The Elevate Blog banner: Real Classrooms. Practical Ideas. Higher Expectations. Three students climb a rocky ridge at sunrise, each pulling the next one up, toward a teacher reaching down to help.

Author: Clay Shumate

  • Student Discourse: How to Get Students Talking to Each Other, Not Just to You

    Student Discourse: How to Get Students Talking to Each Other, Not Just to You

    By Clay Shumate

    Student discourse is students talking to each other about the content — explaining, challenging, building on and revising ideas — rather than taking turns answering the teacher. It is not the same thing as participation, and it is not the same thing as volume. The research that holds up says the part that pays is elaboration spread across the whole room, not how much noise it makes.

    That distinction is the whole article. Almost every piece of advice on this topic is about getting students to talk more. The best available evidence says more talk helps only when most of the room is in it and when what gets said builds on something — and the first of those two conditions is the one nearly every classroom misses.

    Key Takeaways

    • Student discourse is student-to-student, about the content. If every utterance routes through the teacher, that is recitation with a nicer name. The research calls the real version dialogic, and its two markers are authentic questions and uptake.
    • Broad participation is the condition, not a bonus. In 72 English Year 6 classes, elaborated and querying talk predicted maths and spelling-grammar results only where student participation was rated high. Where it was low, the same talk produced no measurable benefit.
    • Individual talk time tracked achievement for every group of students. Across 639 ninth graders, a student’s own talk time and reasoning utterances were strongly linked to a standardised reading score, regardless of socio-economic background or gender.
    • Discussion-based teaching has secondary-level evidence behind it. In 64 middle and high school English classrooms, discussion-based approaches predicted spring performance after controlling for fall performance, and worked for low- and high-achieving students alike.
    • The honest effect sizes are small, and the strongest trial was not run on teenagers. The best randomised test found +0.15 in English and +0.12 in science — about two months’ progress — with no significant maths effect, in pupils aged nine and ten.

    What Is Student Discourse?

    Student discourse is sustained, content-focused talk in which students respond to each other’s reasoning rather than to the teacher’s prompt. The test is simple: pick any student utterance and ask what it is answering. If the answer is always “the teacher’s last question,” you have a recitation pattern — teacher asks, student answers, teacher evaluates, repeat. That pattern is not useless. It checks coverage fast and keeps a room steady. It just is not discourse, and it does not do what discourse does.

    Two pieces of research vocabulary are worth borrowing because they name what actually changes. An authentic question seeks a student’s thinking rather than checking whether they already know the answer in the teacher’s head. “What year did it start?” is not authentic. “Which of those three causes mattered most, and what makes you say that?” is. Uptake means your next move is built from what the student just said rather than from the plan’s next bullet. Uptake is the cheapest high-value habit on this page and it costs nothing but attention.

    Both ideas come out of a long research programme on eighth- and ninth-grade English classes — one of the few large bodies of classroom-talk research done on students the age this site writes for. The original report followed classes across eight midwestern communities over two school years, testing more than 1,100 students in the fall and spring of each. It is cited here for the two definitions and nothing else: it reports descriptive comparisons rather than a modelled effect, and no effect size for discussion is claimed anywhere on this page.

    Why Does Student Discourse Matter More Than Participation?

    Because participation is a count and discourse is a structure. A class where eleven students each said one sentence has high participation and no discourse. A class where four students argued for twenty minutes has discourse and a participation problem. The evidence says you need both, and the second is usually what is missing.

    This is the most useful finding in the literature and it is almost never quoted. A naturalistic study of 72 Year 6 classes across 48 English schools coded two video-recorded lessons per class turn by turn, then matched the codes against end-of-year tests taken months later. Two features came out positive: elaborated talk, where a student extends or explains an idea, and querying, where a student questions or challenges a claim. Both predicted maths and spelling-punctuation-grammar scores only in classes rated high for student participation. In low-participation classes the same talk showed no benefit.

    Read that the way a teacher has to. Getting four articulate students to reason beautifully in front of twenty-two silent ones did nothing for test scores in that study. The talk has to be distributed before its quality starts to matter.

    The same study is worth citing for what it failed to find. Reasoned talk — statements giving an explicit reason — did not predict attainment. Not in maths, not in reading, not on a purpose-built reasoning test. The authors call the work a staging post rather than a conclusion, note the design is correlational and cannot support causal claims, and record that their talk-rules measure had to be discarded because most lessons scored zero on it. That last detail is its own finding: across 72 real classrooms, almost nobody had explicit talk rules.

    What Does the Research Actually Say About Student Talk?

    That it helps, that the effects are modest, and that most of the strongest studies were run on children younger than the students in a 6–12 building. All three are true at once, and an article giving you only the first is selling something.

    StudyWho it was run onWhat it foundWhat it cannot tell you
    Šeďová & Sedláček (2019)639 ninth graders, Czech language artsA student’s own talk time and reasoning utterances were strongly linked to a standardised reading score. Talkative classrooms also did better. The individual link held regardless of socio-economic background or gender.Observational — cannot separate “talking makes you better” from “better readers talk more.” Classroom-level reasoning showed no link.
    Applebee, Langer, Nystrand & Gamoran (2003)64 middle and high school English classrooms, grades 7, 8, 10, 11, 12Discussion-based approaches were significantly related to spring performance after controlling for fall performance and background, for low- and high-achieving students alike.Correlational. The authors note instruction was unequally distributed across tracks.
    Howe, Hennessy, Mercer, Vrikki & Wheatley (2019)72 Year 6 classes (ages 10–11), 48 English schoolsElaborated and querying talk predicted maths and SPAG scores, but only where participation was high. Reasoned talk predicted nothing.Correlational, primary-aged, one country. The authors ask for intervention trials.
    EEF Dialogic Teaching trial (2017)76 schools, 4,958 pupils randomised — Year 5, ages 9–10English +0.15 and science +0.12, about two months’ progress each. Free-school-meals pupils gained +0.16 in maths.Maths overall was +0.09 and not significant. 21% of pupils dropped out of the analysis. Effects fell below the trial’s own detectable threshold. Not a secondary result.
    Murphy and colleagues (2009), meta-analysisStudies of discussion approaches; most participants in grades 4–6Several approaches strongly increased student talk, reduced teacher talk, and substantially improved text comprehension.Few improved critical thinking and reasoning, or literal and inferential comprehension. Effects varied by design, measure and student ability.
    Five sources, with the population stated every time.

    Three things follow from the table rather than from a summary of it. The strongest causal evidence is about nine- and ten-year-olds — the EEF trial is the cleanest test anyone has run, across 76 schools in three English cities all above 20% free school meals, and it is a Year 5 result. The practices transfer to a secondary room; the numbers do not automatically transfer with them.

    The secondary-level evidence is correlational, and it is still the most relevant evidence you have. The 64-classroom study and the 639-student study are both observational and neither can prove talk caused the learning. Both were run on students aged thirteen to eighteen, which no trial of this size has managed. Careful correlational work on the right students beats a clean trial on the wrong ones, as long as nobody dresses the first up as the second.

    And discussion is not a reasoning intervention. The 2009 meta-analysis found several approaches reliably moved comprehension and reliably increased student talk, and that few moved critical thinking. Howe and colleagues found the same from the other direction: reasoning was the one outcome with no main effects. If your pitch is “it teaches them to think critically,” the literature does not have your back yet. If it is “it moves comprehension and gets more students into the content,” it does.

    What About the Effect Size Everyone Quotes?

    Treat it carefully. A large effect size for “classroom discussion” circulates widely in professional development materials, usually traced to the Visible Learning synthesis. Two things are worth knowing first. The official Visible Learning glossary entry for classroom discussion carries a definition and no effect size at all. And the synthesis has a documented correction history: Hattie has acknowledged that the Common Language Effect size figures throughout the original book were calculated incorrectly, with only the Cohen’s d values correct, and a 2014 paper by Schulmeister and Loviscach catalogued further problems with study selection and method.

    Four research findings on student discourse with the population of each study named: 639 Czech ninth graders, 72 English Year 6 classes, 64 middle and high school English classrooms, and a randomised trial of 76 schools with pupils aged nine and ten
    The defensible numbers, with the population attached to each one.

    None of that makes classroom discussion a bad idea. It makes the headline number a bad citation. Use the trial figures instead — +0.15, +0.12, two months, one non-significant result, primary-aged pupils. They are smaller and they are defensible, and a claim that survives a sceptical administrator is worth more than one that impresses a staff meeting.

    How Much Should Students Be Talking?

    There is no validated ratio, and anyone who gives you one is guessing. The research supports a direction and a distribution, not a percentage. So stop counting minutes and count students. Three questions, answerable from a seating chart and a pencil:

    1. How many different students spoke about the content today? Not answered a procedural question — spoke about the content. Write the number down.
    2. How many of those utterances were longer than one sentence? Elaboration is the feature with evidence behind it. One-word answers are not it.
    3. How many times did a student respond to another student rather than to you? This is what separates discourse from recitation, and in most rooms it starts near zero.

    Those three numbers, taken weekly for a month, will tell you more about your classroom than any observation rubric, and they make an honest target: not “more talk,” but “four more students than last week.”

    On scope, honestly: tally marks on a printed seating chart during one discussion, once a week. Under a minute of work, no grades, no data entry, nothing to upload. And nothing here is a record of individual students’ speech that anyone else needs to see — the chart is a working note, and it belongs in the recycling at the end of the month rather than in a file.

    A word on class size, because the advice gets harder as the roster grows. In a section of thirty-two on a fifty-minute period, whole-class discourse will not reach everybody and pretending otherwise wastes the period. Pairs and fours are not the training-wheels version — in a large room they are the version that satisfies the participation condition the research identified. One two-minute paired exchange gets more students reasoning out loud than twenty minutes of whole-class discussion will.

    Three questions a teacher can count weekly to track student discourse: how many different students spoke about the content, how many said more than one sentence, and how many responded to another student rather than to the teacher
    Three counts from a seating chart. Under a minute a week.

    What Are the Five Moves That Produce Student Discourse?

    Ask something that has no answer in your head, wait, make students respond to each other, keep the thread alive, and write down the rules. Each move is small enough to add to a lesson you have already planned.

    1. Ask an authentic question. One where you do not already know what a reasonable student will say. “Was the compromise worth it?” rather than “What did the compromise do?” A question with one right answer belongs in a quick check, not a discussion.
    2. Wait, and make the wait obvious. Ask, then say nothing and let the silence be visible. Students read a two-second pause as permission to stay quiet and a five-second pause as a signal that you are going to wait.
    3. Route the second turn to a student, not to yourself. After a student answers, the default next move is the teacher evaluating. Replace it: “Someone build on that.” “Who sees it differently?” “Say back what you heard, then add to it.” This one substitution turns recitation into conversation.
    4. Take up what they said. Your next question should contain a piece of their answer. “You said it was about money — whose money?” Uptake tells a room that answers are being listened to rather than collected. It is the operational version of standing by your word: if you ask what someone thinks, do something with what they tell you.
    5. Write the rules down. In 72 observed classrooms the talk-rules measure was thrown out because most lessons scored zero. Four lines on the wall is enough: disagree with the idea and not the person, give a reason, let people finish, and anyone can change their mind out loud at no cost.

    That fifth rule carries more weight than it looks. A room where changing your mind is embarrassing will produce confident nonsense and nothing else, because the only safe move is to defend your first answer. Say early that revising a position in public is the point — then praise it the first time it happens, by name, in front of everybody.

    Numbered list of five teaching moves for student discourse: ask an authentic question, wait visibly, route the second turn to a student, take up what a student said, and write the talk rules down
    The five moves in order. Each one works on its own.

    How Do You Run Discourse Without It Going Off the Rails?

    You plan the structure, not the content of what students will say. If a discussion in a grades 6–12 classroom collapses into chaos or dead silence, that is almost always a planning result rather than a student result. Four decisions, made before the lesson:

    • Decide the unit of talk. Whole class, pairs, or small groups. A room with no student-to-student history should not start whole class — pairs first, then fours, then the floor. If you are moving toward groups, defined roles inside each group remove the most common failure, which is one student talking and three watching.
    • Decide what everyone writes before anyone speaks. Thirty seconds of writing raises the number of students who can enter the discussion, which is the condition the research says matters most. It also gives the quiet student something to read from instead of something to invent under pressure.
    • Decide how you will call on people. Hands-up alone concentrates talk in the already-confident, which is exactly the low-participation pattern that made elaborated talk worthless in the 72-class study. A warm, predictable version of calling on students who did not volunteer — after writing time, with a route to pass once — distributes talk without ambushing anybody.
    • Decide where it ends. A discussion with no landing point teaches students that talk is filler. Name the product: a written claim, a revised answer, one sentence on the strongest counterargument. Then use it in the next thing you do.

    And decide, out loud, what a student who does not want to talk is allowed to do. Most discourse advice skips this, and it is the part students notice first. Give an explicit route: a pass, once, with no explanation owed and no penalty, and the answer written instead. Then honour it the first time somebody uses it, in front of everyone, without a sigh — a pass that costs social capital is not a pass. The same provision quietly does the work for a student with a speech difference, a student still acquiring English, and a student having a bad week, none of whom should have to disclose anything to get it. Sentence stems on the wall (“I agree with… because…”, “I see it differently because…”, “Can you say more about…”) raise the floor for all three at once and cost one piece of paper.

    For a structured version of all of this at once, a Socratic seminar is the most forgiving format to start with, because the protocol does the management for you. It lives or dies on the prompt, so it is worth borrowing questions already known to open up rather than writing your own on the first attempt. In a smaller setting, the same five moves work inside small-group instruction at the secondary level, where the participation problem is easier to see and easier to fix. To grade one, use this free Socratic seminar rubric.

    What Happens When the Discussion Gets Near Something Contentious?

    You separate the question you are asking from the question students bring, and you decide which one the lesson is for before you open the floor. A room full of teenagers reasoning out loud will eventually reach something a family has strong feelings about. That is a reason to prepare, not a reason to avoid discourse.

    Three things keep it clean. Frame the prompt around evidence rather than personal position — “what does this source let us conclude” travels much further than “what do you believe.” State the standard you are grading against, if anything is graded, so nobody can reasonably believe their conclusion is what is being scored. And have the redirect sentence ready: name the move, not the student — “that is about a person rather than the idea, so try it again on the idea.” Rehearse it once and it stops being a crisis. If a discussion does go somewhere you did not intend, the useful question afterward is what the prompt invited. A fifteen-year-old cannot derail a conversation that had a clear question, a clear product and clear rules.

    Can a School Actually Roll This Out?

    Yes, with one condition stated plainly: the trial that produced those numbers tested a supported programme, not a handout. The EEF study trained teachers and ran a mentoring cycle inside each school. Fidelity was high for training attendance and the mentor-cycle format, and more variable for how the approach reached the curriculum. So the +0.15 belongs to that package — training, a mentor, two terms — and nobody should promise it for a one-hour staff meeting and a PDF.

    The cost line is small by district standards. No purchase, no platform, no licence, no staffing change. What it needs is time: somebody who can sit in a colleague’s room, watch for the three numbers above, and talk about them afterward without it being an evaluation. A peer-observation cycle with no rating attached is the cheapest intervention on this page and the one most likely to get cut first.

    It is also unusually coachable, which matters for anyone allocating instructional-coach hours. The five moves are observable from the back of a room, countable in one period, and separable — a teacher can work on routing the second turn for three weeks without changing anything else. Standards alignment mostly takes care of itself, because speaking-and-listening standards already require this and are usually the least-taught strand in the document.

    Does Student Discourse Work for Every Student?

    The best data says the individual benefit did not depend on background. In the 639-student Czech study, the link between a student’s own talk time and their reading score, and between their reasoning utterances and that score, held across students regardless of socio-economic background or gender. That is observational and should be stated as such. It is also the most direct evidence available on a question teachers ask constantly, usually in the form of an assumption: that students from harder circumstances need tighter control and less open talk.

    There is no support for that assumption here. The EEF trial’s schools were all above 20% free school meals, and its one statistically significant maths result was for the free-school-meals subgroup specifically. The 64-classroom secondary study found discussion-based approaches working for low- and high-achieving students alike, and the Czech study found the link between a student’s own participation and achievement held regardless of socio-economic background or gender.

    Be careful what that adds up to. It does not say discourse closes gaps; nobody has shown that. It says the appetite to talk about something that matters is not the thing that varies by zip code — and the burden of proof sits with whoever claims some students need silence instead.

    What Goes Wrong, and How Do You Fix It?

    FailureWhat you will seeThe repair
    Four voices, twenty silencesRich talk, flat resultsWrite first, then pairs, then floor. Track distinct speakers, not volume
    Questions with answersShort replies, then nothingRewrite the prompt until you cannot predict a reasonable answer
    Teacher as the hubEvery turn routes through youHand the second turn to a student every time, for two weeks, until it is habit
    No stated rulesInterrupting, or point-scoringFour lines on the wall. Most observed classrooms have none
    Talk with no product“Why are we doing this?”Name the written output before the talk starts, and collect it
    Five common discourse failures and the repair for each.

    One more, because it is the hardest to see from the front of the room: grading the talk. The moment a discussion carries points, some students stop reasoning and start performing, and the least confident get quieter rather than louder. If a discussion needs assessing, assess the written product that came out of it, and keep the quick checks that tell you whether they understood separate from the conversation that got them there.

    How Long Does This Take to Work?

    Longer than one unit, and the best trial we have says its own window was too short. Teachers in the EEF study reported two terms was not enough to embed the approach, which the evaluators recorded as a reason the measured effects may be underestimates. That is an unusually honest thing for a trial report to say, and it sets a realistic expectation: the five moves are easy to start and slow to pay.

    Expect three phases. In the first week or two the distinct-speaker count moves and the talk is awkward. Over the next month students start responding to each other without being told to, which is when your third weekly number stops being zero. After that the content of the talk gets better, and the elaboration the research cares about shows up on its own. Skipping to phase three by demanding sophisticated reasoning in week one produces the four-voices pattern, which the evidence says buys nothing.

    What Should Families Expect to See?

    More talking at school, the same expectations, and nothing new to do at home. Worth saying to parents before they hear a version of it from their child, because “we just talked today” can sound like a wasted period from the outside.

    Three things are fair to promise, and they are what a quiet student’s parent will want to hear. A student is not graded on how much they say — talk is not a behaviour category or a participation score, and the written product is what gets assessed. There is a real route to not speaking, used without explanation, with the answer written instead. And a student who thinks out loud and changes their mind is doing it correctly, not backing down; if that reads as weakness at school the whole method stops working, so it gets named as a strength out loud.

    The honest caveat for a family who asks about evidence: the gains in the strongest study were about two months’ progress in English and science, in a trial on nine- and ten-year-olds, with no significant maths effect. That is worth doing and it is not a transformation. The clearer case for a 6–12 classroom is the Czech ninth-grade data — students who talked more and reasoned out loud more did better on a standardised reading test, across backgrounds.

    What to Do This Week

    Pick one class. Do four things.

    Monday: count the distinct students who say something about the content, and the number of student-to-student responses. Change nothing yet. You need the baseline, and it will probably be worse than you expect.

    Tuesday: rewrite one question in your existing plan so you cannot predict a reasonable answer to it. One question. Ask it, then wait five visible seconds.

    Wednesday: hand the second turn to a student every time, all period. “Build on that.” “Who disagrees?” Nothing else changes.

    Friday: put four talk rules on the wall and count again. If the distinct-speaker number went up, you have the result the research says has to come first.

    Then go find the person in your building who is already good at this and ask how they start. Keeping your ears open and asking a direct question pays off more reliably than reading another article, this one included — and most of the teachers worth asking are waiting for somebody to ask.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is student discourse?

    Student discourse is students talking to each other about the content — explaining, challenging, building on and revising ideas — rather than taking turns answering the teacher. The research tradition calls the real version dialogic, and its two markers are authentic questions (ones with no prespecified answer in the teacher’s head) and uptake (the teacher’s next question built out of what a student just said). If every utterance routes through the teacher, that is recitation rather than discourse.

    What is the difference between student discourse and participation?

    Participation is a count; discourse is a structure. Eleven students each saying one sentence is high participation and no discourse. Four students arguing for twenty minutes is discourse with a participation problem. The evidence says you need both: in a study of 72 Year 6 classes, elaborated and querying talk predicted maths and spelling-grammar scores only in classes where student participation was rated high. Where participation was low, the same quality of talk produced no measurable benefit.

    How much should students be talking in class?

    There is no validated ratio, and anyone offering a percentage is guessing. What the research supports is a direction — several discussion approaches increased student talk and reduced teacher talk — and a distribution, which matters more than the total. Instead of counting minutes, count three things weekly: how many different students spoke about the content, how many said more than one sentence, and how many responded to another student rather than to you. The third number starts near zero in most rooms.

    Does student discourse improve test scores?

    Modestly, and the strongest evidence is not from secondary classrooms. The best randomised trial of dialogic teaching found +0.15 in English and +0.12 in science — about two months’ progress — with maths at +0.09 and not statistically significant, in pupils aged nine and ten. At the secondary level the evidence is correlational: discussion-based approaches predicted spring performance across 64 middle and high school English classrooms, and across 639 ninth graders a student’s own talk time tracked their standardised reading score. Discussion is not a reasoning intervention — a meta-analysis found several approaches improved text comprehension while few improved critical thinking.

    What are examples of student discourse moves?

    Five, in order. Ask an authentic question you cannot predict a reasonable answer to. Wait, visibly, for about five seconds rather than two. Route the second turn to a student instead of evaluating yourself — “build on that,” “who sees it differently,” “say back what you heard, then add to it.” Take up what a student said by putting a piece of their answer into your next question. And write four talk rules on the wall: disagree with the idea not the person, give a reason, let people finish, and anyone can change their mind out loud at no cost.

    How do you include a student who does not want to speak?

    Give an explicit route and honour it. A pass, once, with no explanation owed and no penalty, and the answer written instead — then accept it the first time somebody uses it, in front of everyone, without a sigh. A pass that costs social capital is not a pass. Thirty seconds of writing before anyone speaks raises the number of students who can enter the discussion, and sentence stems posted on the wall (“I agree with… because…”, “I see it differently because…”) raise the floor for a reluctant speaker, a student with a speech difference and a student still acquiring English at the same time, without anyone having to disclose anything.

    Should student discourse be graded?

    Assess the written product that comes out of the discussion, not the talking. The moment a discussion carries points, some students stop reasoning and start performing, and the least confident get quieter rather than louder. Keep quick checks for understanding separate from the conversation that produced the understanding. Telling families plainly that a student is not graded on how much they say is also the single most effective thing you can do to head off the question a quiet student’s parent will otherwise ask.

    Sources

    1. Jay, T., Willis, B., Thomas, P., Taylor, R., Moore, N., Burnett, C., Merchant, G., & Stevens, A. (2017). Dialogic Teaching: Evaluation Report and Executive Summary. Education Endowment Foundation / Sheffield Hallam University. Three-level clustered randomised controlled trial; 76 schools randomised (38 intervention, 38 control) in Leeds, Bradford and Birmingham, all with over 20% of pupils eligible for free school meals; 4,958 pupils randomised and 3,912 analysed. Pupils were in Year 5, aged nine and ten — this is not a secondary-school result. English +0.15 (95% CI 0.00 to 0.30, p = 0.05, about two months); science +0.12 (0.01 to 0.23, p = 0.04, about two months); maths +0.09 (−0.04 to 0.20, p = 0.19, not statistically significant). Free-school-meals pupils: maths +0.16 (0.01 to 0.30). Rated three padlocks (moderate security). Reported limitations include 21% attrition, with 7 of 38 intervention schools providing no post-test data; a baseline EAL imbalance; effects below the trial’s own minimum detectable effect size of roughly 0.25; and teachers reporting that two terms was too short to embed the approach. Read in full. shura.shu.ac.uk (PDF)
    2. Howe, C., Hennessy, S., Mercer, N., Vrikki, M., & Wheatley, L. (2019). Teacher–Student Dialogue During Classroom Teaching: Does It Really Impact on Student Outcomes? Journal of the Learning Sciences. 72 Year 6 classes (ages 10–11) in 48 schools across England; two video-recorded lessons per class coded turn by turn; outcomes were end-of-year tests and a pupil attitude survey taken months later, analysed in two-level models with measured confounds controlled. Elaborated and querying talk were positively associated with mathematics and spelling-punctuation-grammar scores only where the lesson-level rating for student participation was high; with low participation there was no benefit. Reading showed the same pattern but not significantly. Reasoned talk predicted nothing, there were no significant science effects, and there were no main effects on the reasoning test. The talk-rules scale was discarded because most lessons scored zero. Authors’ own caveats: the design is correlational and cannot support causal claims; the sample is England-only and primary-aged; the science and reasoning tests were newly designed; they describe the work as a “staging post” and call for intervention trials. Accepted manuscript read in full; the Cambridge copy of that manuscript has since gone offline, so this links to the published article. doi.org/10.1080/10508406.2019.1573730
    3. Šeďová, K., & Sedláček, M. (2019). Do Those Who Talk More Learn More? The Relationship Between Student Classroom Talk and Student Achievement. Learning and Instruction. 639 ninth-grade students in Czech schools; talk time and the number of utterances featuring reasoning were recorded for each individual student during language arts lessons; achievement was measured with a standardised reading literacy test. A strong link was found between a student’s own talk time and reasoning utterances and that student’s achievement, and at classroom level students in talkative classrooms did better. At classroom level, reasoning utterances were not linked to better results. The positive link between individual participation and achievement was observed in all students regardless of socio-economic background or gender. Observational, so it cannot separate whether talking raises achievement or stronger readers talk more. Abstract read in full from the publisher’s record. pedagogika.phil.muni.cz
    4. Applebee, A. N., Langer, J. A., Nystrand, M., & Gamoran, A. (2003). Discussion-Based Approaches to Developing Understanding: Classroom Instruction and Student Performance in Middle and High School English. American Educational Research Journal, 40(3). 64 middle and high school English classrooms spanning grades 7, 8, 10, 11 and 12. Discussion-based approaches were significantly related to spring performance in hierarchical linear models controlling for fall performance and background variables, and appeared effective across a range of situations and for both low- and high-achieving students. Non-experimental; the authors note that instruction was unequally distributed across tracks, which complicates interpretation. Cited from the ERIC record, which was read; the journal’s full text was not opened in this session. eric.ed.gov
    5. Murphy, P. K., Wilkinson, I. A. G., Soter, A. O., Hennessey, M. N., & Alexander, J. F. (2009). Examining the Effects of Classroom Discussion on Students’ Comprehension of Text: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology, 101(3). Several discussion approaches produced strong increases in the amount of student talk with reductions in teacher talk, and substantial improvements in text comprehension. Few approaches were effective at improving literal or inferential comprehension, or critical thinking and reasoning. Effects were moderated by study design, the nature of the outcome measure and student academic ability. The age range was wide but most studies involved fourth through sixth graders, so this is not a secondary-school finding. Cited from the published abstract and record; the full article was not opened in this session. pure.psu.edu
    6. Murphy, P. K., Greene, J. A., Firetto, C. M., Hendrick, B. D., Li, M., Montalbano, C., & Wei, L. (2018). Quality Talk: Developing Students’ Discourse to Promote High-Level Comprehension. American Educational Research Journal, 55(5). A year-long study of a teacher-facilitated small-group discussion approach in two fourth-grade classrooms. Teacher-initiated discourse decreased, student discourse showed more critical-analytic thinking, and written measures of basic and high-level comprehension increased. The authors describe it as an initial study; two classrooms is a small sample and the abstract reports no effect sizes. Cited from the abstract, which was read; the full text is behind access controls. journals.sagepub.com
    7. Nystrand, M., & Gamoran, A. (1990). Student Engagement: When Recitation Becomes Conversation. National Center on Effective Secondary Schools, Wisconsin Center for Education Research, University of Wisconsin–Madison. The source of the two terms used above: authentic questions, which open the floor to what students actually think, and uptake, where the next question is built out of what a student just said. Eighth- and ninth-grade English classes across eight midwestern communities — 16 middle schools feeding nine high schools — with over 1,100 students tested in the fall and spring of 1987–88 and 1988–89. Cited for the definitions only. This report gives descriptive comparisons rather than regression models, publishes no effect size for discussion, and none is claimed here. The research centre’s own summary page for the wider programme is currently unreachable — its TLS certificate does not match its hostname — so it is not cited. files.eric.ed.gov (PDF)
    8. On the widely quoted “classroom discussion” effect size: the official Visible Learning glossary entry for classroom discussion gives a definition and no effect size and no meta-analyses. Separately, Hattie has acknowledged that the Common Language Effect size figures throughout the original book were calculated incorrectly, with only the Cohen’s d values correct — raised by Topphol (2011) in Norsk pedagogisk tidsskrift — and Schulmeister and Loviscach (2014), Errors in John Hattie’s “Visible Learning”, argued there are considerable issues with study selection and method. No formal published erratum or revised edition is documented. This article therefore does not cite a Visible Learning figure for discussion and uses the trial estimates instead. visible-learning.org glossary · overview of the criticism

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • 10 Point Grading Scale: The Chart, the Cutoffs, and What It Actually Changes

    10 Point Grading Scale: The Chart, the Cutoffs, and What It Actually Changes

    By Clay Shumate

    A 10 point grading scale gives each letter grade a ten-point band: 90–100 is an A, 80–89 a B, 70–79 a C, 60–69 a D, and anything under 60 is an F. It replaced the older seven-point scale, where an A started at 93. Same work, wider bands, sometimes a different letter on the transcript.

    Free Download · Printable PDF

    10 Point Grading Scale Chart

    One page: the letter-grade cutoffs, unweighted and weighted quality points, the 7 point scale side by side, and the five averages where the two scales give a different letter. Print it for your syllabus, your wall or your parent night.

    Download the free chart

    Free. No email address required. Designed for grades 6–12. Using standards-based grading instead? See what a 1–4 score converts to.

    That’s the whole mechanical answer, and it’s the part people come looking for. The part worth staying for is what the switch actually did, because it was never sold as a teaching improvement and it never was one. It moved lines on a page. Whether that helps a student depends entirely on what you do inside the bands.

    Key Takeaways

    • One letter per ten points. A 90–100, B 80–89, C 70–79, D 60–69, F below 60. North Carolina’s state policy writes the bottom band as “below 59,” which leaves 59 unassigned — a small drafting gap that has been sitting in an adopted statewide policy for years.
    • The seven-point scale that the 10 point grading scale replaced started an A at 93 and a B at 85. A student with an 86 average was a B on both scales. A student with a 91 was an A on one and a B on the other.
    • States switched to the 10 point grading scale for transcript comparability, not learning. North Carolina’s board voted on 2 October 2014; South Carolina’s approved unanimously on 13 April 2016. Both rationales were about transcripts, college admissions, scholarships and families transferring in.
    • No study shows that widening a grading band teaches anybody anything. What a wider band changes is which side of a line a student lands on, and how many students sit near a line at all.
    • The research on scale length is not kind to percentages. Simulation work puts the useful number of categories at four to seven. A percentage scale has 101. In one replication, the 73 trained English teachers who graded the same paper on a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96.

    What Is a 10 Point Grading Scale?

    A 10 point grading scale is a percentage grading scale where every letter covers exactly ten points, so the cutoffs land on round numbers: 90, 80, 70 and 60. Here’s the chart, with the 4.0 quality points most transcripts attach to each letter. If you are starting from a raw score like 3/4 or 14/25, the fraction to letter grade chart converts it to a percent first.

    LetterPercentStandard quality pointsWhat it is usually called
    A90–1004.0Exceeds or fully meets
    B80–893.0Meets
    C70–792.0Partially meets
    D60–691.0Credit, barely
    Fbelow 600.0No credit
    The 10 point grading scale, with the unweighted quality points North Carolina’s policy assigns each letter.

    Weighting sits on top of that and is where a lot of transcript confusion actually lives. Under North Carolina’s grading policy, honors courses add 0.5 quality points and AP, IB, Cambridge and eligible dual-enrollment courses add 1.0 — so an A in an AP course is a 5.0, and a student can finish with a weighted GPA above 4.0 while every single grade was earned on the same ten-point bands. Students get both an unweighted and a weighted GPA, and official class rank comes off the weighted one.

    One more thing the chart hides: the scale is a reporting rule, not a grading method. It tells you what band a number falls in. It says nothing about how the number was produced, which is the only part you control.

    How Is a 10 Point Grading Scale Different From a 7 Point Scale?

    The seven-point scale North Carolina used before 2015 set an A at 93–100 and a B at 85–92, and anything below 70 was an F. A 10 point grading scale moves those lines down to 90, 80 and 60. Every cutoff on the seven-point scale is higher, and its F band is much bigger.

    Average10 point scale7 point scaleWhat changes
    95AANothing
    91ABA full letter and a quality point
    86BBNothing
    69DFCourse credit versus repeating the course
    55FFNothing
    The same averages on both scales. Seven-point cutoffs (A from 93, B from 85, F below 70) are the North Carolina ranges WRAL reported at the 2014 vote.
    Side-by-side comparison of the percentage ranges for each letter grade on a 10 point grading scale and a 7 point grading scale, showing a three-point gap at the A cutoff and a ten-point difference at the failing line
    The same five letters, two sets of lines. The gap is smallest at the A cutoff and largest at the failing line, where it decides credit.

    Run a few numbers through both and the pattern shows up fast. A 91 is an A on the ten-point scale and a B on the seven-point. An 86 is a B either way. A 69 is a D on the ten-point scale and an F on the seven-point — that’s the real one, because it is the difference between credit and a repeated course.

    When North Carolina made the change, a local report put the problem in one sentence: a student with a 91 in every class had a 4.0 in Atlanta and a 3.0 at home. That is not a rigor argument. It is a paperwork argument, and it was a fair one.

    Notice what the comparison does not show. It does not show that students on one scale learn more. Both scales are percentage scales. Both carry every problem a percentage scale has. One of them just puts the walls in different places.

    Why Did States Switch to a 10 Point Grading Scale?

    States switched to a 10 point grading scale because transcripts weren’t comparable across state lines, so students graded on a seven-point scale competed for college admission and scholarships at a disadvantage.

    North Carolina’s State Board of Education approved the ten-point range on 2 October 2014, beginning with freshmen in 2015–16. Elementary and middle schools kept the right to use a locally approved system, though the state recommends the same 90–100 scale, and any high school course taken in middle school has to use the high school scale.

    South Carolina’s State Board approved a uniform ten-point scale unanimously on 13 April 2016, effective 2016–17. The reasons the department gave were specific: the change would help military and other families transferring into the state, give South Carolina students an equal chance against neighboring states for college admission and scholarships, and end the confusion for students in dual-credit courses. Its conversion chart puts 59 and below at F, so South Carolina doesn’t have the gap North Carolina’s policy text leaves at 59. The department also said it would re-examine its Hope, Life and Palmetto Fellows scholarship requirements “to ensure fairness and rigor” afterward — which is the quiet admission that moving cutoffs moves who qualifies for money.

    That is the honest case for the switch, and it is strong. It is also narrow. Nobody in either state claimed a wider B band would improve a single lesson, and nobody should quote them as if they had.

    If you are the one who has to implement a change like that, the hard part is not the new chart. South Carolina’s department named the real work in its own announcement: deciding the timing, merging grade calculations for students already enrolled, and preparing for the knock-on effect on lottery-funded scholarships. For a year or two you have students in the same building whose transcripts were built on two different rules, and every one of those families deserves a plain-language explanation before they ask for one.

    Does a 10 Point Grading Scale Make Grades Easier?

    A 10 point grading scale lowers four cutoffs, so on identical work more students clear each line. That isn’t the same thing as grade inflation, and the two get confused constantly.

    Grade inflation is real and it’s measurable. An ACT study of one southern state’s ACT-tested graduates found mean self-reported high school GPA rose from 3.17 in the 2017 class to 3.38 in 2022, and its model adjusted for students’ and schools’ ACT scores when estimating how much of that was inflation. It also found inflation weakened what a GPA predicts: for two students with a 2.5, the one from a school with 0.5 of inflation was predicted to finish first-year college 0.37 GPA points lower.

    Read that carefully before you use it. That study is one state, a sample that was majority White and slightly majority female, and a five-year window that included the pandemic. It does not attribute any of the rise to scale changes, and it does not test scale changes at all. Anyone telling you the ten-point scale caused grade inflation is borrowing a real number to support a claim nobody has tested.

    One finding in it does deserve attention from anyone thinking about equity: the inflation the study estimated was concentrated more among schools whose average GPAs were lower to begin with — a correlation, not a cause. If a GPA means less coming out of the schools whose students can least afford a discounted signal, that is a problem worth naming — and it is a problem about grading practice, not about where the A cutoff sits.

    What the scale change genuinely does is a one-time shift in the distribution. Every student near a cutoff moves up a letter once, and then the system settles. If grades keep climbing after that, the cause is somewhere else — in retake policies, in how late work gets scored, in extra credit, in what gets averaged into the gradebook at all.

    How Many Levels Should a Grading Scale Have?

    A grading scale works best with far fewer than a hundred levels. Simulation research lands on four to seven categories, and a percentage scale has 101.

    Three research findings about grading scale length: the optimum number of rating categories is four to seven, a percentage scale offers 101 levels, and 73 trained teachers scoring the same paper produced marks from 50 to 96
    Three findings that every percentage scale has to answer for, whatever the width of its bands.

    Lozano, García-Cueto and Muñiz simulated thirty-item scales across sample sizes from 50 to 500 and response options from two to nine. Reliability and validity improved as options increased, but the gains flattened out: their conclusion was that the optimum sits between four and seven, that fewer than four costs you real precision, and that past seven the improvement is small. That is a psychometric simulation, not a classroom study, and it is about rating scales generally rather than report cards — but 101 is not within shouting distance of seven.

    Thomas Guskey has made the applied version of this argument for years. His case against percentage grades is that the precision is imaginary: a standard error of two items on a twenty-item test becomes a twenty-point range on a percentage scale, often spanning two letter grades. More cutoffs mean more students misclassified at boundaries, not fewer. And with a pass mark near 60, roughly two-thirds of the scale is devoted to describing gradations of failure that nobody needs.

    The reliability evidence underneath that is older than most grading debates. In 1912 and 1913, Starch and Elliott had 147 high school English teachers grade two identical papers — scores ran 64 to 98 on one and 50 to 97 on the other — and 128 mathematics teachers grade geometry papers, where one paper drew scores from 28 to 95. A century later Hunter Brimi ran the replication with teachers in a single district who’d been trained in a writing-assessment framework. Ninety teachers graded one paper; the 73 who used a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96.

    Here is the part that cuts against the easy conclusion. If fewer levels are better, then the ten-point scale is an improvement on the seven-point one, because its bands are wider and its boundaries are fewer in the range where students actually cluster. But it is still a percentage scale with 101 levels underneath the letters, and Guskey’s own recommendation is not a wider percentage band at all — it is a 0–4 integer scale. If you want that argument in full, including why the conversion back to a letter is the hard part, it is in the 1–4 scale and its conversion problem, and the system it belongs to is laid out in what standards-based grading actually fixes.

    What Changes for a Student at 69 Instead of 70?

    A student at 69 earns a D and course credit on a 10 point grading scale, but an F and a repeated course on a seven-point scale. Same work, same kid, different year.

    That is the strongest practical argument for the wider bands, and it deserves to be stated plainly rather than buried in a policy rationale. It is also the argument that should make you look hard at your own gradebook, because the scale is not what put the student at 69. Something else did, and a wider band does not fix it. It just stops that particular thing from costing a credit.

    There is a cost on the other side, and it is worth saying before someone else does. A ten-point scale hands out credit at 60 that a seven-point scale withheld until 70. Some of those students walk into the next course without the ground under them, and the transcript says they are fine. The letter is not the problem there — the problem is a student moving up without the skill, and nothing about the band width tells you which students those are. That is what the boundary review in the next section is for.

    The zero is where this gets ugly. On a 100-point scale a single zero is not one bad grade, it is a hole — moving a student from a zero to passing takes six or seven times the gain that moving a B to an A takes. Guskey, Fisher and Frey call minimum-grade policies a Band-Aid for exactly this reason: a 50 percent floor is an attempt to fix the arithmetic of the scale without changing the scale, and teachers using one still have to tell apart 51 distinct levels of performance. Several districts have put floors in and then pulled them back out; Texas legislated against them.

    None of that is an argument for giving a student a number they did not earn. It is an argument for not building a system where one missed assignment is mathematically unrecoverable. If a student can screw up that badly in your class, look at the planning before you look at the student — and give them a real route back, whether that is test corrections that actually teach or a reassessment with the same standard and a new attempt.

    How Do You Run a 10 Point Scale Without Lying to Students?

    Run a 10 point grading scale honestly by treating it as the reporting rule it is and putting your effort into what produces the number. Five things, in order.

    Five-step checklist for running a 10 point grading scale: publish the cutoffs in writing, grade against criteria not a curve, keep behavior out of the number, build a route back from a zero, and check the cutoff cases before grades post
    Five steps that decide whether the band is honest. None of them are about the band.
    1. Publish the cutoffs in September, in writing. A rule given in advance is a policy. The same rule produced in May is an argument you will lose. Include the weighting if your school weights, because that is where families get blindsided.
    2. Grade against criteria, not against the class. A ten-point band is only meaningful if 85 means something describable. If it means “a bit above the middle of this particular group,” the band is decoration. A written description of what each level looks like does more for accuracy than any cutoff you pick, and the quickest way in is to write the description of a 90 and the description of a 70 first. Once the top and the pass line are on paper in plain words, the middle writes itself.
    3. Keep behavior out of the number. Compliance, neatness and attendance are real and worth tracking, and they are not what the letter is supposed to report. Starch and Elliott found math teachers factoring neatness, form and spelling into geometry grades in 1913. That has not gone away on its own.
    4. Build the route back before anyone needs it. Decide in advance what a student does about a zero, a missed assessment, or a standard they have not reached yet — and write it down with the cutoffs. Deciding case by case is how you end up being generous to the students who ask and strict with the ones who do not.
    5. Read the cutoff cases by hand before grades post. Pull everyone within two points of a line and look at the evidence instead of the average. In most sections that is a handful of students, and it is a few minutes of reading rather than a re-grade. The arithmetic put them there; your judgment is what the cutoff was always standing in for. If you cannot defend the letter to the student, do not post it — and if the student thinks you have it wrong, let them bring the evidence and make the case. A sixteen-year-old arguing from their own work is the best outcome on this entire list.

    Then say it out loud to the room. Students handle a hard line fine when it was announced in advance and applied the same way to everybody. What they do not forgive is a cutoff that moved. Doing exactly what you said you would do is the entire mechanism, and it works the same way with families as it does with a seventeen-year-old staring at an 89.

    What Should Teachers and Schools Do About a 10 Point Grading Scale?

    Teachers on a 10 point grading scale should put their effort into what happens inside the bands. Schools choosing a scale should know the switch buys comparable transcripts and nothing instructional.

    If you’re a teacher on a ten-point scale, you don’t get to choose it, so spend your effort on the steps above that are yours: published cutoffs, criteria instead of a curve, behavior out of the number, a route back, and a hand-read of the boundary cases. The band is somebody else’s decision. The number inside it is yours.

    If you are the one choosing the system, the honest brief is short. Moving from seven points to ten buys you comparable transcripts, fewer students failing on a technicality, and fewer boundaries to misclassify at — and it buys you nothing instructional. If you want the scale itself to carry meaning, the evidence points past percentages altogether, toward four to seven levels with written descriptors. Start with how the gradebook has to be set up, because that is the part that decides whether a new scale survives its second year.

    Clay’s take: whatever scale you’re on, write your rule down before you need it. That single habit prevents more grading arguments than any scale ever has.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Whatever scale your district uses, the semester exam is where the cutoffs bite hardest, so the test itself should be sound. Mid-Terms.org has 200 free printable midterms with answer keys for grades 6–12 in Social Studies, ELA, Math and Science, with a Form A and Form B for every course.

    What are the letter grades on a 10 point grading scale?

    Each letter covers a ten-point band: 90 to 100 is an A, 80 to 89 is a B, 70 to 79 is a C, 60 to 69 is a D, and anything below 60 is an F. On the older seven-point scale it replaced, an A started at 93, so the same work could earn a different letter on the transcript.

    What letter grade is an 85 on a 10 point scale?

    An 85 is a B on a 10 point grading scale, because the B band runs from 80 to 89. A 95 is an A, a 75 a C, a 65 a D, and anything under 60 an F. An 85 is a B on the older seven-point scale too, but a 91 isn’t: it’s an A on the ten-point scale and a B on the seven-point.

    Is a 10 point grading scale easier?

    On identical work, a 10 point grading scale lets more students clear each line, because four cutoffs moved down. That’s arithmetic, not generosity, and it happens once when the scale changes rather than year after year. It isn’t the same thing as grade inflation, and no study has tested whether switching scales causes inflation. If grades keep climbing after the transition year, look at retake rules, late-work scoring and extra credit.

    Why did states switch to a 10 point grading scale?

    States switched to a 10 point grading scale for transcript comparability, not for learning. North Carolina’s State Board approved it on 2 October 2014, starting with 2015–16 freshmen, after reports that a student with a 91 average could hold a 4.0 in one state and a 3.0 in another. South Carolina’s board approved it unanimously on 13 April 2016, citing families transferring in, college admissions, scholarships and dual-credit confusion.

    Should a teacher round an 89 up to an A?

    Whether to round an 89 up to an A should be decided before September and applied to everyone; that’s the only fair version. A published rule is a policy. The same decision made in May for one student is a favor, and the class will hear about it. The defensible practice is reviewing every student within a point or two of a line against the actual evidence, and letting a student who disagrees bring their work.

    Is a D a passing grade on a 10 point grading scale?

    A D (60–69) normally earns course credit and one quality point, so it passes. Whether it counts toward a specific requirement is a separate question — many graduation pathways, athletic eligibility rules, NCAA core-course lists and college prerequisites set a higher floor than a D. It is also the band most worth a second look, because a student can clear 60 and still walk into the next course without the ground under them.

    Does a 10 point grading scale hurt college admissions?

    A 10 point grading scale generally helps in college admissions, which is why states adopted it. A student graded on a seven-point scale could arrive with a lower GPA than an identically performing student from a ten-point state, and the switch removes that penalty. It doesn’t change course rigor, test scores or weighting, where honors courses usually add 0.5 quality points and AP, IB or dual-enrollment courses add 1.0.

    How many levels should a grading scale have?

    A grading scale needs far fewer than a hundred levels, according to the research. A simulation study by Lozano, García-Cueto and Muñiz found reliability and validity improving up to about four to seven response categories, with little gain past seven. A percentage scale has 101. In one replication study, the 73 trained English teachers who graded the same paper on a 100-point scale gave it scores from 50 to 96.

    Sources

    1. North Carolina State Board of Education. GRAD-009: High School Grading and Transcript Standards. Adopted 1 June 2017, last revised 7 November 2024. States the required high school scale (A 90–100, B 80–89, C 70–79, D 60–69, F below 59), the 4.0 quality-point values, honors +0.5 and AP/IB/CIE/college +1.0 weighting in force since 2015–16, dual unweighted and weighted GPAs, and the local option for elementary and middle schools. The policy text reads “< 59 = F,” which leaves a score of exactly 59 unassigned; that is reported here as written. GRAD-009 (PDF)
    2. South Carolina Department of Education. 10-Point Uniform Grading Scale Approved by State Board of Education. News release, 13 April 2016. Unanimous approval effective 2016–17; rationale covers military and other families transferring in, an equal chance against neighboring states for college admission and scholarships, and confusion in dual-credit courses; notes the implementation work of merging calculations for enrolled students and reviewing the Hope, Life and Palmetto Fellows scholarships. ed.sc.gov
    3. South Carolina Department of Education. 10-Point Grading Scale Conversion Chart. Linked from the release above. Whole-number conversion: 90 and up A, 80 B, 70 C, 60 D, 59 and below F, with honors and AP/IB/dual-credit weightings. ed.sc.gov (PDF)
    4. WRAL. NC changes high school grading scale. 2 October 2014. Reports the State Board vote, the prior seven-point ranges (A 93–100, B 85–92, failing below 70), the 2015–16 freshman start, and the 91-average example yielding a 4.0 in Atlanta against a 3.0 in North Carolina. News reporting, cited for the vote date and the comparison it states rather than as research. wral.com
    5. Guskey, T. R. (2013). The Case Against Percentage Grades. Educational Leadership, 71(1), 68–72. Argues that a 100-level scale creates false precision (a two-item standard error on a twenty-item test becomes a twenty-point range), that more cutoffs mean more boundary misclassification, that roughly two-thirds of the scale describes failure once the pass mark sits near 60, and that a single zero takes six or seven times the gain of a B-to-A move to recover from. Recommends a 0–4 integer scale instead. Read in the author’s own posted copy; this is an argument article, not an empirical study, and his recommendation is not a wider percentage band. tguskey.com (PDF)
    6. Guskey, T. R., Fisher, D., & Frey, N. (2024). The Unwinnable Battle Over Minimum Grades. Educational Leadership, 82(2). Treats 50 percent floors as a “Band-Aid approach” to the arithmetic of the percentage scale, notes that a teacher using one must still discern 51 distinct levels of performance, and records districts amending or rescinding such policies and Texas legislating against them. Cites the four-to-seven-level reliability research. ascd.org
    7. Brimi, H. M. (2011). Reliability of Grading High School Work in English. Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation, 16(17). Ninety high school English teachers in a single district, trained in NWREL’s 6+1 Traits of Writing, graded one identical student paper; the 73 who used a 100-point scale produced scores from 50 to 96. Cited from the ERIC record, which was read; the journal’s full text was not. One paper, one district. eric.ed.gov
    8. Lozano, L. M., García-Cueto, E., & Muñiz, J. (2008). Effect of the Number of Response Categories on the Reliability and Validity of Rating Scales. Methodology, 4(2), 73–79. Monte Carlo simulation of thirty-item scales, inter-item correlations .2–.9, samples of 50–500, two to nine response options; reliability and validity rise with more categories but the optimum sits between four and seven, with small gains past seven. A psychometric simulation of rating scales in general, not a study of report-card grades, and cited from the published abstract. doi.org/10.1027/1614-2241.4.2.73
    9. Sanchez, E. I. (2025). The Implications of Grade Inflation: Evaluating the Prediction of First-Year College GPA Using High School GPA and ACT Scores. ACT Research Report R2432. Mean self-reported HSGPA rose from 3.17 (2017 class) to 3.38 (2022) in one southern state with a statewide ACT contract; cohorts of 22,717 and 16,199 students; inflation appeared concentrated among lower-GPA schools; for two students at a 2.5 HSGPA, 0.5 of school inflation predicted a first-year college GPA 0.37 points lower. One state, a majority-White, slightly majority-female sample, and a window that includes the pandemic. The study does not test grading-scale changes and attributes none of the rise to them. act.org (PDF)
    10. Starch, D., & Elliott, E. C. (1912). Reliability of the Grading of High-School Work in English. The School Review, 20(7), 442–457; and the 1913 mathematics companion study. Cited as reported by Guskey (2013) — 147 English teachers scoring two identical papers 64–98 and 50–97, and 128 mathematics teachers scoring one geometry paper 28–95. The 1912 article’s bibliographic record was confirmed, but the full text was not read in this session, so the figures are attributed to Guskey’s account of them. archive.org

    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Best Value Online PD Subscription for Teachers (2026 Prices)

    Best Value Online PD Subscription for Teachers (2026 Prices)

    By Clay Shumate

    The best value online PD subscription for teachers is usually ISTE+ASCD’s $99 Enhanced Digital membership, paired with free sources like Edutopia and your state’s PD portal. If you need graduate credit for a raise or recertification, skip subscriptions and buy single Teaching Channel courses ($289–$489) after your district confirms it accepts them.

    Key Takeaways

    • ISTE+ASCD’s Enhanced Digital membership costs $99 a year and includes four member ebooks and two free Learning Academy courses, which ISTE+ASCD values at $130 and $170.
    • Teaching Channel sells graduate credit per course, not by subscription: $289 for one credit, $389 for two and $489 for three.
    • Coursera Plus and the ISTE+ASCD Learning Academy each cost $399 a year and only pay off for a teacher who finishes several courses.
    • A certificate from Coursera, edX or the Learning Academy is not automatically a state-approved CEU, so ask your district before paying.
    • Edutopia is free and awards no credit; some state education agencies run free portals that award hours that count in that state.

    An online PD subscription is a paid plan that gives a teacher a year or a month of professional learning, such as courses, books, webinars or credit, from one provider. Value here means three things together: what you pay, whether your state or district will count it, and whether it changes what you do in class on Monday. This page compares the options we could verify on all three. For a broader look at PD formats, see our guide to online professional development for teachers.

    How do the main online PD subscriptions for teachers compare on price and credit?

    No single online PD subscription wins on price, credit and classroom use at once, so match the platform to the job: free sources for ideas, ISTE+ASCD for reading, and Teaching Channel for graduate credit.

    PlatformPrice for one teacherCredit or record you getBest for
    EdutopiaFreeNoneClassroom-tested ideas, videos and podcasts
    State portals (example: TEA Learn, formerly Texas Gateway)FreeState CPE credit, in TexasRequired hours in your own state
    ISTE+ASCD membership$59–$299/yr (digital $59, $99, $199)Enhanced and Pro include two Learning Academy courses a yearReading, books, webinars, a professional network
    ISTE+ASCD Learning Academy$399/yr individual subscriptionCompletion records; 100+ self-paced coursesTeachers who want many short, focused courses
    Teaching Channel (formerly Learners Edge)$289 / $389 / $489 per 1-, 2- or 3-credit course; non-credit $99–$189Graduate credit through partner universities, or a letter of completionSalary lane changes and recertification
    Coursera Plus$59/month or $399/yrCourse and Professional CertificatesTeachers who’ll finish many courses, including outside education
    edXFree to audit; verified certificates usually $50–$300Certificate only on the paid trackTrying a subject before paying
    Kappa Delta Pi$95/yr practicing teachers; $65 candidatesMembership certificate; webinars and workshopsCommunity, publications, scholarships
    Online PD options for one teacher, with 2026 prices.
    No single subscription wins on all three measures.

    Sources are linked in each section below. Prices change, so confirm on each provider’s site before you buy.

    What is the best free online PD for teachers?

    Edutopia is the best free online PD for classroom ideas, and a state education agency’s own portal is the best free source of hours that count. Edutopia is run by the George Lucas Educational Foundation, a nonpartisan 501(c)(3), which describes it as “a free resource” that spotlights what’s working in education (GuideStar profile). It publishes videos, podcasts and topic pages (Edutopia, About). It doesn’t award credit.

    Some states run free portals that do. The Texas Education Agency, for example, launched the Texas Gateway as a free online resource library whose self-paced courses let Texas educators earn continuing professional education (CPE) credit (TEA Texas Gateway announcement). Texas Gateway addresses now redirect to the agency’s TEA Learn site, so Texas teachers should start there. Check your state department of education and your regional in-service center before you pay anyone. More free options are collected in our free professional development for teachers guide.

    Is an ISTE+ASCD membership worth it for one teacher?

    ISTE+ASCD’s $99 Enhanced Digital membership is the best-value tier for most individual teachers, because it adds four ebooks and two Learning Academy courses a year to the $59 Starter tier. ASCD now operates as ISTE+ASCD, and it lists these individual tiers (ISTE+ASCD membership):

    • Starter Digital, $59: eight digital issues of Educational Leadership, bi-weekly expert webinars, topic guides and an online network.
    • Enhanced Digital, $99: everything above, plus four member ebooks and two free Learning Academy courses a year. ISTE+ASCD values the books at $130 and the courses at $170.
    • Pro Digital, $199: eight ebooks and two research journals, plus a companion membership.
    • Print versions run $79, $129 and $299.
    What each ISTE+ASCD digital membership tier includes.
    The $99 Enhanced tier is the sweet spot for most teachers.

    The membership page also lists 25% off Learning Academy courses. Dues aren’t refundable, though they are transferable, and individual memberships aren’t prorated. If you’d rather have unlimited courses than books, the Learning Academy individual subscription is $399 a year for 100+ self-paced courses in two-hour and five-hour formats, with completion records (ISTE+ASCD Learning Academy). The page doesn’t say those records count as CEUs, so check with your district.

    How much does Teaching Channel cost for graduate credit?

    Teaching Channel charges per course, not by subscription: $289 for one credit, $389 for two and $489 for three. Non-credit, hours-only versions cost $99, $149 and $189 and come with a letter of completion. New customers get $100 off a first 3-credit course ($80 off a 2-credit course, $59 off a 1-credit course), and buying more than one graduate-credit course in one order takes 10% off (Teaching Channel pricing).

    Learners Edge became part of Teaching Channel in 2023 (Teaching Channel), so if you’re searching for Learners Edge courses, this is where they are now. Credit is issued through accredited partner universities, including American College of Education, Southern New Hampshire University, Concordia University St. Paul and others. Two partners accept registrations only from certain states (Teaching Channel university partners).

    At $489 for three credits, that’s about $163 a credit, or about $130 a credit with the first-course discount. Before you buy, get written confirmation from your district or state that the credit counts for what you need.

    Are Coursera and edX good for teacher professional development?

    Coursera and edX are good for learning and weak for credit, because their certificates aren’t automatically accepted as state-approved teacher hours. Coursera Plus costs $59 a month or $399 a year and covers over 90 percent of Coursera’s courses, Projects, Specializations and Professional Certificates (Coursera Plus). Education-specific options exist, such as Commonwealth Education Trust’s Foundations of Teaching for Learning: Introduction, which is included with Coursera Plus and rated 4.6 from 875 reviews (Coursera).

    edX lets you audit most open courses free. The audit track doesn’t include certificates or graded assignments, and verified certificates usually cost $50–$300 per course (edX Help Center).

    The catch for both platforms: a course certificate isn’t automatically a state-approved CEU. If you need hours that count, ask first.

    Is a Kappa Delta Pi membership a PD subscription?

    Kappa Delta Pi is closer to a professional society than a course platform: practicing teachers pay $95 a year for webinars, workshops, two publications and scholarships, not formal courses. Kappa Delta Pi dues are $95 a year for practicing teachers and $65 for teacher candidates, and some chapters add local dues. Benefits include webinars and workshops, The Teacher Advocate magazine, The Educational Forum journal, scholarships and discounts (KDP FAQ). Its FAQ doesn’t describe formal courses or continuing education credit.

    How should a teacher choose the best-value online PD subscription?

    A teacher should choose online PD in this order: confirm what the district counts, use free sources first, then pay only for the one thing needed, whether that is credit, reading or a large course catalog.

    1. Find out what counts. Ask your district which providers it accepts for recertification hours and salary credit. That one email can save hundreds of dollars.
    2. Use free first. Edutopia for ideas, your state portal for hours.
    3. Need graduate credit? Buy individual Teaching Channel courses, and only as many credits as you need. If you are weighing those against Teachstone’s CLASS training, the two are compared side by side here.
    4. Need ideas and reading? ISTE+ASCD Enhanced Digital at $99.
    5. Taking a lot of courses? Compare the Learning Academy ($399) and Coursera Plus ($399) based on which catalog fits your subject.
    6. Apply one thing. PD that doesn’t change a lesson isn’t good value at any price. Our PD courses guide and continuing education guide go further.
    How a teacher should choose an online PD subscription, in order.
    Start with the free email to your district. It is the step that saves money.

    Clay’s take: send the district email and use one free source before spending anything, and pay for a subscription only when you know you’ll finish it. That’s a judgment on the prices and credit rules on this page from a grades 6–12 teacher, not a hands-on review of each product.

    Does Elevate the Norm offer teacher PD or credit?

    Elevate the Norm isn’t a PD platform and doesn’t award credit. Elevate the Norm is this site’s own free grades 6–12 classroom approach, built by Clay Shumate, a certified 6–12 social studies teacher, and it hasn’t been independently evaluated. Its classroom management and project-based learning materials are free with no email gate on the resource library, which makes them a no-cost complement to whatever PD you buy. If you’re weighing a schoolwide framework instead of individual PD, start with the classroom culture frameworks Q&A hub.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is the best free professional development for teachers?

    Edutopia is a strong free source of classroom ideas, videos and podcasts, though it awards no credit. For hours that count, check your state education agency first. Some run free portals: the Texas Education Agency launched the Texas Gateway, now TEA Learn, with self-paced courses that let Texas educators earn continuing professional education credit. Your regional service center is the next place to ask.

    How much is an ASCD membership?

    ASCD now operates as ISTE+ASCD. Individual digital memberships cost $59, $99 or $199 a year, and print memberships cost $79, $129 or $299. The $99 Enhanced Digital tier adds four member ebooks and two free Learning Academy courses a year, which ISTE+ASCD values at $130 and $170. Dues aren’t refundable, and individual memberships aren’t prorated.

    Is Learners Edge the same as Teaching Channel?

    Yes. Learners Edge became part of Teaching Channel in 2023, so its graduate-credit courses are now sold by Teaching Channel. A one-credit course costs $289, a two-credit course $389 and a three-credit course $489. Credit is issued through partner universities, and two of those partners accept registrations only from certain states, so check before you enroll.

    Do Coursera certificates count as teacher CEUs?

    Not automatically. Whether a Coursera, edX or ISTE+ASCD Learning Academy certificate counts toward recertification depends on your state and district, so get the answer in writing before you pay. Coursera Plus costs $59 a month or $399 a year and covers over 90 percent of Coursera’s catalog, which only pays off if you finish several courses your district will accept.

    What is the best value PD subscription for one teacher?

    For ideas and professional reading, ISTE+ASCD’s Enhanced Digital membership at $99 a year is the best value, because it bundles four ebooks and two Learning Academy courses. For graduate credit toward a salary lane change or recertification, buy individual Teaching Channel courses only as needed, after your district confirms in writing that it accepts them.

    Should a school buy PD subscriptions or let teachers choose their own?

    This page compares prices for one teacher, not school or district contracts, so it can’t price a group purchase. The step that carries over is deciding which providers count for recertification and salary credit before anyone buys. A district that publishes that list in advance keeps teachers from spending their own money on courses that won’t count.

    How much does a graduate credit cost through Teaching Channel?

    At Teaching Channel’s listed prices, a three-credit course costs $489, or about $163 a credit. New customers get $100 off a first three-credit course, which brings it to about $130 a credit, and buying more than one graduate-credit course in the same order takes 10 percent off. Non-credit versions cost $99 to $189 and come with a letter of completion.

    Will online PD change what happens in class?

    Only if a teacher applies something from it. A certificate or a credit shows hours spent, not a better lesson, which is why this page treats classroom use as one of three measures of value, alongside price and whether the district counts the hours. The practical test is to take one idea from each course and use it in an upcoming lesson.

    How is this page kept accurate?

    Prices and plan details come from each provider’s own site, and we only include platforms whose prices we could confirm. Corrections follow the editorial standards and corrections policy.

    Sources


    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • PBL Rubrics for High School STEM: Best Sets and Sample Criteria

    PBL Rubrics for High School STEM: Best Sets and Sample Criteria

    By Clay Shumate

    The best PBL rubrics for high school STEM pair PBLWorks’ free 6–12 success skills rubrics for collaboration and communication with content rows written from the NGSS science and engineering practices and evidence statements. Defined Learning sells task libraries with built-in rubrics to schools, TeachEngineering is free, and Teachers Pay Teachers rubrics need vetting first.

    Key Takeaways

    • PBLWorks’ 6–12 success skills rubrics are free, can be modified with attribution, and deliberately leave subject content out.
    • The NGSS evidence statements describe observable, measurable parts of each performance expectation, which makes them the closest official source for STEM rubric rows.
    • The EQuIP Rubric for Science evaluates lessons and units, not students, so use it to check a STEM unit before writing the student rubric.
    • Four or five rows is enough for one high school STEM project, chosen from the practices the project actually asks students to use.
    • Score data analysis, evidence-based claims and communication for each student individually, even on a team build.

    STEM projects need criteria a general PBL rubric doesn’t have: Did students define the problem with real constraints? Did they test, collect data, and redesign? Does the claim match the evidence? This guide covers where to get STEM-ready rubrics, what criteria they should include, and gives you a sample table you can adapt. For general grades 6–12 rubrics (presentations, discussions, any subject), see our separate guide to PBL rubric bundles for middle and high school.

    What should a high school STEM PBL rubric measure?

    A high school STEM PBL rubric should score the engineering design process, the science and engineering practices, the quality of data and evidence, and each student’s contribution to the team.

    A STEM PBL rubric is a scoring guide for a science, technology, engineering or math project that grades how students define problems, test designs, use data and defend claims, not just the finished product.

    The NGSS Appendix F lists eight science and engineering practices, and they make a natural backbone for STEM criteria:

    1. Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering)
    2. Developing and using models
    3. Planning and carrying out investigations
    4. Analyzing and interpreting data
    5. Using mathematics and computational thinking
    6. Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering)
    7. Engaging in argument from evidence
    8. Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information
    The eight NGSS science and engineering practices.
    Pick the three or four the project actually asks for.

    You don’t need all eight in one rubric. Pick the three or four the project actually asks students to do. A bridge-design project leans on defining problems, models, and designing solutions; a water-quality project leans on investigations, data, and argument.

    For engineering, the high school NGSS engineering design standards give you ready-made criteria. HS-ETS1 asks students to analyze a major global challenge and specify criteria and constraints (HS-ETS1-1), break a complex problem into smaller solvable parts (HS-ETS1-2), evaluate solutions by prioritizing criteria and weighing tradeoffs (HS-ETS1-3), and use a computer simulation to model a solution’s impact (HS-ETS1-4).

    Where can I get PBL rubrics for high school STEM?

    Free sources such as PBLWorks, the NGSS evidence statements and TeachEngineering cover most of what a high school STEM PBL rubric needs; paid platforms such as Defined Learning mainly save teachers the work of writing project-specific rows.

    SourceCostWhat it gives youSTEM-specific?Watch for
    PBLWorks success skills rubricsFree account6–12 rubrics for critical thinking, collaboration, communication, creativity, self-directionNo, skills onlyAdd your own content rows
    NGSS evidence statementsFreeObservable components of each performance expectationYesNot formatted as rubrics
    NGSS EQuIP rubricFree PDFCriteria for judging lesson and unit designYesEvaluates units, not student work
    TeachEngineeringFree2,200+ NGSS-aligned K–12 engineering lessons and activitiesYesAssessment sections vary by activity
    Defined LearningCustom quotePerformance tasks with built-in rubrics, exemplars, student workIncludes math, science, CTESchool or district purchase
    Teachers Pay TeachersFree to paidSeller-made STEM and engineering rubricsVariesQuality and alignment vary by seller
    Where to get PBL rubrics for high school STEM, free and paid.
    Free sources cover most of it. Paid platforms mainly save you the writing.

    Do PBLWorks rubrics work for STEM classes?

    PBLWorks rubrics work for the skills half of a STEM grade, such as collaboration and communication, but they deliberately leave content out, so STEM teachers pair them with science or engineering rows.

    PBLWorks’ research-based success skills rubrics were developed with the National Center for the Improvement of Educational Assessment and come in a 6–12 version for critical thinking, collaboration, self-directed learning, complex communication, and creativity. PBLWorks says they can be modified with attribution. Its guidance on its 4 Cs rubrics recommends adding content rows or a separate content rubric, because the skills rubrics aren’t meant to assess subject knowledge. The same guidance says to give students the rubric near the beginning of a project and have them assess themselves at checkpoints. For STEM, that split is useful: collaboration and communication come from PBLWorks, and the engineering and science rows come from NGSS.

    PBLWorks’ Project Design Rubric is also worth running your STEM project through before launch. It checks the project itself against the Gold Standard design elements.

    How do I use NGSS tools to build STEM rubric criteria?

    STEM teachers can use the NGSS evidence statements to write student-work rubric criteria and the EQuIP rubric to check that the unit itself is well designed.

    The NGSS site publishes evidence statements that describe observable, measurable components of each performance expectation. For example, there’s a downloadable evidence statement for HS-ETS1-1. These are the closest thing to an official source for rubric rows: pick the components your project targets and turn each into a “meets” descriptor.

    The EQuIP Rubric for Science, Version 3.0 (September 2016) is a different tool. It evaluates lessons and units, not students, in three categories: NGSS 3D Design, NGSS Instructional Supports, and Monitoring NGSS Student Progress. According to NSTA, it was developed by Achieve and NSTA. Use it to check whether a purchased or self-built STEM unit really asks students to use the practices, before you build a student rubric around it.

    Is TeachEngineering a good free source for high school STEM projects?

    TeachEngineering is a good free source for STEM projects: it’s NGSS-aligned and searchable by standard, though some activities need a teacher-made rubric added.

    TeachEngineering describes itself as free, standards-aligned engineering curriculum for K–12, with 2,200+ peer-reviewed lessons and activities aligned to NGSS and state standards, and lets you search by topic, grade, or standard. It’s run by the University of Colorado Boulder with partner institutions and funded by the National Science Foundation. Each activity lists its standards; for instance, an introductory engineering design cycle activity lists MS-ETS1-4 and HS-ETS1-6(MA). That activity’s Assessment section was empty when we checked, which is a good reminder to look before you assume a rubric is included.

    Should I buy a STEM rubric set from Defined Learning or Teachers Pay Teachers?

    Defined Learning makes sense when a school wants a whole STEM task library with rubrics built in; Teachers Pay Teachers makes sense for one specific project, as long as the teacher vets the rubric first.

    Defined Learning says every performance task includes built-in rubrics, exemplars, and student work samples, and its library covers math and science alongside CTE and other subjects. Its FAQ says pricing is a custom quote and it’s sold through school and district partnerships, so it’s not an individual teacher purchase.

    On Teachers Pay Teachers, filter to high school (9th–12th) and science or math, then check every preview for three things: rows tied to specific practices or standards, a separate collaboration score per student, and an editable file. A STEM rubric that grades “creativity” and “neatness” but never mentions data or testing isn’t a STEM rubric.

    What does a sample high school STEM PBL rubric look like?

    A sample high school STEM PBL rubric has one row per skill being graded, and each row maps to an NGSS practice or engineering standard so the grade is easy to defend. Here’s a starting set of criteria you can adapt.

    CriterionMaps toMeets standard looks likeScored
    Problem definitionPractice 1; HS-ETS1-1States the problem, measurable criteria, and real constraints (cost, materials, time, safety)Group, with individual explanation
    Design and modelingPractices 2 and 6; HS-ETS1-2Breaks the problem into parts and uses a sketch, model, or simulation to plan a solutionGroup
    Testing and dataPractices 3, 4, and 5Runs fair tests, records data in a usable table or graph, and uses math to compare trialsGroup, with individual data notebook
    Iteration and tradeoffsHS-ETS1-3Redesigns based on test results and explains which criteria were prioritized and whyIndividual
    Evidence-based claimPractice 7Makes a claim about the best design and supports it with the team’s own dataIndividual
    CommunicationPractice 8Explains the design, data, and limits clearly to a real or authentic audienceIndividual
    CollaborationPBLWorks 6–12 collaboration rubricContributes to the team’s work and helps the team improve, measured per studentIndividual
    Sample STEM PBL rubric criteria, mapped to standards and marked group or individual.
    Most rows score individually, even on a team build.

    Keep it to four or five rows for any one project. Notice that most rows are scored individually even in a team build. That’s the same principle behind our free editable PBL rubric: a strong group product shouldn’t hide a student who can’t explain the data.

    Clay’s take: Before paying for anything, I’d start with PBLWorks’ free collaboration rubric and write four or five content rows from the evidence statements for the standards the project targets. That’s a judgment on the sources above from a grades 6–12 teacher, not a result from a STEM classroom.

    Does Elevate the Norm offer a STEM rubric for high school?

    Elevate the Norm offers free secondary science project ideas and a general editable PBL rubric, but it doesn’t offer a STEM-specific rubric set.

    Disclosure: Elevate the Norm is this site’s own framework, written by a grades 6–12 social studies teacher, and it hasn’t been independently evaluated. STEM teachers will find the most use in 25 project-based learning science projects for grades 6–12, which includes an engineering and design section, and in the PBL in high schools guide. If you need standards-aligned units to pair with a rubric, see where to find Common Core-aligned PBL units. Free tools live in the resources library, and the classroom culture frameworks Q&A covers 63 questions on the classroom systems that make team projects work.

    Sources

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is the best free rubric for high school STEM projects?

    The best free option for high school STEM projects is a combination rather than one rubric. Use PBLWorks’ free 6–12 success skills rubrics for collaboration and communication, then add content rows written from the NGSS science and engineering practices and the free NGSS evidence statements for the performance expectations the project targets. PBLWorks says its rubrics can be modified with attribution.

    Is the EQuIP rubric used to grade students?

    No. The EQuIP Rubric for Science, developed by Achieve and NSTA, evaluates lessons and units for NGSS design in three categories: NGSS 3D design, instructional supports and monitoring student progress. Teachers use it to check a STEM unit before teaching it, then grade student work with a separate rubric built from the NGSS evidence statements.

    Does TeachEngineering include rubrics?

    TeachEngineering activities have an Assessment section, but what it contains varies by activity, and some are empty. The free, NSF-funded library lists 2,200+ NGSS-aligned K–12 lessons and activities, and each one lists its standards. Check the Assessment section of any activity before assigning it, and add a rubric built from the listed standards if the section is thin.

    How many criteria should a STEM PBL rubric have?

    Four or five rows per project is usually enough for a high school STEM PBL rubric. Choose the three or four NGSS science and engineering practices the project actually asks students to use, such as defining problems, analyzing data or designing solutions, then add an individual collaboration row. A single project doesn’t need all eight practices in its rubric.

    Should engineering design projects be graded as a group?

    Teachers can grade the shared design as a group, but data analysis, evidence-based claims and communication should be scored for each student individually. A strong team product can hide a student who can’t explain the data, so the sample STEM rubric on this page scores most rows per student and asks for an individual data notebook even when testing is shared.

    Should a school buy a STEM rubric platform or use free rubrics?

    A school that wants a whole library of STEM performance tasks with rubrics, exemplars and student work samples can request a custom quote from Defined Learning, which sells through school and district partnerships. A school that mainly needs rubrics can start free with PBLWorks’ 6–12 skills rubrics, the NGSS evidence statements and TeachEngineering’s standards-aligned activities.

    How do I turn an NGSS evidence statement into a rubric row?

    Open the evidence statement for the performance expectation the project targets, such as HS-ETS1-1, and pick the components the project actually asks students to show. Turn each component into a plain-language “meets standard” descriptor, as the sample rubric on this page does. The NGSS site describes evidence statements as observable, measurable components, which is why they work as rubric rows.

    When should students see a STEM PBL rubric?

    Students should see a STEM PBL rubric near the beginning of the project, not at the end. PBLWorks’ guidance on its 4 Cs rubrics recommends sharing the rubric early and having students assess themselves at checkpoints. A rubric with rows tied to specific practices also shows students and families exactly what testing, data and explanation the grade depends on.

    How is this page kept accurate?

    Every product fact and standard on this page is checked against its source and linked inline. Offerings and pricing change, so confirm on each site before you buy. See our editorial standards and corrections policy to report an error.


    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

  • Classroom Culture Frameworks With Ongoing Coaching and Feedback

    Classroom Culture Frameworks With Ongoing Coaching and Feedback

    By Clay Shumate

    Classroom culture frameworks with ongoing coaching and feedback include Responsive Classroom, Conscious Discipline, CHAMPS, Teach Like a Champion and PBIS. PBIS coaching usually comes through state and district networks; the paid programs mostly price coaching by quote. Coaching is worth it: a 60-study meta-analysis found it improved teachers’ instruction by 0.49 standard deviations.

    Key Takeaways

    • Teacher coaching improved instruction by 0.49 standard deviations and student achievement by 0.18 across 60 causal studies in a 2018 meta-analysis.
    • Coaching programs with fewer than 100 teachers outperformed larger ones, averaging 0.63 standard deviations on instruction against 0.34.
    • Virtual teacher coaching showed no statistically significant difference from in-person coaching in the same meta-analysis.
    • PBIS coaching runs through school, district and state coaches, while Responsive Classroom, Conscious Discipline and CHAMPS consulting are priced by quote.
    • Two teachers with a camera and one countable target, such as positive interactions per correction, can run a free coaching cycle every two weeks.

    Ongoing coaching is repeated cycles of observation, feedback and goal setting with a coach, as opposed to a single workshop. This page covers what each program’s coaching actually looks like, what the research says about coaching, and how to coach yourself or a colleague for free. If you’re comparing prices on books and workshops instead, see the buyer’s guide to classroom culture frameworks. For every framework at a glance, see the classroom culture frameworks Q&A hub.

    Why does coaching matter more than the classroom culture framework you pick?

    Coaching matters more than the framework because one-time training rarely changes daily classroom practice, while repeated observation and feedback does. The largest review on this is a 2018 meta-analysis by Matthew Kraft, David Blazar and Dylan Hogan in the Review of Educational Research. It pooled 60 studies with causal designs, 56 of them randomized trials (Kraft, Blazar & Hogan, 2018). What it found:

    • Instruction improved by 0.49 standard deviations across 43 studies.
    • Achievement improved by 0.18 standard deviations across 31 studies.
    • Smaller programs did better. Programs with fewer than 100 teachers averaged 0.63 on instruction and 0.28 on achievement. Programs with 100 or more averaged 0.34 and 0.10. The authors point to the difficulty of finding good coaches and getting teacher buy-in at scale.
    • Virtual coaching held up. They found no statistically significant difference between in-person and virtual coaching, though they couldn’t rule out moderate differences.
    What the 2018 teacher-coaching meta-analysis found.
    Sixty causal studies, 56 of them randomized. The instruction effect is the big one.

    Classroom management research points the same way. In the federally funded CHAMPS trial, middle school teachers got three days of workshops followed by monthly coaching for a full year. They praised more, gave more opportunities to respond, and ran better-organized classrooms (IES).

    Which classroom culture frameworks offer ongoing coaching and feedback?

    Responsive Classroom, Conscious Discipline, CHAMPS, Teach Like a Champion and PBIS all offer ongoing coaching and feedback. PBIS coaching runs through state, district and school coaches. The paid programs price most coaching by quote, with two listed exceptions: Teach Like a Champion’s $1,500 video session and the $75 Coaching CHAMPS book.

    FrameworkCoaching formatWho coachesPriceGrade fit
    Responsive ClassroomOne-day consultant observation visit; Kaleidoscope observation tool; Quick Coaching GuidesCRS consultants, then school leadersBy quotePreK–8; secondary course 6–12
    Conscious DisciplineConscious Coaching cohorts (up to 4 people), reflective cyclesCertified instructorsBy quoteEarly childhood–grade 5
    CHAMPS / Safe & Civil SchoolsOnsite consultants and coaches; Coaching CHAMPS bookSCS consultants or your own coachesBook $75; services by quoteK–8; secondary book for 9–12
    Teach Like a ChampionMulti-year partnerships; Video Collaborative sessionsTLAC teamVideo session $1,500; partnerships by quoteK–12
    PBISState, district and school coachesState networks and district staffThrough your state or district; ask locallyK–12
    Teachstone (CLASS)myTeachstone coaching platformProgram or Teachstone coachesBy quoteMostly early childhood
    Which classroom culture frameworks offer ongoing coaching, and in what format.
    All five major programs offer coaching. Only PBIS routinely offers it free.

    What coaching does Responsive Classroom offer?

    Responsive Classroom offers a one-day consultant observation visit with a same-day debrief, then gives school leaders tools to keep observing on their own. In a Consultant Observation and Feedback Visit, a Center for Responsive Schools consultant observes eight to ten classrooms plus spaces like arrival, the cafeteria, hallways and dismissal. The observations run through Kaleidoscope, which produces a school growth profile, and the consultant debriefs with the leadership team that afternoon. The school gets a free pack of Quick Coaching Guides on a focus topic (CRS information sheet).

    After the visit, leaders keep using Kaleidoscope on their own. It comes with school and district packages for one school year after a training course and can be bought separately. The Quick Coaching Guides cover 30 topics for reflection and goal setting, and buying ten or more includes a free Leader Guide. Prices are by quote (On-Site Services).

    The catch: the ongoing part depends on your own leaders doing the observing. The consultant comes once.

    Does Conscious Discipline offer coaching?

    Yes. Conscious Discipline offers Conscious Coaching: small cohorts of up to four adults, led by certified instructors, meeting virtually for one hour or onsite for up to six hours. Participants set goals, reflect and practice together in repeated coaching cycles (Conscious Coaching overview). Its training page also lists an ongoing virtual partnership (Conscious Discipline training). Pricing isn’t posted.

    The coaching focuses on adult mindset and real interactions, which fits the program’s adult-first design. It’s built for early childhood and PreK–5.

    Does CHAMPS offer coaching for teachers?

    CHAMPS coaching comes from Safe & Civil Schools consultants and coaches, or from your own coaches trained with the Coaching CHAMPS book. Ancora Publishing points schools to Safe & Civil Schools for in-person help, and sells Coaching CHAMPS by Tricia Skyles, Randy Sprick and Jim Knight for $75.

    In an interview, Sprick and Skyles described a “freedom within form” model: the district sets clear targets, and teachers choose how to reach them. Their example targets were 90% student engagement, 90% compliance, and three to five positive interactions for every correction. Skyles argued that without clear targets, coaches have nothing to coach toward (Instructional Coaching Group). The CHAMPS trial’s monthly coaching is the strongest classroom-management evidence on this page.

    Does Teach Like a Champion include coaching?

    Teach Like a Champion includes coaching through custom multi-year partnerships and paid video review sessions, but a standalone workshop doesn’t include ongoing coaching. The TLAC team, which moved from Uncommon Schools to Together Education in 2022 (TLAC blog), offers multi-year partnerships. In those, it studies video and artifacts from your school, helps build your own video system, and models PD design. Partnerships are quoted individually. Its Video Collaborative, a 90-minute review of your pre-selected classroom footage, is $1,500 a session, and its 41 TLAC Online modules ($68 for one user) can also be used for 1:1 coaching (TLAC workshop pricing sheet).

    Can you get free coaching through PBIS?

    PBIS coaching is often available to teachers at no direct cost, because it runs through state, district and school coaches rather than a vendor. The Center on PBIS describes coaching at three levels: state coaches work with district teams, and district and school coaches work with administrators and Tier 1 teams. Coaching targets individual skills with feedback, team routines, and the systems that keep PBIS going. The center posts a free coaching self-assessment and practice briefs (Center on PBIS, Coaching).

    Start with your district’s PBIS contact. In Alabama, for example, the state department of education partnered with the University of Alabama’s positive behavior supports office to expand training and ongoing support (University of Alabama News).

    Is Teachstone CLASS coaching useful for secondary teachers?

    Teachstone’s CLASS coaching is built mostly for early childhood programs, so grades 6–12 teachers will usually find a closer fit elsewhere. Teachstone describes myTeachstone as a CLASS coaching platform with frequent online contact between coaches and teachers and online learning communities. Its materials reference Head Start and early childhood quality systems, and pricing goes through sales (Teachstone).

    How can a teacher get classroom management coaching for free?

    A teacher can get free classroom management coaching by pairing with a colleague, recording short lesson clips, and coaching toward one countable target. The 2018 meta-analysis found virtual coaching held up and smaller programs did better, which is good news for a two-teacher arrangement.

    1. Pick one target. Use something you can count, like positive interactions per correction or opportunities to respond, the same practices that improved in the CHAMPS trial.
    2. Record ten minutes of a lesson. Jim Knight’s Focus on Teaching is a full guide to using classroom video for improvement. Follow your school’s recording policy.
    3. Count, then meet for 15 minutes with a peer. Agree on one change.
    4. Repeat in two weeks.
    5. Use free structure from the PBIS coaching resources or your district coach.

    Clay’s take: As a grades 6–12 teacher, I’d try the free routes first: your district’s PBIS coach, or a colleague and one countable target. Pay for vendor coaching when you need expertise your building doesn’t have. That’s a judgment on the research on this page, not a result from my own room.

    A free two-teacher coaching cycle in five steps.
    Two teachers, one camera, one countable target.

    More options are in free professional development for teachers and collective teacher efficacy. If you’d rather customize a framework first, see customizable classroom culture frameworks.

    Does Elevate the Norm offer coaching?

    Elevate the Norm doesn’t offer coaching, but its free grades 6–12 framework gives a peer coach clear things to look for. Disclosure: it’s this site’s own framework, built by Clay Shumate, a certified 6–12 social studies teacher, and it hasn’t been independently evaluated.

    A colleague can watch for whether recognition criteria were announced in advance, whether the teacher followed through exactly as stated, and how transitions run under the 3-2-1-Done class-vs-class point system. The materials are on the free resource library with no email gate. A paid option from the same teacher, the Teacher Emergency Toolkit, includes behavior and MTSS documentation templates that can serve as a record for coaching conversations.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Which classroom culture frameworks include ongoing coaching?

    Responsive Classroom, Conscious Discipline, CHAMPS from Safe and Civil Schools, Teach Like a Champion and PBIS all offer ongoing coaching. PBIS coaching usually runs through state, district and school coaching networks. The paid programs price most coaching by quote, though Teach Like a Champion lists its 90-minute Video Collaborative at $1,500 a session and the Coaching CHAMPS book costs $75.

    Does teacher coaching actually work?

    Yes. A 2018 meta-analysis by Matthew Kraft, David Blazar and Dylan Hogan pooled 60 causal studies, 56 of them randomized trials. Coaching improved teachers’ instruction by 0.49 standard deviations across 43 studies and student achievement by 0.18 across 31 studies. Programs with fewer than 100 teachers did better than larger ones, which the authors linked to finding good coaches at scale.

    Is virtual coaching as good as in-person coaching?

    The 2018 Kraft, Blazar and Hogan meta-analysis found no statistically significant difference between virtual and in-person teacher coaching on either instruction or student achievement. The authors noted their estimates were too imprecise to rule out moderate differences. For teachers without a local coach, that makes virtual options, such as Conscious Discipline’s one-hour virtual cohorts, a reasonable choice rather than a second-best one.

    How can I get classroom management coaching for free?

    Ask your district’s PBIS contact first, because PBIS coaching runs through school, district and state coaches. If none is available, pair with a colleague, record ten minutes of a lesson under your school’s recording policy, and count one target such as positive interactions per correction. Meet for 15 minutes, agree on one change, and repeat the cycle in two weeks.

    What does Teach Like a Champion video feedback cost?

    Teach Like a Champion’s Video Collaborative, a 90-minute review of a school’s pre-selected classroom footage, is listed at $1,500 per session on the organization’s workshop pricing sheet. Multi-year partnerships, which include studying a school’s own video and building its video system, are quoted individually. The 41 TLAC Online modules cost $68 for one user and can be used for 1:1 coaching.

    Should a school pay for vendor coaching or train its own coaches?

    The research favors starting small and well staffed. Kraft, Blazar and Hogan found coaching programs with fewer than 100 teachers averaged 0.63 standard deviations on instruction, against 0.34 for larger programs, and the authors pointed to the difficulty of finding good coaches at scale. Many schools can start with district PBIS coaches or the $75 Coaching CHAMPS book before buying vendor coaching.

    What should a peer coach look for in a classroom?

    A peer coach should look for one target that can be counted, not a general impression. Good examples are positive interactions per correction and opportunities to respond, the practices that improved in the federally funded CHAMPS middle school trial. Sprick and Skyles describe district targets such as three to five positive interactions for every correction, which gives the coach and teacher a shared number to track.

    Do these coaching programs work for middle and high school?

    Some fit secondary classrooms better than others. The CHAMPS trial studied middle school teachers, Teach Like a Champion covers K–12, and PBIS coaching runs K–12. Responsive Classroom is built for PreK–8 with a separate grades 6–12 course, while Conscious Discipline and Teachstone’s CLASS focus on early childhood and elementary programs. Grades 6–12 teachers should start with CHAMPS, Teach Like a Champion or PBIS.

    Sources

    How is this page kept accurate?

    This page is kept accurate by taking program details and prices from each provider’s own site and study figures from the original paper or official summaries, all linked inline. Confirm current prices with the provider. Elevate the Norm and the Teacher Emergency Toolkit are labeled as this site’s own work. Corrections follow the editorial standards and corrections policy.


    About Clay Shumate

    Clay Shumate is a certified secondary Social Studies teacher in the public schools of West Alabama, with seven years of classroom experience, a B.A. in History, and an M.Ed. in Secondary Education. He writes about project-based learning, student responsibility, respect, and practical ways to hold young people to a higher standard while giving them room to learn from mistakes. He is a member of the Society of Professional Journalists and writes to its Code of Ethics; this site’s editorial standards and corrections policy are published in full. More about Clay.

Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.Teacher Emergency Toolkit — practical resources, real classroom support. Shop on TPT.