The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Author: Clay Shumate

  • No Zero Grading Policy: The Math, the Evidence, and the Part Schools Get Wrong

    No Zero Grading Policy: The Math, the Evidence, and the Part Schools Get Wrong

    By Clay Shumate

    A no zero grading policy replaces a score of zero for missing or failed work with a floor, usually 50 on a 100-point scale. It exists because a zero costs a student roughly six letter-grade intervals while every passing grade costs one. The floor fixes that arithmetic. It does not, on its own, get the work done.

    Key Takeaways

    • The argument for a grading floor is arithmetic, not sympathy. On a 100-point scale where 65 passes, the failing band is about two-thirds of the scale while each passing letter grade gets roughly ten points, so a single zero carries a penalty no passing grade can match.
    • The largest study of minimum grading in practice looked at 343,425 sets of grades given to 10,958 students over seven years in one urban high school with a 50 floor, and found no grade inflation. Only 0.3 percent of grade sets started with a minimum grade and ended in a pass.
    • The strongest evidence on the other side is about grading standards, not grading floors. Across 342,098 North Carolina Algebra I students, the strictest-grading quarter of teachers raised same-year test scores by 16.9 percent of a standard deviation over the most lenient quarter.
    • Nobody has run a controlled trial of a no zero grading policy. The leading critique of equitable grading concedes it cites no study measuring the effects of minimum grading itself, and the leading defense comes from one school’s retrospective records. Anyone who tells you the question is settled is selling something.
    • A floor without a required redo is the version that earns the criticism. The policy that holds up pairs the 50 with a recorded reason, a deadline for the real work, and a grade that still says the student has not shown the learning yet.

    Every school argument about zeros collapses into the same two sentences. One side says a zero is the only honest score for work that does not exist. The other says a zero is a punishment dressed up as a measurement. Both sides are partly right, and both sides usually skip the part that decides it, which is what the number does to the average afterward.

    So, in order: what the policy is, the arithmetic that started the fight, what the research on both sides actually found, and the five conditions that separate a defensible floor from a free pass.

    What is a no zero grading policy?

    A no zero grading policy is a grading rule that sets a minimum score for any assignment, so that missing or failed work is entered as that minimum rather than as a zero. On a 100-point scale the floor is almost always 50. The work is still unfinished and the grade is still an F. Only the size of the hole changes.

    Three versions get called by the same name, and they are not the same policy. The first is a bare floor: nothing is entered below 50, and that is the end of it. The second is a floor plus a required redo, where the 50 is a placeholder until the student submits the work. The third replaces the number entirely with an incomplete or a not-yet code until the assignment arrives.

    When a teacher tells you a no zero policy ruined their class, they almost always mean the first version. When an administrator tells you it transformed their school, they almost always mean the second. The two groups are arguing about different rules.

    Why does one zero do so much damage on a 100-point scale?

    A zero is the only score on a 100-point scale that can outweigh a semester of work, because the scale is not evenly divided. A, B, C and D each occupy about ten points. F occupies everything from 64 down to nothing. A zero is not one grade worse than a D; it is about six intervals worse.

    Carifio and Carey put the point plainly in the Mid-Western Educational Researcher: a disproportionate two-thirds of the 100-point scale represents a failing grade, which concentrates every bit of teacher-to-teacher variation at the bottom end of the scale, where it does the most damage. Their summary of the underlying problem is the best sentence written on the subject: “The core and unavoidable problem is the effects of intermittent catastrophic failures.”

    Run the arithmetic on an ordinary grades 6–12 student. Four assignments at 88, 92, 85 and 90 is an average of 88.75, a solid B+. Add one missing fifth assignment and watch what the two choices do.

    Entry for the missing workNew averageLetterPerfect scores needed to climb back to an 80
    Zero71.0C3
    50 floor81.0B0 — already there
    Dropped from the average88.75B+0
    Four scores of 88, 92, 85 and 90, plus one missing assignment. Plain arithmetic, not a finding.

    One missing assignment out of five takes a B+ student to a C, and climbing back to a B takes three more perfect scores that most grading periods do not contain. That is the whole case for the floor, and it is a case about mathematics rather than effort or character. It is also why a four-level scale changes the shape of the problem — though Carifio and Carey note a 0.0–4.0 scale only solves the asymmetry if its minimum is 1.0 rather than zero. The spacing is what matters, not the scale.

    That arithmetic holds whatever letter bands your district uses. A 10 point grading scale moves the failing line to 60, but the 0-to-59 stretch underneath it is still where a single zero does its damage.

    Comparison graphic showing four assignment scores of 88, 92, 85 and 90 and what happens when a fifth is missing: a zero produces a 71 average requiring three perfect scores to recover, a 50 floor produces an 81, and dropping the score leaves an 88.75.
    Same student, same missing assignment, three different entries.

    What does the research on minimum grading actually show?

    The only large-scale study of a school-wide minimum grade found no grade inflation and almost no social promotion. Carifio and Carey analyzed seven years of grading records from one large urban high school with a 50 floor: 343,425 sets of grades across 10,958 students. They report finding no evidence of grade inflation or social promotion.

    The specific numbers matter more than the headline. Only 1,159 grade sets, about 0.3 percent, began with a minimum grade and ended with a passing grade, which is the exact outcome critics predict and it barely happened. 925 students, 8.4 percent of the school, passed at least one course after receiving a minimum grade somewhere along the way, roughly 142 students a year. The authors also report that after adjusting for GPA, students who received minimum grades outperformed peers who never received one on Massachusetts state exams.

    Now the honest caveats, because this is the study everybody quotes and nobody qualifies. Carifio and Carey are advocates for minimum grading, and the article I read is their own point-counterpoint defense of it. It is one school, retrospective records, and no control condition. The design can tell you what happened in a building that adopted the floor. It cannot tell you that the floor caused it.

    What does the evidence against lenient grading show?

    The strongest evidence against lenient grading is about how hard teachers grade, not about whether zeros are allowed. Seth Gershenson tracked 342,098 eighth and ninth grade Algebra I students across about 8,000 North Carolina teachers over ten years and found that students of the strictest-grading quarter of teachers scored 16.9 percent of a standard deviation higher on the end-of-course exam than students of the most lenient quarter.

    The effect carried forward. Those students scored 7.3 percent of a standard deviation higher in Geometry a year later and 8.6 percent higher in Algebra II two years later. It held across subgroups at roughly the same size: 8.2 percent for Black students, 10.3 percent for white students, 10.4 percent for Hispanic students, with the subgroup differences not statistically significant. The effect was slightly larger in less-affluent schools than in more-affluent ones.

    That is a serious result and I am not going to soften it. But read what the study says about its own reach. Gershenson states that “the mechanism that leads from higher standards to higher performance is not clear,” and the report does not study no-zero or grade-floor policies at all. Its only mention of them sits in the implications section as a policy argument, not a tested finding. Grading harder on the work students do hand in is a different variable from what you enter when they hand in nothing.

    The fullest critique of the wider equitable-grading movement comes from Meredith Coffey and Adam Tyner at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, and it is worth reading because it is specific. They assemble real evidence that grades have drifted from achievement: an average ACT-tested GPA of 3.4 in 2021, the highest on record, against composite scores at their lowest since 2010, and TNTP’s finding that students earned the same grade or better in 2022 as in 2019 despite losing about five months of learning. They also cite Figlio and Lucas on stricter-grading teachers producing greater test-score growth, and Babcock’s finding that college students expecting a C studied about 50 percent more than those expecting an A.

    And then they concede the thing the headlines left out. The brief cites no study measuring the effects of minimum grading itself, acknowledges that “it is difficult to quantify the impact of these specific grading reforms on national grading standards,” and allows that “some grading reforms may benefit students.” Its strongest line against the reforms, that there is “not an iota of hard evidence” they help long term, is a claim about missing evidence rather than a finding of harm.

    So the state of the field is this. Nobody has randomized a no zero grading policy. One side has a large retrospective study from an advocate. The other side has strong evidence about a related but different variable and an openly stated absence of evidence about this one. That is not a tie, and it is not a victory. It means the decision has to be made on design and on values, with the evidence informing it rather than deciding it.

    Four rows summarising the no zero grading evidence and naming each sample: Carifio and Carey's 343,425 grade sets in one urban high school, Gershenson's 342,098 North Carolina Algebra I students at 16.9 percent of a standard deviation, the Fordham brief's concession that no study measures minimum grading, and the absence of any randomized trial of the policy.
    Every sample named, including what each one cannot tell you.

    Does a no zero grading policy mean students stop being accountable?

    A floor removes one consequence, and if nothing replaces it, accountability does drop. That is the legitimate complaint and it should not be waved away. Teachers at Leominster Public Schools in Massachusetts concluded that “kids just weren’t learning to be responsible” and the district rescinded its policy, and one teacher in the same reporting described students who could “take half of a year off and still pass.”

    Notice what those complaints are about. Not the number 50 — the missing second half of the policy. A 50 that requires nothing is a gift; a 50 that holds a slot open until the work arrives is a deadline with a different shape. There is also a real argument that a zero was never much of a consequence to begin with. Sarah Duncan of the University of Chicago’s Network for College Success noted in the same reporting that students who get an F tend to withdraw, because “they interpret an F as ‘You do not belong in this environment.’” A consequence that makes a student quit is working as an exit, not a consequence.

    What should a no zero grading policy actually require?

    Five conditions separate a defensible floor from a free pass, and all five are about what happens after the 50 goes in the book. A policy with the floor and none of the rest is the version that gets rescinded two years later. The same test decides whether bonus work belongs in a grade at all: points that measure something other than the standard move the number without moving the learning it reports.

    1. Code every 50 so it says something. A 50 with no explanation tells a student and a parent nothing. Gradebook codes do the work: not mastered, absent, not handed in, did not attempt. One teacher in the Edutopia reporting uses exactly those four so families can see which problem they are looking at. A 50 for a genuine attempt and a 50 for a blank page are different situations wearing the same number.
    2. Keep the floor an F. A 50 on a scale where 65 passes is still failing. If the policy is being sold as protecting students from failure, it is being sold wrong. It protects them from a specific arithmetic distortion, which is a smaller and more defensible claim.
    3. Attach a real deadline to the real work. The floor should hold a place, not close a case. Publish one window, say what happens at the end of it, and hold the line you published. The deadline question deserves its own policy, and the two rules have to agree with each other or students will find the gap in about a week.
    4. Separate the grade from the behavior. If the concern is responsibility, record responsibility somewhere a grade cannot swallow it. Mixing a measure of learning with a measure of compliance produces a number that answers neither question, which is the same problem standards-based grading is built to solve.
    5. Name who keeps using it, and watch the pattern by group. Track which students take the floor repeatedly. Three 50s in a semester is a student who needs something other than a grading rule, and the floor is doing its job only if it buys time for somebody to notice. Run the same count by student group, because a floor applied far more often to one group is either catching a real inequity or hiding one, and you cannot tell which without looking.

    One thing a grading floor genuinely costs you, and the reason the reason codes in condition one are not optional: a 50 is not a measurement. It is a placeholder entered where no evidence exists. A gradebook with nine real scores and one 50 still tells you what the student can do. A gradebook with four real scores and six 50s has stopped being a record of learning, and no amount of averaging will tell you which standard the student missed. That is the strongest objection to the policy and it has nothing to do with accountability. It is why the incomplete or not-yet version is cleaner on the measurement question, and why a floor without reason codes destroys information a teacher needs.

    And one logistical fact that decides whether any of this survives contact with a building: most gradebooks cannot enforce a floor automatically. If the rule depends on every teacher remembering to type 50 instead of 0, the policy will be applied unevenly within the same hallway by November. Check what the software can actually do before the policy is announced, not after.

    Numbered graphic of five conditions for a defensible no zero grading policy: code every 50, keep the floor an F, attach a real deadline to the real work, separate the grade from the behavior, and name who keeps using it.
    Five conditions. The floor on its own is none of them.

    How do you explain a no zero grading policy to a parent who thinks it is soft?

    Lead with the arithmetic and never with the compassion. A parent who hears “we did not want him to feel bad” has every reason to object. A parent who hears “one missing assignment was costing him three perfect scores to recover from, and he is still failing that assignment” is being told something checkable.

    Then say the part most schools skip. The 50 is not the grade for the work; it is the grade for the absence of the work, and it is still an F. The assignment is still due. If the policy does not include that second sentence, the parent is right to push, and the way the message is written decides how the conversation goes more than the policy does.

    The harder parent to answer is the one whose child does every assignment on time. That parent is not asking about arithmetic; they are asking why the gap between their child and a classmate who turned in nothing just got smaller. The honest answer is that it did, by ten points on one assignment, and that their child’s grade is unchanged while the classmate is still failing that assignment and still owes the work. If the policy has no redo requirement, there is no good answer to give that parent, which is another reason the second half of the rule is not optional.

    What does this look like from the student’s side?

    Students read a grading floor as information about whether recovery is possible. That is the honest reason it changes behavior when it changes behavior at all. A student at 71 with three assignments left can do the math and see a path; a student who did the same math and found no path has already decided what the rest of the semester is worth. They also read it as information about whether the adults are consistent, and a floor announced in August and quietly ignored in October is worse than no floor at all.

    And the students who do all the work have a fairness complaint of their own, which deserves a straight answer rather than a lecture about empathy. They notice when a classmate gets fifty points for a blank page. The answer is that the classmate is still failing that assignment, still owes it, and gets no credit until it arrives — and that the student asking is owed the same consistency everyone else is getting. A policy you cannot defend to a sixteen-year-old who did the work is not ready.

    What should a school decide before mandating this?

    A district adopting a floor is making three decisions at once, and most adopt the first and skip the other two. The number, what it obligates the student to do next, and what it obligates the school to do next — which is where the staffing and the money live.

    Carifio and Carey estimate the school they studied saved roughly $1 million over seven years in avoided course repeats, summer school and credit recovery. Treat that figure carefully: it is one school, it is the authors’ own estimate, and savings assume the students who passed had actually learned enough to move on. But it does mean the cost conversation runs in both directions, which is not how the policy usually gets presented to a board.

    Two decisions usually get made by default instead of on purpose. The first is whether teachers keep any discretion. A mandate that strips judgment from every teacher in the building will be worked around, and a rule everyone quietly works around is worse than either option honestly chosen. The second is who chases the redo. The required-work half of the policy is real labor — tracking, reminding, re-collecting, re-grading — and if the answer is “the classroom teacher, on top of everything else,” say so out loud when the policy is announced rather than letting people discover it in week three.

    One compliance item to check before adopting, not after: how the floor interacts with transcripts, GPA calculation and anything your state reports. A grading rule that changes course averages changes the number colleges see, and a district that cannot explain the relationship between its floor and its transcripts has created a problem for its own counselors.

    Clay’s take

    My position starts somewhere slightly different than the research. If a student can fail that badly in my room, the first question is what the planning looked like, and the second is what I was doing for the three weeks it took to get there. A zero that accumulated quietly over a grading period is usually a record of adult inattention as much as student choice.

    So the floor is not the interesting part of this policy. The redo requirement is, and a school that adopts the 50 without it has bought the criticism and none of the benefit. Give a teenager a path back and most of them take it; give them arithmetic saying the semester is already over and some of them believe you. And the honest answer to “what does the research say” is that the research has not been done — which teachers deserve to hear instead of a confident number from whichever side asked first.

    The redo requirement is easier to honor when a second version of the assessment already exists. For the big one at the end of the semester, Mid-Terms.org publishes 200 free printable midterms with answer keys for grades 6–12, and every course comes as a Form A and a Form B, so the student who takes the floor in December has a different paper waiting when the work comes due.

    What to do next

    Pull your own gradebook and find one student whose average is held down by a single zero. Run the arithmetic above on that student and see how many perfect scores recovery would take. If the answer is more assignments than the grading period contains, you have found the problem the floor is built for.

    Then decide the second half before you decide the number. What does the student owe, by when, and what happens when the work arrives? If you cannot answer those three questions, the floor is not ready to adopt. Next, read the late work policy that has to agree with it and the objections to standards-based grading taken seriously, because every real version of this fight ends up in one of those two places. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is a no zero grading policy?

    A no zero grading policy sets a minimum score for any assignment, usually 50 on a 100-point scale, so missing or failed work is entered as that minimum instead of a zero. The grade is still an F and the assignment is still owed. The rule changes only how far a single missing assignment can drag an average down.

    Does a no zero grading policy cause grade inflation?

    The largest study available says no. Carifio and Carey examined 343,425 sets of grades for 10,958 students across seven years in one urban high school with a 50 floor and reported no evidence of grade inflation or social promotion, with only 0.3 percent of grade sets starting at the minimum and ending in a pass. It is one school, retrospective, and written by advocates.

    Why is a zero considered mathematically unfair?

    Because the 100-point scale is not evenly spaced. A, B, C and D each cover about ten points while F covers everything from 64 to zero. That makes a zero roughly six letter-grade intervals below a D rather than one, so a single zero can outweigh several strong scores in a way no passing grade ever can.

    Is there research proving no zero policies help students?

    No. There is no randomized trial of a no zero grading policy. The Fordham Institute’s critique of equitable grading concedes it cites no study measuring the effects of minimum grading itself, and the main study in favor is retrospective records from a single school. Both sides are reasoning from adjacent evidence.

    Does strict grading produce better results than a grading floor?

    Strict grading standards do have strong evidence behind them, but on a different question. Gershenson found that across 342,098 North Carolina Algebra I students, the strictest-grading quarter of teachers raised end-of-course scores by 16.9 percent of a standard deviation. That study measures how hard teachers grade submitted work, not what they enter for missing work.

    What should replace a zero if you do not use a 50?

    An incomplete or not-yet code with a required submission date is the cleanest alternative, because it withholds a number rather than inventing one. Some teachers record the true score on the paper and a 50 in the gradebook with a reason code attached. The common requirement in every workable version is that the real work is still owed.

    How many 50s should one student be allowed?

    Set a count and watch it rather than leaving it open. A student taking the floor three times in a semester needs something a grading rule cannot provide, and the point of the floor is to buy time for an adult to notice. A policy with no counting mechanism cannot tell the difference between a bad week and a pattern.

    Sources

    • Carifio, J., & Carey, T. (2013). The arguments and data in favor of minimum grading. Mid-Western Educational Researcher, 25(4), 19–30. Seven years of grading data from one large urban high school with a 50 minimum: 343,425 sets of grades, 10,958 students; 0.3 percent of grade sets began at the minimum and ended passing; 925 students (8.4 percent) passed at least one course after a minimum grade; estimated savings of roughly $1 million over seven years. The authors advocate for minimum grading, the design is retrospective with no control condition, and it is a single school. Reports the figures of their own 2012 Educational Researcher study, 41(6), 201–208.
    • Gershenson, S. (2020). Great Expectations: The Impact of Rigorous Grading Practices on Student Achievement. Thomas B. Fordham Institute. 342,098 eighth and ninth grade Algebra I students, about 8,000 teachers, North Carolina, 2006–2016. Top grading-standards quartile versus the lowest: +16.9 percent of a standard deviation same-year, +7.3 percent in Geometry, +8.6 percent in Algebra II. Subgroup effects 8.2–10.4 percent, differences not significant. No effect on graduation. The study does not examine no-zero or grade-floor policies; its mention of them is a policy argument in the implications section. Author states the mechanism is unclear.
    • Coffey, M., & Tyner, A. (2024). Think Again: Does “equitable” grading benefit students? Thomas B. Fordham Institute. Assembles the grade-inflation evidence (ACT 2023: average GPA 3.4 against composite scores at a post-2010 low; TNTP False Signals; CALDER and Brookings grade-versus-test gaps) and cites Figlio and Lucas (2004), Gershenson (2020) and Babcock (2010) for stricter standards. Concedes it cites no study measuring the effects of minimum grading itself, that quantifying the reforms’ impact is difficult, and that “some grading reforms may benefit students.”
    • Minero, E. (2018). Do no-zero policies help or hurt students? Edutopia. Cited as practitioner reporting, not a study. Source of the Leominster Public Schools rescission, the gradebook reason-code practice, and Sarah Duncan’s observation that students read an F as not belonging. Describes the 50-percent floor as implemented in districts including Fairfax County and Philadelphia.
    • Minimum grade / grading scale (book excerpt, “Equitable Grading Practices,” p. 84). Corwin. Read as an excerpt; the excerpt does not name its author and ends mid-argument. Sets out the two alternatives — raise the minimum or change the scale — and carries Guskey’s (2004) explanation that secondary teachers keep the zero partly so students feel a consequence. Also cites Reeves (2004).
    • Arithmetic in the table and the recovery counts is my own calculation from the four stated scores, not a finding from any source above.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Executive Functioning Strategies for Students: What Works in Grades 6–12

    Executive Functioning Strategies for Students: What Works in Grades 6–12

    By Clay Shumate

    The executive functioning strategies for students with the best evidence change the environment rather than training the brain. A meta-analysis found training one executive function transfers to that skill (g = 0.44) but not to untrained ones (g = 0.11, not significant). What works in grades 6–12 is externalizing the plan and building in checkpoints.

    Key Takeaways

    • Executive function training mostly trains itself. Across 43 studies of near transfer and 17 of far transfer, training working memory, inhibition or cognitive flexibility produced g+ = 0.44 on the trained component and g+ = 0.11 (p = .11) on untrained ones.
    • Even the gains that appear may not stay. A separate meta-analysis of 90 studies and 8,925 children found executive function can be fostered, but reported no convincing evidence that benefits remained at follow-up.
    • The strongest classroom result here is organizational, not cognitive. In 280 middle schoolers with ADHD, two brief interventions delivered by school staff in under 20 minutes a session beat a waitlist on parent-rated homework problems and organization with large effect sizes.
    • Teaching students to plan and monitor their own work does have real secondary-school numbers. Self-regulated learning training at secondary level averaged 0.54 on academic performance and 0.88 on strategy use, with metacognitive reflection the strongest single component.
    • The same evidence carries a warning for teachers: researcher-delivered versions of these programs outperformed teacher-delivered ones. The gap is implementation and training, which means a half-taught system is a predictable way to get nothing.

    A student who has not started an assignment by minute twelve is not refusing. Usually they cannot find the first move. The gap between knowing what to do and beginning to do it is the single most common thing I see go wrong in grades 6 through 12, and almost nothing in a teacher’s training addresses it directly.

    The industry built around this problem sells brain training — games, apps, working-memory programs, cognitive exercises. The research on that is unusually clear and unusually disappointing. What it supports instead is less exciting and considerably cheaper: stop asking the student to hold the plan in their head. Below: what these skills are, what the transfer research found, the strategies with classroom evidence behind them, how to run this for 150 students, and where the evidence runs out.

    What are executive functioning strategies?

    Executive functioning strategies are the supports that help a student plan, start, organize, hold information, resist distraction and switch tasks — either by teaching a routine or by moving the demand out of the student’s head and into the room.

    The research usually splits executive function into three components: working memory, inhibitory control and cognitive flexibility. In a classroom those show up as holding multi-step directions, not responding to the first distraction, and changing approach when the first one fails.

    The practical taxonomy matters less than the split between two kinds of strategy, because the evidence treats them completely differently. Training strategies try to make the underlying skill stronger — working-memory games, cognitive exercises, apps. Scaffolding strategies reduce how much of the skill the task requires — a written plan, a visible checklist, a checkpoint, a materials system. Most of what gets marketed to schools is the first kind. Nearly all of the evidence favors the second.

    Can executive functioning skills be taught?

    They can be improved on the thing you train, and that improvement mostly does not spread. Training one executive function produced g+ = 0.44 on the trained component and g+ = 0.11 on untrained components, which was not statistically significant.

    Kassai, Futo, Demetrovics and Takacs (2019), in Psychological Bulletin, pooled 43 studies for near transfer and 17 for far transfer across working memory, inhibitory control and cognitive flexibility. Near transfer was clear: interventions did train the component they targeted, g+ = 0.44, p < .001. Far transfer was not: g+ = 0.11, p = .11. Their conclusion is worth quoting in substance — the absence of benefit beyond the trained component calls into question the practical value of training executive functions in isolation.

    The companion paper is gentler and still sobering. Takacs and Kassai (2019) synthesized 100 effect sizes from 90 studies covering 8,925 children and concluded executive function can be fostered in childhood. But they also reported that they did not find convincing evidence for the benefits remaining at follow-up assessment. For typically developing children, mindfulness practices showed moderate effects; for children with neurodevelopmental disorders or behavior problems, learning new self-regulation strategies worked best. Explicit practice on executive-function tasks — computerized or not — produced small to moderate effects, and those effects were consistently weaker for the non-typically-developing children who are usually the reason the program was purchased.

    Both of those studies capped at age 12. That is a real limitation on a grades 6–12 site and it cuts both ways: the discouraging transfer findings are drawn from children younger than most of this audience, and so is the encouraging part. Nobody should be quoting these numbers as high school results, including me.

    Why don’t executive functioning games and apps work?

    Because getting better at a working-memory game makes you better at that game. The skill does not generalize to the untrained skills, and the transfer meta-analysis is explicit that this is why working-memory training has not produced academic gains.

    Kassai and colleagues point directly at that connection, citing the working-memory training literature as the obvious case. If training working memory does not reliably improve inhibitory control — a close cousin measured in the same lab in the same session — there is no reason to expect it to improve a student’s ability to write a document-based essay three weeks later.

    This is not an argument that executive function does not matter. It matters enormously. It is an argument about where the leverage is. A student with weak task initiation does not need a stronger brain; they need the first step written down where they can see it. The second is achievable in a Tuesday lesson and the first is not achievable by any method anyone has demonstrated.

    Which executive functioning strategies actually work in grades 6-12?

    The ones that move the load into the environment: a written first step, a visible plan with times, one materials system taught to mastery, dated checkpoints instead of a single deadline, and a short reflection before submission. Each substitutes a structure for a skill the student does not have yet.

    The strongest school-based evidence here is organizational. Langberg and colleagues (2017), in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, randomized 280 middle school students with ADHD in Virginia to one of two brief interventions or a waitlist. Both were delivered by school mental health providers during the school day, pulling students from electives, in sessions averaging under 20 minutes. Both beat the waitlist on parent-rated homework problems and organizational skills with large effect sizes. The Homework, Organization and Planning Skills program also produced moderate-effect improvements on teacher-rated materials management and organized action behaviors, and outperformed the comparison program on organized actions specifically.

    Note what that intervention consists of. Not cognitive exercises. A binder system, a planner routine, and someone checking it. Students with more severe behavioral dysregulation responded better to the more structured of the two programs, which is the opposite of the usual assumption that struggling students need looser expectations.

    Six rows pairing an executive function that commonly breaks in grades 6 to 12 with an environmental fix: task initiation, planning, materials organization, working memory, self-monitoring and cognitive flexibility.
    Six breakdowns, six structures instead of six skills.
    What is breakingWhat it looks like in grades 6–12The environmental fixWhat the evidence says
    Task initiationTwelve minutes in, nothing on the page, not defiantThe first physical move written on the board: “title and date, then read the first question aloud to your partner”No direct trial. Strongest inference from organizational interventions and from strategy instruction
    PlanningStarts the project the night before it is dueThree dated checkpoints with a product due at each, not one deadlineCheckpoint structure is standard in the organizational programs that worked
    Materials organizationThe assignment was done and cannot be foundOne system, taught to mastery, checked weekly — not three competing systemsDirectly supported: teacher-rated materials management improved with moderate effect sizes
    Working memoryLoses step three of a four-step directionSteps posted and left posted; never deliver four steps verballyTraining working memory does not transfer (g+ = 0.11, ns). Reduce the demand instead
    Self-monitoringHands in work they believe is finished and is notA two-question reflection before submission: what did you do, what is still missingMetacognitive reflection was the strongest component at secondary level (B = 0.82 on performance)
    Cognitive flexibilityFirst approach fails and they stop rather than switchTwo worked approaches modeled, and permission to abandon one named out loudWeakest evidence of the six. Treat as reasonable practice, not a result

    How do you help a student who cannot start?

    Make the first move smaller than the task and physical rather than cognitive. “Start your essay” is a planning problem. “Write the date and copy the question at the top of the page” is not a problem at all, and it ends the frozen state.

    Task initiation is where teachers most often misread the behavior, because a student sitting still with a blank page looks like refusal and is usually paralysis. The two call for opposite responses. A consequence applied to paralysis adds a second problem to the first.

    The sequence that works in my room, and it is three minutes:

    1. Name the state, not the character. “You haven’t started.” Not “you’re wasting time.” One is a fact you can both work from.
    2. Ask which step, not whether they understand. “Which part is the one you can’t get past?” Students can almost always answer this and almost never volunteer it.
    3. Shrink the first move until it is not a decision. Write the title. Copy the question. Read the first source aloud. A move with no judgment in it cannot be gotten wrong, which is what makes it startable.
    4. Stay for the first one. Thirty seconds standing there while they do it, then leave. Leaving before the first move happens wastes the whole conversation.
    5. Come back once. Four or five minutes later, one look, no comment if it is moving. The check is what makes the next one faster.

    The reason this is written as a teacher routine rather than a student skill is the transfer evidence. A student who gets unstuck fifteen times with help has had fifteen models of how to get unstuck. A student who is told to work on their executive function has had none.

    Numbered graphic of five teacher moves for a student who cannot start: name the state not the character, ask which step, shrink the move until it is not a decision, stay for the first one, and come back once.
    Paralysis is not refusal. Three minutes, five moves.

    Does teaching students to plan and self-monitor actually work?

    Yes, and this is where the secondary-school numbers finally appear. Self-regulated learning training at secondary level averaged 0.71 across all outcomes, 0.54 on academic performance and 0.88 on strategy use, with metacognitive reflection the strongest single component.

    Dignath and Büttner (2008), in Metacognition and Learning, pooled 357 effect sizes, 94 of them from secondary school. The secondary results were not weaker than primary — strategy use was actually higher (0.88 against 0.72). In their meta-regression at secondary level, metacognitive reflection carried the strongest effects on academic performance (B = 0.82) and on strategy use (B = 1.45), with motivation strategy instruction next.

    Two findings in that paper deserve to be uncomfortable. First, researcher-directed training outperformed teacher-directed training on both academic performance (B = −0.80) and strategy use (B = −0.64). Second, group work was positive overall at secondary level but negative for secondary mathematics performance (B = −0.65). The motivation figure for secondary rests on a single study and should not be quoted at all.

    The Education Endowment Foundation’s evidence review of metacognition and self-regulation reaches the same general conclusion and adds the same caveat from another direction: most of the underlying research is cross-sectional, so causal claims are hard, and one study it cites suggests higher attainment may drive better strategy use rather than the reverse. It also notes a secondary science intervention that showed no impact alongside poor implementation in many schools, and that programs were effective mainly where they were implemented well with extensive teacher development.

    Which is the honest headline for a teacher reading this. The effect is real and it is contingent on doing the thing properly for long enough. A reflection sheet handed out twice and abandoned is not a small dose of a 0.54 effect. It is zero.

    That researcher-versus-teacher gap is worth reading as an instruction rather than an insult. The difference between the two conditions is training, feedback and somebody watching the implementation — which is the job description of an instructional coach. If your building has one, this is exactly the kind of work to bring them, and the honest ask is not “observe me” but “watch whether my version of this is actually the thing the studies ran.” Nearly every system in this article is easy to half-implement in a way that looks right.

    And on the reflection itself: it is a gate, not a graded item. Two questions on an index card or a form before submission, read in the thirty seconds before you accept the work, not scored. Turn it into a graded assignment and you have added a hundred and fifty things to grade in order to support students who are already behind on grading, which is how this dies.

    How do you do this for 150 students?

    By building the supports into the lesson structure rather than into individual plans. A posted plan, one materials system, dated checkpoints and a closing reflection are classwide and cost no additional minutes once they are routine.

    The individualized version of this work is real and it belongs to special education and school mental health teams. The Langberg interventions were delivered one-to-one by trained providers to students with a diagnosis. A general-education teacher with five sections cannot replicate that and should not pretend to.

    What a classroom teacher can do is remove the executive-function tax from the whole room. If the plan is on the board with times on it, nobody has to hold it. If there is one place assignments live, nobody has to remember which of three places. If a project has three dated checkpoints, no student has to plan backward from a single date, which is the hardest planning task there is and the one we assign most casually.

    One hard line, and it is the most important sentence in this article for anyone with a caseload. A classwide scaffold is not a substitute for a service a student is legally entitled to. Posting the plan does not discharge an accommodation on an IEP or a 504 plan, and “we do checkpoints for everybody” is not an answer to extended time, a separate setting, chunked assignments or organizational support written into a document. Build the classwide version because it helps everyone; deliver the individual services because they are owed. If the two ever get presented as alternatives in a meeting, they are being confused.

    This also reframes who benefits. A posted plan is usually described as an accommodation. It is not — it helps the organized students too, and it means the student who needed it never had to identify themselves to get it. The same logic runs through differentiation that does not require five lesson plans and through the routines worth teaching explicitly.

    One caution on the late-work side. Executive function explains why work arrives late; it does not settle what should happen next. That is a separate argument with its own retracted-study problem, and the evidence on late-work policy is worth reading before you decide a deadline is a scaffold.

    Where does the evidence run out?

    Early, and in four specific places: the transfer research stops at age 12, the classroom trials are clinical samples, nobody has tested the classwide version, and the one measured teacher-versus-researcher comparison went against teachers.

    Five rows summarising the executive function research and naming each sample: the Kassai transfer meta-analysis at 0.44 near and 0.11 far, the Takacs review of 90 studies with no evidence of benefits at follow-up, the Langberg trial of 280 middle schoolers, the Dignath and Buttner secondary-level figures of 0.54 and 0.88, and the Education Endowment Foundation's implementation warning.
    Two meta-analyses say don’t train it. Two say scaffold it.
    • Age ceiling. Both Psychological Bulletin meta-analyses covered children up to 12. Everything said here about transfer is extrapolated upward into grades 6–12, and that extrapolation is an assumption.
    • Clinical samples. The 280-student trial was students with ADHD, delivered by trained mental health providers. Whether the same binder-and-planner routine helps a general-education student with ordinary disorganization is untested, though it is hard to see the harm.
    • No test of the classwide version. Nobody has randomized classrooms to “post the plan with times and run three checkpoints” versus business as usual. The table above is assembled from adjacent evidence, not drawn from a trial of itself.
    • Delivery is a measured weakness. Self-regulated learning training worked better in researchers’ hands than in teachers’. That is the most relevant single finding in this article for anyone planning to run it alone with no training and no coach.
    • Durability is unestablished. One meta-analysis explicitly found no convincing evidence of benefits persisting to follow-up. Nothing here should be sold as building a skill a student keeps for life.
    • Nobody has studied how to take the scaffold off. This is the gap that matters most on a site about student responsibility, and there is no honest research answer to give.

    That last one deserves more than a bullet, because a reasonable student will ask it. If the plan is always posted and the deadline is always broken into three, when does anyone learn to do it themselves? I do not have a study to point at. What I can say is that the alternative — withholding the support so students build the skill under pressure — has no evidence behind it either, and the transfer research gives no reason to think struggling through an unsupported task builds a transferable capacity.

    The defensible position is that the scaffold should narrow rather than vanish. Three checkpoints in the first project, two in the second, one in the third, and name out loud what you are doing and why, so the student is tracking their own progress rather than noticing that the help disappeared. That is a judgment, not a finding, and it is labeled as one. It is also the version that is consistent with how this site thinks about what responsibility actually means — a standard that stays while the support thins out, not a cliff.

    Clay’s take: the room does the remembering

    My classroom runs on lamps. I do not turn the overhead fluorescents on — the light comes from torchiere lamps around the perimeter and a few desk lamps, and the effect is warm and low instead of institutional. I did it because the room is meant to be enjoyed. What I did not expect was how much it changed the start of class.

    The point generalizes, and it is the whole argument of this article. I did not make anyone better at ignoring distraction. I lowered the amount of distraction there was to ignore. That is a worse-sounding intervention and a better-working one, and almost everything in the table above has the same shape.

    The other thing I would say is about the posted plan, because I came to it from a different direction. My method is organization to the minute, and then you pause — the plan goes on the framed whiteboard at the front with times attached, and then you stop talking and let the room settle instead of filling the silence. I started posting times to control pacing. The unintended result is that no student has to carry the sequence in their head, and the ones who cannot carry it stopped being visible as the ones who cannot.

    I will also say what the posted times are not, since this is where it goes wrong. They are a budget and a promise, not a script. When I miss them I say so out loud and give the reason. A schedule nobody acknowledges missing teaches students that the posted plan is decoration, and then it stops working as a support for the kids who were actually using it.

    And one honest admission. Everything above is cheap to start and easy to quit. The posted plan survives in my room because it is tied to how I run pacing, not because I decided to support executive function. The supports that stick are the ones that make your own teaching easier. That is not a research finding. It is the reason most of these systems die in November.

    What to do next week

    Pick one: post the plan with times every day for two weeks, or convert the next project from one deadline into three dated checkpoints with something due at each. Do not do both. Then add the two-question reflection before submission — what did you do, what is still missing — because metacognitive reflection is the component with the strongest secondary-level numbers behind it.

    Skip the brain-training app. If someone is proposing to buy one, the transfer meta-analysis above is the document to put in front of them, and it is one page of abstract. And if you are a parent who already bought one, that is not a parenting failure — the marketing for these products is genuinely persuasive and cites real neuroscience, just not neuroscience that says the product works. The planner routine and the one place assignments live are free, and they are the parts with the evidence.

    Related reading: note taking strategies that survive the research is the working-memory half of this problem, what student responsibility looks like in practice covers the part where the scaffold comes back off, and holding teenagers to a standard without treating them like children is the line this whole topic has to walk. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    When the skill gap is the obstacle: see eight scaffolds that hold up in a secondary classroom — and the contingency finding that explains why most classroom scaffolding never actually fades.

    The working-memory figure most professional development still hands out is seventy years old. Cowan’s review puts the central limit at about four chunks, with individual variation from roughly two to six, and a chunk is whatever a particular student already holds as one unit. What that means for how you lay out a task explains why the same worksheet is a different load for different students, and who pays the highest price for a badly laid-out page.

    A student who cannot get started is a different problem from a student who cannot do the work, and the difference changes what is worth measuring. Once a student is in an intervention, the honest question is whether that intervention is working, which is a question about repeated measures rather than about one good week. The practical version of that, with the evidence stated plainly covers how often to probe, how long before a decision is defensible, and the free tooling whose reading forms stop at grade 8.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are executive functioning strategies for students?

    They are supports that help a student plan, start, organize, hold information, resist distraction and switch tasks. They split into two kinds: training strategies that try to strengthen the underlying skill, and scaffolding strategies that reduce how much of the skill a task demands. The evidence strongly favours the second kind, which includes posted plans, one materials system, and dated checkpoints.

    Can executive functioning skills be improved?

    On the specific thing you train, yes. Beyond it, the evidence is weak. A meta-analysis of 43 near-transfer and 17 far-transfer studies found g+ = 0.44 on the trained component but only g+ = 0.11 on untrained components, which was not statistically significant. A companion review also found no convincing evidence that gains remained at follow-up.

    Do executive function games and apps work?

    They improve performance on tasks resembling the game and do not reliably improve anything else. The far-transfer meta-analysis points to this directly as the reason working-memory training has not produced academic gains. Before a school buys a program, ask what untrained outcome it has improved in a randomized trial, and read the answer carefully.

    How do you help a student who cannot start an assignment?

    Shrink the first move until it contains no decision. “Start your essay” is a planning task; “write the date and copy the question at the top” is not. Name the state rather than the character, ask which specific step they cannot get past, stay the thirty seconds it takes for the first move to happen, and come back once a few minutes later.

    Which executive functioning strategies have the best classroom evidence?

    Organizational ones. A randomized trial of 280 middle schoolers with ADHD found two brief school-based programs — binder systems, planner routines and regular checks, under 20 minutes a session — beat a waitlist on parent-rated homework problems and organization with large effect sizes, and improved teacher-rated materials management with moderate effects.

    Is teaching metacognition worth the class time?

    At secondary level it has the better numbers in this whole topic. A meta-analysis of self-regulated learning training reported an average of 0.54 on academic performance and 0.88 on strategy use at secondary level, with metacognitive reflection the strongest component. The caveat is that researcher-delivered versions outperformed teacher-delivered ones, so a half-run version should not be expected to pay.

    Are these strategies only for students with ADHD or an IEP?

    The individualized versions belong to special education and school mental health teams, and the strongest trials used diagnosed samples. But the classwide supports — a posted plan with times, one place assignments live, three checkpoints instead of one deadline — cost nothing extra and help the organized students too. They also mean a student who needs the support never has to identify themselves to get it.

    Do classwide supports replace an IEP or 504 accommodation?

    No, and treating them as alternatives is a mistake. A posted plan helps everyone and discharges nothing. Extended time, chunked assignments, a separate setting or organizational support written into a document are services a student is entitled to, and “we do checkpoints for the whole class” is not an answer to any of them. Build the classwide version anyway, because it helps.

    Sources

    • Kassai, R., Futo, J., Demetrovics, Z., & Takacs, Z. K. (2019). A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence on the near- and far-transfer effects among children’s executive function skills. Psychological Bulletin, 145(2), 165–188. 43 studies for near transfer, 17 for far transfer. Near transfer g+ = 0.44 (p < .001); far transfer g+ = 0.11 (p = .11), no convincing evidence. Authors conclude the lack of benefit beyond trained components questions the practical value of training executive functions in isolation. Children only; not a secondary-school sample.
    • Takacs, Z. K., & Kassai, R. (2019). The efficacy of different interventions to foster children’s executive function skills: A series of meta-analyses. Psychological Bulletin, 145(7), 653–697. 100 independent effect sizes from 90 studies, 8,925 children up to age 12. Executive function can be fostered, but “we did not find convincing evidence … for the benefits to remain on follow-up assessment.” Mindfulness moderate for typically developing children; strategy-teaching best for non-typically-developing children; explicit task practice small to moderate and weaker for non-typically-developing children.
    • Langberg, J. M., Dvorsky, M. R., Molitor, S. J., Bourchtein, E., Eddy, L. D., Smith, Z. R., Oddo, L. E., & Eadeh, H.-M. (2017). Overcoming the research-to-practice gap: A randomized trial with two brief homework and organization interventions for students with ADHD as implemented by school mental health providers. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 280 middle school students with ADHD in Virginia; HOPS and CHIEF versus waitlist; sessions averaging under 20 minutes. Both beat waitlist on parent-rated homework problems and organizational skills, large effect sizes; HOPS improved teacher-rated materials management and organized action behaviors at moderate effect sizes. Numeric effect sizes are reported as magnitude labels in the record read; the published article carries the values.
    • Dignath, C., & Büttner, G. (2008). Components of fostering self-regulated learning among students: A meta-analysis on intervention studies at primary and secondary school level. Metacognition and Learning, 3, 231–264. 357 effect sizes (263 primary, 94 secondary). Secondary: 0.71 across all outcomes, 0.54 academic performance (n = 34), 0.88 strategy use (n = 54). Metacognitive reflection strongest at secondary level (B = 0.82 performance, B = 1.45 strategy use). Researcher-directed training outperformed teacher-directed (B = −0.80 performance). Group work negative for secondary mathematics (B = −0.65). The secondary motivation figure (0.17) rests on one study and is not quoted here as a finding.
    • Muijs, D., & Bokhove, C. (2020). Metacognition and Self-Regulation: Evidence Review. London: Education Endowment Foundation. Concludes improving self-regulated learning and metacognition can raise attainment, particularly where multiple elements are included. Caveats recorded here: most studies are cross-sectional so causal claims are hard; one study suggests higher attainment may drive strategy use rather than the reverse; a secondary science intervention showed no impact with poor implementation; programs were effective mainly where implemented well with extensive teacher development.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Annotation Strategies for Grades 6–12: What the Evidence Supports

    Annotation Strategies for Grades 6–12: What the Evidence Supports

    By Clay Shumate

    Annotation strategies work when the mark forces a student to think — write a question, restate a chunk in their own words, flag a contradiction. They stop working when students only highlight. A randomized eighth-grade study found structured annotation beat normal instruction by d = 0.46; highlighting alone is rated low utility, alongside rereading.

    Key Takeaways

    • Annotation has one real randomized result in a secondary classroom. In 256 eighth-grade social studies students across five teachers, a structured annotating condition gained an average of 44.19 points pre-to-post against 40.95 for the control, d = 0.458 — a medium effect.
    • Highlighting is not the same thing as annotating, and the distinction decides whether this works. Dunlosky and colleagues rated highlighting and underlining low utility in their review of ten learning techniques, alongside summarization and rereading.
    • When annotation is the untrained control condition, it loses. In 149 fifth and sixth graders reading textbook chapters on ancient Greece and Rome, a trained relational-reasoning group outscored the annotation group (β = 0.25) and the other trained group (β = 0.41).
    • The mechanism that carries the weight is self-explanation. A meta-analysis of 69 effect sizes and 5,917 participants found g = 0.552 for prompting learners to explain material to themselves, with a detectable effect at every level of schooling (high school k = 13, g = 0.426).
    • The federal practice guide for grades 4–9 puts strong evidence behind a bundle, not a marking system: build word and world knowledge, ask and answer questions about the text, determine the gist of short sections, and monitor your own comprehension. Annotation is a vehicle for those four, nothing more.

    Most annotation advice is a list of symbols. Circle unfamiliar words, star the main idea, underline evidence, question mark where you are lost. Students learn the symbols in four minutes and then produce pages that look annotated and prove nothing. I have graded stacks of those pages.

    The research is not about symbols. It is about whether the student had to generate a thought to make the mark. That distinction separates the one condition that produced a medium effect in a real middle school from the condition that lost to a trained comparison group in a journal article the same year. Below: what the evidence shows, the five marks worth teaching, the one most classrooms default to that does nothing, how often to run it, and where the research stops.

    What are annotation strategies?

    Annotation strategies are the specific marks and notes a reader makes directly on a text while reading it — questions, restatements, connections, objections, and symbols — in order to make their own thinking visible. The marks are not the point. The thought required to produce the mark is the point.

    That definition matters because it cuts the category in two. Marking that requires a decision about importance, meaning or disagreement is generative. Marking that requires only a hand movement — a highlighter dragged across a line that felt important — is not. Both get called annotation. Only one has evidence behind it.

    It also separates annotation from note-taking, which it is often confused with. Notes live somewhere else: a page, a document, a two-column template. Annotation lives on the text, which is its one structural advantage — the thought stays attached to the sentence that caused it. If you want the other half of this, the evidence on what belongs on a separate page is a different literature with different numbers.

    Do annotation strategies actually improve comprehension?

    Yes, when it is explicitly taught and structured. The best secondary evidence is one study: 256 eighth graders, randomized by class section, d = 0.458 on unit tests. One school, never replicated — and still more than most classroom reading strategies can show at this grade level.

    The study is worth the detail because the detail is where the usefulness lives. Lloyd, Kim, Cox, Doepker and Downey (2022) ran it in a middle school in the southern United States where over 90 percent of students were economically disadvantaged. Each of five teachers taught two sections; one section per teacher was randomly assigned to annotate. Both groups read the same texts — ReadWorks, Newsela and the standard textbook — and answered the same 20-question pre- and post-tests across a six-week unit.

    The intervention was not a handout. Teachers got two hours of training. Students annotated at least twice a week, a minimum of ten sessions, at least ten minutes each. Series one came out at d = 0.320, series two at d = 0.353, and the averaged comparison at d = 0.458, p < .001. Gender showed no significant main effect.

    Two things in that design are easy to skim past and both matter. First, the dose: twenty-plus sessions over six weeks. Nobody tested whether one lesson on annotation symbols does anything, and there is no reason to assume it does. Second, the population: a high-poverty eighth-grade cohort, which is the population most annotation advice is written for and almost never tested on.

    What annotation strategies don’t work well?

    Highlighting alone is the one to stop teaching as a strategy. Dunlosky and colleagues rated highlighting and underlining low utility across learners, materials and outcome measures, and placed it with summarization and rereading rather than with practice testing.

    Their 2013 review in Psychological Science in the Public Interest graded ten techniques students actually use. Practice testing and distributed practice earned high utility. Elaborative interrogation, self-explanation and interleaved practice earned moderate. Highlighting or underlining, summarization, the keyword mnemonic, imagery for text, and rereading all earned low. The review’s own framing is blunt: the techniques students lean on hardest do not consistently boost performance.

    Why highlighting fails is not mysterious. Deciding what matters in a passage requires already knowing what matters in the passage. A student who can reliably pick the important sentence has largely already comprehended the text, and a student who cannot will highlight the sentence that sounded impressive. Timothy Shanahan made this point in a trade report on the question, arguing that annotation can hinder comprehension specifically when readers lack the knowledge to separate important from unimportant information. That is commentary rather than a trial, and it is worth reading as such.

    The other honest problem is that annotation can lose to something better. Hattan and Alexander (2021), in the Journal of Educational Psychology, randomly assigned 149 rural students to one of three conditions reading textbook chapters on ancient Greece and Rome: a traditional knowledge-mobilization technique, a relational-reasoning technique, or text annotation as the control. Relational reasoning — comparing what the text says against what you already know — scored significantly higher than annotation (β = 0.25) and than mobilization (β = 0.41).

    Read that result precisely. Annotation was the business-as-usual condition and received no training, while the comparison groups did. It does not show annotation is harmful. It shows that untrained annotation is a low bar, and that a trained thinking routine clears it. Note also the grade band: fifth and sixth graders, which sits at the bottom edge of a grades 6–12 audience and below it for half the sample.

    Which annotation strategies work best?

    The five that survive the evidence all require the student to generate language rather than mark a location: ask a question, restate a chunk, name the connection, flag the disagreement, and predict what comes next. Each one is a self-explanation prompt wearing a reading-strategy costume.

    That is not a rhetorical flourish. Self-explanation is the single best-evidenced mechanism available here. Bisra, Liu, Nesbit, Salimi and Winne (2018) pooled 69 effect sizes from 64 reports covering 5,917 participants and found g = 0.552 (95% CI 0.454 to 0.650) for prompting learners to explain material to themselves. Grade level did not moderate it significantly (QB = 3.051, p = .384): elementary g = 0.483, high school g = 0.426, undergraduate g = 0.611. Social sciences specifically came in at g = 0.555 across six effect sizes.

    Numbered graphic of five annotation marks worth teaching: the question, the restatement, the connection, the objection and the prediction, each with the thinking it requires from the student.
    Five marks. Each one is a self-explanation prompt.
    The markWhat the student writesWhat it forcesWhere it fails
    The questionA real question in the margin, ending in a question markNaming what you do not understand, which requires monitoring comprehensionStudents write “what?” Require the question to be answerable by the next page
    The restatementOne sentence per section, in their own words, no copied phrasesDetermining the gist — the practice named in the federal guideCopying. Ban any clause that appears in the text
    The connection“This is like … because …”Relational reasoning against prior knowledgeVague connections to personal life. Require the because
    The objection“I don’t buy this because …”Evaluating a claim against evidence rather than absorbing itStudents think disagreeing with a textbook is not allowed. Say out loud that it is
    The predictionOne line before a section break: what happens or follows nextBuilding a model of the text rather than decoding sentence by sentenceFiction-style guessing on expository text. Ask what the author will argue next
    Highlighting onlyNothingNothing it can be held toRated low utility. Keep it as a locator, not a strategy

    Highlighting still earns a small place. As a locator — mark the three lines you will come back to, then write beside them — it saves time and the writing does the work. The failure mode is highlighting as the finished product.

    What does the strongest evidence actually recommend?

    The federal practice guide for grades 4–9 puts strong evidence behind a bundle of four comprehension practices, and annotation is not one of them. It is a delivery method for three of them.

    The What Works Clearinghouse guide Providing Reading Interventions for Students in Grades 4–9 makes four recommendations. Three carry a strong evidence rating: build decoding of multisyllabic words, provide purposeful fluency-building, and “routinely use a set of comprehension-building practices to help students make sense of the text.” The fourth — practice with stretch text — carries moderate evidence. The comprehension recommendation rests on 34 studies, 23 meeting WWC standards without reservations and 11 with reservations.

    Its four parts are worth naming because they map almost exactly onto the marks in the table above: build world and word knowledge relevant to the passage; give students repeated chances to ask and answer questions about the text; teach a routine for determining the gist of a short section; and teach students to monitor their comprehension as they read. The question mark, the restatement and the comprehension check are items two, three and four.

    A caution for anyone reading this at district level, because it is the predictable way this gets ruined. Annotation is free, which makes it attractive to mandate, and it is visible on a page, which makes it attractive to put on a walkthrough form. Both of those are mistakes. The only result here came from a six-week routine with teacher training behind it, and an annotation box on an observation rubric reliably produces annotated-looking pages rather than thinking — the same substitution of the visible for the real that makes highlighting feel productive. Fund the training and the short texts; do not count the marks.

    This is the most useful reframe in the whole topic. You are not teaching annotation. You are teaching four comprehension practices, and annotation is the cheapest way to make them visible and gradeable on a page you can collect. The same logic applies to what you can actually see a student understanding in any format.

    How often should students annotate?

    The only dose with a result attached is twice a week for at least ten minutes, across at least ten sessions in a six-week unit. That is the schedule the eighth-grade study ran, and the effect belongs to that schedule, not to annotation in general.

    Which means the honest answer to “should I do an annotation day?” is no. One lesson on symbols has no evidence behind it and considerable evidence against the general class of one-off strategy lessons. Annotation that works is a recurring routine on short texts, not an event on a long one.

    It also means short texts. Ten minutes of real annotation covers one or two pages at this grade level, not a chapter. A teacher assigning fifteen pages of annotated reading is assigning highlighting, whatever the directions say.

    And it means solving the problem nobody writing about annotation seems to have: most students in grades 6–12 cannot write in the book. School textbooks are inventoried and reissued, which makes the core instruction physically impossible on the main text in most buildings. The workarounds are all fine and worth choosing deliberately rather than improvising on the day. Print the one page. Use sticky notes, which is what the eighth-grade study did. Put a two-inch margin column on a half-sheet that sits beside the book. Or move the text to a device. What does not work is assigning annotation on a consumable students do not have, which produces nothing and teaches them the assignment was not serious.

    One accessibility note that belongs here rather than in a footnote. The requirement is that the student generate the thought, not that they write it by hand. A restatement spoken to a partner who writes it down, dictated to a phone, or typed is the same cognitive act. Students with writing disabilities, slow handwriting or a hand injury should not be locked out of the one practice here with evidence behind it because the delivery got confused with the strategy.

    Here is the sequence I would run, built from the two studies and the practice guide rather than from the symbol charts:

    1. Pick a text you could read aloud in four minutes. One page. Expository. Something they need for the unit anyway, not a strategy exercise.
    2. Teach one mark. One. Start with the restatement, because determining the gist is the practice with the clearest instructions in the federal guide and the easiest to check.
    3. Model it badly on purpose, then well. Write a restatement that copies three words from the text and ask the room why it does not count. The rule becomes theirs instead of yours.
    4. Annotate the first chunk together, then release one chunk at a time. This is the gradual release the practice guide’s comprehension studies almost all use.
    5. Collect and read for one thing only. Did the sentence require thought? That is a thirty-second judgment per page and you can do a class set in a planning period.
    6. Add the second mark after two weeks, not two days. The question mark next, then the objection. Five marks across a semester is a realistic ceiling.
    7. Keep doing it after it stops feeling new. The result came from twenty sessions. Session four is where most classrooms quit.
    Numbered graphic of a seven-step sequence for teaching one annotation mark: choose one page, teach one mark, model it badly first, release one chunk at a time, read for one thing, add the second mark after two weeks, and keep going past session four.
    Seven steps, one mark at a time.

    How do you stop students from faking it?

    Make the mark impossible to produce without thinking, then grade the thinking rather than the quantity. Every faked annotation page shares one feature: the marks could have been made without reading. Remove that possibility and the problem mostly disappears.

    Three requirements do most of the work. Ban copied clauses in a restatement — any phrase lifted from the text makes the line void. Require the word because in a connection or an objection, which is the self-explanation prompt in its smallest possible form. And cap the number of marks per page, which kills the volume strategy outright; six good marks beats forty.

    The grading question is where teachers rightly get nervous, because an annotation assignment sounds like a stack of unquantifiable pages. It is not. One mark, read for whether it required thought, scored out of two. Collect six pages a semester rather than sixty, and spot-check the rest during the lesson while students are still writing — which is also when the information is useful to you rather than historical.

    Does annotation work on a screen?

    Probably, but nobody has demonstrated it for grades 6–12 with the clarity of the paper study, so treat digital annotation as a reasonable extension rather than an evidenced equivalent.

    The honest state of play: the secondary result above was produced with symbols, highlighters and sticky notes on paper. The sizeable research literature on social annotation tools — shared margins where students see and reply to each other’s notes — sits overwhelmingly in higher education, and transferring an undergraduate result to a ninth-grade room is exactly the move this site tries not to make.

    What does carry over is the mechanism, since self-explanation showed a detectable effect at every level of schooling and did not vary significantly by subject. A comment box that demands a because is doing the same cognitive work as a margin that demands one. The practical differences are mundane: a shared margin changes who the annotation is performed for, and you can see every student’s thinking at once, which beats carrying a paper set around. If devices are the constraint you are working around, reading on screens has its own set of problems worth sorting out first.

    Where does the evidence run out?

    It runs out early, and the gaps are large enough to name plainly: one secondary randomized study, no comparison between marking systems, no high school sample at all, and no test of whether annotation skill lasts past the unit.

    Five rows summarising the annotation evidence and naming each sample: Lloyd and colleagues 2022 with 256 eighth graders at d = 0.458, Hattan and Alexander 2021 with 149 fifth and sixth graders where annotation was the untrained control, the Bisra self-explanation meta-analysis at g = 0.552, the Dunlosky low-utility rating for highlighting, and the federal practice guide's strong rating for comprehension-building practices.
    Every sample named, including the two that cut against annotation.
    • One study carries the grade band. Lloyd and colleagues is a single eighth-grade cohort in one school. It was randomized by section rather than by student, five teachers delivered it, and it has not been replicated. A medium effect from one site is a reason to try something, not a reason to mandate it.
    • No high school evidence. The two classroom studies here are grades 5–6 and grade 8. For grades 9–12 the argument is entirely mechanistic: self-explanation works at high school level (g = 0.426, k = 13), and these marks are self-explanation prompts. That is a reasonable inference and it is not a result.
    • Nobody has compared marking systems. There is no trial showing a five-symbol code beats a three-symbol code, or that AVID-style marking beats a plain question margin. Anyone selling you a specific system is selling a preference.
    • Durability is untested. Both studies measured outcomes inside or just after the intervention. Whether a student who annotated for six weeks in eighth grade still does it in tenth is unknown.
    • The one measured comparison went against annotation. Hattan and Alexander found a trained alternative beat it. If you have time to teach one thinking routine properly, the evidence does not clearly say annotation should be that routine.

    Clay’s take: the margin is the only place I can see them think

    I teach history, so most of what I assign was written by somebody who wanted students to believe it. A question mark in the margin is worth more to me than any comprehension question I could write. The margin tells me where the student stopped following; my question only tells me whether they can answer my question.

    The place this pays off is the whiteboard table. I built that table and it sits in the corner under a lower lamp with a rug and the better chairs, and students ask to go there. When a kid comes over with a page they have marked up, I am not diagnosing them from scratch. The page already tells me where it went wrong, and we start from that sentence. Without the margin I would be asking questions until I found the gap, which costs the whole conference.

    What I will not claim is that I taught annotation well my first few years. I taught the symbols. Students learned the symbols, handed in colorful pages, and understood the reading no better than before. The change was dropping four symbols and keeping one requirement: write a sentence that proves you thought about this, and do not use the author’s words to do it. The pages got uglier and the conferences got shorter.

    And the thing the research says that I would say anyway: a highlighter is a confidence machine. It makes a student feel like they studied. Ask them to write one sentence instead and the feeling goes away, which is the first honest signal either of you has had.

    What to do next week

    Pick one page, not a chapter. Teach the restatement only, ban copied phrases, and require one sentence per section. Collect it on Friday and read for a single question: did this require thought? Then do it again the following week, because the only result anyone has was produced by doing it twenty times.

    If you want the companion pieces: what the evidence says about the separate page covers guided notes and the laptop-versus-longhand fight, five checks that fit a real week is where annotation becomes information you can act on, and the engagement guide has the version of this that sits inside a wider set of routines. Document-based projects are where the objection mark starts earning its keep, and checking who made a source before you read it is the same habit pointed at the open web. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    Annotation is a reading method, not a revision method. If a text is too hard for students to start alone, an interactive read aloud can carry the class through the first pages before the marking begins. When students move from reading the text to preparing for an assessment on it, the study techniques with the strongest evidence are practice testing and spacing — and highlighting rates near the bottom of the same list.

    The payoff shows up fastest on a timed task. Margin notes that record a document’s position rather than its content are what make the grouping step possible when students have to build one argument from several sources.

    Annotation is a during-reading move; it assumes students are already in the text. The before-reading counterpart asks them to take a position first and then go hunting for whatever supports or demolishes it — how to build an anticipation guide covers the three-phase version, including why the column students fill in after reading is the one that does the work.

    Marking a text up is one pass, not the whole job. The protocol that surrounds it gives each reading its own question — what the text says, how it is built, what it means — and confines the marking to the middle one. How close reading works in grades 6–12 sets out that sequence, along with an honest account of why the comparison studies behind it do not exist.

    Marking the page and talking about the page are different acts, and only one of them is audible. Reciprocal teaching puts four comprehension jobs into a student-led conversation, which is the part its originator says is load-bearing. The four roles, and why the dialogue is the piece that works covers what each role asks for, what the roles look like when students are performing them rather than doing them, and how to pick a text that gives the clarifier something to do.

    Before a student can annotate usefully, somebody has to show them what the marks are for. A margin note is the visible residue of a decision, and most students have never watched an adult make one out loud. How to narrate your own reading so the decision is audible sets out the difference between a think aloud and reading a passage aloud, what the federal guides actually rate as strong, and the one head-to-head test in which narration beat nothing at all.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What are the best annotation strategies for students?

    The five with the best support all require the student to generate language: write a real question, restate a section in their own words with no copied phrases, name a connection using the word because, record a disagreement, and predict what the author argues next. Each is a self-explanation prompt, and self-explanation is the mechanism with the strongest evidence behind it.

    Does annotating actually improve reading comprehension?

    In the one randomized secondary study available, yes. Lloyd and colleagues (2022) assigned 256 eighth graders by class section to structured annotation or normal instruction across a six-week unit and found an average effect of d = 0.458 on unit tests. It is a single school and has not been replicated, so treat it as promising rather than settled.

    What annotation strategies don’t work well?

    Highlighting on its own. Dunlosky and colleagues rated highlighting and underlining low utility in their review of ten learning techniques, grouping them with rereading and summarization rather than with practice testing. The problem is that choosing what to highlight requires already knowing what matters, so it rewards students who have comprehended and gives the others nothing.

    How often should students annotate?

    The only schedule with a result attached is at least twice a week, ten minutes or more per session, for at least ten sessions. A single lesson on annotation symbols has no evidence behind it. Short texts matter too: ten minutes of genuine annotation covers one or two pages in grades 6 through 12, not a full chapter.

    Is annotation the same as taking notes?

    No. Annotation lives on the text, so the thought stays attached to the sentence that caused it. Notes live on a separate page or document. They draw on different research literatures with different numbers, and a student can be good at one and poor at the other. Both are worth teaching, but not in the same week.

    How do you grade annotation without drowning in paper?

    Grade one thing: did the mark require thought? That is a judgment of a few seconds per page, scored out of two. Cap the number of marks per page so volume cannot substitute for quality, collect six pages a semester rather than sixty, and spot-check the rest while students are still writing, when the information is useful to you.

    Does annotation work for struggling readers?

    The eighth-grade study was run in a school where over 90 percent of students were economically disadvantaged, which is more relevant than most reading research. But one literacy researcher has argued annotation can hinder comprehension when readers cannot separate important from unimportant information, which is a real caution. Teaching the restatement first rather than importance-marking addresses it directly.

    What if students cannot write in the textbook?

    That is the normal case in grades 6 through 12, and it has four workable answers: print the single page, use sticky notes as the eighth-grade study did, add a wide margin column to a half-sheet that sits beside the book, or move the text to a device. Choose one deliberately. Assigning annotation on a consumable students do not have produces nothing.

    Sources

    • Lloyd, Z. T., Kim, D., Cox, J., Doepker, G. M., & Downey, S. E. (2022). Using the annotating strategy to improve students’ academic achievement in social studies. Journal of Research in Innovative Teaching & Learning, 15(2), 218–231. 256 eighth graders, five teachers, sections randomly assigned; over 90% economically disadvantaged. Series 1 d = 0.320; series 2 d = 0.353; averaged d = 0.458, p < .001. No significant gender effect.
    • Hattan, C., & Alexander, P. A. (2021). The effects of knowledge activation training on rural middle-school students’ expository text comprehension: A mixed-methods study. Journal of Educational Psychology, 113(5), 879–897. 149 rural fifth and sixth graders randomly assigned to knowledge mobilization, relational reasoning, or text annotation as the control. Relational reasoning scored higher than mobilization (β = 0.41) and than the annotation control (β = 0.25). Note the grade band and that annotation received no training.
    • Bisra, K., Liu, Q., Nesbit, J. C., Salimi, F., & Winne, P. H. (2018). Inducing self-explanation: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review. 69 effect sizes from 64 reports, 5,917 participants. Random-effects g = 0.552 (SE = .050, 95% CI 0.454–0.650). No significant moderation by grade level (QB = 3.051, p = .384): elementary g = 0.483, high school g = 0.426 (k = 13), undergraduate g = 0.611. Social sciences g = 0.555.
    • Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students’ learning with effective learning techniques. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58. Practice testing and distributed practice rated high utility; elaborative interrogation, self-explanation and interleaved practice moderate; highlighting/underlining, summarization, keyword mnemonic, imagery for text and rereading all rated low. Read via the journal’s abstract and summary page; the full text sits behind a login.
    • Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse. Providing Reading Interventions for Students in Grades 4–9 (Educator’s Practice Guide). Recommendation 3, “routinely use a set of comprehension-building practices,” carries a strong evidence rating based on 34 studies (23 meeting WWC standards without reservations, 11 with reservations). Its parts: build world and word knowledge; ask and answer questions about the text; determine the gist of short sections; monitor comprehension while reading.
    • Barnum, M. (2023). Annotation can hinder reading comprehension compared to other literacy strategies. K-12 Dive. Cited as a trade report, not a study. Carries Timothy Shanahan’s argument that annotation can hinder comprehension when readers lack the knowledge to distinguish important from unimportant information, and points to the two studies above.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Note Taking Strategies for High School Students: What the Research Supports

    Note Taking Strategies for High School Students: What the Research Supports

    By Clay Shumate

    The note taking strategies with the best evidence for high school students are the ones that change what a student does with the page: partially completed guided notes during the lesson, and self-quizzing from those notes over several short sessions afterward. Handwriting versus typing matters far less than most advice claims.

    Key Takeaways

    • Guided notes — a partially completed handout students fill in — have the strongest numbers here. A meta-analysis of 12 studies and 1,529 students found an overall effect of d = 0.546 against student-generated notes, though every study was post-secondary.
    • The famous pen-beats-laptop study was run on 65 Princeton and 151 UCLA subject-pool students, and a 2019 direct replication did not reproduce it. Two experiments found no consistent difference, and the effect shrank further once students studied their notes.
    • Note-taking’s own benefit is real but modest. Across 57 comparisons of note-taking against no note-taking, the effect was described as positive but modest — and higher grade levels did not increase it.
    • What a student does afterward is where the big, well-replicated effects live. Practice testing and spacing study across sessions were both rated high utility in a major review; summarization, highlighting and rereading were all rated low.
    • Teach one format, teach it explicitly, and then spend your time on the review step. There is no credible secondary-school trial showing one template beats another.

    Almost every article on this subject answers a different question than the one students are asking. Teenagers want to know what to put on the page; the research is mostly about what happens to the page afterward. That gap explains why so much note-taking advice feels true and changes nothing.

    Below is what holds up: five strategies ordered by what they cost a teacher, the honest version of the handwriting-versus-laptop fight, the one intervention with real numbers behind it, and the review step that does most of the actual work.

    What are the best note taking strategies for high school students?

    Five, in order of what they cost you to run: guided notes, a two-column page with a question margin, a hard stop for processing, pair-and-compare, and self-quizzing from the notes later in the week. The last one carries the most evidence.

    1. Guided notes — costs one planning block, once. Hand out the lesson’s structure with the key terms, figures and transitions left blank. Put the blanks on the items that carry the reasoning, not on incidental detail — a page of fill-in-the-blank trivia is a worksheet wearing a strategy’s name. Students write less and think more, and nobody loses the thread because they were still copying the previous slide.
    2. A question margin — costs nothing. Students rule off the left third of the page and write questions there, not content. The content goes on the right. The margin turns the page into a quiz by Friday instead of a transcript, which is the whole point of the two-column formats.
    3. A hard stop to process — costs three minutes. Stop talking twice a lesson and have students finish a sentence, fill a gap, or write the one thing they are not sure about. Taking notes while listening is a split-attention task; a pause is how you stop charging students for your pacing.
    4. Pair and compare — costs two minutes. Students swap pages and add what they missed in a different colour. It surfaces gaps immediately, it is the cheapest formative check in the room, and it runs on the same mechanics as any other structured student talk.
    5. Self-quizzing from the notes — costs the student time, not you. Cover the right column, answer the questions in the margin, check. Three short sessions across the week, not one long one the night before. This is the step with the strongest research in the entire article and the one students skip.

    Notice that four of the five change the page and the fifth changes the week. If you only have the appetite for one, take the fifth. And be realistic about the first: one guided-notes page for the hardest lesson in a unit is achievable and reusable next year; one for every lesson is not, and a plan that assumes it will collapse by October.

    Numbered graphic of five note taking strategies ordered by teacher cost: guided notes, a question margin, a hard stop to process, pair and compare, and self-quizzing from the notes.
    Five strategies, ordered by what they cost you to run.

    Is handwriting notes better than typing on a laptop?

    Probably a little, in some conditions, on a question nobody has properly tested on high schoolers. The original finding was real; the direct replication did not reproduce it, and both studies ran on university students.

    Pam Mueller and Daniel Oppenheimer’s 2014 study in Psychological Science is the source of every “the pen is mightier” headline. In Study 1, 65 students from the Princeton subject pool took notes on five TED Talks. On factual questions there was no difference at all. On conceptual questions the longhand group did better. Laptop notes averaged 309.6 words against 173.4 longhand, with 14.6 percent verbatim overlap with the talk against 8.8 percent — which is the mechanism the authors proposed: typing fast enough to transcribe means you can skip the thinking.

    Study 2, with 151 UCLA subject-pool students, added a group told explicitly not to transcribe. The instruction did nothing — verbatim overlap was 12.07 percent with the warning and 12.11 percent without it. Study 3 tested a week’s delay and found no main effect of method at all; the only significant result was an interaction, where longhand students who got ten minutes to study their notes outperformed the other three groups.

    Then in 2019, Kayla Morehead, John Dunlosky and Katherine Rawson published a direct replication and extension in Educational Psychology Review. In their first experiment longhand students did better on factual questions and showed no advantage on conceptual ones — the opposite pattern to the original. Their second experiment found no significant difference at all on an immediate test, and a group that took no notes did not perform worse than the note-takers. Across two delayed tests, method had no effect. Their meta-analysis of the direct replications found small, non-significant effects favouring longhand, and they concluded that naming a superior method “seems premature.”

    StudyWho it was run onWhat it foundWhat it means for a 10th grader
    Mueller & Oppenheimer (2014), Study 165 Princeton subject-pool studentsNo difference on factual questions; longhand better on conceptual. Laptop notes 309.6 words vs 173.4, 14.6% vs 8.8% verbatimThe mechanism is transcription, not the pen. A typist who paraphrases is not the person in this study
    Mueller & Oppenheimer (2014), Study 2151 UCLA subject-pool studentsTelling laptop users not to transcribe changed nothing — 12.07% vs 12.11% verbatimDo not expect a reminder to fix it. Change the task instead
    Mueller & Oppenheimer (2014), Study 3109 UCLA subject-pool students, one-week delayNo main effect of method. Longhand plus ten minutes of study beat everything elseThe study step is doing the work in the one result that survived a delay
    Morehead, Dunlosky & Rawson (2019)Undergraduates, two experiments plus a replication meta-analysisLonghand advantage on factual, not conceptual; no consistent difference overall; a no-notes group matched the note-takersNobody should be telling your students the question is settled
    Any of them, on teenagers—Not testedEvery number above comes from a university lab. Treat the transfer as an assumption

    The defensible position for a high school teacher: if a student is transcribing instead of thinking, that is a problem whatever they are typing on, and the fix is a page that cannot be transcribed — which is what guided notes and a question margin are for. The same requirement, applied to the text itself rather than a separate page, is what separates annotation that works from highlighting. Banning laptops on the strength of a Princeton lab study is more certainty than the evidence supports. None of which overrides a device policy your school has already set; if yours restricts laptops, that is a conversation to have with an administrator rather than a rule to quietly ignore.

    Does taking notes actually help, or just feel productive?

    It helps, modestly. Across 57 studies comparing note-taking with no note-taking, the benefit of the act of writing was positive but small, and it did not get larger in higher grades.

    Keiichi Kobayashi’s meta-analytic examination of the encoding effect in Contemporary Educational Psychology looked at exactly this. Three of its findings are worth a teacher’s time. Interventions designed to improve note-taking did not reliably increase the benefit, and neither did a higher schooling level. Visual presentation of the material interfered with note-taking — a useful limit to hold next to what pairing words with pictures does and does not buy you. And recall tests picked up the effect more readily than recognition or higher-order tests did — so the gain is clearest on the kind of question that asks students to produce something, and least clear on the kind we say we care about most.

    That middle finding deserves a sentence on its own. If you are projecting a dense slide and talking over it while students write, you are running the condition that interfered. The three minutes of silence in strategy 3 above is not a courtesy; it is the correction, and it is the same reason the first five minutes of a lesson are worth protecting.

    Five rows summarising the laptop versus longhand research, naming the sample for each: 65 Princeton students, 151 UCLA students, 109 UCLA students at a one-week delay, the 2019 undergraduate replication, and a final row noting teenagers were never tested.
    Every number here comes from a university lab.

    Do guided notes work better than letting students take their own?

    Yes, by a clear margin against blank-page notes, and by much less against a full set of teacher-provided notes. That second comparison is the one that tells you what to hand out.

    Karen and David Larwin’s meta-analysis of guided notes pooled 12 studies, 27 effect sizes and 1,529 students. The overall effect was d = 0.546 (95% CI 0.342 to 0.749), which the authors describe as the average guided-notes student outperforming about 72 percent of students without them. Twenty-one of the 27 effects were positive.

    The moderator analysis is the practical part. Against students generating their own notes from scratch, guided notes returned d = 0.781. Against a full set of professor-provided lecture notes, d = 0.265 — small, though still significant. In other words most of the value is in giving students structure, and you lose a lot of it by filling the structure in for them. The blanks are the intervention.

    Two honest wrinkles. Every included study was post-secondary — the authors found no graduate studies and, relevant here, no secondary ones. And the discipline breakdown was not uniform: education d = 0.749, physics d = 0.614, psychology d = 0.603, but mathematics came out at d = −0.355 and dentistry at −0.142, neither significant. A procedural subject where the working is the content may not behave like a content-heavy one, and a maths teacher should treat this as untested rather than as support. Scaffolding the task without lowering the standard is the same principle that governs any other differentiation decision.

    What should students do with their notes after class?

    Quiz themselves from the notes, in short sessions spread across several days. Those two moves have the best-replicated evidence in the whole study-skills literature, and they are the two students almost never make.

    Dunlosky and colleagues’ review of ten learning techniques in Psychological Science in the Public Interest rated practice testing and distributed practice high utility — the authors note these benefited students across many ages and ability levels. Rated low utility: summarization, highlighting and underlining, rereading, keyword mnemonics and imagery for text. On highlighting, the review found most studies show no benefit beyond simply reading the text.

    Read that list next to what students actually do with notes, and the problem is obvious. Rereading the page and highlighting it are the two default behaviours, and they are both in the low column. So the review routine worth teaching is four steps:

    1. Cover the content. The question margin stays visible; everything else is hidden.
    2. Answer out loud or in writing. Produce the answer before checking. Looking first converts a test into a reread, which is exactly the swap that kills the benefit.
    3. Check and mark the misses. Only the misses. A short list of what you got wrong is the study list.
    4. Come back in two days, then before the test. Three ten-minute passes beat one thirty-minute pass, and the spacing is doing the work, not the total. It is also less total time than cramming, which is worth saying to a student carrying six other subjects.

    For families asking what to buy: nothing. No pen, app or subscription in this literature outperforms a covered page and a question. If a parent wants to help, the useful job is asking their teenager to answer three questions from the margin out loud on Wednesday — not checking whether the notes look neat, which is the thing that is easy to see and does not matter.

    If you want this to happen rather than to be recommended, put the first pass in class. Two minutes of covered-column quizzing as a starter costs almost nothing and is the same trade as retrieval on old material for early finishers. Students who have done it once with you are considerably more likely to do it alone.

    Should I teach Cornell notes or another format?

    Teach one format explicitly, then stop optimising the format. There is no credible secondary-school trial showing that a particular template beats another, and the research weight sits on use rather than layout.

    Cornell’s structure — a cue column, a notes column, a summary strip — is sensible and the cue column is doing the job the question margin above does. What it does not have is a body of randomized evidence in grades 6–12 saying it outperforms a well-run two-column page. Treat it as a reasonable default rather than an evidence-based one, and be honest with students that you are choosing it for consistency. The summary strip is the hardest square on the page to teach well, and the research on summarizing disagrees with itself about how much that skill is worth.

    What does matter, and what teachers routinely skip, is teaching the format like content: model a page under a document camera, show a bad example next to a good one, and look at students’ actual pages more than once in the first fortnight. A format assigned and never inspected is a format that quietly becomes a transcript again.

    Three things to look for when you do inspect one, because “are these good notes?” is not a question you can answer by glancing: are any of the words the student’s own rather than yours, is there at least one question on the page, and is anything marked as not understood. A page with none of those is a transcript, whatever template it is on. If the format in question is a structure students keep for a whole term, the same inspection question runs through our piece on what to require in an interactive notebook.

    And leave a door open. A student who already has a system that works — and some do, including ones that look like nothing you would recommend — should be allowed to keep it once they can show you it passes those three tests. Forcing a template onto a method that is already working is the kind of compliance exercise this site exists to argue against.

    Numbered graphic of a four-step note review routine: cover the content, answer before you check, mark only the misses, and come back in two days and again before the test.
    The step students skip, in four moves.

    Where does the evidence run out?

    Almost immediately, once you ask about teenagers specifically. Every quantitative claim in this article comes from a population that is not a high school class.

    • The laptop-versus-longhand literature is university students — Princeton and UCLA subject pools in the original, undergraduates in the replication. There is no equivalent trial on 15-year-olds, and the replication failed on the adults it was run on.
    • The guided-notes meta-analysis contains no secondary studies at all. Its authors say they found none at graduate level and the included work is undergraduate. The d = 0.546 is a real number about a different population.
    • Kobayashi’s review reports the gain most clearly on recall tests and least clearly on higher-order ones. If what you care about is analysis rather than retrieval, the encoding effect is on weaker ground.
    • Nothing above is broken out for students with disabilities, or for English learners, or for students who cannot write at speed. Guided notes are widely recommended as an access measure and that recommendation is older than the evidence base quoted here; check the accommodations on file rather than inferring from a meta-analysis.
    • No study here tested a format. Cornell, outline, mapping, charting — the comparative question is effectively unanswered in secondary classrooms.

    Clay’s take: I have taught this at three levels of device access

    The laptop question looks different to me than to most people arguing about it, because I have taught at all three levels of device access.

    My second year, devices meant one cart shared between two classrooms. By my final year before my current school it was one device per student, and it is 1:1 again now.

    What that taught me is that the device is rarely the variable. On the shared-cart years students wrote everything by hand and most of it was still a transcript. The pages that were worth anything were the ones where the task made transcription impossible — blanks to fill, a question to write, a partner’s page to compare against. That is a design choice, not a stationery choice.

    I also take the research’s own hint seriously: I am circulating for most of the period, which means I can see what is actually on the page while there is still time to do something about it. A page that is three slides behind tells me something a quiz on Friday cannot, and it is the same reason pulling a few students to a table beats reteaching the whole room.

    And I would rather be honest with students than tidy. When a teenager asks whether handwriting makes them remember more, the true answer is that the study everyone quotes was run on college students and did not replicate, and that what they do on Wednesday with Monday’s notes matters more than which hand they used. Treating them as people who can hear that is most of what this site is about.

    What to do next week

    Five moves, and none of them needs a purchase or a new system. Build one guided-notes page, add two silent stops, teach the question margin once, run the first review pass in class, and then look at four pages to see whether any of it landed.

    1. Pick your busiest content lesson and build one guided-notes page for it. Leave the key terms, the figures and the transitions blank, and nothing else.
    2. Add two three-minute stops to that lesson where you are not talking.
    3. Teach the question margin once, explicitly, with a bad example beside a good one.
    4. Put a two-minute covered-column quiz at the start of the next lesson so students have done the review step with you before you ask them to do it alone.
    5. Walk the room and look at four pages. If they are transcripts, the task needs changing before the format does.

    If you want the next step after notes, the same retrieval logic is what makes test corrections teach instead of hand back points, and the quickest checks for whether any of it landed are the five-minute formative ones. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    Good notes are the raw material; what a student does with them afterwards is the other half. The study skills evidence ranks ten common review methods and puts rereading those notes near the bottom — well below testing yourself on them.

    A reference in a student’s own notebook and a reference on the classroom wall are not the same tool, and in secondary the wall is the weaker of the two. The reason is social rather than cognitive: a sixteen-year-old will not turn toward a chart in front of twenty-nine classmates if looking means admitting she forgot. Why the wall is the weakest part of the anchor chart covers that cost, the fix that makes consulting a reference private, and what the classroom-display research actually measured.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is the best note taking strategy for high school students?

    Guided notes during the lesson plus self-quizzing from them afterward. The guided handout gives students structure without letting them transcribe, and the quizzing is where the best-replicated evidence sits: practice testing and spacing study across several short sessions were both rated high utility in a major review of learning techniques, while rereading and highlighting were rated low.

    Is it better to write notes by hand or type them?

    The honest answer is that nobody has shown this clearly for high schoolers. The well-known study favouring handwriting used Princeton and UCLA subject-pool students, and a 2019 direct replication did not reproduce it — in one experiment a no-notes group did as well as the note-takers. If a student is transcribing rather than thinking, change the task rather than the tool.

    What are guided notes?

    A partially completed handout that carries the lesson’s structure with key terms, figures and transitions left blank for students to fill in. A meta-analysis of 12 studies and 1,529 students found d = 0.546 against student-generated notes but only d = 0.265 against a full set of teacher-provided notes, which suggests the blanks are what matters.

    Are Cornell notes evidence-based?

    Cornell’s cue column is a sound idea and the format is a reasonable default, but there is no credible randomized trial in grades 6–12 showing it beats another well-run two-column page. Pick one format for consistency, teach it explicitly, and spend the rest of your effort on whether students actually review from it.

    How should students review their notes?

    Cover the content, answer the questions in the margin from memory, check, and mark only what was missed. Then repeat in two days and again before the test. Three ten-minute passes beat one thirty-minute session, because the spacing is doing the work rather than the total time.

    Does taking notes even make a difference?

    A modest one. Across 57 studies comparing note-taking with no note-taking, the benefit of the writing itself was described as positive but modest, and higher grade levels did not increase it. The same review found visual presentation of the material interfered with note-taking, which is a reason to stop talking over a dense slide.

    How do I help a student who cannot write fast enough to keep up?

    Start with the accommodations or plan on file rather than improvising, then give that student the guided-notes page with more filled in and the same blanks everyone else has for the key ideas. Reducing the transcription load is not reducing the standard, and a page the student can finish is a page they can revise from.

    Sources

    • Mueller, P. A., & Oppenheimer, D. M. (2014). The pen is mightier than the keyboard: Advantages of longhand over laptop note taking. Psychological Science, 25(6), 1159–1168. Study 1: 65 Princeton subject-pool students. Study 2: 151 UCLA subject-pool students. Study 3: 109 UCLA subject-pool students with a one-week delay. No high school sample in any study; the Study 3 main effect was null and the surviving result was an interaction with a ten-minute study period.
    • Morehead, K., Dunlosky, J., & Rawson, K. A. (2019). How much mightier is the pen than the keyboard for note-taking? A replication and extension of Mueller and Oppenheimer (2014). Educational Psychology Review, 31(3), 753–780. Abstract read via ERIC; the experiment-level detail quoted here (the factual versus conceptual reversal, the no-notes group, the effect of studying notes) was read in the Learning Scientists’ summary of the paper and is attributed to that summary rather than to a reading of the full text, which sat behind a publisher paywall.
    • Kobayashi, K. (2005). What limits the encoding effect of note-taking? A meta-analytic examination. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 30(2), 242–262. 57 note-taking versus no note-taking comparisons. Abstract read; it describes the overall effect as positive but modest without giving a figure in the abstract, so no number is quoted here. Schooling level did not increase the benefit; visual presentation interfered; recall tests detected the effect more than recognition or higher-order tests.
    • Larwin, K. H., & Larwin, D. A. (2013). The impact of guided notes on post-secondary student achievement: A meta-analysis. International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, 25(1), 47–58. 12 studies, 27 effect sizes, 1,529 participants, all post-secondary. Overall d = 0.546; d = 0.781 against student-generated notes and d = 0.265 against full provided notes; mathematics d = −0.355 and dentistry d = −0.142, neither significant.
    • Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students’ learning with effective learning techniques. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58. Practice testing and distributed practice rated high utility; summarization, highlighting/underlining, rereading, keyword mnemonics and imagery rated low; elaborative interrogation, self-explanation and interleaved practice rated moderate.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • How to Talk to a Student Who Is Failing: What to Say, and When

    How to Talk to a Student Who Is Failing: What to Say, and When

    By Clay Shumate

    Talk to a student who is failing privately, early, and about one specific thing rather than the whole grade. Name what is missing, ask what is getting in the way, say plainly that you expect them to reach the standard, and leave with one task and one date. Then check back when you said you would.

    Key Takeaways

    • A failing grade is usually the last signal, not the first. In Chicago Public Schools, freshman absences alone explained 63 percent of the variation in course failures, against 8 percent for eighth-grade test scores.
    • Private, specific and early beats comprehensive. One behaviour, one question, one task, one date. A conversation that covers nine problems gives the student nothing to do tonight.
    • In a randomized study of 44 seventh graders, attaching one sentence to critical feedback — high expectations, and I know you can reach them — raised essay revision among African American students from 17 to 71 percent. A 44-student study is promising, not settled.
    • Ask what is getting in the way, not what is wrong at home. The American School Counselor Association states that even school counselors do not diagnose; a teacher notices and routes.
    • Structured follow-up has the clearest evidence and the clearest limit: in the two randomized trials the What Works Clearinghouse accepted on Check & Connect, the programme had positive effects on staying in school and no discernible effects on completing school.

    Most of these conversations go wrong in the first thirty seconds, and almost never because the teacher was unkind. It is because the teacher opened with the grade. A 41 on a progress report is an aggregate of a dozen decisions a student has already made and mostly cannot undo, so leading with it hands a teenager a number they cannot act on and a feeling they will act on instead.

    What follows is the structure that holds up: when to have the conversation, the six things it needs, the four very different situations a failing grade can mean, the sentences to leave out, and the honest research on all of it — including the part that found no effect on graduation.

    What should you say to a student who is failing?

    Say one specific thing that is missing, ask one open question about what is getting in the way, state that you expect them to reach the standard, and agree one task with a date on it. Six moves, in order, and the whole thing fits in four minutes.

    1. Pick the moment, not the lesson. After class, at your table, during independent work — anywhere the rest of the room is not an audience. A conversation about a failing grade held within earshot of twenty-eight people is a performance, and the student will play their part in it.
    2. Open with the specific, not the total. “You have three missing assignments and two of them are the ones the unit test is built on.” Not “you are failing my class.” The first sentence is a problem with an edge on it. The second is a verdict.
    3. Ask what is getting in the way, then stop talking. This is the question most teachers skip because they already have a theory. Ask it anyway. The answer is frequently logistical — a shared laptop, a shift that ends at eleven, a folder lost in a locker change — and logistical problems have fixes.
    4. Say the expectation out loud. Not a pep talk. One sentence: this standard is the standard, and you can reach it. The research below suggests that sentence does real work, particularly with students who have reason to wonder whether the adult in front of them has already written them off.
    5. Agree one task and one date — and let the student pick them. Ask which one they want to start with and when it will be done. A teenager who names the date is holding their own deadline; one who is handed it is complying with yours. The student who owes eleven assignments needs the first one back, not a recovery plan.
    6. Say when you will check, and then check. A follow-up that does not happen teaches the student that the conversation was for your records. That is the part teachers drop, and it is the part that carries the evidence.
    Numbered graphic of six moves in a conversation with a failing student: pick the moment, open with the specific, ask what is getting in the way, say the expectation out loud, agree one task and one date, and say when you will check.
    Six moves, in order. The whole thing fits in four minutes.

    When is the right time to have this conversation?

    Before the grade is failing. The warning signs that predict a failed course are attendance and missing work, and both are visible weeks earlier than the average on a progress report.

    The clearest evidence on this is still Elaine Allensworth and John Easton’s on-track study of Chicago Public Schools freshmen, and the numbers are blunt. Fifty-three percent of CPS freshmen failed at least one semester course. Students who ended ninth grade on-track graduated in four years at about 82 percent; students who were off-track graduated at about 22 percent. And freshman absences alone explained 63 percent of the variation in course failures, against 8 percent for eighth-grade test scores.

    Their sentence on absence is the one worth pinning above a gradebook: “Just one week of absence per semester indicates problems with students’ grades.” Not two weeks. One. Students with the lowest eighth-grade test scores who missed one week averaged fewer Fs (1.3) than top-scoring students who missed two (2.1).

    That is one large urban district and a cohort that entered high school in 2000–01, so the percentages are not national facts. The ordering has held up well enough that most early-warning systems use the same signals, and the lesson for a teacher is simple: check the attendance column before building a theory about motivation. The reasons behind a pattern of absence are mostly outside your room, which is a separate problem with its own evidence base.

    Does telling a student you believe in them actually help?

    One sentence of it, attached to critical feedback, has measurable support. Open-ended encouragement that is not attached to anything does not. The distinction matters more than the sentiment.

    David Yeager and colleagues ran a set of field experiments on what they called wise feedback. Seventh graders handed back a marked-up essay received one of two notes. The control note read: “I’m giving you these comments so that you’ll have feedback on your paper.” The other read: “I’m giving you these comments because I have very high expectations and I know that you can reach them.”

    Seventy-one percent of African American students who got the second note revised their essay, against 17 percent who got the first. For White students the difference — 87 against 62 percent — was not statistically significant. Among African American students who had reported low trust in the school, none of the control group revised and 82 percent of the treated group did. A second study the following year found treated students incorporated 5.54 of the teacher’s edits against 2.19.

    The caveats are large. Each study had 44 students, and only students carrying B or C averages were eligible — which the authors say limits how far this travels to the students a teacher would call failing. The race-by-condition interaction was not significant, and the authors call the trust findings tentative. It is a reason to say the sentence, not proof that saying it fixes a grade.

    What it does explain is why the sentence is not flattery. The mechanism is attribution: a student handed hard criticism has to decide whether it means the teacher thinks they can do better or thinks they cannot. Most teachers mean the first and say neither.

    Four rows naming each study behind the article and who it was run on: the Chicago on-track indicator, a 44-student wise-feedback experiment, a 99-study relationships meta-analysis, and two Check and Connect trials.
    Every finding, with the population it came from.

    It is also worth knowing that the relationship itself matters more in high school than most people assume, not less. Debora Roorda and colleagues’ meta-analysis of 99 studies and 129,423 students found positive teacher–student relationships associated with engagement at r = .39 overall, and the secondary-school estimates were larger than the primary ones — r = .30 to .40 for engagement across 23 studies. The authors flag that as unexpected, and they state plainly that the design “does not permit conclusions about causality,” since most of the underlying studies are cross-sectional. The modest, useful read: a student rarely takes hard feedback from an adult they have decided is not on their side. That does not mean being liked. It means being predictable.

    Which conversation does this student actually need?

    Four different problems produce the same failing grade, and each needs a different opening line. Working out which one you have in front of you takes about ninety seconds in the gradebook and saves the entire conversation.

    The categories are for your diagnosis, not for the student’s ears — say the question out loud, never the label, and be ready to be wrong when they answer. One caution on the third row: “I’ve missed you” only works if it is true, and a teenager can tell.

    What the grade actually isHow you can tellHow to openWhat success looks like in two weeks
    Missing work, not failed workScores are mostly zeros; the attempts that exist are passing“You can do this — three of these were never turned in. Let’s pick one.”One assignment in, and the student knows the window for the rest
    Attempted and not learnedWork is submitted and scoring low; quiz and test scores agree“You’re doing the work. Something in the middle isn’t landing. Show me where it stops making sense.”Reteaching or a reassessment scheduled, not more of the same practice
    Not in the roomAbsences or tardies cluster; grade drop tracks them“I’ve missed you. What’s making it hard to get here?”An attendance plan with someone other than you in it
    Something outside the classA sudden change in a student who was fine; across several subjects“Something’s changed. I’m not going to pry. Who in the building do you trust?”The student has talked to a counsellor; you have adjusted one deadline

    Most teachers’ default script is written for the second row while most failing grades belong to the first. Missing work is a logistics problem in a motivation costume, and it responds to a clear window and a short list better than to a conversation about caring — which is the same argument behind a late work policy with a floor instead of a zero.

    For the second row, “show me where it stops making sense” is not a figure of speech. Have the student work one problem out loud, or read you their notes from the lesson in question. The breakdown is usually three steps earlier than either of you assumed, and you cannot scaffold a gap you have not located. Check the student’s accommodations or IEP before you design any of it — the case manager may already know the answer, and an agreement that cuts across a plan on file is worse than no agreement.

    What should you never say to a student who is failing?

    Anything that asks the student to account for their character rather than their work. The four sentences below are all well-intentioned and all of them end the useful part of the conversation.

    • “You’re so much smarter than this.” It sounds like a compliment and lands as a charge: the student now has to explain why they are a disappointment. Replace it with the expectation sentence, which does the same job without the accusation.
    • “Do you even care about this class?” A teenager asked this in front of a grade they are ashamed of will say no, because no is the only answer that protects them. Then both of you are stuck with it. What not caring usually turns out to mean is a different problem entirely.
    • “At this rate you’re not going to pass.” Probably true and entirely useless. A student who already knows the number needs the next step, not the forecast. If the mathematics genuinely no longer works, say what is still available — credit recovery, a summer option, a reassessment window — in the same breath.
    • “Is everything okay at home?” Well meant, and not yours to ask cold. It invites a disclosure you are not trained or authorised to handle and it can read as an assumption about the student’s family. “What’s getting in the way?” gets you the same information and leaves the student in charge of how much they say.

    One more guardrail, and it is an administrator’s point: only offer what your school actually permits. A reassessment window, a late-work floor or a credit-recovery route is school policy before it is your policy, and a promise you cannot keep does more damage than the original grade. If you are not certain what is allowed, ask before the conversation rather than walking it back afterward.

    And one structural rule: do not make this conversation the consequence. A failing grade is already a consequence. Layering a lecture on top of it teaches the student that coming to you with a problem costs them something, which is the opposite of what the next six weeks require. The distinction between a consequence and a punishment is worth being precise about.

    What if the problem is clearly bigger than your class?

    Route it, immediately, and do not try to handle it yourself. Notice, name that you have noticed, hand the student to someone whose job this is, and follow the referral path your school already has.

    The boundary here is not a matter of taste. The American School Counselor Association’s position statement on student mental health states that “school counselors do not diagnose” and that providing long-term therapeutic counselling in school is inappropriate even for a counsellor who holds a therapy licence; their role is brief counselling, crisis intervention, and referral to school and community providers. If that is the limit on a licensed counsellor, a social studies teacher’s limit is considerably tighter.

    What ASCA does list as warning signs is squarely in a teacher’s field of view: changes in grades or attendance, shifts in mood, school avoidance. You are well placed to see those and badly placed to interpret them. So the move is three sentences long — something has changed, I am not going to pry, here is who I think you should talk to — followed by a walk to the counsellor’s office or an email to them the same day.

    That assumes a counsellor who is reachable, and in a lot of schools the counselling caseload makes that optimistic. If yours is carrying hundreds of students, find out now — not in the moment — who the route actually is: a school social worker, a nurse, an administrator, a named point of contact for a district programme. The referral path existing on paper is not the same as you knowing it.

    If a student says something that makes you worry about their immediate safety, that is not a conversation to finish alone or to leave until tomorrow. Follow your school’s reporting procedure that day and tell your administrator.

    Four rows pairing a sentence to avoid with a replacement, covering you are smarter than this, do you even care, at this rate you will not pass, and is everything okay at home.
    Four well-meant sentences, and what to say in their place.

    What happens after the conversation?

    The follow-up is the intervention. Structured, repeated contact with one named adult has the strongest evidence in this area — and a clear ceiling.

    Check & Connect is the tested version: a named monitor who tracks attendance, behaviour and grades, intervenes when a signal trips, and coordinates with the family. The What Works Clearinghouse intervention report accepted two randomized trials without reservations and rated it positive effects on staying in school (improvement index +25), potentially positive effects on progressing in school (+30), and no discernible effects on completing school (+1).

    That last row is the honest headline: the programme kept students enrolled and did not demonstrably get them to a diploma. Both trials ran in Minneapolis with fewer than 350 students in total, all ninth graders receiving special education services for learning, emotional or behavioural disabilities, and the WWC rates the extent of evidence small in every domain.

    The scaled-down version a teacher can actually run is one adult, one signal, and a check-in that happens on the day it was promised. Not a case plan — a thirty-second question on Thursday because Thursday is when you said. It is the same reason test corrections only work when the student has to produce thinking rather than the right answer: the structure does the work, not the sentiment.

    Contacting home belongs in this stage rather than the first one, and it belongs after you have told the student. To be clear about what that means for a family: telling the student first is a matter of hours, not weeks, and it is not a reason to delay contact. It is so the student hears it from you rather than at the dinner table. Send it in a language the family reads, say how they can reach you, and keep every other student out of it — including the one whose grade the parent asks to compare. If the next step is a conference instead of a message, these are the questions actually worth the fifteen minutes.

    Where does the evidence run out?

    Sooner than any of the above implies. There is no randomized trial of the teacher–student conversation itself, and every study cited here was run on a population that is not quite yours.

    • Nobody has tested the conversation. What has been tested is a written note on feedback, a monitoring programme, and a correlation. The four-minute talk is assembled from those, not validated as a unit.
    • The wise-feedback studies had 44 participants each, were limited to students with B and C averages, and the authors call the trust moderation tentative. Treat the sentence as low-cost and promising, not as an established lever.
    • The on-track figures are one district, one era — Chicago Public Schools in the early 2000s. The ordering of the signals has replicated widely; the numbers are not national facts.
    • Check & Connect’s trials were ninth graders with disabilities in one city, and the completing-school result was no discernible effect. Anyone selling monitoring as a graduation strategy is quoting the first row and skipping the third.

    Clay’s take: the grade is information about the plan too

    My position here is unfashionable and I will defend it: if a student in my room could fail badly enough for it to matter, that is mostly a planning problem.

    If a kid can screw up that badly in a classroom, what was the teacher doing the entire time? I am moving between tables most of the period. A grade that collapses without my noticing is a grade I stopped looking at.

    So I read a failing grade as two pieces of information. One is about the student, and it is usually attendance or a stack of untouched work rather than anything about character. The other is about me — where the scaffolding was thin, which day the class lost the thread, what I posted and then quietly let slide. The second half is what I can fix this week.

    Where I will not go is “let them fail so they learn.” Manufactured stakes are not a teaching method. Students can struggle, do a thing badly, need help and still be held to the standard afterward; what they should not be able to do is walk off a cliff an adult built and then watched them approach. The article on when to let students wrestle and when to step in walks through where that line sits.

    So I keep the conversation small and keep my word about it. A teenager who has been failing for a month has usually had plenty of adults be disappointed at them and very few be specific with them. Specific, and then back on Thursday like you said, is most of the job.

    What to do tomorrow

    1. Sort your gradebook by missing assignments rather than by average. The list you get is the list of conversations worth having, in order.
    2. Pick the top three students. With 120 or 150 on a roster you are not having thirty of these this week, and three conversations you finish beat ten you start. Sorting by missing work rather than by who worries you keeps the choice honest.
    3. For each one, work out which of the four rows above you are looking at before you say a word.
    4. Hold it somewhere private, in four minutes, with one task and one date out of it. Private rarely means an empty room — the doorway as the bell goes, your table during independent work, and the two minutes while everyone else packs up all count.
    5. Write the check-in date where you will see it, and set the due dates on a schedule you can actually mark — twelve recovery assignments landing the same Friday helps nobody. Then check in on the day, even if nothing has changed, because that is the part the student is actually measuring.

    If the student’s problem turns out to be refusal in the moment rather than a quiet backlog, that is a different ninety seconds and it comes first. Everything on this site is free and nothing asks for your email address.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How do you start a conversation with a student who is failing?

    Start with one specific missing piece of work rather than the grade, and start somewhere private. “You have three missing assignments and two of them are what the test is built on” gives a student something to do. “You are failing my class” gives them a verdict to react to. Then ask what is getting in the way and let them answer.

    Should you tell a student they are failing?

    Yes, and earlier than most teachers do. A student who learns it from a report card has lost the weeks when it was fixable. Say it plainly, say it in private, and pair it with the one task that starts the recovery. Attendance and missing work show the problem coming long before the average does.

    Does telling a student you have high expectations actually work?

    There is real but small-scale evidence for it. In a randomized study of 44 seventh graders, a note saying the teacher had high expectations and believed the student could reach them raised essay revision among African American students from 17 to 71 percent. The sample was tiny and limited to B and C students, so treat the sentence as low-cost and promising rather than proven.

    What should you not say to a failing student?

    Avoid “you’re smarter than this,” “do you even care,” and “at this rate you won’t pass.” All three ask the student to defend their character instead of fixing their work. Also avoid opening with “is everything okay at home?” — “what’s getting in the way?” gets the same information and leaves the student deciding how much to share.

    Should I contact the parents before or after talking to the student?

    After. A student who finds out at dinner that you emailed home has learned that you go around them. Telling them first, at the end of class, costs twenty seconds and keeps them a party to their own situation. The exception is anything involving immediate safety, which goes to your administrator the same day.

    What if a failing grade seems to be about something outside school?

    Notice it, say you have noticed, and route it. Do not probe and do not offer a theory about what is happening. The American School Counselor Association states that school counselors do not diagnose, which puts a teacher’s limit well short of that. Three sentences and a walk to the counselor’s office is the whole move.

    How often should I follow up after the conversation?

    On the day you said, and briefly. Thirty seconds on the agreed date does more than a long meeting a fortnight later, because the student is measuring whether you meant it. Structured follow-up with one named adult has the best evidence in this area, though the strongest trials showed it kept students enrolled without demonstrably improving graduation.

    Sources

    • Allensworth, E. M., & Easton, J. Q. (2007). What Matters for Staying On-Track and Graduating in Chicago Public High Schools. Consortium on Chicago School Research, University of Chicago. Chicago Public Schools freshmen, 2000–01 entering cohort and surrounding years; a single large urban district. The 63 percent / 8 percent variance comparison, the 82 / 22 percent graduation figures and the one-week-of-absence sentence all come from this report.
    • Yeager, D. S., Purdie-Vaughns, V., Garcia, J., Apfel, N., Brzustoski, P., Master, A., Hessert, W. T., Williams, M. E., & Cohen, G. L. Breaking the cycle of mistrust: Wise interventions to provide critical feedback across the racial divide. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. Studies 1 and 2 each used 44 seventh graders at one suburban northeastern middle school, restricted to students with B or C averages; Study 3 used about 76 mostly tenth graders at an urban New York City high school. The authors describe the trust moderation findings as tentative.
    • Roorda, D. L., Koomen, H. M. Y., Spilt, J. L., & Oort, F. J. (2011). The influence of affective teacher–student relationships on students’ school engagement and achievement: A meta-analytic approach. Review of Educational Research, 81(4), 493–529. 99 studies, 129,423 students, preschool to high school. The secondary estimates quoted here rest on 23 studies for engagement and 17 for achievement. The authors state the design does not permit causal conclusions.
    • What Works Clearinghouse (2015). Check & Connect intervention report. Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Two randomized trials in Minneapolis high schools, fewer than 350 students in total, all ninth graders receiving special education services for learning, emotional or behavioural disabilities. Positive effects on staying in school; no discernible effects on completing school.
    • American School Counselor Association. The School Counselor and Student Mental Health (position statement; adopted 2009, revised 2015, 2020 and 2025). Source of the “school counselors do not diagnose” language and of the warning-sign list. This article is not legal, medical or clinical advice, and district policy sits on top of all of it.

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.