initiative did not achieve its goal of increased student achievement and graduation. The sites spanned elementary through high school, and the initiative changed pay and staffing too, so the null result belongs to the package rather than to one rubric component.

    What should you do if you disagree with your score on managing classroom procedures?

    Ask which level descriptor the score was based on and what specific evidence the observer recorded, because the rubric language is public and checkable. Most evaluation systems allow a written teacher response in the record. Disagreeing about a decimal is rarely worth the energy; disagreeing about an inaccurate factual observation, in writing, sometimes is.

    Sources

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Formal vs Informal Formative Assessment: What Actually Separates Them

    Formal vs Informal Formative Assessment: What Actually Separates Them

    By Clay Shumate · Updated October 24, 2026

    Formal formative assessment is planned before the lesson and produces a record you can look at later — an exit ticket, a quiz, an embedded prompt. Informal formative assessment happens in the moment, usually through questioning, and leaves no artifact. Both are formative only if you actually change what you do next.

    Key Takeaways

    • The difference between formal and informal formative assessment is planning and evidence, not rigor: formal checks are designed ahead of time and leave a record, informal checks happen live and do not.
    • Informal questioning is the most common form of formative assessment in classrooms, which means most teachers are already doing the harder one badly rather than not doing it at all.
    • Ruiz-Primo and Furtak’s ESRU model — elicit, student responds, recognize, use — is the clearest test of whether an informal check was real. Most classroom questioning stops at the second step.
    • The famous 0.4 to 0.7 effect size for formative assessment is not well supported. A 2011 meta-analysis found a weighted mean of 0.20 across 42 effect sizes, and a 2012 critique argued even that number is unreliable.
    • Formal and informal are not a clean binary. WestEd lists informal-versus-formal as just one of fourteen dimensions along which formative assessments vary.

    Every district PD session on formative assessment eventually reaches the slide that says “formal vs. informal,” and the slide is almost always wrong. It usually implies formal means serious and informal means casual, which leaves teachers thinking the real work is the exit ticket and the questioning is just talking.

    It is the other way around more often than not. The informal version is harder to do well, happens hundreds of times a day, and is the one nobody ever gets coached on. This article explains what the distinction actually is, what the research says about each, and when to use which. If you want the strategies themselves rather than the categories, the full list of formative assessment strategies is the better starting point.

    Is formative assessment formal or informal? What separates them

    Formal formative assessment is planned in advance, given to everyone at a set point, and produces something you can look at after the bell. Informal formative assessment is unplanned, happens inside instruction — usually as a question — and produces only what you noticed at the time. Both are formative because of what you do with the information, not because of the format.

    That last clause is the one people skip. Formative assessment is defined by purpose, not by instrument. Black and Wiliam’s 1998 definition, still the one most researchers use, covers activities that “provide information to be used as feedback to modify the teaching and learning activities.” A quiz you collect, grade, and never act on is not formative. A question you ask and genuinely respond to is.

    WestEd’s review of the research makes the same point and then complicates it usefully: formal and informal are not two boxes but a spectrum, and the report lists informal-versus-formal as only one of fourteen dimensions along which formative assessments vary — alongside spontaneous versus planned and curriculum-embedded versus stand-alone. Those dimensions overlap but they are not the same axis. A question can be planned in advance and still leave no record. An exit ticket can be invented on the spot.

    Comparison table of formal and informal formative assessment across six rows: when it is designed, typical form, whether it leaves a record, who it reaches, how it fails, and which question it answers.
    Formal and informal formative assessment compared across six dimensions.
    Formal formative assessmentInformal formative assessment
    When it is designedBefore the lessonIn the moment, usually inside a discussion
    Typical formsExit ticket, embedded written prompt, ungraded quiz, hinge question on a slide, whiteboard checkQuestioning, listening in on group work, reading over a shoulder, a follow-up probe
    Leaves a record?Yes — you can sort it, re-read it, bring it to a PLCNo, unless you write something down
    Who it reachesEveryone, at onceWhoever answered, which is rarely everyone
    Main failure modeCollected and never acted on; becomes a gradeTeacher hears the answer, says “good,” and moves on
    Cost per usePlanning time up front, review time afterAlmost no prep; high cognitive load during the lesson
    Best forDeciding what tomorrow looks like; evidence you can show someoneDeciding what the next five minutes look like
    Grade it?NoNot possible, and that is a feature
    Formal and informal formative assessment compared on the dimensions that change what a teacher does.

    What counts as informal formative assessment?

    Questioning, mostly. WestEd calls informal questioning the most common form of formative assessment there is. It also includes listening to a group argue, reading over a shoulder during work time, and the follow-up probe you ask when an answer sounds memorized.

    The useful research here comes from Maria Araceli Ruiz-Primo and Erin Furtak, who studied three middle school science teachers working through a physical science unit on buoyancy and built a model called the ESRU cycle. It has four steps: the teacher Elicits a response, the Student responds, the teacher Recognizes what the response actually revealed, and the teacher Uses it to do something different.

    That fourth step is where almost all classroom questioning dies. A teacher asks, a student answers, the teacher says “right” and keeps going. That is an E and an S. Nothing was assessed. The ESRU model is valuable precisely because it makes the gap visible: in Ruiz-Primo and Furtak’s study, the teacher who more often completed full cycles had students who performed better on an embedded assessment than the students of the other two teachers.

    Be careful how much weight you put on that result. It is three teachers, in middle school science, in one unit, with no control group — a point later raised by Derek Briggs and colleagues when they reviewed how this literature gets synthesized. It is a good model and a small study. Treat the ESRU cycle as a coaching lens, not as proof of an effect size.

    The four steps of the ESRU cycle for informal formative assessment: elicit, student responds, recognize what the answer revealed, and use it to do something different. Most classroom questioning stops at the second step.
    The ESRU cycle, and the step where most questioning stops.

    What counts as formal formative assessment?

    Anything written and planned that you designed to show whether the class is ready to move on — and that you do not grade. Exit tickets, embedded written prompts, whiteboard checks, hinge questions, ungraded quizzes. Each sits at a point in the unit where you need a decision, and each is built before the lesson rather than improvised in it.

    What makes these formal is not that they are written. It is that you decided in advance what you needed to know and built an instrument to find out. WestEd describes these as embedded prompts, often requiring a written response, placed at key points in instruction to identify next steps. The planning is the point: a question you wrote yesterday is almost always a better question than one you improvise at 10:42.

    The failure mode is equally specific. A formal check becomes a small summative test the moment it enters the gradebook, and students respond accordingly — they protect the score instead of showing you the confusion. If you want the evidence to be honest, the check cannot count. That is also the argument running through our piece on what standards-based grading actually fixes.

    Is formal formative assessment the same thing as summative assessment?

    No, and this is the confusion that wrecks the whole topic. Formal and informal describe how a check is built. Formative and summative describe what the result is for. They are two separate axes, which means a written test can be formal and formative, formal and summative, or — most commonly in real schools — formal, labeled formative, and used summatively. Our guide to the difference between formative and summative assessment works through that second axis in detail.

    Run the four combinations and the distinction gets concrete. A planned exit ticket you sort and act on is formal and formative. A unit test that decides a grade is formal and summative. A follow-up question that changes your next sentence is informal and formative. And a teacher mentally marking a student as “one of the weak ones” based on an offhand answer is informal and summative, which is the one nobody names and the one that does the most damage.

    That fourth box deserves a sentence of its own. An informal check that quietly hardens into a judgment about a student is not assessment at all; it is a prediction, and teenagers notice being predicted. If an informal check does not change what you do, it should not change what you think about who the student is either.

    The practical test for any check, formal or informal: name the decision it feeds. If the only answer is “it shows me where they are,” it is going in a gradebook or a drawer, not into instruction.

    The formal-and-summative box still has to be filled at some point, usually at the end of the semester. For that one, the Mid-Terms.org library has 200 free printable midterms with answer keys for grades 6–12 across Social Studies, ELA, Math and Science, which leaves your planning time for the formative checks that actually change instruction.

    Is formal or informal formative assessment more effective?

    No study answers that cleanly, and anyone who tells you otherwise is extrapolating. The honest position is that the evidence base for formative assessment as a whole is thinner than its reputation, and it has almost never been broken out by formal versus informal.

    Start with the number everybody quotes. Black and Wiliam reported in 1998 that “typical effect sizes of the formative assessment experiments were between 0.4 and 0.7,” drawing on 250 sources. That range is on a thousand PD slides.

    It did not hold up. Neal Kingston and Brooke Nash reviewed more than 300 K–12 studies in 2011 and found that only 13 reported enough information to calculate an effect size. From 42 independent effect sizes they got a median of 0.25 and a weighted mean of 0.20 — a third of the low end of the famous range. By subject: English language arts 0.32, mathematics 0.17, science 0.09.

    And then the correction got corrected. In 2012 Derek Briggs, Maria Araceli Ruiz-Primo, Erin Furtak, Lorrie Shepard and Yue Yin argued that the 0.20 figure is not reliable either: the search was not replicable, studies meeting the criteria were excluded while one without a control group was included, and effect sizes calculated with and without pretest data are not comparable. In one study they recalculated, the mean shifted from −0.32 to −0.14 depending on the formula. Their conclusion is the one worth carrying: a different sample of studies could produce an average substantially higher or lower, so considerable uncertainty remains.

    What that means for a Tuesday: formative assessment is a reasonable bet with an unreliable price tag. Do not choose between formal and informal on the strength of an effect size, because there is no credible effect size for either one separately.

    When should you use formal vs. informal formative assessment?

    Match the check to the decision you are about to make. Informal checks tell you what to do in the next five minutes. Formal checks tell you what tomorrow looks like. If you are not about to make either decision, you are collecting data for no one.

    • Mid-explanation, something feels off. Informal. Stop, ask one student to say the last step back in their own words, then probe the part they skipped. You need an answer in ten seconds, not a record.
    • Deciding whether to move to the next lesson. Formal. You need everyone, not the four hands that go up. Three questions on the way out is enough.
    • Group work is running and you cannot tell who is doing the thinking. Informal. Listen without intervening for ninety seconds per group; you learn more than any written check will tell you.
    • A misconception you have seen every year. Formal, and planned months ago. Write the prompt that exposes it and put it in the unit at the point it usually appears.
    • You have to explain a reteach decision to a coach, a parent, or a PLC. Formal. “It felt shaky” is not evidence. Sixty-one exit tickets is.

    How do you run both in one week with 150 students?

    Run informal checks constantly and formal checks twice a week, and read the formal ones in a sort rather than a grade. The whole system should cost you under thirty minutes of out-of-class time per week, or it will not survive October.

    1. Pick one informal habit to improve, not five. The highest-value one is the U in ESRU: after a student answers, do something with it out loud. “So if that’s true, what happens when…” Thirty seconds, no prep, and it is the step the research says separates teachers.
    2. Write two formal checks when you plan the unit, not the night before. Place them at the two points where students have historically gotten lost. Three questions each, maximum.
    3. Sort, do not grade. Three piles: got it, partial, not yet. Count the piles. That takes about eight minutes for 150 papers and it is the only number you need.
    4. Change one thing tomorrow because of the piles. Reteach the partials in a ten-minute opener, or pull the “not yet” group while everyone else starts. If nothing changes, stop running the check.
    5. Tell students what the pile meant. Not a score — the actual gap. A check students cannot see the result of teaches them that checks are for the teacher.
    Five steps for running both formal and informal formative assessment in one week in under thirty minutes: improve one informal habit, write two formal checks during unit planning, sort rather than grade, change one thing tomorrow, and tell students what their pile meant.
    A week of both, for under thirty minutes of out-of-class time.

    Subject-specific versions of step two are worth stealing rather than inventing: there are worked examples for reading, writing and science, and a free printable set if you would rather not build from scratch.

    What does good informal formative assessment look like to an observer?

    It looks like the teacher changing course. An observer cannot see a formative check directly, because the evidence is a decision rather than a document. What they should watch for is the gap between what the lesson plan said and what the teacher actually did after a student spoke.

    Four things worth looking for, whether you are being observed or doing the observing:

    • Follow-up questions outnumber new questions. A room where every question goes to a different student is a room where nothing is being probed.
    • Wrong answers get used rather than corrected. “Say more about that” after a wrong answer is the single clearest sign the teacher is assessing rather than quizzing.
    • The plan visibly bends. Something got cut, repeated, or reordered during the period.
    • Being wrong is survivable. If the only students answering are the ones who are sure, the informal check is sampling the wrong population and the data is worthless.

    That last point is not a soft one. An informal check only works if students will show you a half-formed idea, and they will only do that if the room is safe for it — which is why respect that goes both ways is an assessment issue before it is a culture issue.

    What should a school actually invest in?

    Coaching on the informal side and time to build the formal side — in that order, and neither of them is a purchase. The most common district response to formative assessment is to buy a platform or mandate a template, and both of those produce compliance rather than instruction.

    Three things that cost staffing rather than software:

    1. Someone scripting questioning with teachers. A coach sitting in for twenty minutes and transcribing the question-and-answer sequence is the only feedback that improves informal checks. There is no template for the U in ESRU.
    2. Unit planning time that includes writing the two checks. If the checks are written during planning, they land at the right points and cost nothing in-week. If they are written the night before, they will be generic and they will stop in October.
    3. A rule that formative checks do not enter the gradebook. This is free, it is the single biggest determinant of whether the evidence is honest, and it has to come from leadership because an individual teacher who stops grading checks looks like they are lowering the standard.

    One caution on the evidence, since this is where a district asks for it. The strongest study design in this area is Decristan and colleagues’ cluster-randomized trial of embedded formative assessment, and it found that the assessment and general classroom process quality — cognitive activation, supportive climate, classroom management — interacted. The practice did not work on its own; it worked in rooms that were already running well. That sample was elementary science, so a secondary leader is reasoning by analogy. But the implication travels: a formative assessment rollout in a building where classroom management is the real problem is solving the second problem first.

    Clay’s take: the informal one is the one nobody coaches

    Districts invest in the formal side because it produces artifacts, and artifacts are what you can put in a binder. So teachers get templates, exit ticket banks, and a data meeting. Nobody sits in the back of a room and says, “you asked eleven questions this period and used the answer to two of them.”

    That is backwards, and it is backwards for a reason worth naming: the informal version is the one that respects students as thinkers. A written check asks a teenager to produce the right answer. A real follow-up question asks them to explain their reasoning to an adult who is actually listening, and then does something visible with what they said. Teenagers can tell the difference between those two experiences instantly.

    The other thing I would say to an administrator: do not mandate a daily exit ticket. You will get 180 pieces of paper a year per teacher and no change in instruction, because the mandate produces the artifact and the artifact is not the thing. Ask instead what got retaught last week and why. If the answer is specific, the assessment is working regardless of what format it took.

    What should you do next?

    Count your U’s for one period. Teach normally, and afterward mark how many times a student answer actually changed what you said next. Most teachers find the number is one or two, and most are surprised by that. It is the cheapest diagnostic in this whole article and it does not require a template.

    Then add exactly one formal check to next week’s plan, sort it into three piles, and change one thing because of it. If you want strategies to fill that slot, go to the main strategies list; if you are assessing a project rather than a lesson, assessment for project-based learning covers the version where there is no unit test at the end.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is formative assessment formal or informal?

    It can be either. Formative assessment is defined by purpose, not format: any check whose results you use to change what you teach next. A planned exit ticket or ungraded quiz is formal formative assessment because it is designed in advance and leaves a record. A follow-up question during a discussion is informal formative assessment because it happens live and leaves no artifact.

    What are examples of informal formative assessment?

    Questioning is the most common example. Others include listening in on a group while it works, reading over a shoulder during work time, and asking a follow-up probe when an answer sounds memorized. They count as formative only if you use what you heard, which is the step most classroom questioning skips.

    What is the difference between formal and informal formative assessment?

    Formal formative assessment is planned before the lesson, given to the whole class, and leaves a record you can review later – an exit ticket or an embedded written prompt. Informal formative assessment happens live inside instruction, usually through questioning, and leaves no artifact. Both are formative only if the teacher changes something as a result.

    Is a quiz a formal or an informal formative assessment?

    A quiz is formal, because it is planned in advance and produces a record. Whether it is formative depends on what happens next. If the score goes in the gradebook and nothing is retaught, it functioned as a small summative test. If you sort the results and change tomorrow’s lesson, it was formative, regardless of the name on it.

    Which is more effective, formal or informal formative assessment?

    No credible study separates them. Formative assessment as a whole has a contested evidence base: the often-quoted 0.4 to 0.7 range from 1998 was revised to a weighted mean of 0.20 in a 2011 meta-analysis, and a 2012 critique argued even 0.20 is unreliable. Choose based on the decision you need to make, not on an effect size.

    What is the ESRU cycle?

    ESRU stands for elicit, student responds, recognize, use. Ruiz-Primo and Furtak proposed it in 2007 to describe informal formative assessment: the teacher asks, the student answers, the teacher recognizes what the answer revealed, and the teacher uses it. Most classroom questioning stops after the student answers, which means no assessment actually happened.

    Should formative assessments be graded?

    No. The moment a check counts, students protect the score instead of showing you what they do not understand, and the evidence you get back is worse. Sort the responses into got it, partial and not yet, tell students what their pile meant, and keep the gradebook out of it. The point is a teaching decision, not a number.

    How many formal formative assessments should I run per week?

    Two is enough for most secondary courses, placed at the points in a unit where students historically get lost. Three questions each. If you are running one every day and never changing instruction because of them, you have added paperwork rather than assessment. The weekly cost should stay under thirty minutes of out-of-class time.

    Does informal formative assessment work with a class that will not talk?

    Only if you fix the talking first, because informal checks sample whoever answers. In a quiet room the four confident students become your data, which tells you almost nothing about the other twenty-six. Use written formal checks as the backbone until wrong answers are survivable, then shift weight back toward questioning.

    Sources

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Why Is Student Behavior Getting Worse? What the Data Actually Shows

    Why Is Student Behavior Getting Worse? What the Data Actually Shows

    By Clay Shumate

    Student behavior is getting worse in the sense that matters most to teachers — attention, attendance, and everyday disrespect — but not in the ways people usually mean. Serious violence and bullying are flat or down over a decade. What rose is low-level disruption, chronic absence, and the number of adults who feel the room has changed.

    Key Takeaways

    • In a December 2024 EdWeek Research Center survey of 990 educators, 72 percent said students were misbehaving more than in fall 2019, and that share has climbed every year since 2021.
    • Federal teacher surveys disagree: the share of public school teachers saying student misbehavior interfered with their teaching was 41 percent in 2011–12 and 43 percent in 2015–16, then fell to 32 percent in 2020–21 — a year with so much remote and hybrid instruction that the comparison is not clean.
    • Student-reported bullying at school dropped from 28 percent in 2010–11 to 19 percent in 2021–22, while the share of high schoolers who skipped school because they felt unsafe nearly doubled from 7 percent in 2013 to 13 percent in 2023.
    • Chronic absenteeism is the clearest measured worsening: roughly 15 percent of students before the pandemic, 28.5 percent in 2021–22, and still 23.5 percent in 2023–24 — about 57 percent above the pre-pandemic rate.
    • No national dataset establishes a cause. Anyone telling you with confidence that it is phones, or parents, or discipline reform, is giving you an opinion wearing a statistic’s coat.

    Ask a room full of teachers whether student behavior is getting worse and you will not get a debate. You will get stories. The phone that will not go away. The kid who walks out mid-sentence. The parent email that starts at a ten. Nobody in the building thinks this is the same job it was in 2019.

    Then you go look at the national numbers and they do not line up neatly with the stories. Some of them point the other way. That gap is worth understanding, because the version of this question you answer determines what you try to fix.

    This article is the evidence, honestly reported, including the parts that cut against the premise. If you want the practical side instead, start with prevention that happens before anything goes wrong or what to do with the students who take the most out of you.

    Why is student behavior getting worse, according to teachers?

    Teachers overwhelmingly report that behavior is worse than before 2020, and the share saying so keeps rising. In the EdWeek Research Center’s December 2024 survey of 990 educators, 72 percent said students misbehave more than they did in fall 2019 — 48 percent said a lot more. Only 9 percent said students misbehave less.

    What makes that finding hard to wave off is the direction of travel. The same organization asked a version of this question in 2021 and got 66 percent. In early 2023 it was 70 percent. By late 2024 it was 72 percent, and the share saying behavior was about the same as 2019 had fallen from 24 to 20 percent. If this were a pandemic shock wearing off, the line would be going the other way.

    It has not. In an EdWeek Research Center survey of more than 1,000 educators fielded between April and June 2026, student behavior was the single most commonly named challenge for the coming school year, at 75 percent — ahead of student engagement at 70 percent and well ahead of budget uncertainty at 42 percent. Half of respondents expected behavior to get worse again.

    Federal data on schools says something similar, in flatter language. The National Center for Education Statistics’ School Pulse Panel surveyed 1,714 public schools in May 2024. Eighty percent said the pandemic was still negatively affecting students’ behavioral development. Twenty-six percent said lack of focus or inattention was having a severe negative impact on learning — the single highest-rated problem on the list, above classroom disruption at 19 percent and academic unpreparedness at 21 percent. Thirty-six percent reported disrespect toward staff at least weekly.

    What does the data say that cuts against this?

    Several of the longest-running federal measures of student behavior show flat or improving trends, not worsening ones. That does not make teachers wrong. It means the thing teachers are describing is not the thing those surveys measure.

    Start with the measure closest to the claim. NCES asks public school teachers directly whether student misbehavior interfered with their teaching. In 2011–12, 41 percent said yes. In 2015–16, 43 percent. In 2020–21, 32 percent. By that measure, teacher-reported interference dropped by about a quarter.

    Before anyone uses that to tell teachers they are imagining things: 2020–21 was the year of remote and hybrid instruction. A teacher looking at a grid of muted squares is not managing a hallway. That reading is badly confounded, and a newer comparable figure is what the field actually needs. The honest statement is that the most direct federal trend line on this question ends at a year nobody can interpret cleanly.

    The student-reported measures are less ambiguous and still mixed. In the Department of Justice’s School Crime Supplement, the share of students ages 12 to 18 who said they were bullied at school fell from 28 percent in 2010–11 to 22 percent in 2018–19 to 19 percent in 2021–22. NCES cautions that the 2021–22 survey changed and that there was no consistent trend across the period, so do not treat that as a clean slope — but it is not a rise.

    The CDC’s Youth Risk Behavior Survey, which collected 20,103 usable questionnaires from high school students in 2023, tells the same split story. Being bullied at school went from 20 percent in 2013 to 19 percent in 2023, which CDC scores as a decrease overall — though it jumped from 15 percent in 2021 to 19 percent in 2023, which is the kind of two-year move that feels like a trend from inside a building. Meanwhile two things got clearly worse: being threatened or injured with a weapon on school property rose from 7 to 9 percent, and skipping school because of safety concerns rose from 7 to 13 percent.

    Six measures of student behavior since 2019: educator perception rising from 66 to 72 percent, inattention disruption and device use rated severe by 26, 19 and 16 percent of schools, bullying falling from 28 to 19 percent, skipping school over safety rising from 7 to 13 percent, and chronic absenteeism rising from about 15 to 23.5 percent.
    The national measures disagree because they count different things.

    Why do teacher reports and student data disagree?

    They measure different things. The national surveys count discrete, nameable events — a fight, a bullying incident, a weapon. Teachers are describing the texture of a class period: attention that will not hold, work that does not get started, a reply that would have been unthinkable six years ago. None of that generates an incident report. The middle one has its own playbook: what to try when a student stops working.

    That is why the School Pulse Panel finding is the most useful one in this whole article. The top-rated problem was not violence. It was inattention. The second was classroom disruption. Sixteen percent of schools said unpermitted device use was severely hurting learning. These are the low-floor, high-frequency behaviors that never show up in a crime statistic and consume an entire career’s worth of patience.

    What’s being measuredSourceDirectionWhat it actually tells a teacher
    Educators’ perception of misbehavior vs. 2019EdWeek Research Center, Dec 2024, 990 educatorsWorse, and still rising (66% → 70% → 72%)The adults in buildings are not adjusting to a new normal. They think it is still moving
    Teacher-reported interference with teachingNCES NTPS/SASS, 2011–12 to 2020–21Down, 41% → 43% → 32%Confounded by remote instruction; needs a post-2021 reading before anyone leans on it
    Inattention, disruption, device useNCES School Pulse Panel, May 2024, 1,714 schoolsSevere impact reported by 26% / 19% / 16%The real complaint, and the one no violence statistic captures
    Bullying at schoolDOJ School Crime Supplement, ages 12–18Down, 28% (2010–11) → 19% (2021–22)Schools got better at this. It is worth saying out loud
    Skipped school over safety fearsCDC YRBS, high school, 2013 vs 2023Up, 7% → 13%Students feel less safe even where incidents did not rise
    Chronic absenteeismAEI analysis of 44 states + DC, 2025Up, ~15% → 23.5%The clearest, largest, best-documented worsening on this list
    Six measures of student behavior since 2019, and what each one is actually about.

    What actually got measurably worse?

    Attendance. It is not close. Chronic absenteeism — missing at least 10 percent of the school year — sat at roughly 15 percent before the pandemic. It hit 28.5 percent in 2021–22, fell to 25.4 percent in 2022–23, and was still 23.5 percent in 2023–24 across the 44 states and the District of Columbia that reported. That is about 57 percent above the pre-pandemic rate, and the rate of improvement slowed in the most recent year.

    This belongs in a behavior article because it is upstream of most of what teachers are describing. A student who misses a day a week is behind, and a student who is behind has every reason to avoid the work, refuse the task, or get removed from the room instead of failing in front of people. If you only have the energy to fix one thing this year, what actually brings students back to class will buy you more than any behavior system will.

    The second clear worsening is the subjective one, and it is real even though it is a feeling: students are more likely to say they stayed home because they did not feel safe. Thirteen percent in 2023, against 7 percent in 2013. A school can have a falling incident rate and a rising fear rate at the same time, and the fear is its own problem.

    So what is causing it?

    Nobody knows, and that answer is more useful than a confident wrong one. None of the datasets above are designed to identify causes. They count things. Every causal story on offer right now is a hypothesis with some supporting correlation and no national test behind it.

    Here is what gets proposed, and what each claim is actually standing on.

    1. Missed social development during the shutdowns. The most widely held explanation, and the one schools themselves endorse: 80 percent of schools told the School Pulse Panel in May 2024 that the pandemic was still negatively affecting students’ behavioral development. That is a belief held by people in a position to know. It is not a measurement of the mechanism.
    2. Phones and screens. Sixteen percent of schools called unpermitted device use a severe drag on learning, and inattention topped the list. That is consistent with a phone story and also consistent with several others. The honest treatment of the evidence here is in our piece on cell phones in the classroom, which does not claim more than the studies support.
    3. Parents. Educators increasingly name this one, and in an EdWeek Research Center survey of more than 5,800 teachers fielded between August and November 2025, 58 percent said more guidance from parents on behavior would help — the most-chosen answer. Worth noting what that is: teachers’ judgment about what would help, not evidence that parenting changed.
    4. Discipline reform. Commonly blamed, rarely evidenced in the direction claimed. Suspension rates fell in many districts over the same period that bullying fell and absenteeism rose, which is not a pattern that picks a side. Our review of what the restorative practices research actually shows includes the findings that do not flatter it — including that half-implemented programs are barely distinguishable from no program at all.
    5. Staffing and instability. Sixty-one percent of schools told NCES in 2024 they needed more classroom-management training, up from 50 percent two years earlier. A building with more new teachers has more rooms where behavior is being learned on the job. Among teachers with three or fewer years of experience, 36 percent reported misbehavior interfering with teaching, against 30 percent of those with 20 or more years.

    Most likely all five are doing some work and the mix differs by building. What should make you suspicious is any version of this argument that explains everything and predicts nothing.

    Five proposed explanations for worsening student behavior and the evidence each rests on: missed social development, phones and screens, parents, discipline reform, and staffing instability.
    Each common explanation, and what evidence it actually rests on.

    Is it worse in some schools than others?

    Yes, and the pattern is the one you would guess. Districts serving more disadvantaged students had higher absenteeism both before and after the pandemic, according to the AEI analysis. The relative increase was similar across district types, though — meaning the shock hit everybody and landed on top of an existing gap. In the federal teacher data, 36 percent of teachers in city schools reported misbehavior interfering with teaching, against 29 to 33 percent elsewhere.

    Two things follow from that, and they pull in opposite directions. A district average hides a lot; the building with the worst numbers needs a different response from the building at the mean, and a single district-wide behavior initiative will be over-built for one and under-built for the other. But a gap in a behavior statistic is not a statement about the students in the higher-number building. It describes attendance, staffing stability, and how many first-year teachers are learning to run a room in September — all of which are distributed unevenly on purpose.

    One more caution on the numbers in this article, because it matters for a grades 6–12 reader. The School Pulse Panel and the federal teacher surveys cover K–12 and report elementary, middle and high schools together unless broken out. The CDC survey is high school only, and the School Crime Supplement covers ages 12 to 18. Where a figure is specific to secondary students, this article says so; where it is a K–12 average, treat it as the direction rather than your number.

    What can one teacher actually do about it?

    Stop trying to solve a national trend inside a 50-minute period, and spend the effort on the three or four things that are genuinely inside your control. None of this is new. It is just more load-bearing than it used to be.

    1. Fight for attendance before you fight for compliance. The student in the seat can be redirected. The student who is not there cannot. Track who is drifting toward a day a week and intervene while it is still three absences, not thirteen.
    2. Design the period so inattention has nowhere to sit. Inattention is the top-rated problem in the federal data, and it grows in the gaps — the dead four minutes at the start, the ten minutes after the work is finished. Routines and procedures are an attention strategy before they are a discipline strategy.
    3. Handle disrespect privately and immediately. Thirty-six percent of schools report disrespect toward staff weekly. Handled in front of an audience it becomes a contest the student cannot afford to lose. Handled quietly, at the desk or at the door, it is usually over in thirty seconds.
    4. Keep the consequence proportional and keep the kid in the room. Removal that buys escape from work rewards the behavior it is meant to punish. Consequences that teach rather than humiliate are harder to run and they do not hand the student a reason to come back angrier.
    5. Do what you said you would do, every single time. This is the whole thing. Teenagers calibrate on follow-through, not on tone. A teacher whose stated consequence arrives on schedule has a quieter room than a teacher with a louder voice and a flexible memory.

    How would you know any of this is working?

    Pick measures you can actually read in four weeks, not a climate survey in May. Five that a single teacher can track without extra software:

    • Minutes to full start. Time from the bell to the point where everyone is working. If that number falls, inattention is losing ground. If it holds at six minutes, nothing else you changed matters much yet.
    • Attendance for your five most-absent students. Not the class average, which hides them. Five names, days present per week, updated Friday.
    • Referrals by type, not count. Split them into disruption, disrespect, and safety. A falling total that is all one category is a different story from a falling total across the board.
    • Work started versus work finished. If most of your incompletes are never-started rather than half-done, the problem is entry into the task, not stamina.
    • Repeat names. If the same four students account for most of what you log, you have four plans to make, not a class-wide culture problem.
    Five things a single teacher can track in four weeks: minutes to full start, attendance for the five most-absent students, referrals by type rather than count, work started versus finished, and repeat names.
    Five measures a single teacher can read in four weeks.

    And one thing worth telling families straight when they ask whether behavior has gotten worse: the honest answer is that attendance and attention have, that serious incidents mostly have not, and that the school is working on the first two. Over-claiming a crisis makes parents more anxious than the data supports. Denying the change makes teachers feel unheard. Neither helps.

    What should a school do instead of a crackdown?

    Pick one measurable problem and resource it properly, rather than launching a program on every problem at once. The evidence that half-implemented behavior initiatives barely outperform doing nothing is the most consistent finding in this literature, and most buildings are running three of them.

    Two candidates stand out from the data in this article. Attendance, because the gap between 15 percent and 23.5 percent is the largest documented change and it feeds everything downstream. And classroom-management support for early-career teachers, because schools themselves asked for it — the share wanting more training jumped from 50 to 61 percent in two years — and because the experience gradient in the federal data is real.

    What the data does not support is a tougher-consequences push sold as evidence-based. Fifty percent of teachers in the 2025 EdWeek survey said tougher consequences would help, and that is a legitimate thing for a profession to ask for. It is not the same as a study showing it works.

    Clay’s take: the question is wrong, and it costs us

    “Is student behavior getting worse” is a question about teenagers. Almost everything actionable in the data above is a question about adults instead. Specifically, about whether students came to school, whether anybody noticed when they stopped, whether the new teacher in room 12 ever got taught how to run a room, whether the period had dead space in it.

    I do not think a kid can wreck a class period that badly on their own. If it happened, something upstream was already broken, and the student is the place it finally showed. That is not an excuse for the behavior and it does not mean the consequence goes away. It means the consequence is the smallest part of the fix.

    The other thing worth saying plainly: students who are poorer or further behind are not a different species with different needs. They need the same clarity, the same follow-through, and the same assumption of competence — and the research on what high expectations actually are is a lot more modest than the posters suggest. Treat the behavior data as information about your building’s systems. It is a poor description of the kids.

    What should you do next?

    Pull your own numbers before you accept anyone else’s narrative. Count how many of your students missed ten percent of the days so far this semester. Count how many of your referrals last month were inattention and low-level disruption rather than anything that would appear in a safety report. If your building looks like the national data, the first number will be larger than you expect and the second will be most of the list.

    Then fix the period before you fix the policy. Start with the prevention side of classroom management, and if attendance is where your numbers are worst, go straight to the absenteeism piece.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Is student behavior actually getting worse, or does it just feel that way?

    Both, depending on which behavior. Educators report worsening consistently and the share saying so has risen every year since 2021, reaching 72 percent in a December 2024 EdWeek Research Center survey. But long-running student-reported measures of bullying and violence are flat or down over a decade. The honest answer is that low-level disruption, inattention and absence got worse while serious incidents did not.

    What is the single biggest measured change in student behavior since 2019?

    Chronic absenteeism. It ran around 15 percent of students before the pandemic, peaked at 28.5 percent in 2021-22, and was still 23.5 percent in 2023-24 across 44 states and the District of Columbia. That is roughly 57 percent above the pre-pandemic rate, and the pace of improvement slowed in the most recent year of data.

    Do phones explain the rise in classroom disruption?

    Phones are a plausible contributor, not a proven cause. In May 2024, 16 percent of public schools told federal surveyors that unpermitted device use was severely hurting learning, and inattention was the top-rated problem at 26 percent. Those figures are consistent with a phone explanation and also with several others. No national dataset isolates the effect.

    Why does federal data show teacher-reported misbehavior going down?

    Because the most recent federal reading is from 2020-21, a year of widespread remote and hybrid instruction. Teachers reported misbehavior interfering with their teaching at 41 percent in 2011-12 and 43 percent in 2015-16, then 32 percent in 2020-21. A drop measured during school closures is not evidence that classrooms improved, and a newer comparable figure is what the field needs.

    Is middle school or high school worse for behavior?

    Middle school, by the federal numbers, though the gap is not huge. In 2020-21, 37 percent of middle school teachers said misbehavior interfered with teaching, against 27 percent of high school teachers. High school leads on a different measure: 45 percent of high school teachers said tardiness and class cutting interfered, against 34 percent in middle school.

    Would tougher consequences fix this?

    There is no national evidence that they would, though half of teachers surveyed in 2025 said they would help. Tougher consequences are a reasonable professional request and a poor evidence claim. What the data does support is boring: better attendance, fewer dead minutes in a period, and real classroom-management training for early-career teachers.

    Are students less safe at school than they used to be?

    Reported incidents mostly say no; students’ own sense of safety says yes. Bullying at school fell from 28 percent of students ages 12-18 in 2010-11 to 19 percent in 2021-22. Over roughly the same period, the share of high schoolers who skipped school because they felt unsafe rose from 7 percent in 2013 to 13 percent in 2023.

    Sources

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Top Cheap Classroom Supplies for Grades 6–12 in 2026

    Top Cheap Classroom Supplies for Grades 6–12 in 2026

    By Clay Shumate

    Most secondary classrooms run on a short list of boring, refillable supplies: pencils, paper, sleeves, markers, folders, cards, clipboards, sticky notes, and clips. The goal is to stretch a limited budget across five or six class periods, so every item has to earn its spot by getting used the very next day.

    Pencils, crayons, colored pencils, a spiral notebook, glue stick, scissors, eraser, paper clips, construction paper, and a ruler arranged on a desk

    For grades 6–12 teachers working on a tight budget, the top cheap classroom supplies are bulk No. 2 pencils, plain copy paper, and reusable dry-erase sleeves, because they get used by every class period, every day, and the sleeves turn one printed page into dozens of uses. Plan how students will borrow and return those supplies before buying anything else, since a supply without a routine disappears by October. New to the classroom? Start with the guide to classroom management for new teachers.

    One note applies to the whole list. Prices, pack sizes, and shipping change constantly, so check the delivered cost on the day you order.

    Quick picks:

    • Best first step: a free routines checklist before spending anything.
    • Best everyday buy: bulk No. 2 pencils for every period.
    • Best reuse value: dry-erase sleeves paired with low-odor markers.
    • Best for organization: two-pocket folders and binder clips.
    Quick picks for cheap classroom supplies, and what each one is for.
    Four picks, and what each one is actually for.

    1) Elevate the Norm’s Free Routines and Procedures Checklist

    The first recommendation costs nothing to download. The Routines and Procedures Checklist is a printable planning pack with space to write your own procedures for entry, materials, help-seeking, transitions, late arrival, and turning in work.

    No email address is required to download it. Printing does cost something, whether that’s school copier paper or your own home ink, so print only the pages you’ll fill out.

    Here’s why it sits ahead of every physical supply:

    • It tells you what to buy. Once you’ve written how students borrow a pencil, you know how many pencils you need.
    • It prevents waste. Supplies without a procedure get lost, broken, or hoarded.
    • It doubles as sub material. A completed checklist shows a substitute how your room runs.

    Next-day use: Fill in the materials and help-seeking sections tonight. Tomorrow, teach just those two procedures in the first five minutes and practice them once with each class.

    If you want more background before writing your own, the broader guide on classroom routines and procedures explains how to teach and rehearse each one with adolescents.

    2) Bulk No. 2 Pencils

    Pencils are the single supply you never want to run out of. A student without a pencil stalls the whole first ten minutes, and a quick, no-drama loaner keeps class moving.

    Buy pre-sharpened woodcase pencils in large packs. For five or six sections, start with roughly two to three dozen in a loaner cup and keep a backup box in a drawer. You’ll replace them all year, so a cheap, decent pencil beats a premium one.

    • Pre-sharpened saves time. A pencil sharpener line during a warm-up is a transition problem.
    • Mark loaners. A strip of colored tape near the eraser makes the class set easy to spot.
    • Add pencil-top erasers. Erasers wear out long before the pencil does.

    Next-day use: Run a retrieval warm-up where students write three things they remember from yesterday’s lesson, in pencil, on a half sheet. Collect pencils at the door using the borrowing procedure you wrote on your checklist.

    3) Plain Copy Paper

    Copy paper ranks this high because nearly every other activity depends on it. Even if your school stocks the copier, a personal ream in the room covers the days the workroom runs dry.

    Buy standard letter-size, 20 lb paper by the ream or case. Cut some sheets in half ahead of time; half sheets work well for exit tickets and stretch each ream twice as far.

    • Exit tickets on quarter or half sheets, one of many formative assessment strategies that cost almost nothing.
    • Source analysis where students annotate a printed primary source.
    • Folded study guides students build themselves.
    • A one-pager assignment that summarizes a unit on a single sheet.

    Next-day use: For a history source analysis, print one short document per student and have them mark the author, date, purpose, and one piece of evidence in the margins. The same sheet becomes a discussion starter for every section.

    4) Reusable Dry-Erase Sleeves

    Dry-erase sleeves give the best reuse value on this list. Slide any printed page inside, and students write on the plastic, wipe, and reuse it next period.

    A class set of 30 to 35 sleeves covers most secondary rooms. Pick sleeves with a reinforced edge, since flimsy seams split early.

    • One copy, many classes. A single printed graphic organizer serves all your sections.
    • Instant formative checks. Students hold up answers, and you scan the room in seconds.
    • Low-risk practice. Wiping away a wrong answer lowers the stakes for hesitant students.

    Next-day use: Put a blank map, timeline, or equation template in each sleeve. Ask four quick questions, have students hold up answers after each, and reteach whichever question splits the room. Keep tissues or old socks nearby as erasers.

    5) Low-Odor Dry-Erase Markers

    Sleeves are useless without markers, and low-odor markers are easier on a full room of teenagers in back-to-back periods. Fine or bullet tips suit sleeves; chisel tips suit the main whiteboard.

    Plan on one marker per student for sleeve work, plus a separate teacher set. Markers dry out faster than any other item here, so they carry the heaviest replacement burden.

    • Cap check before collection. Students click the cap shut and show it before returning the marker.
    • Store tip-down or flat, depending on the brand’s instructions.
    • Keep a dead-marker cup so empty ones never go back into circulation.

    Next-day use: Use markers for a “show me” check during notes. Pause after each key idea and have students write a one-word summary on their sleeves.

    6) Two-Pocket Folders

    Folders are the answer to lost papers. A two-pocket folder per student, kept in the room, holds current work and stops the “I left it at home” problem for anything you don’t send out.

    Buy plain poly folders if you can; they outlast paper versions and survive a full year of handling. Assign a color per class period to make sorting fast.

    • Class work folders: left pocket for in-progress, right pocket for finished.
    • Emergency sub folder: your seating chart, procedures checklist, and two ready lessons.
    • Parent communication organizer: printed Parent-Teacher Communication Logs on one side, notes on the other.

    Next-day use: Build your emergency sub folder tonight. Include a current classroom seating chart for each period, attendance steps, and one lesson that runs without you.

    7) Ruled Index Cards

    Index cards are small, cheap, and surprisingly versatile. Ruled 3×5 cards work for almost everything; 4×6 cards give more room for writing.

    A pack of a few hundred covers months of quick activities across several sections.

    • Get-to-know-you cards on day one, kept for reference.
    • Retrieval flashcards students make and quiz each other with.
    • Exit tickets that sort easily into “got it” and “needs help” stacks.
    • Career-prep interview practice, with one question per card.

    Next-day use: Run a mock interview activity. Write common job-interview questions on cards, pair students, and have them take turns asking and answering. Students then rate one answer on clarity and respect, which connects to communication skills employers look for.

    8) Basic Hardboard Clipboards

    Clipboards make any room a work space. Students can write during gallery walks, hallway activities, or anywhere desks aren’t available.

    Plain hardboard clipboards are inexpensive and durable. A class set isn’t necessary; 15 to 18 covers partner work in most rooms. Get one for yourself too.

    • Gallery walks with posted sources or stations.
    • Outdoor or library work without desks.
    • Teacher observation notes during group work.

    Your own clipboard is useful for private behavior records. Note observable actions (“left seat three times during notes”) with the date and time, and keep the page face down.

    Next-day use: Post six images or documents around the room. Students rotate with clipboards and record one observation and one question at each station.

    9) Sticky Notes

    Sticky notes give every student a quick, low-pressure way to respond. Standard 3×3 pads work best; bulk packs keep the cost per note low.

    Keep a few pads in a shared supply bin and one pad at your desk.

    • Parking lot questions students post without interrupting.
    • Exit polls sorted on the board by answer.
    • Annotation flags in textbooks or novels.
    • Quick reminders for absent students’ work.

    Next-day use: At the end of class, have each student write one thing they understood and one question on a sticky note, then post it by the door. Sort them after class to plan tomorrow’s warm-up.

    10) Binder Clips

    Binder clips are the quiet organizer of a secondary room. They hold stacks of papers by class period, keep sub plans together, and replace staplers for temporary bundles.

    A mixed pack of small, medium, and large clips covers most needs, and they last for years.

    • Period stacks: one clip per class for collected work.
    • Absent work bundles labeled with a sticky note.
    • Cable management for chargers and projector cords.
    • Hanging displays by clipping student work onto string.

    Next-day use: Clip a stack of collected work for each period, then attach a sticky note with the date and any missing names. Grading goes faster when papers stay sorted.

    How to Stretch a Secondary Classroom Supply Budget

    The best way to stretch a supply budget is to buy only what your routines will use every week. Use the table below as a quick comparison of the list.

    How to stretch a secondary classroom supply budget.
    Reuse potential is the column that decides a tight budget.
    ItemDaily useReuse potentialReplacement burdenBest for
    Routines ChecklistPlanningHighPrinting onlySetting procedures
    No. 2 PencilsEvery periodLowHighLoaners
    Copy PaperEvery periodLowHighExit tickets, sources
    Dry-Erase SleevesMost daysHighLowFormative checks
    Low-Odor MarkersMost daysMediumHighSleeve work
    Two-Pocket FoldersDailyHighLowOrganization
    Ruled Index CardsWeeklyLowMediumRetrieval, interviews
    Hardboard ClipboardsWeeklyHighLowGallery walks
    Sticky NotesWeeklyLowMediumQuick responses
    Binder ClipsDailyHighLowPaper stacks

    What Does Your School Already Provide?

    Ask before you buy. Many schools stock copy paper, pencils, or markers in a workroom, and some departments keep shared clipboards or folders.

    Check with your department head, front office, and any supply closet. Ask whether a funding process covers classroom supplies, and whether your school accepts donations from families. Write down what’s available so you don’t duplicate it.

    Which Purchases Remove the Biggest Daily Obstacles?

    Start with whatever stops class most often. If students show up without pencils, pencils come first. If papers vanish, folders come first.

    Watch for one week and note what interrupts instruction. This tells you which purchase will save the most class time. Tie each purchase to your classroom expectations, so students know how the supply fits the way the room runs.

    How Do You Compare Delivered Cost per Usable Item?

    Divide the total delivered price by the number of usable items. Include shipping and tax, since a cheap pack with high shipping isn’t cheap.

    On sites like Amazon, the delivery charge shown on a search page isn’t the product price, so open each listing and check both. Compare the same pack size across retailers like Walmart, Amazon, and wholesale suppliers before deciding.

    When Does Buying in Bulk Actually Save Money?

    Bulk only saves money on items you’ll use up before the year ends. Pencils, paper, and sticky notes are safe bulk buys.

    Markers are trickier because they dry out in storage. Buy them in moderate quantities and restock midyear. Clipboards and binder clips last for years, so one well-chosen purchase is enough.

    How to Make Cheap Supplies Support Reliable Routines

    Cheap supplies last when students know exactly how to use, borrow, and return them. A written procedure for each shared item saves more money than any coupon.

    How Will Students Borrow and Return Shared Supplies?

    Set a simple borrowing system before handing anything out. Students take a loaner pencil from one cup and return it to another cup at the door, or they trade a small item (like a student ID) for a supply.

    Teach the routine on day one and practice it. Keeping supplies moving cleanly is part of smooth classroom transitions. Assign a supply manager role in each class to check bins at the end of the period; it gives students real responsibility, and the list of student leadership activities has more roles like it.

    What Should Be Ready for Tomorrow’s Warm-Up and an Emergency Substitute?

    Prep tomorrow’s warm-up and an emergency sub folder ahead of time. Keep half sheets, pencils, and sleeves ready by the door so students can start immediately.

    For warm-ups, pull a prompt from a list of bell ringer ideas and keep it consistent. For subs, place a folder with your seating chart, procedures checklist, attendance steps, and two lessons in a clearly labeled spot. Add an early finisher activity so the sub has a fallback plan. The sub plans guide covers what else to leave.

    How Can You Keep Behavior Records and Family Communication Private?

    Keep records out of student view and write only what you observed. Use a clipboard or folder that stays at your desk, face down, and never leave notes on a projected screen.

    Describe actions, not character. “Talked during directions twice” is clearer and fairer than “disruptive.” For family contact, a printed communication log lets you record dates, topics, and follow-ups. Include positive calls too, so families hear good news as well as concerns.

    How Will You Know Whether a Supply Is Worth Replacing?

    Track how often each supply gets used and how fast it disappears. If sleeves come out three times a week, replace any damaged ones. If clipboards sit untouched all semester, skip buying more.

    At the end of each quarter, take a quick count. Note what ran out, what broke, and what never got used. That list becomes your next shopping list, and it keeps your spending tied to how your class works.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are the top 10 cheap classroom supplies for middle and high school teachers?

    This list is a free routines checklist, No. 2 pencils, copy paper, dry-erase sleeves, low-odor markers, two-pocket folders, ruled index cards, hardboard clipboards, sticky notes, and binder clips. Each one works across several class periods and has a clear next-day use.

    What should I buy first with a small classroom budget?

    Buy pencils and copy paper first, since they’re used every period. Then add dry-erase sleeves and markers for quick formative checks once those basics are covered.

    Is it cheaper to buy classroom supplies on Amazon or Walmart?

    Neither is always cheaper; prices and shipping change often. Compare the full delivered cost per usable item, including shipping and tax, on the day you order.

    Where can teachers buy school supplies in bulk for cheap?

    Teachers buy in bulk from large retailers, wholesale school supply sites, and warehouse stores. Check for case pricing, minimum orders, and shipping costs before comparing deals.

    Are reusable dry-erase sleeves cheaper than individual whiteboards?

    Sleeves cost less per student in most cases and store flat in a single bin. They also hold any printed template, which individual whiteboards can’t do.

    Where can I download free classroom procedure checklists without giving my email address?

    Elevate the Norm’s Routines and Procedures Checklist downloads free with no email required. More free teacher printables are available the same way.

    When you’re ready for more grades 6–12 materials, the Teacher Emergency Toolkit store on Teachers Pay Teachers has resources you can print and use tomorrow.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.